What do you think?
Rate this book
The Roddy and Val DeVere Gilded Age Series #3
A Fatal Gilded High Note
New York's "Diamond Horseshoe" balcony in the Metropolitan Opera House glittered with ladies' jewels in January 1899, and Society seated in private boxes heard Mozart's murder victim sing his song of death-unaware that the sudden death of a "Coal King" in Box 18 will be ruled a homicide.
When opera-goers Val and Roddy DeVere are asked to investigate ("on the q.t."), Val finds herself suspected of complicity in the murder.
The police have "material evidence" against her. Before a jury, Val's lawyer husband reminds her, "'material' evidence can be the bright, shiny object that overrides all reason and fact."
When opera-goers Val and Roddy DeVere are asked to investigate ("on the q.t."), Val finds herself suspected of complicity in the murder.
The police have "material evidence" against her. Before a jury, Val's lawyer husband reminds her, "'material' evidence can be the bright, shiny object that overrides all reason and fact."
360 pages, Kindle Edition
Published March 17, 2022
5 people are currently reading
34 people want to read
About the author
Cecelia Tichi
33Ìýbooks79ÌýfollowersA fresh start for every new book, and author Tichi's zest for America's Gilded Age and its boldface names draws this seasoned writer to a crime fiction series while uncorking the country's cocktail cultures on the printed (and ebook) page. Tichi digs deep into the Vanderbilt University research library to mine the late 1800-1900s history and customs of Society's "Four Hundred," its drinks, and the ways high-stakes crimes in its midst make for a gripping "Gilded" mystery series that rings true to the tumultuous era. The decades of America's industrial titans and "Queens" of Society have loomed large in Tichi's books for several years, and the titles track her recent projects:
� Civic Passions: Seven Who Launched Progressive America (and What They Teach Us)
� Jack London: A Writer's Fight for a Better America
� What Would Mrs. Astor Do? A Complete Guide to the Manners and Mores of the Gilded Age
� Gilded Age Cocktails: History, Lore, and Recipes from the Golden Age
� Jazz Age Cocktails: History, Lore, and Recipes from the Roaring Twenties.
� A Gilded Death (crime fiction)
� Murder, Murder, Murder in Gilded Central Park (crime fiction)
� A Fatal Gilded High Note (crime fiction)
Cecelia is at work on a fourth in the series, “A Gilded Free Fall.� She enjoys membership and posting in Facebook’s The Gilded Age Society. You can read more about Cecelia by visiting her Wikipedia page at: or her website: .
� Civic Passions: Seven Who Launched Progressive America (and What They Teach Us)
� Jack London: A Writer's Fight for a Better America
� What Would Mrs. Astor Do? A Complete Guide to the Manners and Mores of the Gilded Age
� Gilded Age Cocktails: History, Lore, and Recipes from the Golden Age
� Jazz Age Cocktails: History, Lore, and Recipes from the Roaring Twenties.
� A Gilded Death (crime fiction)
� Murder, Murder, Murder in Gilded Central Park (crime fiction)
� A Fatal Gilded High Note (crime fiction)
Cecelia is at work on a fourth in the series, “A Gilded Free Fall.� She enjoys membership and posting in Facebook’s The Gilded Age Society. You can read more about Cecelia by visiting her Wikipedia page at: or her website: .
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews
May 2, 2022
3.5/5 Stars
A Fatal Gilded High Note follows Roddy and Val DeVere as they search for the killer of Coal King Leon Rankin, who was murdered during the opera in the box next to the DeVere's.
For starters, I really liked the idea behind this novel. The characters are funny and witty and have enjoyable personalities. The ending of the novel was quite the plot twist, which (if you've followed me for any length of time now, you know) is a major bonus for me. I definitely didn't see the ending coming the way that it did...it was simultaneously satisfying and frustrating all at the same time.
The drawback for me was that there was A LOT going on in the plot that didn't feel necessarily relevant. I kept getting bogged down in all of the detail surrounding Val's extracurricular activities and social justice movements. It made the story move kind of slowly, and there was just a ton of information to take in from both an extracurricular standpoint as well as a pertinent-to-the-plot standpoint.
As a New York lawyer, Roddy is able to decipher a lot of the information that drives the investigation, which was helpful, since there was a lot to unpack and understand how everything connected to each of the suspects. There were moments, though, where it felt like over-explanation was being done, just to make sure the reader really knew what was going on, which I didn't love. I prefer when an author is able to determine when a reader will need help connecting dots and when a reader is able to infer information from the text.
Admittedly, the middle of this book was rough for me. I really liked the beginning and the end, but the middle was definitely a struggle due to all of the detail being thrown at the reader and the depth/details of the side plots. Now, when I first started this novel, I had no idea it was part of a series. Upon reaching the last page, that became readily apparent, which made the side plots and the level of detail associated with them more understandable, and thus forgivable.
As far as cozy mysteries go, this one isn't a favorite, but I enjoyed it enough to want to read more of Val and Roddy's adventures.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from BookSirens and the review above is a voluntary review*
***This review was originally published on BeccasBookshelves.com***
A Fatal Gilded High Note follows Roddy and Val DeVere as they search for the killer of Coal King Leon Rankin, who was murdered during the opera in the box next to the DeVere's.
