What do you think?
Rate this book
Society of Beasts #1
The Vicar and the Rake
Debut author Annabelle Greene brings us the brilliant first book in her Society of Beasts series, in which a quiet country vicar is unwillingly reunited with the duke who left him long ago�
As a young man, Sir Gabriel Winters left behind his status as a gentleman, turning his back on his secret desires and taking a self-imposed vow of celibacy. Now he’s a chaste, hardworking vicar, and his reputation is beyond reproach. But, try as he might, he’s never forgotten the man he once desired or the pain of being abandoned by his first love.
Edward Stanhope, the Duke of Caddonfell, is a notorious rake, delighting in scandal no matter the consequence. With a price on his head, he flees to the countryside, forced to keep his presence a secret or risk assassination. When Edward finds Gabriel on his estate, burning with fever, he cannot leave him to die, but taking him in puts them both in jeopardy.
With the help of a notorious blackmailer, a society of rich and famous gentlemen who prefer gentlemen, and a kitten named Buttons, they might just manage to save Edward’s life—but the greatest threat may be to their hearts.
As a young man, Sir Gabriel Winters left behind his status as a gentleman, turning his back on his secret desires and taking a self-imposed vow of celibacy. Now he’s a chaste, hardworking vicar, and his reputation is beyond reproach. But, try as he might, he’s never forgotten the man he once desired or the pain of being abandoned by his first love.
Edward Stanhope, the Duke of Caddonfell, is a notorious rake, delighting in scandal no matter the consequence. With a price on his head, he flees to the countryside, forced to keep his presence a secret or risk assassination. When Edward finds Gabriel on his estate, burning with fever, he cannot leave him to die, but taking him in puts them both in jeopardy.
With the help of a notorious blackmailer, a society of rich and famous gentlemen who prefer gentlemen, and a kitten named Buttons, they might just manage to save Edward’s life—but the greatest threat may be to their hearts.
274 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 12, 2020
90 people are currently reading
745 people want to read
About the author
Annabelle Greene
5books60followersAnnabelle Greene writes hot, heartwarming historical romances with plenty of humor.
When she isn't crafting the perfect HEA, she's making pasta or walking along Italy's beautiful Adriatic coast.
When she isn't crafting the perfect HEA, she's making pasta or walking along Italy's beautiful Adriatic coast.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 206 reviews
October 28, 2020
*3.5 stars*
was a very impressive debut from author . Despite some mixed reviews from my friends, I liked a good deal, and even bumped up my rating the more I sat on my feelings.
I have a huge weakness for historical romances, and I love, love, love M/M historicals, so I was ready and willing to love this story. It did not disappoint. Combine a long-pined after romance with some very deep feelings and a virgin (!), and you have me hooked.
I enjoyed the humor of the story, which I wasn't expecting, and I also really liked how well the author developed the chemistry between the two MCs. In fact, all of the characters, including the secondary characters, were very strong, and I enjoyed them a great deal. They felt very well-developed and conceived, something that new writers often struggle with. I thought everything from the pacing to the romance was really well done.
Where I got a bit lost was with the mystery and action elements towards the end. It seemed a bit muddled, and I'm not one for big dramatic, mysterious endings. I got a bit confused with all of the shuffle, but it didn't take away from my overall enjoyment of the book. I wish things had been simplified a bit, but I'm excited and hopeful for the rest of the books in the series.
A great debut which promises even better things to come, look out for .
*Copy provided in exchange for an honest review*
goodreads|||
was a very impressive debut from author . Despite some mixed reviews from my friends, I liked a good deal, and even bumped up my rating the more I sat on my feelings.
I have a huge weakness for historical romances, and I love, love, love M/M historicals, so I was ready and willing to love this story. It did not disappoint. Combine a long-pined after romance with some very deep feelings and a virgin (!), and you have me hooked.
