From the kickstarter: The Secret Loves of Geek Girls was a collection of comics, prose, and illustrations all on the themes of dating as a geek. The collection was full of stories from comic creators, sci-fi writers, videogame designers, cosplayers, and fans! The stories were a diverse range on different topics from first dates to discovering your sexuality and they've touched the hearts of people the world over. And this redux project will be the same! The Secret Loves of Geek Girls: Redux is a project with the same mandate as the original: Geek Girls sharing true stories about love, sex, and dating. Where the original project was limited to 5 pages each for the stories, we're going even smaller with this one: Most creators are contributing 1 page stories, with some up to 4 pages long.
Hope Nicholson is the owner of Winnipeg-based publishing Bedside Press. She's an ardent comics fan passionate about bringing new stories to light, and author of the book "The Spectacular Sisterhood of Superwomen" which shines light on characters forgotten by comics history.
Slightly more uneven than the first Secret Loves, but still a decent read. If you have a choice, go with the ebook version - the use of colour makes a huge difference in the illustrated stories, actually making one more readable. Looking forward to the upcoming Secret Loves of Geeks, which extends to both genders.
Another enjoyable anthology put together by Hope Nicholson. A bit thinner than the other 2 in this series but still great nonetheless. My top 3 stories were:
"A True Story" by Janet Hetherington Some of the dudes she drew in this story remind me of the adults that worked at the comic book stores I frequented as a youth. All I could think was a 13 year old me would have loved getting a comic book about a lovesick vampire.
"Be With" by The Paolis I'm definitely considering getting their version of Maleficent as my next tattoo.
"Hot Pre-Teen Make Out Sesh" by Meags Fitzgerald Awkward comedy at its best. The punchline hits perfectly.
Really more of a 3.5, but rounding up again. Great content, as usual. Still feels very much like a mixed bag and some feel more confessional than anything, but the quality of the work is still very high. Feel like this is exactly how long these anthologies should be. Just enough to satiate, but not not enough to make you resent the length.
Didn’t love it as much as the original, but still a cute read in the exploration of life as a girl geek.
Agree with other commenters, would have been great to see it longer, but it was part of a special little Kickstarter program, which had its limitations :)
This book was released after The Secret Loves of Geek Girls but before The Secret Loves of Geeks to whet the appetite of fans anxious for more intimate tales of love and relationships from fannish women. It delivers.
A VERY SHORT middle volume, and I could swear some of the stories are reprinted in vol.3, but I still loved this! "The Secret Loves" was such a fantastic little series, I really hope similar projects (perhaps by another publisher) will be released in the future.
The stories in this mini volume didn't resonate with me quite as much as those in , but I'm still very happy that this mini volume exists. I enjoy the mixed format of prose and comics and the wide variety of personal narratives that are on display.