ŷ

Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

New Milton #2

Between the Lines

Rate this book
Theo Wishart has given up on finding love.

Luca Moretti doesn’t want to find it.

A handful of summer days may change their lives forever—if they’re brave enough to look between the lines.

Eyes might be windows to the soul, but for Theo Wishart they’re all shuttered. His dyspraxia makes it hard to read people. He doesn’t do relationships and he certainly doesn’t do the great outdoors. Two weeks spent “embracing beach life� while he tries to close the deal on a once great, now fading seaside hotel is a special kind of hell.

Until Luca. Gorgeous, unreachable Luca.

Luca Moretti travels light, avoiding all romantic entanglements. Estranged from his parents, he vows this will be his last trip home to New Milton. His family’s hotel is on the verge of ruin and there’s nothing Luca can do to save it. He’s given up on the Majestic, he’s given up on his family and he’s given up on his future.

Until Theo. Prickly, captivating Theo.

No mushy feelings, no expectations, and no drama—that’s the deal. A simple summer fling. And it suits them both just fine. But as the summer wanes and their feelings deepen, it’s clear to everyone around them that Theo and Luca are falling in love. What will it take for them to admit it to themselves—and to each other?

This book is approximately 73,000 words



One-click with confidence. This title is part of the
Carina Press Romance Promise : all the romance you’re looking for with an HEA/HFN. It’s a promise!

241 pages, Kindle Edition

First published December 10, 2018

31 people are currently reading
730 people want to read

About the author

Sally Malcolm

36books286followers
Sally Malcolm was bitten by the m/m romance bug in 2016 and hasn’t looked back. It’s fair to say she’s obsessed with the genre. She has four contemporary m/m romances out, set in the fictional Long Island seaside town of New Milton.

She's also the author of eight Stargate novels and novellas, including the hit "Apocalypse" trilogy. She has penned four Stargate audio dramas for Big Finish Productions, including Stargate SG-1: "An Eye for an Eye" starring Michael Shanks, Claudia Black, and Cliff Simon.

Sally lives in South West London.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
106 (22%)
4 stars
217 (45%)
3 stars
115 (24%)
2 stars
29 (6%)
1 star
6 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 139 reviews
Profile Image for ~✡~Dαni(ela) ♥ ♂♂ love & semi-colons~✡~.
3,419 reviews1,011 followers
January 4, 2019
~4.5~

With this book, Sally Malcolm has proven that she can hold her own in the M/M romance arena. She's clearly an accomplished writer and has a flair for language.

Between the Lines is set in the same world as Perfect Day. We're even invited to Joshua and Finn's wedding! However, this book, which is not based on an Austen novel, can be read as a standalone.

Theo arrives in New Milton ready to prove himself to his successful hotelier father. The Majestic is a grand hotel owned by the Moretti family, but it's seen better days. The elevator is broken; the rooms are empty; and Jude Moretti and her husband, Don, are barely making ends meet. Theo is determined to buy the Majestic and turn it into a golf resort for the wealthy. He's just not prepared for the force that is Luca Moretti.

Luca is back home for the summer. Resentful of Don (his stepfather), angry with Jude for even considering selling their family legacy, Luca has no time for uptight guys with snooty British accents. Luca is like a wounded animal, quick to lash out in rage, licking his hurts in secret.

Luca and Theo meet by running into each other. Literally. Hot coffee is involved. The next time they meet they're both wearing a suit and negotiating the sale of the Majestic.

Jude begs Theo to get to know the hotel and the town; she's not ready to make a decision regarding the sale. So Theo spends time in New Milton, and he and Luca develop a tentative friendship that turns into a summer fling. Think walks on the beach, bodybording lessons, and intimate conversations.

The enemies-to-lovers theme is really well done. Luca, especially, blows hot and cold, and isn't willing to share himself with Theo. Even though Theo initially comes across as arrogant, nothing could be further from the truth. Theo has a disability that affects his coordination and time awareness. He's always been clumsy and terrible at sports.

I love stories with imperfect MCs, and I fell for Theo almost immediately. Brash, charming Luca was harder to like. I hated the way he treated Theo, but Luca's behavior didn't ruin the story for me.

Luca, Jude, and Don are flawed characters. Luca's beef with Don wasn't unfounded, far from it. Don tried, but he didn't try enough. I wanted to hate Don, but I couldn't. It was obvious how much he worried about Jude's health and wanted the best for her.

That was one of my favorite things about this story: how nuanced the characters were, how they were motivated by their fears, and how Luca had to forgive, not just for his mom's sake but for his own.

The ending is inspirational and heartwarming. It speaks to following your dreams, even when you're scared, even if rejection is a real possibility. The epilogue made me super happy. This story has a wonderful HEA!

My one complaint, besides the lack of communication between the men (which was sooo frustrating!), is that the steam level was quite low. It's not a deal-breaker by any means; the slow burn was subtle and sexy. But I wanted more passion, damn it!

I certainly hope this isn't the last story set in New Milton.
Profile Image for ☆ Todd.
1,422 reviews1,578 followers
October 11, 2018

Strike another one in the *WIN* column for Sally Malcolm. After really enjoying "Perfect Day", I had high hopes for this story and wasn't disappointed.



Theo was a bit of a persnickety oddball right from the start, but I immediately loved him, though, I think his overall strangeness could've been pumped up a few notches. And his dyspraxia was rarely even touched upon in the story, actually.



But Luca was the MC that I connected most closely with in the book, though. Yes, he could be a bit of a standoffish, broody prick at times, but right from the get go, you could see that he had a heart of gold and a lightness about him that drew others into his orbit. Luca was a bit like Finn from "Perfect Day", now that I think about it.



The guys for sure didn't start out on the right footing with one another, but I loved seeing them spend time together and get to know one another better, until they finally gave in to the immediate attraction that they'd both felt.



The book had a few angsty, dramatic moments, but I felt that it never crossed the line into unrealistic territory. Both MC's had their issues, which they worked through. Slowly. And sometimes painfully. But they did the work, especially Theo, and came out the other side better off for confronting their fears.
Hey, you okay?

He wasn’t really. The song, and his startling revelation, had left him feeling raw and unbalanced. Rash.