I enjoyed the humor of the story, which I wasn't expecting, and I also really liked how well the author developed the chemistry between the two MCs. In fact, all of the characters, including the secondary characters, were very strong, and I enjoyed them a great deal. They felt very well-developed and conceived, something that new writers often struggle with. I thought everything from the pacing to the romance was really well done.
Where I got a bit lost was with the mystery and action elements towards the end. It seemed a bit muddled, and I'm not one for big dramatic, mysterious endings. I got a bit confused with all of the shuffle, but it didn't take away from my overall enjoyment of the book. I wish things had been simplified a bit, but I'm excited and hopeful for the rest of the books in the series.
A great debut which promises even better things to come, look out for .
*Copy provided in exchange for an honest review*
goodreads|||
April 28, 2021
I love historical, particularly Regency era, M/M romance. Since Ava March, my go-to author for historical romance, went MIA in 2016, I've been on the lookout for stories about dukes, le bon ton, and stable boys (or something similar - I'm not picky).
Going into this book, I was all YESSS, come on, baby, this is gonna be good. And that feeling persisted until approximately the 60% mark, and then ever so slowly, disappointment set in.
I love the idea of childhood friends reconnecting and the opposites attract theme: Edward, or Scandal as the gossip rags call him, is the rake of the title, drinking and screwing his way through London. Gabriel is the virginal vicar, working himself to the bone even when he's sick.
The first half focuses on Edward and Gabriel meeting again after a decade-long separation. We get some hurt-comfort as Edward nurses a feverish Gabriel, then a slower burn as Gabriel tries to deny his desires.
There was some tedious back and forth between the men, with Gabriel feeling guilty about wanting Edward and Edward thinking he's not good enough for Gabriel, but overall I was enjoying the setting, secondary characters, steamy scenes, and trajectory of the story.
But at 60%, the book took a noisedive. The entire focus shifted to the mystery surrounding why a certain duke wants Edward dead (granted, this storyline is the reason Edward escaped to the country, but I didn't expect it to get so convoluted).
We're introduced to the Beasts (Edward's closest friends who, along with Edward, founded a sort of underground club for men who like other men). We also meet Maurice, Edward's brilliant, brooding brother who has the dirt on everyone in society. The atmosphere changes from somber but hopeful to tense and despairing, what with murder, deception, and betrayal.
The resolution to the mystery was not at all believable. I'm not going to get into how and why, but the Duke of Sussex's plan and the final resolution were far more complicated than they needed to be. Things just didn't add up.
The ending, while happy, struck me as anachronistic. Had the story been set in the present day, I would have swooned. But in 1818? I don't think so.
Also, I really liked Maurice and Caroline, Gabriel's sister, who danced around each other the entire story, and was rooting for them to get a HEA too, but nope, that thread was dropped.
It was impossible not to compare this book to K.J. Charles' amazing Society of Gentlemen series, and it fell short by a mile.
Going into this book, I was all YESSS, come on, baby, this is gonna be good. And that feeling persisted until approximately the 60% mark, and then ever so slowly, disappointment set in.
I love the idea of childhood friends reconnecting and the opposites attract theme: Edward, or Scandal as the gossip rags call him, is the rake of the title, drinking and screwing his way through London. Gabriel is the virginal vicar, working himself to the bone even when he's sick.
The first half focuses on Edward and Gabriel meeting again after a decade-long separation. We get some hurt-comfort as Edward nurses a feverish Gabriel, then a slower burn as Gabriel tries to deny his desires.
There was some tedious back and forth between the men, with Gabriel feeling guilty about wanting Edward and Edward thinking he's not good enough for Gabriel, but overall I was enjoying the setting, secondary characters, steamy scenes, and trajectory of the story.
But at 60%, the book took a noisedive. The entire focus shifted to the mystery surrounding why a certain duke wants Edward dead (granted, this storyline is the reason Edward escaped to the country, but I didn't expect it to get so convoluted).