For starters, I really liked the idea behind this novel. The characters are funny and witty and have enjoyable personalities. The ending of the novel was quite the plot twist, which (if you've followed me for any length of time now, you know) is a major bonus for me. I definitely didn't see the ending coming the way that it did...it was simultaneously satisfying and frustrating all at the same time.
The drawback for me was that there was A LOT going on in the plot that didn't feel necessarily relevant. I kept getting bogged down in all of the detail surrounding Val's extracurricular activities and social justice movements. It made the story move kind of slowly, and there was just a ton of information to take in from both an extracurricular standpoint as well as a pertinent-to-the-plot standpoint.
As a New York lawyer, Roddy is able to decipher a lot of the information that drives the investigation, which was helpful, since there was a lot to unpack and understand how everything connected to each of the suspects. There were moments, though, where it felt like over-explanation was being done, just to make sure the reader really knew what was going on, which I didn't love. I prefer when an author is able to determine when a reader will need help connecting dots and when a reader is able to infer information from the text.
Admittedly, the middle of this book was rough for me. I really liked the beginning and the end, but the middle was definitely a struggle due to all of the detail being thrown at the reader and the depth/details of the side plots. Now, when I first started this novel, I had no idea it was part of a series. Upon reaching the last page, that became readily apparent, which made the side plots and the level of detail associated with them more understandable, and thus forgivable.
As far as cozy mysteries go, this one isn't a favorite, but I enjoyed it enough to want to read more of Val and Roddy's adventures.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from BookSirens and the review above is a voluntary review*
***This review was originally published on BeccasBookshelves.com***
February 13, 2022
Valentine and Roderick DeVere are avid opera-goers, and usually enjoy themselves in their private box at the Metropolitan Opera House, but when a noisy group of people occupy the next box, one that has been rented out to them, Roddy in particular is not pleased. Before the end of the opera, the group leaves, but one man remains - dead in his chair! During their tentative exploration of the box, Val loses an earring, a piece of “material evidence� that could spell very hot water indeed for her, if she and Roddy are unable to solve the murder themselves�. I’m very much enjoying this set of historical mysteries, taking place in this case in January of 1899, when the gap between the very wealthy (like the DeVeres) and everybody else is as large as it ever had been; a subplot in this book involves Val’s increasing involvement in a women’s organization determined to look into the unhealthy and ill-paying working conditions of young women in department stores, with the aim of improving their circumstances. The mystery itself is fairly plotted, although I found myself disappointed in the final reveal simply because I had no reason not to like a certain character and plenty of reasons to dislike several other suspects; by which I mean, of course, that I didn’t figure it out until the end, which I generally consider to be high praise in the mystery genre! I look forward to reading more from this author; recommended. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
March 8, 2022
A Fatal Gilded High Note is the latest entry in the “Gilded Age� series of cozy mysteries by Cecelia Tichi, and it is just as charming as the previous two novels.
Set again in NYC, January 1899, the story is told from first person POV of Val, a young woman raised in the Wild West silver mines of Nevada. She and her debonair, “old New York society� husband Roddy de Vere, become embroiled in the investigation of a man murdered in the box next to theirs in the Diamond Horseshoe of the opulent new Metropolitan Opera. The murdered man is wealthy with many enemies, and the young couple feel compelled to ferret out the truth and clear the suspicion hanging over Val.
The couple is young and energetic, in their third year of marriage, and the dialogue between them is fresh, intelligent, and lovingly teasing at times. Val’s involvement in championing fair wages and working conditions for women is a strong secondary thread in the story, and gives her character more depth than that of Roddy’s persona. But the sum is greater than the parts, and theirs is a strong partnership to behold! The plot moves well and the writing is smart and lively, and the many references to the history of the times and its famous locales is fascinating.
I highly recommend this cozy mystery novel to fans of novels featuring clever, crime-solving couples and stories set in the “Gilded Age� period in NYC.
Thank you to BookSirens and the author for the ARC. This is my honest review.
Set again in NYC, January 1899, the story is told from first person POV of Val, a young woman raised in the Wild West silver mines of Nevada. She and her debonair, “old New York society� husband Roddy de Vere, become embroiled in the investigation of a man murdered in the box next to theirs in the Diamond Horseshoe of the opulent new Metropolitan Opera. The murdered man is wealthy with many enemies, and the young couple feel compelled to ferret out the truth and clear the suspicion hanging over Val.
The couple is young and energetic, in their third year of marriage, and the dialogue between them is fresh, intelligent, and lovingly teasing at times. Val’s involvement in championing fair wages and working conditions for women is a strong secondary thread in the story, and gives her character more depth than that of Roddy’s persona. But the sum is greater than the parts, and theirs is a strong partnership to behold! The plot moves well and the writing is smart and lively, and the many references to the history of the times and its famous locales is fascinating.
I highly recommend this cozy mystery novel to fans of novels featuring clever, crime-solving couples and stories set in the “Gilded Age� period in NYC.
Thank you to BookSirens and the author for the ARC. This is my honest review.
March 11, 2022
I was really glad to be back in the gilded world of Val & Roddy de Vere again!