Which was probably why he said, �I wish I could have that, you know? That kind of love.

With you.
In regards to steam, there was some, but not so much as to feel gratuitous. For me, the frequency of the sexy times hit the Goldilocks zone pretty dead-on.



The resolution for the problem with the sale of the hotel, Luca's childhood home and family legacy, went almost exactly as I'd predicted, although I didn't care. Not one bit.

But guys, JOSH & FINN'S WEDDING!!!



Christ, I normally *loathe* Big Gay Wedding plots in stories, but this one was seriously amazing and heart-felt.

Pro Tip: When they mention the title and artist of "The Song" in the book, stop and watch the YouTube video and really *listen* to the lyrics, then continue reading. All the feels, people! ALL of them. Purrrr-fection.

Aaaaand that's probably the first and last time you'll ever hear me gushing about a storybook wedding, but this one was extremely non-Disney'esque, so some major points there. ;- )



This second book in the New Milton universe was not based upon a Jane Austen book, so we blessedly weren't forced to endure the repeated "chase and run away" scenario seen in "Perfect Day". Praise the Lawd!

The book worked perfectly fine as a standalone, with very little exposure to the characters from the first book -- except for the very touching wedding scene, which was a huge highlight of this story for me.

In regards to pacing and length, there were a few times when events were a bit slow, and the story felt a bit long, but I never got bored and lost interest. I simply wanted to get to the next bit of excitement.

I'd rate this book at around 4.25 stars and recommend it to anyone who enjoys "some" drama and steam, but not an overabundance.

-----------------------------------------------

My ARC copy of the book was provided by the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for a fair, unbiased review.

See All My Latest Reads (Review Quick-Links)

-----------------------------------------------
Profile Image for Judith.
724 reviews2,916 followers
October 25, 2018



Another enjoyable story by Sally Malcolm with engaging characters in a quaint small town setting.If you've read Perfect Day by this Author you'll be familiar with the town and some of the characters.


Luca Moretti is a bit of a free spirit,not one to be tied down to any place or anyone.He's back in his home town after five years to try and persuade his mother not to sell the place he used to call home....the ageing Majestic Hotel.His mother,Jude,feels she doesn't have much option other than selling to a large investment company.The hotel needs time and money spent on it...something she's unable to give.Luca arrives in town full of hostility which is directed at Jude's husband who made his views on Luca's sexuality very clear years ago and this is the first time Luca has returned in years.

Theo Wishart is the man given the job of persuading Jude to sell the beautiful old hotel but it's not going to be an easy transaction.Jude offers Theo a life line in negotiations....stay at the hotel for two weeks and feel the beauty of it and the town.


Theo and Luca don't get off to the best start but their attraction for each other soon becomes apparent.And yes,it was insta lust/love but this is one of those books that just worked for me.Their feelings moved fast but I found it believable and they are pretty cute together.


Theo has dyspraxia,he can't read people well and his last 'relationship' with a man didn't end well.He's adorably awkward and has no idea how to relax and embrace his experience in New Milton.There are some lovely moments between them....Luca teaching Theo to body board,beach top walks holding hands,slow dancing at a wedding.Can Theo dare to hope Luca might be the one and will Luca be prepared to give up his wanderlust and settle down?

And will the hotel be rescued?


Recommended read.


Review copy provided by the publisher,via NetGalley.
Profile Image for Nazanin.
1,227 reviews821 followers
January 6, 2019
4.5 Stars

Well, it’s official! This author became one of my fave authors! Her books are really awesome! She definitely can write! Love her writing! She writes in such a way that you can feel, feel everything! This story is so emotional, intense and a bit angsty! All the elements that I like in a book! She can create characters that you can’t not love them! Theo was full of heart, brave and simply amazing (and he has a disability but it doesn't play a huge part of the story). Luca was a bit too judgy and could believe the worst of people but still I liked him so much. These two were perfect with each other! Told in dual POV, 3rd person. It’s the second installment in the "New Milton" series with character crossover but it can be read as a standalone. It’s so well-written with well-developed characters (characters with depth) and a satisfying read for me! I didn’t rate it five stars because I wanted to see that wedding! Overall, loved it and hope you enjoy it as well!
Profile Image for Heather K (dentist in my spare time).
4,046 reviews6,454 followers
February 3, 2019
*3.5 stars*

was my first book by , but it certainly won't be the last (well, mostly because I already own two of her other books! I'm a hoarder!). Despite a few issues I had with the story, I really enjoyed it and think that Sally Malcolm did a very nice job.

I love, love, love a MC with some type of disability, and I was very excited to read about a MC with dyspraxia. The depiction of Theo's dyspexia felt real and extremely well-done, and I wasn't at all surprised to find out later that the author has a personal connection to that condition. I wanted evern more details about Theo's dyspraxia and how it affects him, but I was still really pleased with how it was portrayed.

I also really enjoyed the writing, which felt easy and not forced. I could see myself falling head-over-heels for one of this author's stories because of her fluid and straightforward writing style.

However, some aspects of the story bothered me. The relationship veered a little too close to instalove for my tastes, if I'm being honest. I don't like when we get intimacy and feelings too early in the story, and I felt like the "I love yous" were far too fast. They went from fondness to everlasting love in a blink, and even though I know that's possible in real life, I don't like it in my romance. It wasn't quite instalove, but it was nearly there for me.

I also thought that Theo put himself out there WAY more than Luca. I wanted more grovelling from Luca, more vulnerability from him. His stubbornness was a bit of a turnoff, and though I loved Theo and thought that he put his heart on the line more than once, I didn't love how he took all the chances.

Overall, I thought that was a very nice summer romance, and I can see why it's a hit with readers. Super excited to see what else this author has to offer.

*Copy provided in exchange for an honest review*

goodreads|||

Profile Image for Optimist ♰King's Wench♰.
1,805 reviews3,951 followers
December 24, 2018
�4.5�

It happened again. Except this time my face leaked a lil.

Seriously, who and where in the hell did this Sally Malcolm person come from? She's gone 3 for 3!