We're introduced to the Beasts (Edward's closest friends who, along with Edward, founded a sort of underground club for men who like other men). We also meet Maurice, Edward's brilliant, brooding brother who has the dirt on everyone in society. The atmosphere changes from somber but hopeful to tense and despairing, what with murder, deception, and betrayal.
The resolution to the mystery was not at all believable. I'm not going to get into how and why, but the Duke of Sussex's plan and the final resolution were far more complicated than they needed to be. Things just didn't add up.
The ending, while happy, struck me as anachronistic. Had the story been set in the present day, I would have swooned. But in 1818? I don't think so.
Also, I really liked Maurice and Caroline, Gabriel's sister, who danced around each other the entire story, and was rooting for them to get a HEA too, but nope, that thread was dropped.
It was impossible not to compare this book to K.J. Charles' amazing Society of Gentlemen series, and it fell short by a mile.
September 26, 2024
A gorgeously written, historical gay romance. Lyrical and emotional, but also a little long-winded with a slightly boring middle.
Gabriel and Edward grew up together. Gabriel was left heartbroken when Edward suddenly leaves without a word. Gabriel pens the most heartfelt letters, but they are never returned. Gabriel can’t help but read the gossip postings, where Edward is said to have quite the reputation of leading multiple men astray.
Ten years later, Edward returns to his country house, only because his life is in danger from his latest conquest.
“I think you’re an arrogant, oversexed dilettante who abandoned all sense of duty and responsibility at eighteen years old. Who left behind everything, and everyone, on some selfish pursuit of pleasure that blackens the lives of all those closest to you.�
Tell me how you really feel Gabriel.
Gabriel has become a reverend, hoping his prayers to God will help balance out the feelings he has for another man.
The truth finally surfaces of the reasons that Edward fled as a teenager. Gabriel is such a source of comfort, never losing sight of who Edward is at the core of his soul. Edward struggles to feel he is worthy of Gabriel’s attention and care.
“I’m afraid of you because you think that deep down, I’m a good man...and I’m not.�
Regency gay romance
Intrigue/mystery
Secret Society
Loved you since childhood
Virgin
They had explored so many ways to satisfy one another the previous night; there had been play, and laughter, and moments of sweetness that had expressed so much more than words ever could.
Had the middle bits been tightened up a little, this would have been a home run!
The ending was perfection.
Gabriel and Edward grew up together. Gabriel was left heartbroken when Edward suddenly leaves without a word. Gabriel pens the most heartfelt letters, but they are never returned. Gabriel can’t help but read the gossip postings, where Edward is said to have quite the reputation of leading multiple men astray.
Ten years later, Edward returns to his country house, only because his life is in danger from his latest conquest.
“I think you’re an arrogant, oversexed dilettante who abandoned all sense of duty and responsibility at eighteen years old. Who left behind everything, and everyone, on some selfish pursuit of pleasure that blackens the lives of all those closest to you.�
Tell me how you really feel Gabriel.
Gabriel has become a reverend, hoping his prayers to God will help balance out the feelings he has for another man.
The truth finally surfaces of the reasons that Edward fled as a teenager. Gabriel is such a source of comfort, never losing sight of who Edward is at the core of his soul. Edward struggles to feel he is worthy of Gabriel’s attention and care.
“I’m afraid of you because you think that deep down, I’m a good man...and I’m not.�
Regency gay romance
Intrigue/mystery
Secret Society
Loved you since childhood
Virgin
They had explored so many ways to satisfy one another the previous night; there had been play, and laughter, and moments of sweetness that had expressed so much more than words ever could.
Had the middle bits been tightened up a little, this would have been a home run!
The ending was perfection.
June 17, 2023
Don’t let the corny title dissuade you, this book is a piercing and exceedingly romantic Regency thriller.
