i had a hard time suspending my disbelief that it was *impossible* to escape the bathroom after the tornado ended, especially considering the way everything wrapped up. that said, i do love horror that is based on elements of isolation and confinement, so i was willing to (mostly) put all that aside and just enjoy the absolute fucking chaos.
honestly, not bad for a novella, and i think the story has the potential to translate really well to screen for the upcoming movie.
3.5 stars
(cw: casual racism, mentions of self harm, attempted suicide, alcoholism, loss of a loved one, cannibalism, murder)
I'm not sure I've ever discussed my background in acting or how reading scripts and screenplays have influenced my fiction preferences. But now is the time. WE NEED TO DO SOMETHING takes place in a bathroom. No scene changes. Think Neil Simon's third act of PLAZA SUITE but instead of just the daughter locked in the bathroom, the whole family is in there and instead of comedy gold & hilarious Jewish accents--you have thick family tension and foreboding darkness. No. Scene. Changes. It takes a certain level of genius to pull off a story that takes place in a bathroom. It doesn't matter if it's a comedy or horror. Naturally, a story has several scene changes. The environment itself is like a character- the protagonists interact with the environment, it generates atmosphere, sets the mood, provides motivations for movement in the characters (going up the stairs, tripping on a tree branch, the lighting from the summer sun or the chill of a winter moon) So when Max Booth III limits himself and his characters to the confines of a basic bathroom, this is a resignation of almost everything a writer would lean on to drive the story. Everything except the characters performing under laser point focus. To be honest, it's uncomfortable for the reader. I felt a claustrophobic tension for damn near the entirety of this novella. Imagine a rubberband held tight to its snapping point and a sharp edge applying the tiniest amount of pressure. That's how I felt reading this story. Like I was turning the crank of a Jack-In-The-Box popup toy. Which maybe doesn't sound so bad, except what if I told you that once the Jack pops up, he's going to stab you in the feelings over and over again until everything goes really dark? That's this book. A low-level threat to your emotions as you watch a family wind up to a startling, disturbing finish. Did I enjoy it? I mean, enjoyment is the wrong word. I can't say I took pleasure in experiencing everything Max put these characters through--I was especially invested in one of them and I knew like halfway through there would be some sacrifice. Pain and suffering. So enjoyment is the wrong word. I endured it. I respect it. And it further cemented in my mind that Max Booth III is one of the most talented horror writers working in the industry right now. WE NEED TO DO SOMETHING testifies.
This book has been on my want list for a long time; I had no idea what it was about because I had never read the blurb, but the cover piqued my interest.
After receiving the copy, I discovered that there is also a film. Here are my opinions after reading/watching both of them in one day.
Disappointed. Disappointment plain and simple. It got off to a great start. Max's writing was excellent, and I was eager to find out what would happen next. However, 80 percent of the way through the book, nothing happens save for occasional butt and fart jokes. The gore was basic, and I've read better, so that didn't entice me, and the characters felt like a bunch of jerks (which they were supposed to be). The ending was okay, but it left us hanging, which is also okay because I like that kind of ending.
Overall disappointment.
All this time I was imagining the bathroom to be a small one but when I watched the movie it was really big.
Great premise but jumps the rails quickly. Realistic parts make little sense (just take the hinges off the bathroom door already). Hallucinatory/supernatural parts become tiresome. Needs a copyedit. Unsatisfactory non-ending.
When I was kid, I went through Hurricane Marilyn in the Virgin Islands and when it got really bad in the night, I hunkered down with my parents, grandparents, and sister in my grandparents� guest bathroom as the hurricane raged outside. It was one of the scariest times in my life. This truly unsettling novella brought back many of those memories, as it takes place completely in a bathroom after a Texas family finds refuge there when a major storm comes through their town.
The story starts off tame enough, with a little tension between the family and discomfort with the conditions. But soon, things get more surreal and more terrifying. As the time in the bathroom crawls on, Booth’s writing provides a palpable unease where I wasn’t sure what was real and what wasn’t. I don’t want to get into too many details as it’s best to go in blind so that the events in here have maximum impact, but I read most of this with a real sense of dread as I began to feel the claustrophobia, smell the odors, and, once things started to go truly bonkers, I began to read all of it with bulging eyes.
Did any of this really happen in the story? Some of it might have. Some of it might not. Based on how horrifying this was, I would hope it was all just a bad nightmare for the main character. But deep down, I feel like I know the truth.
it’s going to be okay it’s going to be okay it’s going to be okay it’s going to be okay it’s going to be okay it’s going to be okay
I devoured this book in one sitting! It's a dark and twisted tale of a family getting trapped in their bathroom after a storm. The scene quickly devolves into madness, much to our reading enjoyment.
I listened to the audiobook. The narrator was fantastic and did an amazing job. I thought it was creepy, atmospheric, and claustrophobic. It was short and sweet. I really enjoyed it.
A dysfunctional family gets trapped in their bathroom during a tornado. The drama that endues is crazy.
UNHINGED & LOVED IT, especially that ending! but there were a couple problematic/ racist lines and I think it would've been even better without the occult stuff which is rare for me to say. loved how psychological it got though!