Val was one of last year’s best new litteratur aquaintances and I love her way of being able to fit into the upper class life of her husband while still being true to her wild west origin. Much thanks to her husband’s mostly modern way of thinking of course, as women’s rights still had a long way to go at the time. Something Val feels strongly about.
I also enjoy the language which feels authentic for the time while still being easy to read.
This book has a darker theme than the previous somehow, Val is more somber and occasionally quite blue.
I’m not sure if this was why I made a break in my reading, or if that was just because the world got a little more dark and crazy the latest weeks�
However, once I picked the book up again I read it through in one go.
It’s entertaining in a kind of slowpaced and diary writing way. We follow Val to meeting for women’s right, in social and sleuthing situations and they all get the same gravitas in her first person tellings. I apreciate that very much actually.
I look forward to the next book in the series hoping for a bit more of the feisty Val from the first book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Val was one of last year’s best new litteratur aquaintances and I love her way of being able to fit into the upper class life of her husband while still being true to her wild west origin. Much thanks to her husband’s mostly modern way of thinking of course, as women’s rights still had a long way to go at the time. Something Val feels strongly about.
I also enjoy the language which feels authentic for the time while still being easy to read.
This book has a darker theme than the previous somehow, Val is more somber and occasionally quite blue.
I’m not sure if this was why I made a break in my reading, or if that was just because the world got a little more dark and crazy the latest weeks�
However, once I picked the book up again I read it through in one go.
It’s entertaining in a kind of slowpaced and diary writing way. We follow Val to meeting for women’s right, in social and sleuthing situations and they all get the same gravitas in her first person tellings. I apreciate that very much actually.
I look forward to the next book in the series hoping for a bit more of the feisty Val from the first book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
March 7, 2022
The historical detail in this book depicting mostly New York but southern states too is wonderful. The descriptions of the 'moneyed but now ruined' Roddy whose family are saved by marrying the new money of Valentine (although the marriage is based on love) are very insightful. Valentine holds the purse but although Roddy is modern there are instances of his background that tolerate but do not like Val's notions of how to live: ie: her interaction with the house staff and servants (scandal - giving days off) or her involvement in the movement to help shop staff (girls or ladies) a decent wage and better conditions, or even dare I say it giving women the right to vote. I also lapped up the details of the couple having separate bedrooms, this makes the story vivid and real. This book is a great way to absorb correct historical details in a fun way despite a murder in the background.
The Cozy Mystery aspect - murder at the Opera is well dealt with and it is the backbone of the novel.
I truly enjoyed this second book in a series but both books are great standalone reads too.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily
The Cozy Mystery aspect - murder at the Opera is well dealt with and it is the backbone of the novel.
I truly enjoyed this second book in a series but both books are great standalone reads too.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily
March 4, 2022
A Fatal Gilded High Note was a treat. I love the interactions between Val and Roddy DeVere. The world building in this is simply amazing, immersive and lovely.
(As per Book Sirens, I don't share spoilers)
This was a rollercoaster ride, like most of the series (although you can read this as a standalone, I'd start with one, "A Gilded Death".) I do enjoy how Ms. Tichi uses the extensive research of the time period to build the story. She surprised me with the progression of the story and the twist at the end. I wish Val was as much of a strong force as I remember from the previous, but, Roddy did take a bit more of a step forward in this.
All together, it is a great read, especially for fans of historical fiction and a good murder mystery!
(I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily with great honor and delight!)
(As per Book Sirens, I don't share spoilers)
This was a rollercoaster ride, like most of the series (although you can read this as a standalone, I'd start with one, "A Gilded Death".) I do enjoy how Ms. Tichi uses the extensive research of the time period to build the story. She surprised me with the progression of the story and the twist at the end. I wish Val was as much of a strong force as I remember from the previous, but, Roddy did take a bit more of a step forward in this.
All together, it is a great read, especially for fans of historical fiction and a good murder mystery!
(I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily with great honor and delight!)
February 9, 2022
A Fatal Gilded High Note Book 2 by Cecelia Tichi. I think this series is wonderful. I love Roddy and Val, they are marvelous characters with a nose for mysteries. It is 1899 and Roddy's family is saved from "genteel" poverty by Val's millions. Roddy loves opera and he and Valentine are dressed in their best and in box 17. But, Mr Rankin is killed in Box 18. Unfortunately, Valentine lost an earring in the same box and she is a suspect. This begins an exciting part of the story. I really think that Cecelia Tichi writes excellent cozy mysteries. She builds the story and leads the reader to discover the clues. I spent an enjoyable time reading a wonderful book. I received an arc for free and am leaving my review voluntarily.
March 9, 2022
When the "Coal King" is murdered in the opera box next to Roddy and Valentine little did Val know that her worst nightmare would come true.
In 1897 Roddy is a lawyer helping to investigate the death of the Coal King to clear his wife of murder charges. The deeper they dig into his past only adds more suspects to the list.
The pieces of the puzzle start to fall in place putting Val's life in danger. The end will surprise you.
Mystery, suspense, betrayal, government corruption.
Also, throughout the story there are a few cocktail recipes that Roddy has created to help other alcohol establishments.
Thank you Booksirens and the author for a digital copy. Read and reviewed voluntarily and the opinions expressed here are unbiased and entirely my own.