It's her penchant for the enemies to lovers trope and the masterful way she builds tension that appeals but the way she wields words to craft characters and create the atmosphere of this sleepy little Long Island town that hits my feels with laser-like precision every time that's landed her on my auto-author list with lightening speed.



This time we have Luca and Theo.

Luca is kind of a beach bum who bounces around the country with his surfboard never far away. He's the ultimate rolling stone. On the surface. Underneath that feckless exterior lies hidden depths and a broken heart.

Theo is driven, no nonsense and comes across a bit sanctimonious. He's posh and buttoned-up. But underneath lies the heart of a romantic.

I liked both of them but I really loved Theo for too many reasons to count.



Their journey from enemies to lovers is one I'll not soon forget and will likely have to reread for the comfort of not just Theo and Luca but New Milton.

New Milton is hard to resist. The town is charming and I love catching up with its inhabitants. I can't wait to see who'll be next to fall in love in this series and get on the Sally Malcolm Express to Feelstown again.

Speaking of, you could technically read this one as a stand alone but I'd recommend at least reading Perfect Day beforehand as Finn and Josh have a fairly significant role here.

Recommend to readers who enjoy enemies to loves, loads of tension, don't mind a little miscommunication and maybe are a card carrying member of the Squishy Marshmallow Club.
Profile Image for Ele.
1,319 reviews40 followers
October 17, 2018
*3.5 stars*

I had a hard time rating this one. I struggled a lot because, although I really enjoyed the story, my complaints were too many for me to round up. In any case, Between the Lines proves that Sally Malcolm is a new a force to be reckoned with in MM, and an author I'm definitely interested in.

The writing is absolutely beautiful. I like the dialogue but I love the prose. Not flowery but not too sharp either, just very evocative. Perfect for this type of slow burning, sweet romance. I usually get so bored with inner monologues but the words just flowed here.

I have all the love for Theo. What a sweet, kind-hearted and caring person. Because of his dyspraxia, Theo struggles with a lot of everyday stuff. This makes it very hard to connect and read other people. Luca was harder to like but I loved how protective and sweet he was to Theo.

The epilogue was perfect and necessary to the story. Extra points for Josh and Finn's cameo appearance.

So, what didn't work?

For starters, this felt a little bit insta-lovey. I mean it had only been nine days before the "I love you's" came. For me it's just too little time for all these feelings to develop and for Theo to make his grand gesture. The epilogue, though, made it a little better.

Speaking of which... I felt that Luca should have been the one to reach out and even grovel. He was awful to Theo but he did nothing to make things right, not even after he learnt the truth about the way things happened.

Another thing that frustrated me was the amount of miscommunication between the characters. The "fight" in the end could have been avoided in my opinion, if only the characters had been willing to talk instead of interrupting each other and jumping to conclusions.

Last but not least, Jude. I rarely base my rating and review on how secondary characters behave but this was important to the story. So MANY hurt feelings between Luca and his mother. Nothing was resolved in my opinion. They didn't really talk about the core of the problem, Jude just defended her love for Don and Luca just forgave her. And as much as I love flawed characters, I draw the line at mothers who put their homophobic husbands above their kids. I know I'm kinda opinionated about this but it's just how I am.

I realize I sound like I have a lot of niggles, but I still recommend this book to all MM readers and I sure hope there are more books to come in this universe.
Profile Image for Zuzu.
1,058 reviews33 followers
December 2, 2018
3.5 stars

This story was about 2 guys - 1 who never thought he'd have an HEA and the other who thought he didn't need one.

I liked this book but didn't love it because I felt like there were some unresolved issues.

Luca didn't ever resolve the issue he had with his mother, Jude, marrying someone who had homophobic tendencies. Luca felt his mother betrayed him when she married Don and I never felt like this issue was resolved between them even though the story tried to make it seem that way.

I also wanted to see Theo stand up to his overbearing father. At the end, when Theo revealed he , it was just stated as a fact but I felt cheated in not seeing how that all went down. It just seemed too easy when it never seemed like his father would allow that to happen.

And while I don't mind instalove, these 2 just didn't spend a lot of time together and I never truly felt their connection. Yet I still enjoyed the story and would recommend it to anyone who likes a straightforward romance with fairly low angst.

ARC provided by the publisher via NetGalley.
Profile Image for Jassy.
18 reviews13 followers
December 2, 2018
**4.5 stars**

Between the Lines is the first book I’ve read by this author and I didn’t know what to expect in terms of writing style but also plotwise. Let me just say� it totally took me by surprise.
The writing style is very, very good � fluent and funny.
The blurb makes sense in retrospect but when I first read it I didn’t get the right feeling what the actual story is. So I will try to sum it up: Luca has left home because his mother decided to marry a homophobic guy. He should have inherited the family hotel Majestic but doesn’t want it anymore. It’s anyhow on the verge of ruin. That’s where Theo comes in. His father’s company wants to buy the hotel and turn it into something modern. So in the beginning Theo is basically Luca’s enemy. However, Theo is forced to make a deal to stay two weeks in order to understand the beauty of the hotel better as it is. And he spends a lot of time with Luca during those two weeks and of course they both fall in love (very beautifully�)!
The characters are both very well developed:
Luca is resentful and scared of loving anyone - perfectly understandable concerning his past.
Theo has dyspraxia, meaning his motoric coordination is not that good and he has a hard time reading people. He is a romantic at heart but has given up on ever finding love� until Luca.
I loved the Romance (yeah, capital R) in this book. Just a tiny example� Theo cannot dance and is scared of making a fool of himself. At a wedding Luca just dances with him anyhow and that was so emotional for me.
Another great thing is that even if there are conflicts � what family doesn’t know conflicts? � there are no outright bad people. Even the homophobic partner of Luca’s mother is not that bad. And that is quite an achievement because some good people have prejudices and it is hard to overcome them. I found that very realistic.
All in all, I was very happy about the book and I recommend it to those who want a fluffy and sweet read.

**ARC kindly provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review**
Profile Image for Sam I AMNreader.
1,587 reviews323 followers
December 28, 2019
This was super sweet, but honestly, felt like it was too short. Feels like something between a full length novel and novella and that just didn't quite sit with me after some reflection.