Hmm. I'm not sure how I felt about this book. It was suffocating and claustrophobic in a good way but the characters were unlikeable and shallow.
The thing about the dog and the licking scared me shitless but that's about it. Truly being trapped in a bathroom with people you don't like is a bad thing but how everything turned out at the end didn't have an impact on me. With such premise, there could've been a lot of possibilities to make this more interesting.
Anyway, it's just a short book. Another good thing.
This was a much anticipated novella. It was just fine for me. It's my belief that the author intended to make the whole of this family extremely unlikeable. With that, he succeeded admirably. I couldn't stand any of them. I really like, sometimes prefer, unlikeable characters. But the annoyance factor got to me. The verbal abuse of the dad, the terminal optimism of the mom, the caricature of the annoying little brother who incessantly talked about poop. It grated on me.
There was an incredibly creepy scene that will stick with me. Some really gross ones, too. I think if you really enjoy a good locked room story and aren't at all squeamish, you may like this one. I appreciated the concept, but I did find myself having a difficult time suspending my disbelief.
i don't have words for this level of mind fuckery that the author has served us with. all i can say is that max booth III completely understood the assignment and he gets an a+ from me!
TW: Abuse, alcoholism, toxic parent relationship, gaslighting, language, bullying, family drama, prejudiced views, cutting, animal death, cheating, death of child
SPOILERS
About the book:A family on the verge of self-destruction finds themselves isolated in their bathroom during a tornado warning. Release Date: May 8th, 2022 Genre: Horror Pages: 188 Rating: �
What I Liked: 1. The idea behind the book 2. The writing was okay
What I Didn't Like: 1. Hated everyone 2. The ending 3. The confusing parts that went nowhere
Overall Thoughts:I was interested in reading this book because one time I got stuck in a bathroom during a storm. I went to a bread store to apply for a job when there was a tornado coming. The associates there made me go into the bathroom with them and fill out my application. We were in the bathroom for like an hour. It was so awkward. It was such a tiny bathroom made only for one person. And the funny thing is I didn't even get the job.
Right off the bat let's talk about how much of a piece of crap the dad is. He constantly tells his son to stop freaking out but then when the weather report comes in he purposely tells his son something he knows is going to upset him. He said yells at him to stop freaking out like he's getting a kick out of the kid having a reaction. Such a gaslighter. And just the way he talks to his family is gross. I just want to giant monster to eat him.
This might be a record. I don't know if I've ever hated every single character in a book like I do this family.
I hate in books/movies they act like you can't call 911 if you have no service. Is so stupid 911 runs on a different service then cellular towers so you're going to get through. You might get a busy signal but they advise you to keep on trying.
Did we really need a run down of bathroom items? Who doesn't have these items in their own bathroom?
This dad makes Jack Torrence look like father of the year. Ah.
Ad placement for Hulu since this book was turned into a movie on Hulu.
Tell me a guy wrote this book without telling me a guy wrote this book: 22 uses of fart & 24 uses of butt.
The dad says "Imagine the fucking irony of escaping only to get mowed down by some fucking maniac with a gun". 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
How are they able to see in the dark in the bathroom with no window and no lights? They comment that they think the snake has left but it's night time so how can they see?
Her battery is STILL alive... It's been weeks!
Final Thoughts:Cool so the book just ends with an ambiguous ending. Sometimes an ambiguous ending works and sometimes it's so stupid and cheap. In this case it's cheap. Seriously that's what you're going to give us as an ending. I would have given this book a higher rating but I just can't believe that the author left us with this ridiculous open-ended ending. I'm mad. There is zero zero closure to this book. You don't know if it's a monster. You don't know if people are getting shot because of something happened. You don't know if everything they thought of while they were in the room was real. You know nothing. I could have never read this book and been perfectly fine because leaving me with that ending did nothing for the book. Ah. I am annoyed.
Recommend For: � Ambiguous endings � Family drama � Edge of your seat stress
Sometimes, the simplest plots work. Take, for example, Max Booth III's novella "We Need to Do Something": a dysfunctional Texas family is literally stuck together in a tight bathroom during a tornado.
That's the plot. Seriously.
Strangely, it works, and it works surprisingly well. Besides being claustrophobic as hell, the novel also gradually introduces a supernatural element, one that could easily be dismissed as the crazy imaginings of people in a high-stress situation. It simply adds a disquieting aspect to an already horrifying experience.
This is my first Booth novel, but it won't be my last.
Btw: There is apparently a movie version of this, which came out in 2021, at the height of the Covid-19 pandemic. I have not seen it, but I have heard good things. I think it's available on Amazon Prime.
This is a 150 pages novella happening in a bathroom, like literally around the toilet bowl and it's featuring four characters. We Need to Do Something is lean, intense, creative and downright terrifying. Based on a true story, the bathroom also acts as a metaphorical purgatory for the characters who each have to cleanse their sins. It works both as a survival and a psychedelic horror story.