In 1897 Roddy is a lawyer helping to investigate the death of the Coal King to clear his wife of murder charges. The deeper they dig into his past only adds more suspects to the list.
The pieces of the puzzle start to fall in place putting Val's life in danger. The end will surprise you.
Mystery, suspense, betrayal, government corruption.
Also, throughout the story there are a few cocktail recipes that Roddy has created to help other alcohol establishments.
Thank you Booksirens and the author for a digital copy. Read and reviewed voluntarily and the opinions expressed here are unbiased and entirely my own.
March 9, 2022
This my second read from this author. I am a fan. The story is wonderfully written and the main characters are entertaining. The mystery plot and the scenery keeps the story interesting.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
February 23, 2022
Val and Roddy DeVere once again find themselves in the midst of murder and more in this 3rd book in the series of Gilded Age mysteries that started with A Gilded Death. This time, the murder takes place at the opera house and Val is more involved than she would like to be. She and Roddy go to great lengths to quietly investigate the death since it’s one of the “new money� folks. As they do so, we once again get a glimpse of life for the well heeled and “old money� families in 1899 New York City. Val also gets involved with working conditions for women in particular, thanks to joining the Consumers League and meeting real life activists Florence Kelley and Mother Jones.
I read this book while also watching The Gilded Age TV show on HBO, and it is fun to see the similarities in portrayal of upper crust life in those days. Ms. Tichi and Julian Fellowes (of Downton Abbey fame) have both done their research on the times. The TV show helped bring to life the book for me, to see and hear the customs and opinions of the old moneyed folks regarding the new moneyed folks (and the costumes are amazing). Val isn’t supposed to walk the streets of NYC unaccompanied because ladies just don’t do that (plus it’s not safe) � Val finds this frustrating and I would too. After all, she grew up in the “Wild West� without such restrictions. But she does her best to fit in, because she loves her husband (who comes from old money although the family needed Val’s silver mine money to maintain their status) and tries to not dismay her mother-in-law too often.
As with previous books in the series, we get to learn more of Val’s history, and we’re treated to several cocktail recipes thanks to Roddy’s quiet work helping various establishments to improve on their alcoholic offerings. Roddy is more active in the sleuthing this time around, and I have to say I was a little disappointed in Val’s demeanor in this book. She doesn’t come across as strong a character as in the first books. My hope is that she will return to form in the next book in the series. There’s also very little of her close friend Cassie in this book, a character whom I find to be quite interesting and would love to see more of in the future.
As with the first books, the mystery is interesting, the writing is excellent, and although the voice is first person past tense (Val’s voice) it doesn’t detract from the story. (My preference is 3rd person past tense voice, but I won’t let a different voice interfere with my enjoyment of a book.) The story is complete and you don’t need to read the first two books to enjoy this third one. If you like period pieces along with a cozy mystery and a peek into a lifestyle most of us will never come close to, with a strong female character and her supportive husband, you will enjoy A Fatal Gilded High Note and the other books in the series. The cocktail recipes are a nice bonus!
I received an Advance Reader Copy of A Fatal Gilded High Note for free, and I leave this review voluntarily and with pleasure.
I read this book while also watching The Gilded Age TV show on HBO, and it is fun to see the similarities in portrayal of upper crust life in those days. Ms. Tichi and Julian Fellowes (of Downton Abbey fame) have both done their research on the times. The TV show helped bring to life the book for me, to see and hear the customs and opinions of the old moneyed folks regarding the new moneyed folks (and the costumes are amazing). Val isn’t supposed to walk the streets of NYC unaccompanied because ladies just don’t do that (plus it’s not safe) � Val finds this frustrating and I would too. After all, she grew up in the “Wild West� without such restrictions. But she does her best to fit in, because she loves her husband (who comes from old money although the family needed Val’s silver mine money to maintain their status) and tries to not dismay her mother-in-law too often.
As with previous books in the series, we get to learn more of Val’s history, and we’re treated to several cocktail recipes thanks to Roddy’s quiet work helping various establishments to improve on their alcoholic offerings. Roddy is more active in the sleuthing this time around, and I have to say I was a little disappointed in Val’s demeanor in this book. She doesn’t come across as strong a character as in the first books. My hope is that she will return to form in the next book in the series. There’s also very little of her close friend Cassie in this book, a character whom I find to be quite interesting and would love to see more of in the future.
As with the first books, the mystery is interesting, the writing is excellent, and although the voice is first person past tense (Val’s voice) it doesn’t detract from the story. (My preference is 3rd person past tense voice, but I won’t let a different voice interfere with my enjoyment of a book.) The story is complete and you don’t need to read the first two books to enjoy this third one. If you like period pieces along with a cozy mystery and a peek into a lifestyle most of us will never come close to, with a strong female character and her supportive husband, you will enjoy A Fatal Gilded High Note and the other books in the series. The cocktail recipes are a nice bonus!
I received an Advance Reader Copy of A Fatal Gilded High Note for free, and I leave this review voluntarily and with pleasure.
February 22, 2022
I'm so glad I found Cecelia Tichi and her Gilded Age series! Cozy mysteries are my escape after I've read several big, complex and/or intense books where the content requires a lot of concentration and thought. It's these cozies that allow me to enjoy a great story, have a few chuckles and give me that refresh every reader needs from time to time.