But...engaging enough to keep me reading late. In other words, still recommend.
Profile Image for Gaby.
1,044 reviews118 followers
March 17, 2025
3 stars for the stupid miscommunication especially because Theo was very clear that he needed Luca to be honest with him and he wasn’t.

But mainly the 3 stars are because I cannot excuse shitty parent behaviour. Luca’s mom, Jude, clearly chose her homophobic husband over her son and then acted shocked when he didn’t want anything to do with them. Don being all “Luca has a duty towards her.
Mom� just pissed me off even more 🤦🏻‍♀�. The barely there apology Don gives Luca was meh and more of the I’m sorry you are offended for what I think instead of I’m sorry for being a dick.

The romance was cute even though it was a bit too insta-lovey for my tastes.
Profile Image for h o l l i s .
2,679 reviews2,279 followers
December 31, 2019
I almost never read other reviews before writing my own but as I sat here, trying to figure out if I would round up, knowing this was my least favourite of the two and a half books in the New Milton series (so far), I happened upon this review. Which says everything perfectly. But I'll still put below what I had intended to say anyway.

Not unlike the first book I just finished, this story was brimming with a lot of feeling. Malcolm's writing just digs in under my skin. It wasn't as emotional as PERFECT DAY but there was moments, and passages, that just wowed me. Additionally, one of the leads (Theo!) in this story is just the most precious bean.

There was a lot to love, including some cameos from book one, but there was just something that didn't feel settled, or as strong, about it. This romance does happen quick so, unlike book one, where we had -- maybe -- some underdeveloped characters but a strong connection, this time we have strong characters with strong motivations and sense of self, but just a connection that comes too quick. Possibly this would've been helped by making the novel itself a bit longer and also dragging out that initial dislike phase, let them fight against the attraction, the interest, a little longer, but who am I to say it would've helped. Just a thought.

I also have to mention that despite Theo's father being the obvious one to dislike, I actually struggled more with Luca's family. Plus miscommunication is never really my jam, particularly one like in this story that should've been so easily avoided, so, these also worked against the overall picture.

But it was still a pretty sweet story, which would've been sweeter by a certain individual groveling a bit more (or, y'know, even making the effort), and I will absolutely read on. This author's writing totally does it for me and I'm loving how all these stories feel so different yet are so very much tied together by the setting and the surrounding familiar faces.

3.5 stars
Profile Image for Caz.
3,138 reviews1,147 followers
December 14, 2018
Between the Lines is another emotionally satisfying and beautifully crafted romance from the pen of Sally Malcolm, and is a wonderful follow-up to both and , both of which are also set in the fictional Long Island resort of New Milton. This novel is set a few months after the events of Perfect Day (and I loved the glimpses we were afforded of Josh and Finn at their wedding), and is an enemies-to-lovers romance between two men from vastly different backgrounds who meet when one of them arrives in town to negotiate the purchase of The Majestic, a family-run hotel that has seen better days.

Theo Wishart has travelled to New Milton in order to seal the deal over the purchase, and set in motions his father’s plan to develop the hotel and its land into a luxury resort. He is anxious to prove himself by closing the deal, especially in the light of a particularly embarrassing incident which led to his being accused of sexual harassment by a colleague, and his father’s obvious belief that Theo doesn’t have what it takes to make it in the cut-throat world in which he operates. Theo’s dyspraxia means that he doesn’t read people well; he gets distracted easily and has had to devise a number of coping mechanisms (such as timing himself in the shower and reminding himself to make eye contact with people) to help him to fit into a world which often views his lack of co-ordination and discomfort in social situations as things that make him someone to deride or pity rather than just someone who is different.

Luca Moretti was born in New Milton but left home five years earlier, after his mother remarried and his step-father Don made it clear that he couldn’t accept Luca’s sexuality. Luca loves his mother and he loves his home, but he only returns for the summers now, to help out at the hotel and to take on some part-time work as a lifeguard and surf instructor. He’s furious about his mother’s plans to sell the Majestic, and believes that Don is pushing her to sell, his anger blinding him to the fact that Jude Moretti is not quite herself, and that, after a life of hard work, she deserves to have an easier time of it.

When Theo arrives for his meeting with Jude and Don, he’s dismayed to discover that the rude guy who collided with him outside the coffee shop earlier is her son � and with the hostility coming off him in waves, it’s clear he’s vehemently opposed to his mother’s plan to sell the hotel. Josh can also tell that he stands every chance of getting his mother to change her mind. Jude expresses her concern about Lux Properties� plans to redevelop the site, suggesting that perhaps she and Luca (mostly Luca) would be more amenable to the sale if the redevelopment was something more in line with the community, and floats the idea that Theo should spend a couple of weeks in New Milton, getting a feel for the place. Perhaps then, he might come to see what’s so special about The Majestic and its place in the community � and will be able to persuade his father to rethink his development plans. Theo and Luca agree reluctantly to the idea, neither of them enthused at the prospect of spending two weeks in each other’s company, but each hoping to use the time to persuade the other to their point of view.

Sally Malcom does a great job of creating a strong connection between these two very different men; she has a real gift for imbuing her characters with a true depth of personality and for creating strong emotional connections between them. The frisson of attraction that sparks between Luca and Theo is almost instantaneous, although they both do their best to ignore it, dismissing the idea of acting on it as a terrible one given their situation. But eventually, they can’t deny it any more and they agree to have a summer fling for the two weeks Theo is there and then go their separate ways with no regrets (hah � good luck with that!). As they start spending time together, Luca comes to understand and appreciate Theo for the kind, loving person he is and Theo learns more about what makes Luca tick, how hurt he was by his mother’s remarriage and her silence when his step-father refused to accept him. As the two men fall for each other, Theo realises just why Luca is so attached to The Majestic, and starts to wonder if there might be an alternative to the plans his father has proposed, one that would preserve the spirit of the hotel while also allowing Jude and Don the freedom to enjoy their retirement. We’re treated to some lovely snapshots of Luca and Theo’s time together as their relationship develops, delighted as they take two steps forward and then frustrated as they take one step back, past insecurities and hurts seeming as though they’re destined to keep them apart. Even so, their relationship grows organically and doesn’t feel rushed or lacking in plausibility. The romance is full of humour, warmth and affection as well as some beautifully conceived sexual tension which culminates in some nicely steamy moments. But the elephant in the room is just waiting in the corner, keeping the reader on tenterhooks waiting for the other shoe to drop. When it does, the impact is visceral - Theo sees it coming yet can do nothing to stop it - and I certainly had a lump in my throat while reading.