Summary: Estranged childhood friends Sir Gabriel Winters and Edward Stanhope, Duke of Caddonfell, have chosen very different life paths. Each has found his own way to exist in a society that shuns them for who they love—Gabriel choosing a chaste, God-devoted life; Edward creating the Society of Beasts, a secret club for aristocratic gay men. In contrast to his celibate friend, Edward has a libertine reputation. When one of his affairs finally enrages someone who money and power cannot deter, Edward absconds to his abandoned family home. In Hardcote, fate binds Gabriel and Edward and together they face off against a deadly enemy.
Writing: Passionate, heartfelt, and charming. Every character (except the villain, obviously) is lovable. Annabelle Greene creates sharp, witty dialogues and a compelling mystery. While entertaining, the book also offers pointed commentary on class, privilege, and society. Not to mention, Greene actually knows how to write a sexy enthusiastic consent scene.
My Feelings: I am obsessed with this gorgeous cover. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and loved Gabriel and Edward. In addition to physical attraction, there is so much emotional intensity between the two. If you love The Will Darling Adventures like I do, you will probably love this book too.
If you like�
-Friends-to-Lovers
-Adopted Kitten
-Secret Society
-Mystery & Intrigue
-Regency MM Romance
Conclusion: 5 stars
Star Criteria
1: Is the book engaging/enjoyable/entertaining? Yes.
2: Is the book creative? Yes.
3: Does the book offer educational value? Yes—early 1800s English society.
4: Does the book highlight underrepresented voices? Yes—MCs and many secondary characters are gay.
5: Does the book challenge existing literary norms and tropes? Is it innovative? Yes.
Original review (May 7, 2023):
One of the most romantic books I've ever read. Hopefully one day I will reread and write a real review. If you liked The Will Darling Adventures by K. J. Charles you will love this.
Summary: Estranged childhood friends Sir Gabriel Winters and Edward Stanhope, Duke of Caddonfell, have chosen very different life paths. Each has found his own way to exist in a society that shuns them for who they love—Gabriel choosing a chaste, God-devoted life; Edward creating the Society of Beasts, a secret club for aristocratic gay men. In contrast to his celibate friend, Edward has a libertine reputation. When one of his affairs finally enrages someone who money and power cannot deter, Edward absconds to his abandoned family home. In Hardcote, fate binds Gabriel and Edward and together they face off against a deadly enemy.
Writing: Passionate, heartfelt, and charming. Every character (except the villain, obviously) is lovable. Annabelle Greene creates sharp, witty dialogues and a compelling mystery. While entertaining, the book also offers pointed commentary on class, privilege, and society. Not to mention, Greene actually knows how to write a sexy enthusiastic consent scene.
My Feelings: I am obsessed with this gorgeous cover. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and loved Gabriel and Edward. In addition to physical attraction, there is so much emotional intensity between the two. If you love The Will Darling Adventures like I do, you will probably love this book too.
If you like�
-Friends-to-Lovers
-Adopted Kitten
-Secret Society
-Mystery & Intrigue
-Regency MM Romance
Conclusion: 5 stars
Star Criteria
1: Is the book engaging/enjoyable/entertaining? Yes.
2: Is the book creative? Yes.
3: Does the book offer educational value? Yes—early 1800s English society.
4: Does the book highlight underrepresented voices? Yes—MCs and many secondary characters are gay.
5: Does the book challenge existing literary norms and tropes? Is it innovative? Yes.
Original review (May 7, 2023):
One of the most romantic books I've ever read. Hopefully one day I will reread and write a real review. If you liked The Will Darling Adventures by K. J. Charles you will love this.
Shelved as 'dnf'
May 9, 2022DNF at 6%
I know, it barely seems like I gave the book a chance, but I promise I tried as much as I could. General warning for spoilers, even though I can’t spoil too much, for obvious reasons.