In "A Fatal Gilded High Note" the story of Roddy and Val, the high society couple who live in Gilded Age New York City are back at it, but this time when they're at the opera enjoying the show in their exclusive box, they're disrupted by a murder in the box right next to them. Soon the police are asking Roddy and Val to help out with the investigation on the "QT", which is nothing new, since they've been helpful in the past. And this time the police find "material evidence" that links Val to the crime, so it's vital Roddy and Val figure this one out quickly!
I just love Roddy, Val! They're such a cool couple and definitely not the norm for the Gilded Age. Val is a gal from the Wild West and doesn't conform to New York society's rules for a "lady," she's one go getter and doesn't care what others say about her. After all it's her family's money that the couple counts on. Her father made a killing in silver out west where Roddy and Val met when Roddy was taken there as a young man to "dry out." What's really cool is Roddy's hobby as a mixologist is a big part of the book Tichi gives the reader the recipes for all his exotic drinks. I don't drink, but it's a fun part of the storyline.
These books make me laugh, they're good mysteries that I try to figure out as I'm reading, and the characters are great, but Roddy and Val are so cute together I picture them as a stuffy high-class couple out on their walks or lunching at the club and laughing together, just having fun. They seem like they'd be great friends to have! I'm hooked and so glad to know there's another book on the way, as I learned when I finished this one. Anything about the Gilded Age grabs my attention, but these books present it in such a fun way it's really entertaining, and Val is so independent and unlike a lady of the era it's refreshing. She bucks the system and Roddy is right there with her supporting everything she does! it's just great cozy mystery fiction and I can't wait for more! Oh, and I can't forget their French Bulldog Velvet, she's got a starring role in this one, but for me she steals the scene in every book! I highly recommend this series, it's become a favorite of mine and again, I'm so glad I found it! Happy Reading!
In "A Fatal Gilded High Note" the story of Roddy and Val, the high society couple who live in Gilded Age New York City are back at it, but this time when they're at the opera enjoying the show in their exclusive box, they're disrupted by a murder in the box right next to them. Soon the police are asking Roddy and Val to help out with the investigation on the "QT", which is nothing new, since they've been helpful in the past. And this time the police find "material evidence" that links Val to the crime, so it's vital Roddy and Val figure this one out quickly!
I just love Roddy, Val! They're such a cool couple and definitely not the norm for the Gilded Age. Val is a gal from the Wild West and doesn't conform to New York society's rules for a "lady," she's one go getter and doesn't care what others say about her. After all it's her family's money that the couple counts on. Her father made a killing in silver out west where Roddy and Val met when Roddy was taken there as a young man to "dry out." What's really cool is Roddy's hobby as a mixologist is a big part of the book Tichi gives the reader the recipes for all his exotic drinks. I don't drink, but it's a fun part of the storyline.
These books make me laugh, they're good mysteries that I try to figure out as I'm reading, and the characters are great, but Roddy and Val are so cute together I picture them as a stuffy high-class couple out on their walks or lunching at the club and laughing together, just having fun. They seem like they'd be great friends to have! I'm hooked and so glad to know there's another book on the way, as I learned when I finished this one. Anything about the Gilded Age grabs my attention, but these books present it in such a fun way it's really entertaining, and Val is so independent and unlike a lady of the era it's refreshing. She bucks the system and Roddy is right there with her supporting everything she does! it's just great cozy mystery fiction and I can't wait for more! Oh, and I can't forget their French Bulldog Velvet, she's got a starring role in this one, but for me she steals the scene in every book! I highly recommend this series, it's become a favorite of mine and again, I'm so glad I found it! Happy Reading!
May 23, 2022
Meet Val (Valentine from the "Wild West") and her husband Roderick (Roddy) DeVere (of the wealthy DeVeres). While at the Metropolitan Opera House, they were in their own box when a coal magnate was murdered in the next box. What brought them into the business of investigation was an invite by the police commissioner to quietly nose around among the wealthy patrons and also possible enemies of the deceased without disclosing the real cause of death. The investigation appeared to be hard work while Val had to deal with her totally disapproving mother-in-law, dissention among the servants, trying to overcome her own disdain of society rules, and working to improve the plight of women working in retail. Meanwhile, Roddy gets stuck with the legal work (and the fun of devising new cocktail recipes). Good research, interesting characters, fine descriptions, and a lively sleuthing. Delightful!
I requested and received a free e-book copy from BookSirens and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Independent Book Publishers Association
I requested and received a free e-book copy from BookSirens and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Independent Book Publishers Association
April 25, 2022
I love reading about "The Gilded Age". This time period in history is simply enthralling to me. I love imagining the dresses worn, the way people carried themselves, their deportment, manners, just everything is so different from what life is like today for us. The Gilded Age, was a time of gentlemen, and well mannered women,, nothing like society is today. But even then you find there are those who go against the grain, those who can not accept things for the way they are and try to change the way society is. I guess that is what brings about progress and change, but it is sad to me sometimes that all this, everything that personified that era is gone, what we have left of that period is the writings of some great authors, the art work, statues, paintings and such of great artists, some of the wonderful buildings and homes that were built during that time of riches and affluence still stand today, these are a testament to the times from which they have evolved and I love all of it.
