What happens when the realization of a dream isn't what you imagined... and the secret you've spent a lifetime guarding is finally laid bare?
Determined to become one of the country's premier newspaper photographers, Elizabeth Westbrook travels to the Colorado Territory to capture the grandeur of the mountains surrounding the remote town of Timber Ridge. She hopes, too, that the cool, dry air of Colorado, and its renowned hot springs, will cure the mysterious illness that threatens her career, and her life.
Daniel Ranslett is a man shackled by his Confederate past, and he'll do anything to protect his land, and his solitude. When an outspoken Yankee photographer captures an image that appears key to solving a murder, putting herself in danger, Daniel is called upon to repay a debt. He's a man of his word, but repaying that debt could reveal secrets from his past he would prefer remain buried.
Forced on a perilous journey together, Daniel and Elizabeth's lives intertwine in ways neither could have imagined when first they met from a distance.
Tamera Alexander is a USA Today bestselling novelist and one of today's most beloved authors of inspirational historical romance and women’s contemporary fiction. While being Gram Tam is her current favorite role, she’ll never turn down a stroll through an old cemetery or browsing through antique shops.
Her books have been awarded numerous industry-leading honors—among them the Christy Award, the RITA Award, the Carol Award, Library Journal's top honors—and have earned the distinction of Publisher's Weekly Starred Reviews. In 2020 she was inducted into the Christy Award Hall of Fame which recognizes authors for their legacy and contribution to Christian fiction. Her deeply drawn characters and thought-provoking plots have earned her devoted readers worldwide.
Tamera and her husband love living in Nashville, Tennessee, and treasure the time spent with their grown children and grandchildren. They live a short distance from the Southern mansions that serve as the backdrop for many of her critically-acclaimed novels. Tamera views her writing as a way to grow closer to the Lord Jesus Christ—and her deepest desire is that those who read her novels will take steps closer to Him as well.
I started this book after not finishing another, and I had hoped this one would be much better and kind of erase the other not-great book for me. And for the first part, it was. (So it did help!) However, as the story went on, things went downhill.
Characters: Both main characters, Elizabeth and Daniel, held so much promise in the first part of the book. I enjoyed that Elizabeth was older (thirty-two, I think) than most women in historical fiction. And she wasn't even obsessed with getting married or not being married. Yay! Yes, she was very forward and sharp, but it worked. She seemed like the type of woman who was trying to be a good journalist and fighting against the odds of it all. And Daniel! I loved him at the beginning. His whole background was intriguing - Confederate soldier, sharpshooter, hunter, hermit-like kinda dude. And he had a dog, too! (Beau was adorable.) I loved Daniel and Elizabeth's interactions at the beginning, and Daniel honestly seemed like a very good man. And then things just went sort of weird. (I'll touch on this in a minute.) However, the characters seemed well-crafted. The other characters also were interesting - Josiah, the sheriff and his sister, and other townspeople. The next few books were definitely getting set up in this one!
Plot/Setting: The setting was absolutely beautiful! I enjoyed the descriptions of the mountains and the characters' appreciation for God's Creation. Timber Ridge was a nice little town without too many hard edges of Old West towns. (No shootouts on Main Street - at least in this one.) As mentioned above, the first part of the book moved a lot better than the latter parts. This may be due to my reading this book across a week or two, but the ending just dragged. It also felt like a lot of stuff started happening really quickly - so quickly I didn't even care that much and wasn't invested in it. I think the pacing could've been changed slightly, and maybe I would've enjoyed it better. And the climax? I liked how it tied things together, but it all came about too quickly, and I had kind of forgotten about the villain by then.
Romance: I'm adding this category today, because this is where things started getting weird. There were just too many instances of the characters lusting after one another. At one point, Daniel had to cut Elizabeth's corset off because of a medical emergency, and despite the fact she was close to death, he had to think about how beautiful she was and all of this. And then he thinks back to that time throughout the book. Elizabeth also has these weird thoughts about Daniel when they sleep the night in a cave together. Nothing inappropriate occurs, but these instances and thought patterns were just kind of creepy to me. I don't mind if the characters think the other character is good-looking, but I don't want to know about their thoughts that are going places they shouldn't - repeatedly. Give me the romance where they love each, not just because they're physically attracted, but because they have good character and a love for the Lord.