Luca and Theo are wonderfully rounded characters who have more in common than they’d at first thought. Both have difficult familial relationships; Luca clearly resents Don’s place in his mother’s life while Theo is well aware that his father views him as a disappointment. They’re prickly and wary of letting anyone get close, and yet they find a way past each other’s defences to an extent neither had expected was likely or possible. The secondary characters are strongly drawn, too, and I found Jude and Don especially to be true-to-life in the sense that their dilemmas felt real and messy, and their flaws made them seem like real people. When we learn of Don’s prejudice it’s easy to then believe he’s pushing Jude to sell the hotel and to paint him as the villain of the piece � but the author shows us things aren’t that black and white. He’s misguided about Luca, for sure, but he loves his wife dearly, and, as we learn later, is motivated primarily by concern for her. Jude, too, is similarly multi-faceted; she has valid reasons for wanting to sell up but is torn up about it, wanting to preserve something for Luca but also needing to do the right thing for herself.

All these facets of the characters and their stories are seamlessly woven together, but the focus is firmly on Luca and Theo and their love story, which is beautifully written and gorgeously romantic; they make a terrific couple and I adored getting to know them, both individually and together. Between the Lines is highly recommended � it’s a superb read, and I was captivated from start to finish. Sally Malcolm is an incredibly talented writer, and I can’t wait to read whatever she comes up with next.
Profile Image for Fabi NEEDS Email Notifications.
1,037 reviews146 followers
November 29, 2018
This book has the most accurate blurb I've ever seen.

I'd never heard of dyspraxia prior to this book. It's amazing the things we learn about reading romance novels. As the author herself says, their greatest draw has always been and continues to be, that they show us that happily-ever-afters are for everyone.

Us romance readers love to read about characters who overcome obstacles to find their true love. For me, it's never more poignant than when a character struggles with a disability and finds the soulmate they deserve.

Theo & Luca give us a beautiful story of love and acceptance. Overcoming mistakes and building a future filled with happiness.

I thoroughly enjoyed this romance!

3.5 stars!

Review ARC graciously provided by the publisher via NetGalley.
Profile Image for CrabbyPatty.
1,693 reviews193 followers
July 4, 2021
Theo is sent by his father to purchase the Majestic Hotel in New Milton, which will be torn down to make way for a sleek modern hotel / resort / golf course. Although owner Jude and her husband desperately need to sell, they hope that Theo will get a sense of why the Majestic is so special and invite him to stay there while negotiating the sale.

Jude's son Luca (who we met very briefly in "A Perfect Day") is at the Majestic this one last summer as a lifeguard and teaching surfing and boarding. Luca has no permanent home, other than a converted van, and spends his winters working at ski resorts.

Theo has dyspraxia which includes poor balance and muscular coordination and issues with judgement, processing and other cognitive skills.
People were difficult, that was the problem. They were confusing and he didn't have the knack for connecting with them. He couldn't make himself understood and he couldn't understand them in return. Sometimes he imagined a glass wall stood between himself and other people - he could see them well enough, he just couldn't break through.
Or as Theo later tells Luca: "You ever hear the expression 'the eyes are the window to the soul?' Well, to me, all the blinds are down. I can't read people. It's a dyspraxic thing." The two men eventually decide to indulge their sexual attraction with a short summer fling, and Luca agrees to always tell Theo the truth, but Feelings change everything. Malcolm does a wonderful job of showing us that growing love combined with the realization they will each go their separate ways soon, and yet each man wonders if this could become something more. I like the pace of this story, as the romance grows and develops and we learn more about Theo and Luca, and the Majestic hotel works its magic and makes Theo think that perhaps one day it could play an important role in their future.

My only niggle with "Between the Lines" is Luca's massive angst-filled miscommunication with Theo and basically becoming an asshat in the later part of the book until he comes to his senses. It feels out of character and just too much given their gentle dynamic. Also Luca's stepfather has made some homophobic comments in the past and while it's hard to imagine Luca's mother in effect choosing him over her son, I like how Malcolm offers the start of an unthawing and understanding between Luca and his stepfather. It's not perfect, but it's a work in progress.

It took me a while to really get into this story (unlike "A Perfect Day" which captured my heart right away), but as we get to know Theo's beautiful spirit and his hope and dreams for a loving relationship, family and home and how Luca finds himself on the cusp of getting something he never fully realized he wanted, I was completed hooked. AND the ending and epilogue a year later is absolutely perfect! Bonus: we also get a loving update on Finn and Josh and their swoon worthy wedding. 4.5 stars for "Between the Lines."

I received an ARC from Carina Press, via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review.


Profile Image for Bookreader87(Amanda).
1,167 reviews45 followers
December 27, 2018
3.5 Stars

Luca has been away from what he use to know as home for 5 years. Ever since his mother remarried he has not found a reason to return to the Majestic, the hotel his mother owns. However, news his mother is selling brings him back. He may not be around, for good reasons in my opinion, but the Majestic means a lot to him.

Theo is put to the task of convincing the owner's of the Majestic to sell. When he arrives to the town of New Milton he doesn't expect there to be a family quarrel. What should have been an easy sale becomes complicated when Jude, the owner, wants him to stay and learn what makes the Majestic so special.

With Theo coming in for the sale and Luca trying to stop it they are natural enemies. However, they are forced to spend time together and feelings change.

There were just a few things that bothered me with this book.

Overall another solid read by this author.
Profile Image for Melissa.
1,352 reviews92 followers
December 13, 2018
A complimentary copy was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

LOVED THIS! Such a well written story with real characters and genuine feelings and situations. Sally Malcolm wrote a five star romance (see what I did there? This is about a hotel, which are given star ratings, and so are books. ;) ).