Cecelia Tichi is a master at capturing the atmosphere of the Gilded era, the essence of the times and she does it spectacularly in this book. You will find all the twists, turns, red-herrings and more along with beautiful descriptive passages that set time and place wonderfully, so that we, the readers are transported back to that gilded era in history. inside this mystery, perfect for a quick weekend read.
Thank you to the author, publisher and to Booksirens for the free ARC, I am leaving my honest review in return.
Cecelia Tichi is a master at capturing the atmosphere of the Gilded era, the essence of the times and she does it spectacularly in this book. You will find all the twists, turns, red-herrings and more along with beautiful descriptive passages that set time and place wonderfully, so that we, the readers are transported back to that gilded era in history. inside this mystery, perfect for a quick weekend read.
Thank you to the author, publisher and to Booksirens for the free ARC, I am leaving my honest review in return.
May 10, 2022
As an opera lover I was drawn to the title and then the description of this cosy mystery set in the “Gilded Age� at the turn of the century. Cecilia Tichi cocoons the reader in the richness and grandeur of the time but through Valentine de Vere (our narrator) we also view the other side of the coin as she researches the working conditions of females in retail, domestic and other workplaces.
Of course, for a mystery, we need a murder�.and this occurs at the Met in the box next to that of Val and her husband Roderick. Unfortunately when seeping blood causes them to investigate, Val somehow loses an earring, leading to her being a possible suspect (amongst others). They decide to checkout the background of the deceased, a self made “coal� king, his family and associates, discovering some surprises along the way.
I am a sucker for historical detail and this has bucketloads, including several cocktail recipes “du jour�. Val and Roddy are an engaging couple and I loved the way Velvet the French Bulldog is included as a part of their family. I got a bit bogged down as Roddy was untangling the victim’s business dealings but the novel picked up speed (just like the “Louisa�!) and pulled in for a barn storming finish.
I look forward to reading the other books in the series. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Of course, for a mystery, we need a murder�.and this occurs at the Met in the box next to that of Val and her husband Roderick. Unfortunately when seeping blood causes them to investigate, Val somehow loses an earring, leading to her being a possible suspect (amongst others). They decide to checkout the background of the deceased, a self made “coal� king, his family and associates, discovering some surprises along the way.
I am a sucker for historical detail and this has bucketloads, including several cocktail recipes “du jour�. Val and Roddy are an engaging couple and I loved the way Velvet the French Bulldog is included as a part of their family. I got a bit bogged down as Roddy was untangling the victim’s business dealings but the novel picked up speed (just like the “Louisa�!) and pulled in for a barn storming finish.
I look forward to reading the other books in the series. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
March 20, 2023
Going back in time to when the gentry and the commoners did not associate themselves with each other, brings a whole new (really old) way of being. Those who made their wealth on the railroads or copper mines or silver were a breed all their own. But so was the gentry of the New England states. They did not accept the newly wealthy from the "wild west" feeling themselves far superior to them. But when east meets west in those days lots of tensions arise. When murder happens, it doesn't take much to cast aspersions on the unaccepted "wild" wife of one of their own. It's up to them to clear their name and find out just exactly who did it.
This was a very enjoyable read and I would recommend it to anyone who loves historical novels.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This was a very enjoyable read and I would recommend it to anyone who loves historical novels.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 7, 2022
Roderick and Valentine DeVere are part of high society in New York at the end of the 19th Century. They are beginning to have a habit of getting involved in mysteries. In this book Val is a suspect because her earring is found at the murder scene. This makes solving the puzzle even more imperative for Roddy and Val.
Not only is A Fatal Gilded High Note an enthralling murder mystery, but its setting, in wintry New York for high society ladies and gentlemen, makes it also something of a social commentary. Despite the position her marriage has brought her, Val does not for one moment forget the humble early years of her life. She is interested in bringing better working conditions to saleswomen in the large stores of the time. She even (shock, horror) likes to give her household staff a day off now and then.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Not only is A Fatal Gilded High Note an enthralling murder mystery, but its setting, in wintry New York for high society ladies and gentlemen, makes it also something of a social commentary. Despite the position her marriage has brought her, Val does not for one moment forget the humble early years of her life. She is interested in bringing better working conditions to saleswomen in the large stores of the time. She even (shock, horror) likes to give her household staff a day off now and then.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
June 29, 2023
I do like Cecelia Tichi's books. I like the period that they evoke, I especially like the character of Valentine DeVere and furthermore, Tichi knows how to spin a good yarn to make an enjoyable murder mystery so, her books are super easy to read and involving without being taxing. Just how I like my fiction.
In this book, the third of the Valentine DeVere mysteries, Roddy and Val are at the opera when a famous coal magnate is killed in one of the boxes, although this is not something that Hoff, the opera's owner, wants the public to know. When Roddy and Val are visited by the police chief and a suggestion is made that Val may know more about what happened to the "Coal King", Leon Rankin, than she cares to admit, Roddy and Val find themselves coerced into a situation where an investigation into the murder has more than justice for the killer depending on it - Val's reputation is also at stake.