Moral/Theme: I think the main moral of this was allowing God to shape your dreams. Elizabeth went out West to pursue her dream, but God changed her through her experiences and gave her a better and new objective. However, there was this whole vein of lying throughout the book. Elizabeth knew it was wrong, but she lied to a lot of people both in the town as well as her father. This was never fully addressed. Yes, she ended up telling the truth after a newspaper article was printed with her whole background in it. And we never heard about her telling her dad that everything she'd said to him was a lie. I wouldn't have had a problem with this if it'd been resolved. She never asked the Lord for forgiveness for all of her lies - it just all kind of sorted itself out. I would've liked to see a strong teaching against lying since that was included in the plotline.
Overall, this was an okay read. The historical details about photography and the Battle of Franklin were interesting, and the author obviously did her research! This definitely isn't my favorite book by Tamera Alexander, but I think I'll try to read the next book in the series sometime.
I'd like the characters and then I wouldn't. The research about old photography was superb but a lot of other research was completely missing (glad to be able to say the author's more recent books haven't had this issue).
Elizabeth had major issues with lying and though her conscience bothered her at times it didn't make her stop and .
A truly atrocious asthma crisis scene made me cringe to no end. 1) when the patient's airway is completely closed, sulphur isn't going to help open it. 2) a real doc wouldn't carry a patient for several minutes to a spring when CPR isn't even working; her only hope was an immediate trach, and he would have done that or she would be dead. 3) They wouldn't spend time hacking through whalebone of a corset and undressing her...they'd undo things by their ties as the design was meant to. 4) afterward she wouldn't be able to dress without ordering a $300 or so fresh custom corset to replace the destroyed one, but I guess that's beside the point if the scene would have left her dead in real life (corsets are NOT like bras that come to size...they have to be individually fitted to each body and can't be loaned at the drop of a hat). (note: it takes a person around three minutes to suffocate; that much action is flatly impossible for her) (also the guy taking a moment to think of lust then?!)
Her travel would have ruined her name because no society would consider her helper Josiah to be an appropriate chaperon, especially when they're cuddling for warmth in a cave.
Someone thinking a sniper is an "unfair warrior"? Urghhhhhhh.
The whole scenario of the battle felt uber modern and really unrealistic for a historic conscience to get hung up on.
The ending was super rushed.
So yeah, not a winner for me. But Josiah's ending was good. I'm going to think of Josiah's ending when I think of this book. :)
What happens when the realization of a dream isn't what you imagined. . . and the secret you've spent a lifetime guarding is finally laid bare?
This first book in the Timber Ridge Reflections series was amazing. The characters were so compelling, each flawed by their past; yet their relationships were so warm and caring. I loved that the author developed such a deep relationship between Elizabeth and Josiah- a friendship between a white woman and a man of color was totally out of character at this point in history. The slow emerging friendship/romance between Daniel with his rough, gruff, private yet tender spirit and Elizabeth was wonderful. The closeness between Daniel and his dog, Beau, as well as his growing understanding, connection, and respect for Josiah as he began to understand more about each of their pasts. Elizabeth was such a strong woman for her time period, yet at the same time had her vulnerabilities.
The story line and setting were superb. Alexander's obvious research into photography of that time period and historical context as well as her knowledge of Colorado culture, topography, and native American lifestyle all added to the richness of the overall story. Winding its way through the plot was a faith thread that was both honest and believable.
If you like historical fiction, definitely don't miss this one. It made my 2016 favorites list.
FAVORITE QUOTES: (Way too many to include but a few!) "Better to keep your focus on the goal rather than the obstacles."