We Need to Do Something is a breathless, unexpected terror, like a low-key Netflix film you've just stumbled upon by sheer luck in the dead of night. Not the kind of book Max Booth usually writes, but he might be even better at this more tragedian style than he is at the wisecracking/humor-laced horror he got us used to.
A bleak single-location horror novella that fully utilized its limited scope for grandeur, my favorite type of horror stories often involve degradation of the human psyche, and We Need to Do Something is immediately up my street from page one, by introducing a dysfunctional family that is already hanging on by a thread, even before they are being terrorized by their increasingly desperate situation. We Need to Do Something strikes the perfect balance of ambiguity vs. clarity; the immediate outcome of the family members is clear, but the happening in the world beyond their confined space is completely open to interpretation. Depending on how one interpret the more surreal elements (which are all disturbing in the best way possible), this can be a straightforward survival story gone wrong, or something more outlandish and sinister.
Perfectly paced and no holding back on ugliness of all kinds, We Need to Do Something is not a 'fun' horror, it's emotionally draining, stressful, and hopeless, but at the same time so perfectly captured. Definitely read the author's afterword at the end � 2020 was a hard year for a lot of people, and I can see writing this novella during that time must've been a cathartic exercise.
Well that sure was something - what starts out as a claustrophobic tale of survival horror as one family bands together in their bathroom to wait out a tornado ends in a fever dream of terror! The description of this book is as simple and vague: " A family on the verge of self-destruction finds themselves isolated in their bathroom during a tornado warning." That's it. That's all the reader gets. And that's basically all I am going to leave you with because I want your senses to react like mine did. I want you to feel as stressed, confused, disgusted, and heartbroken as I did. ENJOY! It's going to be okay...
The first 60% really worked for me. The setting of a family trapped in a bathroom. The family being in the edge of disaster and none of them getting along. Was leaving me anxiety ridden and I LOVED it. However I realized I was really intrigued about what was going on. And I was looking forward to knowing those answers. But as we get closer to the end I realized no answers were coming.
Now this book is a wild and weird ride. And if you like that please read it. I just need a little more of a logical explanation then just what we are given.
A claustrophobic tale of realism, surrealism, and the struggle for sanity. All of which don't creep too far into fiction, if at all. A fine example of what can be done with minimalism and having a keen eye for knowing the desperation we all have within us--a desperation for freedom, love, escapism, and nourishment.
The entire family was unbearable. They could not make smart decisions to save their lives, and it shows. Here are some jumbled up points that really stick out to me:
1. Y’all were scared bc a rattlesnake came in and didn’t watch it? 2. Follow up: you didn’t check behind the toilet (literally everywhere in that bathroom) when it disappeared? 3. It just seemed so unrealistic that it would be ‘impossible� to get out of the bathroom. 4. Follow up: what kind of bathroom do y’all have that the door opens OUTWARDS? 5. The amount of pee and fart comments from the little brother annoyed me to no end, and made me extremely grateful for my empty womb. 6. Sister found a ritual that said it would destroy everything and still did it? And was surprised that it actually did destroy everything? 7. GIRL STFU. Not everything is about you! Maybe be quiet once in a while, especially when there is machine gun fire outside.
The only part that was genuinely interesting was the “dog� outside of the bathroom door and the resulting tongue thing. But even that, the whole “Hunter of tongues� thing was a little obnoxious.
This whole book was just obnoxious, and the anger that I felt towards every single one of these characters was damn near unbridled.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I never could've expected the ride this book was going to take me on. It was filled to the brim with surprises and had me picking my jaw up off the floor several times throughout it.
DNF. Not only did I not finish this, but I barely started it. When I hated these characters so much I started rooting for the tornado, I decided to just spare myself.
I understand leaving room for character growth, but between a girl suggesting her parents should just kill themselves and saying things like, "thank god for cancer" in reference to her dead grandmother, and parents telling eachother to "shut the fuck up," and getting physically abusive right in front of their kids, it was just a little much. There were more examples, but I just can't be bothered to go searching for them.
A word of advice out there to prospective authors; Character growth is a wonderful, beautiful thing, but you have to start with individuals that have at least a few redeeming qualities so that your audience doesn't irreparably loathe them.
Call me unforgiving, but I don't want the abusive drunkard of a father to realize his folly and swear to never mistreat his kids and wife again. I want him to get sucked out of a window by an EF5 tornado and impaled by a rusted 1988 Toyota pickup.
And the stupid kid who is outright inhumanely cruel to her little brother and is glad her grandma died of cancer because she used a naughty word once, I don't want her to suddenly understand how lucky she is to have a family. I want her to watch said family die in horrible ways and to be left absolutely alone in the world so she might actually appreciate what she used to have.
But that's just me, I guess. I'm vindictive to horrible people, and these were horrible people. I had zero interest in reading about them.
3.5 stars This family was SO annoying. I recognize that the author intended this, but wow these are unlikeable people. Admittedly this was hard to get into because I wanted to punch everyone. Also there is a LOT of talk about pooping and peeing. Yet, despite my criticisms, I ended up getting quite immersed and found the ending quite strong. I'd recommend this one if you enjoy horror about terrible people.