Those of you who have read Tichi's fiction before will know how important outward appearances are to the members of the Society to which Roddy and Val belong. There are standards that need to be met and Val sometimes falls short of these due to her upbringing, which is very much NOT that of potential society dame. So, when her already slightly tarnished status is likely to become blackened, Val's reputation must be preserved, most particularly for the sake of Val's mother-in-law, who mixes with some of the great people of influence and stature in New York City.
As usual, Tichi's plot unfolds at the right pace, with characters being introduced throughout, some of whom are suspects in the crime that the DeVeres are looking into, but some of them are also of the period and are used by Tichi to increase the atmosphere, but also to reflect the cultural mores and social issues of the day. I was interested in the inclusion of Mother Jones, a labour activist who is incorporated into the story as Val is involved with a women's group helping poorly paid women who can barely survive on their wages. Details like this add depth to the novel and having Val meet an actual historical figure contemporary to the time gives an extra layer of credence to the narrative and Tichi's conjuring of the period.
Another great read from Tichi.
I was privileged to read this book as an ARC. This is my true and unbiased opinion of the book.
In this book, the third of the Valentine DeVere mysteries, Roddy and Val are at the opera when a famous coal magnate is killed in one of the boxes, although this is not something that Hoff, the opera's owner, wants the public to know. When Roddy and Val are visited by the police chief and a suggestion is made that Val may know more about what happened to the "Coal King", Leon Rankin, than she cares to admit, Roddy and Val find themselves coerced into a situation where an investigation into the murder has more than justice for the killer depending on it - Val's reputation is also at stake.
Those of you who have read Tichi's fiction before will know how important outward appearances are to the members of the Society to which Roddy and Val belong. There are standards that need to be met and Val sometimes falls short of these due to her upbringing, which is very much NOT that of potential society dame. So, when her already slightly tarnished status is likely to become blackened, Val's reputation must be preserved, most particularly for the sake of Val's mother-in-law, who mixes with some of the great people of influence and stature in New York City.
As usual, Tichi's plot unfolds at the right pace, with characters being introduced throughout, some of whom are suspects in the crime that the DeVeres are looking into, but some of them are also of the period and are used by Tichi to increase the atmosphere, but also to reflect the cultural mores and social issues of the day. I was interested in the inclusion of Mother Jones, a labour activist who is incorporated into the story as Val is involved with a women's group helping poorly paid women who can barely survive on their wages. Details like this add depth to the novel and having Val meet an actual historical figure contemporary to the time gives an extra layer of credence to the narrative and Tichi's conjuring of the period.
Another great read from Tichi.
I was privileged to read this book as an ARC. This is my true and unbiased opinion of the book.
March 26, 2022
“I had thought that moustache wax was out of fashion, but apparently not.� Val’s droll wit and frequent reminiscing about her years in the Wild West give this murder mystery a real “tang� and keep it from becoming just another rich couple’s hobby. Roddy’s and Valentine’s unpredictable marriage is romantic and full of real friendship intelligent banter - resources they put to good use when investigating a murder in an adjoining opera box that threatens to ruin their own reputations. There were so many interesting characters, and an equal number of twists and turns! One page would have me laughing aloud, and the next, trying not to nibble my nails with anxiety. I really couldn’t narrow down the suspects until almost the very end of the book� and even then there was another stunning surprise! I love the setting in late 19th century New York. High society’s etiquette and lifestyle are well researched and interestingly portrayed. I could totally identify with Val’s consternation as she tries to find her place in a changing world. I’m looking forward to the rest of the books in this great series, and adding Cecelia Tichi to my list of must-read authors. I received a complimentary advance review copy from the publisher via Book Sirens, and was not required to post a review.
March 18, 2022
Take a trip back in time to January 1899 where Val and Roddy DeVere are sitting in their private balcony box at the Metropolitan Opera House. Little did they know the events right next to them in rented balcony Box 18 “Coal King� Rankin was being murdered. Surprisingly, Val and Roddy are asked to quietly investigate the case. When police find material evidence Val left at the crime scene she is suddenly under suspect. The stakes are raised high as Val's lawyer husband Roddy has to convincingly prove his wife is innocent in front of a jury.
A Fatal High NoteÌýis an unraveling tale as Val and Roddy track down information about the elusive Rankin and his business competitions with Flager, the wealthiest railroader in town. Cecelia Tichi weaves this mystery and delivers so many thought-out directions and elements with an entertaining cast of characters.
I recommend the book for fans of the tv showÌýA Gilded AgeÌýand complicated mysteries. This is the third installment in the Val and Roddy mystery series and I have to confess Roddy has completely stolen my heart and is my newest literary crush. I love how forward-thinking both Val and Roddy are despite their confines of high society that are governed heavily by Mrs. Astor's strict standards. The historical accuracy of Tichi will appeal to true history buffs and also makes for delightful conversations at your next book club meeting.
I suggest finding a quiet little reading nook to read this book. You will need your thinking cap with this one. Even the most seasoned of mystery and crime fans such as myself will be pressed hard to solve the mystery before the very last page.
A Fatal High NoteÌýis an unraveling tale as Val and Roddy track down information about the elusive Rankin and his business competitions with Flager, the wealthiest railroader in town. Cecelia Tichi weaves this mystery and delivers so many thought-out directions and elements with an entertaining cast of characters.