There can't be different versions. Truth is a constant. A person's perspective might be skewed, but that doesn't change what the truth is."
"That's what God does with us, after all. Puts us out into the world where the only real boundary is that of His love. His love either compels us or restrains us. There is nothing stronger.."
"As long as you're still breathing, child, you still got choices."
Although I rated this book with only 3 stars, I really don't think it had anything to do with Tamera Alexander's writing or the story itself. I enjoyed the main plot and the way the other details of the sub plots were woven into the story. I especially enjoyed Josiah's character. I think I just had a hard time connecting with the heroine which I've found lately either makes or breaks a book for me. Elizabeth was a likeable personality but I didn't feel that she put God first in her life. She claimed to want to follow God but then lied to everyone to manipulate her life into what she wanted rather than what God wanted for her. She would then justify her actions and question why God wasn't blessing her efforts to become the photographer she felt He wanted her to be. I know we all deal with putting God first in our lives on a daily basis but I never really saw her repent and ask for forgiveness from those she lied to and manipulated. I think that may have made me feel like she had changed for the better and learned from her mistakes by the end of the book.
Sadly, I had to make myself push to the end of this one but it won't stop me from reading Tamera Alexander's other books. I would highly recommend her Fountain Creek Chronicles series.
I enjoy stories featuring complex characters who grow and mature throughout the telling of their story. Finding your worth in God and the redemption that can only be found in Him are the wonderful takeaways from this book. I enjoyed the rich historical details, the dual povs, and the well developed characters. The platonic relationships between the characters in this book were a nice detail as well.
However, I had a really hard time getting into this story. It took until almost the 40% mark for me to feel the slightest interest in either MC. I think this was due in large part to my dislike of plots that are predicated almost entirely on lies. Or secrets. Or both. I'm past the point in my life where I start reading a story like that and think to myself: "Ooh, I wonder how it's all going to play out? Isn't this fun?" Instead my thoughts are more along the lines of: "Ugh. Lies and secrets? Again? Why can't people just be honest with each other?" And of course I understand that's part of the MCs' growth, but I just couldn't find it in myself to care. Plus the first 40% of the book was pretty dull. And after the plot starts picking up a little, the story is still pretty dull.
Overall, I enjoyed the message and the writing style, but this story missed the mark for me.
I was very impressed with the writing of this book. I always hesitate a little going into Christian fiction, sometimes all they do is pray and preach and the story gets lost. There was none of that is this. The story was the base of this book and it was very powerful and moving. The main character I liked and learned to love as the book went on. I like how she saw in herself the changes that needed to be made and made them. The leading man was awesome and I totally fell in love with him and how he handled Elizabeth. I could see this book turning into a movie everything was described well, I had a vivid picture in my head throughout. The love story was so well done with a dislike and attraction and a very subtle build. The action was well done and didn't feel forced to try to throw the main couple together. This was just a well written love story with glimpses into slavery, the civil war and settling the west. I will be reading more by this author.
Elizabeth Westbrook's dream of becoming a newpaper photographer whose work is accepted under her own name (instead of a male pen name), is put to the test when she travels to the untamed Colorado Territory. Her assignment is to take pictures of the area's majestic countryside and surreptitiously investigate the feasibility of investors back east developing the area around the town of Timber Ridge into a resort property. Elizabeth is a strong, prickly character whose occasionally abrasive manner can be a little hard to take. However, Alexander does an excellent job of balancing Elizabeth's drive to succeed with her fears and insecurities. Her brash manner is extremely realistic compensation for a lifetime of hurt and struggle. In a society that held certain limited expectations for the role of women, Elizabeth bucks convention on multiple fronts.
Daniel Ranslett, who served as a Confederate sharpshooter in the war, immediately clashes with Elizabeth. He doesn't understand her drive and she doesn't understand his enigmatic manner and reluctance to serve as her guide. However, his loner status masks pain of a different sort - the mental and emotional toll of combat. Daniel is a wonderful hero - though he's a wounded, gentle spirit he possesses a core of unwavering moral strength and character. He's the perfect foil for Elizabeth, who has some tough lessons to learn about truth and honor while in turn he must learn about brokenness and trust.