I felt very connected to Theo because of his dyspraxia. I've never heard of dyspraxia, and before Theo explained to Luca what life was like for him as a result, I thought Theo might have a form of autism. He doesn't make eye contact, can't read sarcasm or understand if someone is being serious or telling a joke. If it's not spelled out in words and logic, Theo often doesn't understand. Eye contact is hard for me so that really struck me first with Theo, and in social situations I don't always know what to do, say or how to act and I know I miss things others don't. So for these reasons Theo had my heart right away. Being an adult is hard, but add on "not normal" things, and it's brutal.

Luca at first doesn't like Theo - thinks he is British snob. But after getting to know Theo, Luca can't help but be drawn to him and I loved Luca for not treating Theo as a child (which was always Theo's complaint) because he has coordination issues. These two fit well together, and yes they had their ups and downs, and those were hard to read because each felt pain because of it. And then add in Luca's feelings of betrayal by his mother (because she chose to marry Don, who didn't start off well with Luca being gay), and the selling of the hotel - Luca was a volcano just waiting to erupt. And whew, when he spewed all his hot ash all over Theo over a misunderstanding, that was hard.

I enjoyed this story from start to finish. There wasn't a stinker word in the bunch and I found myself reading every word, not skipping a single part because I was so absorbed in every minutiae that these characters did, and the complete story of the town and hotel, even Theo's dad was great (even if he is a money man). I would love to have been able to experience the ending in more detail but it was so yummy as it was. Sigh. Such a great romance. 5 stars and I highly recommend.
Profile Image for Lily.
125 reviews30 followers
October 28, 2018
2D6D172A-5F94-4516-A8BE-D3A99C83E577.gif

Just like the previous book I’ve read by this author, this book had me completely charmed. The atmosphere, the prose, the setting, the characters, they all made this story so lovely and captivating.

The story take us back to New Milton, and to the town’s beautiful hotel, the Majestic. But even though it’s beautiful, it also suffers from major neglect, and therefore, lack of guests. Basically, it’s losing money, which makes the owner, Jude, consider selling it.

Theo Wishart would very much like to buy the Majestic for his father’s company, so he travels all the way from New York to convince Jude to sell it. But when he arrives to New Milton he encounters one big obstacle - Jude’s son, Luca.

Luca Moretti strongly objects to selling the hotel. Even though he doesn’t want to run it himself, he still cares for it. He loves traveling from place to place, so he doesn’t see himself settling down in New Milton and taking over his family legacy. But the main reason he can’t stay in New Milton for long is his strained relationship with his stepfather, who has some issues with his sexuality.

After Luca makes his objection very clear, Jude offers Theo a deal - stay in the Majestic for two weeks and get to know the hotel and the town, after that she will make her final decision. Theo isn’t very happy about it, but agrees.

Then, it’s enemies-to-lovers all the way. Theo and Luca aren’t very fond of each other in the beginning, to say the least. Luca thinks that Theo is an uptight British prick, while Theo is angry that Luca won’t give his consent to selling the hotel, something that would make Jude’s decision much easier. But when they get to know each other for real, they start to care for each other, which makes Theo’s plans for the hotel much more difficult.

I loved both of the MCs, but I have to admit that Theo truly captured my heart. Underneath his arrogant facade, he is insecure, sensitive and oh so sweet. He suffers from dyspraxia, which makes it difficult for him to preform everyday physical tasks. He also can’t read people that well, so he often feels awkward and stupid in social situations. When Luca finds out about Theo’s difficulties, it makes him understand Theo much more, and realize that he isn’t who he though he was at the beginning.

I did have some things that bothered me in the story and stopped me from giving it a five stars rating. The main issue for me was Luca’s Mom, Jude. I can’t really understand her. Even though it’s clear that she loves her son, she married someone who sees his sexuality as a sin. I can’t understand how a mother can choose a man over her child, so I was a little annoyed that in the end Luca just forgave her without them resolving their issues properly.

Also, the steam level was a little too low for my taste, I was missing some hotness and passion, but that’s probably me and not the book.

47976511-2B6D-426E-B9C5-94D4A13A9E7D.gif

Overall, I highly recommend this book, and really look forward for future books from this author.

An ARC was kindly provided by the publisher, via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Alisa.
1,875 reviews200 followers
December 24, 2018
This author is quickly becoming a favorite of mine. This is set in the same town as and if you've read that (which you should do because it's fantastic) you'll be happy to see some cameos of Finn and Josh in this one.

Luca is back in town because his mother is planning to sell their family home which is also a hotel. He's upset at her choice but does not want to take it over himself because he's hurt and angry at his mother for marrying a man who's religion is not accepting of Luca's homosexuality.

Theo works for his father's company and he's attempting to buy the old hotel. It's his chance to prove himself to his father and get some recognition from the over bearing and harsh man. Theo has some unique challenges and he is quite the opposite of Luca. The two men immediately dislike each other but that quickly turns to an attraction neither of them wants. They decide to have a fling but that also quickly turns to something much more serious than they were expecting.

I love this author's writing and story telling style. She does a fantastic job of getting you to identify with her characters. I loved Theo and felt so much for him. He's such a realistic type of person and everyone who's ever been awkward will really identify with some of the things he goes through. I wasn't sure about Luca at the beginning but as he starts to open up to Theo I really felt for him. I understood his anger at his mother.

One of the things I really like about this author's characters is how human they are. She shows how complicated relationships can be. Luca and his mother's relationship is super well done. His mother and his step-father make some pretty big mistakes but his mother loves him and his step-father loves his wife. Nothing was magically solved and the story showed that sometimes you hurt the ones you love and there's not much you can do but try to forgive that person and move on with your relationship.

The romance was so sweet. I loved these two together. Luca was so respectful of Theo and yet was a perfect support. Some of their moments together were so tender and heart felt.

This can be read as a standalone or can be read before the other two books in the series. Their main connection is that they all take place in the same town and some of the side characters overlap into all three books.

**ARC provided through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review**

Profile Image for Em.
707 reviews4 followers
December 12, 2018
This review originally appeared at . I gave Between the Lines an 'A.'