I recommend the book for fans of the tv showÌýA Gilded AgeÌýand complicated mysteries. This is the third installment in the Val and Roddy mystery series and I have to confess Roddy has completely stolen my heart and is my newest literary crush. I love how forward-thinking both Val and Roddy are despite their confines of high society that are governed heavily by Mrs. Astor's strict standards. The historical accuracy of Tichi will appeal to true history buffs and also makes for delightful conversations at your next book club meeting.
I suggest finding a quiet little reading nook to read this book. You will need your thinking cap with this one. Even the most seasoned of mystery and crime fans such as myself will be pressed hard to solve the mystery before the very last page.
March 28, 2022
This is a long but very rewarding read. It is set at the end of the 19th century in New York but includes a trip to Florida by Private Rail Car. There is a theme running throughout about women's rights and there is a lot of reference to the old rich and their servants. It is my impresion from reading a fair amount of history that the author has done a good job of portraying the era in that society. The mystery has many characters which makes it interesting and intricate in terms of solving it, including the skirting of legalality by police and important people. I would gladly read other books in this series
March 24, 2022
NYC, January 1899 is the setting of this book, and it is delightfully written. This is a new to me author, so I started the book with a sense of trepidation. That feeling didn't last long as I was soon swept away by this clever mystery. Val and Roddy de Vere are excellent characters and quite the crime solving couple. I think this book will appeal to fans of The Gilded Age and fans of well written mysteries. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
June 6, 2022
This book was very slow to start and somewhat hard to get into. The sleuthing team of Roddy and Val is reminiscent of Nick and Nora or Tommy and Tuppence just in the gilded age. Once it got going, it was a solid mystery, with a good plot line and a nice twist at who done it. Val is a strong female character but I was disappointed that she didn’t rebel a bit more against the housekeeper or the odious mother-in-law. The historical depiction of the people and places were well written. While this book didn’t hit my wow factor it was still a good read and I look forward to reading other things by this author and hoping the continuing adventures of Roddy and Val show Val standing up more to the small minded of that age. *** Thank you to the author, the publisher and BookSirens for an ARC of this novel.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 30, 2023
I found the mystery itself interesting, an unusual location, characters that I like, all of the basics of a good mystery. However, I found Val's constant referrals to her life out west to be irritating, her western adage bring down the tone of the story. Roddy talks like an idiot instead of a erudite lawyer. I am giving you my honest opinion, which is formed by reading on a daily basis for forty years. I have had a book in my hand before the first grade. I wish to help this author, and I believe the editor should have caught these problems, they are obvious, as you are reading, boom, they smack you in the face, there is no smooth continuity in this story, page after page it jumps out. I appreciate the opportunity to give my review, and hope the stilted conversations are replaced, because, as it is, I cannot recommend it. I tried giving it a 2.5.
Thank you,
carolintallahassee
Thank you,
carolintallahassee
August 9, 2022
Another cozy mystery in this series that isn't technically a named series, but still follows the crime-related adventures of the same couple. Each book itself is a stand-alone story, so you won't feel confused if you pick up this one, even though its the third adventure for Val and Roddy. This mystery dug into the history of the Metropolitan Theater, which was quite interesting to me. I have yet to find a copy of the very first book in this series (A Gilded Death, I believe), but I enjoyed the second book and this third book, and am looking forward to reading the fourth.
I received an e-ARC from BookSirens for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an e-ARC from BookSirens for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
March 25, 2022
Historical fiction.
1899 society in New York.
Beautifully written!
Great characters.
Attention grabber.
Entertaining!
Enjoyable!
Read!
1899 society in New York.
Beautifully written!
Great characters.
Attention grabber.
Entertaining!
Enjoyable!
Read!
July 12, 2022
This is a new author for me. Not knowing Ms. Tichi’s work I found it rather difficult to read. The structure of the sentences was rather awkward to nagivate. Perhaps my schooling in UK English prevents me appreciating the American language. That said I do read other American authors with no problem at all. I felt I was going round in circles with the plot and ended up rather confused but maybe that was the purpose. They gave me a good insight into the way of life during that era for women. Not one of my favourite reads but it could be someone else’s best read of the month.
March 9, 2022
am not sure why I had trouble really getting into this book or caring about solving the mystery. I do like the main characters and the book is well written. The mystery of who did it is good in that it is not easy to figure out who it is. These books do not follow a formula. In the end when we do find out, I was a bit puzzled as to the motive of one person. So while it isn't my favorite book, I do think it is good and many will enjoy it.
July 19, 2022
My favorite part of this book is the characters. They are interesting and likable; the personalities of the main characters shine through as clever and quick-witted. The plot was interesting and had a twist at the end that I wasn’t expecting. There is a lot going on in the book so the reader needs to pay attention. Overall,I found this book quite enjoyable and will look for the next in the series. I received a copy of this book and this review is voluntary.
August 10, 2022
A very descriptive story about murder and the mystery of solving a very intricate puzzle. I enjoyed the characters and the storyline. I loved Val’s rebellious side and wished for more of that at the end of the book. The ending was short but not so sweet. I can only imagine how frustrating it was to be a woman in that time period. No voice, no foot to stand on.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 18, 2023
I enjoyed the Opera being the setting for this mystery. I am a real fan of this series and enjoy books set in the Gilded Age.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.