From a Distance is a beautifully crafted, thoroughly absorbing novel full of richly drawn, unforgettable characters. There's a dash of mystery, but the real strength of the novel is the journey Elizabeth and Daniel undergo towards surrender. Elizabeth and Daniel are two of the most well-drawn, imperfect characters I've ever run across - you know characters are "real" when you alternately want to shake them when you're frustrated, empathize with their hurts, and cheer at their triumphs. As a native of Tennessee and an amateur Civil War history buff, I loved how Alexander wove together snippets of Tennessee and Civil War history into her Colorado frontier-set story. While the action of the novel takes place ten years after the end of the Civil War, Alexander does a beautiful job of showing the heartbreaking, far-reaching cost of that conflict on its survivors. I also enjoyed learning about photographic processes in the 1800's - it's eye-opening to read about the processes and Elizabeth's job struggles in an era when cameras (and women in the workforce) are taken for granted. This is a novel about choices - how one chooses to overcome tragedy, health problems, trust issues - and God's sovereignty and care over even the most minute details of one's life. When the dreams they cling to are stripped away, Daniel and Elizabeth's story shows how in vulnerability and brokenness God pours out blessings and strength and dreams much greater and more rewarding than one's human frailty can possibly imagine.
I read this book when it first came out. I am a big Tamera Alexander fan. Every book of hers that I have read, which is all of the ones that are currently out, I have enjoyed. I love the historical facts, the characters, the suspense and the romance. Alexander has wonderful endings to her stories. This book is no exception. The whole book is very well written and I was very impressed at the how she brought it all together at the end.
The author never will write an ending that isn't rushed! She's like, "Well, we went through that slow-paced, sweet romance with lots of different timelines and complexity and it wasn't exactly a thriller ... andnowigottawrapitupsofastDONE."
I know, I love Tamera Alexander's books more than anything, but this is a flaw that shows up in most of her stories!! xP
I really enjoyed all the different layers to this book. Learning to trust God. Living by Jesus' words we have from the Bible. Romance. Mystery. Friendship. History.
I feel though like some loose ends were left and not the kind to be answered in the next book of the series...which I already checked out ;)
This started off a little boring and I really disliked the heroine at first—she had a really obnoxious, off putting personality and it was frustrating to read! I also wasn’t enjoying the overall story and where I thought it was going to lead� BUT after the halfway mark the story totally redeemed itself and was not exactly what I thought. I really enjoyed it. This was one of Tamera Alexander’s earlier books and it still encompasses her great storytelling ability, the character depth and interesting storylines but she’s definitely polished her skills since this book. Still in all, I enjoyed it and will be reading the next in the series.
I liked how this book started out right in the middle of a scene. When an author uses this technique, more likely than not, it's successful in pulling me into the action and keeping my interest throughout the novel. Tamera Alexander does this well. I liked how spunky (well, let's face it, Josiah was right . . . sassy!) Elizabeth was, but that she also learned how to be humble and allow herself to be taught by those who knew more about specific things than she did. I especially liked that she learned to give all her hopes and dreams to God and that He would give her even better ones in return! I also enjoyed Daniel's character. He was definitely flawed, and haunted by the things he'd experienced, especially in the war, but he also learned to be humble and trust in God's leading. However, I think my favourite character just might have been Josiah. His kind and gentle humour was definitely a high point for me.
This is the first book in the Timber Ridge Reflections series by Tamera Alexander.
Full of ambition as a photographer for a newspaper, Elizabeth Westbrook travels to remote Timber Ridge amid the magnificent mountains of Colorado. She hopes to get stunning photos that will further her career. Also she hopes to find a cure for her mysterious ailment. From the first, Daniel Ranslett seems determined to cut across her plans. In the course of the book's events, both protagonists change, especially Elizabeth, who changes so fast and radically I find it a little hard to believe. Apart from this, the characters are better developed than is often the case for this romantic/old-fashioned type of book.