I was predisposed to like this book, I don’t know why but I had a good feeling about this series, so I kept going after my initial reaction, which wasn’t very positive. The writing style seems a little too…dramatic for my taste. The characters have all these Big Feelings, but it’s hard to take them seriously when the book has barely started and I don’t know them and they just sound like…well, like they’re drama queens, to be honest, and that’s not the type of personality I can easily associate with a vicar or a duke living in 1818. At first, I thought it was a failed (for me) attempt at humor, with one of the MCs starting the book thinking he was dying. Not metaphorically, like I thought at first, but literally dying. And while he was sick and dying in a flowerbed (don’t ask), he could still think in details about all he had done that day and about a letter he had received by his sister and about his childhood friend who abandoned him and about all those times he had gone to said childhood friend’s house and thought about him and about his childhood friend’s reputation and� are you starting to see why I didn’t think he was actually dying at the beginning?
Even so, I went on. Until the same character, who is still so sick he can’t even walk by himself, spends his half minute of mental clarity since the book started opening his eyes, seeing his childhood friend—you guessed it, he’s the other MC—for the first time in 10 years and� OMG, he wants him. It doesn’t matter that he’s feverish and weak, the passion cannot be contained or denied. And the other man, who hasn’t bothered to reply to any of his letters or to make sure he hadn’t died in the 10 years they didn’t see each other, of course is so overwhelmed that he begs him not to die and then� and then... overcome by feelings and passion…They Kiss.
I’ve already reached my drama quota for the entire book, so I’m out, but I’m hoping I might connect better with another pair of characters, so I’m not writing the author off. Yet.
I know, it barely seems like I gave the book a chance, but I promise I tried as much as I could. General warning for spoilers, even though I can’t spoil too much, for obvious reasons.
I was predisposed to like this book, I don’t know why but I had a good feeling about this series, so I kept going after my initial reaction, which wasn’t very positive. The writing style seems a little too…dramatic for my taste. The characters have all these Big Feelings, but it’s hard to take them seriously when the book has barely started and I don’t know them and they just sound like…well, like they’re drama queens, to be honest, and that’s not the type of personality I can easily associate with a vicar or a duke living in 1818. At first, I thought it was a failed (for me) attempt at humor, with one of the MCs starting the book thinking he was dying. Not metaphorically, like I thought at first, but literally dying. And while he was sick and dying in a flowerbed (don’t ask), he could still think in details about all he had done that day and about a letter he had received by his sister and about his childhood friend who abandoned him and about all those times he had gone to said childhood friend’s house and thought about him and about his childhood friend’s reputation and� are you starting to see why I didn’t think he was actually dying at the beginning?
Even so, I went on. Until the same character, who is still so sick he can’t even walk by himself, spends his half minute of mental clarity since the book started opening his eyes, seeing his childhood friend—you guessed it, he’s the other MC—for the first time in 10 years and� OMG, he wants him. It doesn’t matter that he’s feverish and weak, the passion cannot be contained or denied. And the other man, who hasn’t bothered to reply to any of his letters or to make sure he hadn’t died in the 10 years they didn’t see each other, of course is so overwhelmed that he begs him not to die and then� and then... overcome by feelings and passion…They Kiss.
I’ve already reached my drama quota for the entire book, so I’m out, but I’m hoping I might connect better with another pair of characters, so I’m not writing the author off. Yet.
October 4, 2020
I WANTED TO LOVE THIS BOOK - IT JUST DIDN'T HAPPEN
Actual rating: 2.5 �
I don't dislike this book at all. But it didn't really impress me in any way either. There were certain things that I couldn't overlook, that dragged down the overall experience.
👍 What I Liked 👍
Secondary characters: Gabriel and Edward are our two main protagonists and they are the ones that are supposed to carry this story. But sadly, I didn't connect with them. I couldn't get into them at all. Luckily, they were flanked by two great supporting characters, their siblings! Maurice, Edward's brother, was surly and blunt. Caroline, Gabriel's sister, was clever and protective. And when the two of them were together, there were definite sparks, that I felt deserved a book of their own.