I had mixed feelings about the New Milton book that precedes this one, Perfect Day, Ms. Malcolm’s take on Jane Austen’s Persuasion. I liked it, but not as much as our reviewer did. So it’s a bit ironic that reading Between the Lines, its loosely-linked follow-up, provided me with a perfect day. Strong writing, an engaging story, and superbly rendered principal characters kept me engrossed from the first page to the last and I read the whole thing over the course of a lazy Sunday afternoon. The past looms large in Between the Lines � two men, opposites (and adversaries), forge an intense bond after a ‘fling,� that’s anything but. Intimate, tender and deeply moving, Between the Lines is further proof Sally Malcolm belongs on your auto-buy list.

When Theo Wishart arrives in New Milton (the same town featured in Perfect Day), he’s out to prove to his father he has what it takes to follow in his footsteps despite a string of embarrassing missteps at the family business, Lux Properties. He has his eye on The Majestic, a grand seaside hotel that’s recently fallen on hard times, hoping to purchase it on the cheap and redevelop it into a destination golf resort for the wealthy. New Milton is an ideal vacation destination; the increased tourist traffic will also be a boon to the sleepy town. Theo is confidant Jude Moretti, the owner, is ready to sell � after all, The Majestic is barely staying afloat, and Theo is ready to buy � he only needs her to sign the papers and transfer ownership. After arriving early to New Milton, he’s killing time before heading to The Majestic to meet with Jude and her husband Don, when disaster strikes. Theo inadvertently collides with a man on the sidewalk, spilling coffee on his clean dress shirt. The ensuing confrontation is, as usual with Theo, a disaster.

Luca Moretti loves The Majestic and New Milton. He had a happy childhood raised in his family’s hotel � but when his mother remarried and her new husband made it abundantly clear he couldn’t accept Luca’s sexuality, he left. He’s spent the last decade as a nomad, flitting from place to place as the seasons change, never settling anywhere for too long and avoiding romantic attachments. He’s only returned to New Milton after learning of his mother’s plan to sell the hotel. Unwilling to take over The Majestic, he’s still hopeful � with the right words � he can convince her not to sell. He’s just arrived in New Milton when his visit gets off to a rough start � a handsome, arrogant (and totally overdressed) stranger, clearly a tourist, collides with him on the sidewalk and then tries to blame him for his spilled coffee. He suppresses his anger and heads to The Majestic, his sunny optimism tinged with a foreboding of worse things to come.

When Theo shows up to make his pitch for The Majestic, he’s met by Jude, Don and a glowering, suspicious and angry Luca. It’s obvious mother and son aren’t in agreement about selling the property, and Theo is doubtful he can close the deal� until Jude offers him a lifeline. What if Theo stays for two weeks and get to know the hotel and the town; Luca can show him around, and Jude can have a bit more time to consider his offer? It’s clear to Theo, despite his dyspraxia (a condition that makes it nearly impossible for him to read people), there’s something more to the conflict between mother and son and that Luca doesn’t like or trust him � or want to spend the next two weeks as his tour guide. But Theo needs to prove himself to his father, and he needs The Majestic. So he agrees to the deal.

Although neither man has high hopes for the next two weeks spent in each other’s company, it isn’t long before they form a tentative friendship. Theo is attracted to Luca, but isn’t sure if Luca feels the same, and he doesn’t trust his instincts. Luca is attracted to Theo, but can’t quite figure him out � it seems like Theo is interested in more than a friendship, but it’s hard to be sure. Only after Luca confronts him � and Theo finally confesses he has dyspraxia and how it affects him, do they admit they’d like to be more than friends. The pair agree to a short summer fling while Theo is staying at The Majestic, although it’s clear from both of their PoVs that their feelings are far from casual.

As Theo and Luca transition from enemies to loves, the narrative alternately charms readers with lovely vignettes of their developing intimacy, and frustrates, as they stubbornly keep a part of themselves separate, fearing rejection and afraid to trust how they feel. It’s an idyllic interlude from reality � they deliberately avoid discussing their impending separation, or their disparate dreams for The Majestic � and it’s a bittersweet pleasure watching them fall in love, knowing it can’t last. Theo and Lucas are appealing heroes, and although they seem to have little in common, the author does a masterful job establishing how well those differences complement each other.

Unfortunately, the things they have in common � fear drives their decision making, fractured parental relationships, trouble communicating � ultimately tears them apart. Watching Theo and Luca fall for each other is akin to watching a car crash in slow motion� you just know the crash is coming but you keep hoping it doesn’t. It does.

Much like in her other stories, Ms. Malcolm proves adept at showing the vulnerable and flawed facets of her principal (and secondary) characters. Luca and Theo are lovely and mostly good to each other, but they struggle. Past, unresolved hurts make it difficult for Luca to trust Theo, and he’s quick to lash out whenever he feels threatened; Theo wants a partner to love and shower with affection, but a painful past relationship has led him to doubt his appeal or his instincts � and his dyspraxia only exacerbates his insecurities. Both men have complex relationships with their parents (and step-parent), and although I think these secondary characters � and the problems they present � absolutely enhance this story and add nuance and complexity to it, they’re a largely unlikeable lot.

Between the Lines is an apt title for this beautiful love story. As the novel unfolds, Luca and Theo struggle to understand what they mean to each other when neither is brave enough...

See the rest of this review at .
Profile Image for MaDoReader.
1,349 reviews166 followers
November 19, 2019
Ellos son monos y tal, le daría dos etrellas porque mi cuerpo está en plan "it was ok", pero no me parece justo con el libro.
Profile Image for Aeren.
510 reviews30 followers
February 18, 2019
Me gusta mucho la forma en la que escribe pero se me ha hecho bastante lentillo, sin embargo, está muy por encima de la media.
Profile Image for Andrea.
1,170 reviews154 followers
October 22, 2018
ALL THE STARS! I need this author to write more (pretty please!), because the two books I have read by her so far were just wonderful! If you like your romance character-driven, without any pointless drama, and only one believable conflict that needs to be overcome (and is so by being sensible and, yes, communication!), go give this author a try!

"Nine days of summer fun and that's all."