It is quite well written but point of view wavers often. The ending ties off all the pieces a bit too neatly for my taste. A pleasant read.
4.5 stars It took a little too long for me to get into this one, or it would have been five stars. I wasn't crazy about the Wild West setting at first, and I honestly sort of hated the main character for a while because she was so arrogant and foolish. That being said, the author more than redeemed herself. The ending was perfect. The romance built up in such a way that it filled me with longing for the characters. It wasn't too preachy or cheesy. I really enjoyed this one.
An entertaining read for sure. Character development was great, and I honestly had no complaints whatsoever. A great way to pass 3-4 hours. Tamara Alexander is quickly becoming a must read author for me.
She is a liar, a bold faced liar, and the author keeps making light of her lies. Calling it a secret..... pffft!
She lies to her father, to the sheriff, to her friends, to the man/men she hires and then add to that, she claims love for God.
And she is self centered and selfish. This is not a decent woman to be heroine, just a typical greedy, selfish, career oriented woman. Not all career women are like her, but the selfish, self-centered ones are. That first of all is way out of place or the time and place this 'book' is supposed to be based on, 1875. Come on Tamera, make it a little realistic eh?
I am only at Chapter 14 and so sick of her lies and her manipulation. And really am tired of reading over and over how she convinces herself the 'reason' she is there in Colorado and it is OK to lie about. Ya we can all say disobeying God is OK, but does that really make it OK cause we say so?
Her medicine, she lies to others about that. her school books that were sent to her, the consequence of the lie she told her father, she lies to someone about that too.
She is demanding and wants to please only a faceless newspaper editor, after she pleases herself. And have people bragging about her!.... Not bragging about God who created what she photographs.
If anyone would marry this liar, then they would have problems the rest of their lives. A liar won't stop lying because she got married. In fact if she cannot be truthful before marriage, the truth will be a challenge after marriage even more so.
Oh and the author making lies OK, claiming they are small lies, well that is exactly what Satan, the father of the lie wants people to think. Yet this is what Jesus said. (John 8:44) .�.�."You are from your father the Devil, and you wish to do the desires of your father. That one was a murderer when he began, and he did not stand fast in the truth, because truth is not in him. When he speaks the lie, he speaks according to his own disposition, because he is a liar and the father of the lie."
More of how God feels about liars here. (Revelation 21:8) .�.�."But as for the cowards and those without faith and those who are disgusting in their filth and murderers and the sexually immoral and those practicing spiritism and idolaters and all the liars, their portion will be... death.�
There are no small lies, either it is a lie or it is the truth.
Then you read her personality, the one that demands she get the 'photographs' and bring all sorts of folks to an area that the locals want left alone. But in her selfish desire, she cannot see past what she wants.
She is rude and condescending to those she thinks are lower than her.
Usually I can finish a book before reviewing it, but this one is badly written and the morals are so lacking, I just cannot wait.
No wonder men think that women push the limits of being equal. Because in this book , the heroine is not even trying to be a good photographer, she is an manipulative, sneaky conniving, sort of woman, that gives all of us a woman a bad name. And worse yet gives God a bad name.
And she plays games with her asthma, a life threatening disease, especially back in the 1875. Really, really, really?
I am rather surprised, because the Fountain Creek series seemed to be fairly well written.
I don't know how this books ends, probably the fool marries her, 'forgiving' this unrepentant liar, because the author mistakenly tries to force us to believe God demands we blindly forgive unrepentant ones.
Yet if God cannot get this heroine to stop lying, how does anyone expect the man to do so?
