On a dark, brooding evening on the Isle of Wight, Agnes Raybould and her companion find themselves an empty first-class compartment on the train. But before long a middle-aged man, clearly in high spirits after dining at his club, joins them, and begins a conversation. His name is Edwin Blanchard - and within moments of the train leaving the station, Agnes and her accomplice strangle him .
Detective Inspector Colbeck is called to Scotland Yard immediately and is given details of the violent murder by Tallis. Both Colbeck and Sergeant Leeming are swiftly despatched to Queen Victoria's favourite country home on the island to find out exactly what took place on that dreadful, eery night.
Keith Miles (born 1940) is an English author, who writes under his own name and also historical fiction and mystery novels under the pseudonym Edward Marston. He is known for his mysteries set in the world of Elizabethan theatre. He has also written a series of novels based on events in the Domesday Book, a series of The Railway Detective and a series of The Home Front Detective.
This continues the ongoing tales of DCI Colbeck, Sgt Leeming etc.
A foul crime on the Railways sets our detectives off on a convoluted trail yet again.
The story runs smoothly and the characters are well balanced and believeable as are the various interactions with members of the Public (high and low staus wise)
I thoroughly enjoyed the tale, but once again found the ending a little rushed and there was plenty of opportunity to let it run out for a little more with details of the aftermath. However a thoroughly enjoyable tale.
I enjoyed this addition to the Railway Detective series. Inspector Colbeck and Sergeant Leeming are dispatched to Portsmouth and the Isle of Wight to solve a brutal murder. They uncover a nasty blackmail scheme in their investigation. The investigative team is expanded to include Constable Hinton. They are ultimately successful in catching the bad guys. There's a cameo appearance by Queen Victoria too. She supplements the cast of recurring characters from previous books in the series. This series is light reading that is fast-paced. It's interesting historical fiction too. Some may say it's formulaic, but even so that does not detract from a reader enjoying the story. There's a good plot, interesting characters and a brilliant sense of place. It's not necessary to have read other books in the series in order to enjoy this story.
Another unsatisfactory addition to the series. I really have lost all hope for the Colbeck series. It started so well and was great for a long time, but now these books are just tedious, what with all the extraneous characters and scenes that bring absolutely nothing at all to the story. Why do we constantly have to cut back to Madeline Colbeck and her horribly vituperative father? They add nothing to the plot nor even to the character development. Just adding ballast that is not required. I think this is my last Colbeck book. I shall go back and re-read the earlier stories, and recall the good old days!
I really enjoyed this book. Set in the late 1800’s it’s a murder mystery with some interesting characters. It weaves stories of quite a few characters in and out, some of which seem superfluous and just there as page fillers, and some of the conversations with the criminals were often repeated, but otherwise I enjoyed reading it.
Published in 2024, 'Murder in Transit' is the 22nd book in the popular 'Railway Detective' series featuring Detective Inspector Colbeck of Scotland Yard, against a setting of 1860s England. In this instalment, the murder of a serial philanderer spills out into additional crimes. As usual, the London-based-detective finds himself investigating a a crime on the railway network in another part of the country, allowing plenty of leeway for Marston's great way with eccentric characters from around the land. Relaxing.
Another solid instalment of the Railway Detective series. This time, he was investigating the murder of a man in a railway carriage on the way to the Isle of Wight. If I am honest, the series is becoming a little tired and quite formula driven. The filler sections featuring Inspector Colbeck's wife and her very irritating father add nothing to the story and seem to be virtually the same in each book with only slight variations, Not sure how much life this series has left.
I have read all these books and enjoyed them, but they had been getting a little formulaic and perhaps lacking in excitement in recent years. This well-written story of the murder of a man leading a double life in Sussex and the Isle of Wight was back to the old quality, with interesting characters and a hunt for the criminals that was both exciting and probably more accurately reflective of real police work. The moral hypocrisy of the female criminal was interesting and it was nice to see the return of certain characters from earlier books. The only weaker points are the rather dull bits about Madeleine's home life, the endless dilly-dallying of Hinton and Lydia, and the abrupt ending, with nothing more about the criminals' fate. And I still want to know why Helen Rose became Helena!
Another very entertaining novel in The Railway Detective series.
This one is set in Portsmouth and the Isle of Wight, and, once again, Queen Victoria puts in an appearance. The storyline manages to combine murder with blackmail, as the murderers find out who the victim had been having affairs with and use this to gain extra money - although blackmailing to the tune of £200 per month in 1866 seems rather excessive.
As always, a well put together plot, although this time, Alan Hinton seems to operate at a higher level than Leeming, making me wonder if the author is planning a changing of the guard?
Unfortunately very repetetive. Events from former books and descriptions of the characters are told over and over again. And always the same, unsubstantial interludes of Colbecks home, his wife, her dumb and nasty father and her Lydia friend. The story in this book could have been interesting, but it was thin and unsatisfying. It's over with us, Inspector Colbeck. Sadly.
Starting in such a dramatic way, I had great expectations of a thrilling story throughout. This didn't materialise as it settled into quite a lengthy investigation. Although there was little action it was an interesting read with ladies being blackmailed, Queen Victoria's household being disrupted and friends reunited. A pleasant cosy read.
I think the Railway Detective may have reached his terminus. Not a patch on previous books in the series. Far too many irrelevant domestic interludes and references to past cases. Perhaps Colbeck should retire?
Terrible. I assume at this point the writer is just running on fumes. This basically has no mystery, just characters talking about everything they did as they did it, and making very little sense. Just horrible.
Another brilliant read. I particularly enjoyed the scenes with Queen Victoria, I thought they were an interesting little touch. If you haven't read any of these books I can highly recommend them, they are very enjoyable.
A bit disappointed with this latest book in the series. The story line and hunt for clues are quite good. However, the characters haven’t really developed. Also, the home scenes with Colbeck’s wife, daughter and father-in-law are unnecessary.