When Theo literally stumbles into Luca's live, neither is prepared -or even willing- to make room for even the possibility of feelings. But when their mutual attraction proves impossible to ignore, they make a deal: just a nice and easy summer fling. Which, of course, does not work out as planned�

I absolutely adored those two! Both were wonderful characters on their own, but coming together, letting their walls come down, and seeing the change this brings, was just sweet -and at times heartbreaking. I loved how openly they talked about their issues, how Luca cared and respected Theo's illness without making him feel any worse for it. This was a wonderful (I should probably come up with a better word at this point; amazing! marvelous! glorious! take your pick, they all apply) story about two people who couldn't be more different coming together in the sweetest way. I loved it from the very first chapter on, and just couldn't put it down. I loved spending time with them so much, I'm a bit sad to say goodbye so soon.

This story is connected to her previous book, Perfect Day in that you meet the amazing couple from Perfect Day again. You don't have to read both to enjoy the stories though. But since I loved Perfect Day to distraction (it's a modern, m/m retelling of Jane Austen's Persuasion! *swoons*), I can't leave without saying that I highly recommend that one, too!

*I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review*
Profile Image for Roberta Blablanski.
Author4 books64 followers
November 12, 2018
Confession time: Characters who start off completely against love and relationships, and then have an epiphany because of the main love interest usually aren't my cup of tea. I'm cynical and jaded. It takes a lot to convince me one person can completely change someone so drastically. In Between the Lines, Malcolm knocks this trope out of the ballpark. I was rooting for Luca and Theo with every fiber of my being.

If you've read Perfect Day by Malcolm, you may remember Luca being very briefly mentioned as the summer lifeguard/surf instructor and son of the owner of the bed and breakfast on the bay. He's travels all over the country, taking jobs in different states for each season. He's the anti-relationship, anti-love MC. He's up for fun and zero attachments. Until...

...dear Theo. Oh, how he stole my heart. I learned a lot about dyspraxia through Malcolm's portrayal of Theo. He's sensitive and proud and passionate and trusting, and I just loved him. That's not to say I didn't love Luca. I did, just in a different way.

These two were so sweet together when they finally got their heads out of the sand. I adored the grand gesture and the inclusion of "The Luckiest" by Ben Folds, my favorite song by one of my favorite artists.

Without a doubt, I am looking forward to Malcolm's next offering in the M/M romance genre.
Profile Image for Skirmish.
557 reviews
August 9, 2020
Book Reaction:
Rating: 4 Stars - minor quibbles but I loved it to bits

I received a copy of Between The Lines from Carina Press via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Riina Y.T..
Author7 books60 followers
October 16, 2018
I enjoyed reading Between the Lines but find it very difficult to review. I'm hovering somewhere between a 3 and 4 stars, mostly because the pacing and length got in the middle of my enjoyment with the story. The book is very slow, the storytelling fantastic. The plot fell a little flat for me but the romance is very sweet, kinda mellow and almost drama free.

Overall the story felt a bit long. There were a few times when events were too slow for me, scenes dragged and some even seemed unneeded to move the story along. For me it was a book I had no problem with putting aside in favor of doing something else, reading something else. I'd pick it up again the other day for an hour or too. Neither the characters or their romance filled me with a need to finish it ASAP.

The book started out interesting. I liked getting to know Luca-- we had an instant connection and he remained my favorite character till the end. His hang ups with Don, his step father, are understandable but I had a hard time agreeing with his way of justifying it. Mostly I felt sad for Luca and his mother! I wanted Luca to give his mother less of a cold shoulder! Poor woman.

Theo I took longer to warm up to. I found him quite likable once I got to know him better. They're both great men and I enjoyed seeing them fumble their way toward a somewhat fragile friendship, those first moments were the best.

I don't know about chemistry, I mean they worked well together but it wasn't all that scorching. I do like a little awkwardness, so that wasn't it. Maybe the "middle" part of the story went on for too long and it got less exciting. All in all, it was an okay romance. Insta-love, something I dig, but I have a hard time buying their actual connection. After only spending a few days together it was difficult to truly appreciate their love. In the end I found myself rooting for them, despite Luca being a bit of a coward who should have done more what he wanted.

I would recommend Between the Lines if you read and adored Finn and Joshua's story in Perfect Day. It can be read as a stand alone but honestly, it makes much more sense to read in order!



Many, many thanks to the publisher who kindly provided a free copy for an honest and impartial review.
Profile Image for Joyfully Jay.
8,742 reviews504 followers
December 10, 2018
A review.

4 stars


Sally Malcolm offers a story of two men that, despite their prickly exteriors, is on the sweet side. Theo arrives to the small beach town and has something to prove. He needs to make this deal to show his father, who is his boss, that he can handle it. Theo has a neurological disorder called dyspraxia that makes some things in his life more challenging. While Theo does sometimes wish certain things were easier for him, this story is not about him trying to overcome anything.

When Theo and Luca crash into each other, there is something there immediately, but Theo doesn’t think that romance will ever find him, and Luca’s not at all interested. Luca has a lot of anger built up with his mother and the situation with The Majestic. The hotel has always been his home and Luca has so many unresolved feelings and is too angry to say what he really wants. He can’t even admit that he really wants Theo.

From the beginning of the book, I knew how it would end, but it was still engaging to see it play out. These guys don’t communicate, oh they have their reasons, and it takes one of them to really step up and go after what they want to make both of their dreams come true.

Read Michelle's review in its entirety .


Profile Image for BevS.
2,832 reviews2 followers
May 6, 2020
Beautifully written again by Sally, but I just couldn't warm to Luca...he was a complete arse IMHO. He behaved like a spoiled brat for most of the read; I also didn't have a very high opinion at all of Luca's mum and her homophobic husband - how could you marry someone who felt the way he does about gay people [engrained it may've been, but that shouldn't mean you can't form an opinion of your own...unless you are and always will be a lemming of course 😕] when your own son is gay??

Theo...I liked. His 'barrow boy' of a father not so much, yuck!! Theo was not an entitled brat; he was decent and honest, and I have to question whether Luca deserved him. The solution to the hotel conundrum was fairly obvious although the 'celebrity' person himself only had a very tenuous link to the actual town itself. Shame we didn't get to see more of Josh and Finn other than the wedding ceremony, but hey, they've had their story...sighs.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 139 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.