👎 What I Disliked 👎
Push and pull: Gabriel and Edward's relationship was actually quite annoying. For the first 2/3 of the book they took turns pulling each other closer only to push them away moments later. Honestly, it got boring really fast.
Romance?: Yeah, I didn't really see any romance between these two. Lots and lots of lust - and MANY smutty encounters (I think this book was more smut than anything else) - but romance? No, I didn't really see anything like that.
ARC provided by the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
Follow me for more book loving content!
� Facebook � �
Actual rating: 2.5 �
I don't dislike this book at all. But it didn't really impress me in any way either. There were certain things that I couldn't overlook, that dragged down the overall experience.
👍 What I Liked 👍
Secondary characters: Gabriel and Edward are our two main protagonists and they are the ones that are supposed to carry this story. But sadly, I didn't connect with them. I couldn't get into them at all. Luckily, they were flanked by two great supporting characters, their siblings! Maurice, Edward's brother, was surly and blunt. Caroline, Gabriel's sister, was clever and protective. And when the two of them were together, there were definite sparks, that I felt deserved a book of their own.
👎 What I Disliked 👎
Push and pull: Gabriel and Edward's relationship was actually quite annoying. For the first 2/3 of the book they took turns pulling each other closer only to push them away moments later. Honestly, it got boring really fast.
Romance?: Yeah, I didn't really see any romance between these two. Lots and lots of lust - and MANY smutty encounters (I think this book was more smut than anything else) - but romance? No, I didn't really see anything like that.
ARC provided by the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
Follow me for more book loving content!
� Facebook � �
September 9, 2021
I originally tried to read this in audio, but I suck at reading in audio, so after the latest epicness of Once a Gentleman, I got the ebook. This author is only two books into her career, and she's on my one-click list. I don't read a lot of historicals, because it can take me a while to get into the style, but she nailed it. She has all the codependency and passion, compelling characters and epic romance that I need in my books. Her writing is wonderful, and her characters are amazing. I will say I enjoyed the second book more, but that's partially because of the epicness that is , and I have to say this is a really strong debut.
Things I loved:
Gabriel&Edward, and their star-crossed love
Gabriel's sister and Edward's brother
Bryce because he's the perfect manservant and a really good friend
Buttons the cat because he's adorable and demands to be carried in waistcoats
Frakes
The ending😍
Also includes a bit of mystery, possessiveness, a dark tortured past, and tons of mutual pining.
I had some niggles with the pacing, but all in all, this is really good.
Things I loved:
Gabriel&Edward, and their star-crossed love
Gabriel's sister and Edward's brother
Bryce because he's the perfect manservant and a really good friend
Buttons the cat because he's adorable and demands to be carried in waistcoats
Frakes
The ending😍
Also includes a bit of mystery, possessiveness, a dark tortured past, and tons of mutual pining.
I had some niggles with the pacing, but all in all, this is really good.
January 22, 2024
Considering this is a debut novel and I am a huge fan of MM historicals, I loved it. I loved the MCs, their past, their hesitations, their passion for each other. The secondary characters are real and I can’t wait to read their stories. The mystery was fun and kept me interested.
The story is a bit messy and all over the place, the ending a bit over the top and unrealistic to the time period, but I still enjoyed myself the whole time, and what more can you ask for?
The story is a bit messy and all over the place, the ending a bit over the top and unrealistic to the time period, but I still enjoyed myself the whole time, and what more can you ask for?
October 7, 2020
This was a new-to-me author whose debut book I picked because I love historical novels and the blurb roped me in. I'm glad I did because I absolutely enjoyed it.
To start with, I especially liked the way the story began because I certainly was not expecting it. It told me that this author meant business and how the rest of the story unfolded backed it up. It was very well written, with the characters well fleshed out and the pacing just right.