I'm not the target audience for this book so take my review with a grain of salt. I'm not sure this book is categorized as "Western" but it's the closest to the Western genre I've gotten and I enjoyed it more than I thought! I say this because, as someone with a grandfather who's favorite movie and TV genre of all time was Western, I feel safe in saying I've seen them all. And it's definitely not my favorite. So, all this to say I've been hesitate to read Western. But I was pleasantly surprised. As a book categorized as "Christian Fiction" I was expecting a lot of preaching. But that wasn't the case at all. God and religion are only occasionally mentioned and when they are, it's very natural to the character or the situation; very organic to the story. However, I felt the author went out of her way to establish who "good Christian people" are (doesn't smoke, drink, curse or gamble) and who "bad non-Christian people" are (they smoke, they drink, they curse, they gamble). Which, I just wasn't a fan of. I know some folxs like straightforward, non-complicated characters or situations, but that's not me. But because the author set this distinct boundary of who is "good" and "bad", I was surprised by how much lying our main character. Especially after being established as "good". Just lie, after lie, after lie. Elizabeth (our main character) gave me Selina Meyers vibes (from HBO's Veep). Just one fib after another to get what she wants with little thought to the consequences to herself or the people around her. This aside, I did enjoy the story, and, once again, pleasantly surprised by the mystery involved. Certainly didn't expect it but glad it was there. 3 stars, didn't love it, didn't hate it.
Growing up with frequent vacations to Colorado, From a Distance transported me to a time long ago, and adventures in those incredible mountains. The fictional story of a woman photographer is a reminder of the huge contribution women made to the settling of the West. Filled with scenic grandeur, danger, and romance, the book will keep you on the edge of your seat. Don’t miss it!
This is by far my favorite book by this author! So much heartache, struggles; yet God's comfort and believable resolutions made for a fantastic first book in the series! I'm looking forward to reading the next ones!
My goodness, this took me forever to get into, and I used to reread it allllll the time! But it wound up being a very engrossing read about halfway through.
The records show that I acquired this book in November 2012. I'm really not sure why I picked it, except that it was undoubtedly free and the description interested me. However, it never intrigued me enough, and sadly, I judge books by their covers and this one was passed over again and again. Since then, however, I have come to love Tamera Alexander's books, and when I discovered that I had another one hiding in my library, I decided the time had come to read it. This time I would be "going to Colorado" in 1875. Elizabeth Westbrook is a photographer whose goal is to shoot magnificent pictures that would give her recognition and a better position. She kept that as a secret from the people she met, but also from her powerful father, who thought she was headed west to become a teacher. She first hired a former slave to assist her, and soon afterward met Daniel, a mysterious man who usually kept to himself. Dangerous circumstances caused Daniel to accompany Elizabeth and Josiah to the cliff dwellings, and as they traveled together, the three grew closer and learned more about each other's secrets. While the first half of the book didn't keep me enthralled, it heated up intensely at the midpoint and didn't let up until the conclusion. I loved being surprised that there is actually a connection between this story and the Carnton series. Now I add a trip to the Maroon Bells to my bucket list.
From a Distance took me a bit to get into, but once I had more of the story of Elizabeth, Josiah, and Daniel, I could not stop reading. Tamera Alexander creates the Colorado Territory so beautifully that it feels like you're there. This takes place right after the end of the Civil War, and I loved seeing how life out west adjusted to that change. This is a story of romance, friendship, wilderness, mystery and the best, and worse, parts of a small town. I loved this and cannot wait to read the next book in this series!
I was bored for most of the book and didn't find myself caring for the characters, in particular the main character, Elizabeth. She is lying to everyone around her for most of the time, including her father. We never actually see her come clean with her father either. Some of the stuff that happens or actions of the characters felt off for the time period. It did make me appreciate how much easier taking a picture is nowadays, compared to the early years of photography.
Tamera Alexander weaves a story of pain and promise and passion that ties in all the threads - even the title. This is a book I'll read again. And again.
This is my favorite Tamera Alexander novel. My daughter loved it so I read it, and I loved it. It's about a woman who wants to be a photographer shortly after the Civil War, but of course, women have it harder to prove themselves during this period. There's a murder mystery to solve, an interesting historical perspective, a clean romance, and lots of humor. A great read!