All the characters added something to the overarching story and even when issues were dealt with "too conveniently"(in my opinion) at the end, there wasn't a boring moment from start to finish; which is just how I like my books.
As you may infer from the blurb, this was sort of a "second chance-ish" romance mixed into the intrigue that inadvertently followed a rake such as Edward Stanhope who I adored. His sense of humor was impeccable and his banter with everyone around him had me laughing most times. He however had a lot of personal demons which meant that he had a lot of internal battles to wage.
This brings me to another thing I loved about this story; which was that Edward wasn't miraculously saved from his personal demons just because the generous, sometimes judgy but infinitely good hearted Gariel Winters made him feel loved and cherished. Edward still had to go on a journey of self discovery to heal himself; albeit in extreme settings. Gabriel also had a lot of soul searching to do on himself.
As I said earlier, I enjoyed every bit of this book and as I was reading, I kept thinking how great it would be to have more books to shed light on the other "Beasts". So, you can imagine my joy when I discovered that more books were in the offing. I will definitely be reading those books.
***eARC Graciously Provided by Publisher via Netgalley in Exchange for an Honest, Unbiased Review ***
To start with, I especially liked the way the story began because I certainly was not expecting it. It told me that this author meant business and how the rest of the story unfolded backed it up. It was very well written, with the characters well fleshed out and the pacing just right.
All the characters added something to the overarching story and even when issues were dealt with "too conveniently"(in my opinion) at the end, there wasn't a boring moment from start to finish; which is just how I like my books.
As you may infer from the blurb, this was sort of a "second chance-ish" romance mixed into the intrigue that inadvertently followed a rake such as Edward Stanhope who I adored. His sense of humor was impeccable and his banter with everyone around him had me laughing most times. He however had a lot of personal demons which meant that he had a lot of internal battles to wage.
This brings me to another thing I loved about this story; which was that Edward wasn't miraculously saved from his personal demons just because the generous, sometimes judgy but infinitely good hearted Gariel Winters made him feel loved and cherished. Edward still had to go on a journey of self discovery to heal himself; albeit in extreme settings. Gabriel also had a lot of soul searching to do on himself.
As I said earlier, I enjoyed every bit of this book and as I was reading, I kept thinking how great it would be to have more books to shed light on the other "Beasts". So, you can imagine my joy when I discovered that more books were in the offing. I will definitely be reading those books.
***eARC Graciously Provided by Publisher via Netgalley in Exchange for an Honest, Unbiased Review ***
March 10, 2024
4.5 stars
I love downloading a free book on a whim and it ends up being excellent! 🥰❤️
Edward, Duke of Caddonfell, is forced to flee London after being caught with a very powerful man's son. Once he returns to his family's home in the country, he comes across his former childhood friend Sir Gabriel Winters, passed out in a flowerbed. After Edward nurses Gabriel back to health, Gabriel returns the favor when Edward's life is in danger.
Read this book if you love: former childhood friends to lovers, handsome vicars, forced proximity, hurt/comfort, AN ADORABLE ADOPTED KITTEN NAMED BUTTONS, found family, protective siblings.
This book was amazing. The yearning and sexual tension was exquisite! Edward and Gabriel's journey was beautifully written, from wary friendship to a passionate romance. Edward doesn't feel like he's good enough for Gabriel, so he frequently hides behind his well-known rake persona to push him away and Gabriel is so patient and loving and is just...not having it 😂 Whenever Edward tries to keep him at a distance he's like "Yeah, I know what you're doing and I'm not buying it" Edward and his younger brother Maurice had a horrific childhood, so Edward doesn't feel like he's capable of love. It's incredibly powerful when he finally lets down his walls. Gabriel has an equally powerful journey as he grapples with his faith and what that means for his relationship with Edward. Their HEA is gloriously well-earned. The final chapter had me giggling and kicking my feet.
But Poor Hartley! EVERYONE NEEDS TO GROVEL AT SOME POINT IN THIS SERIES (I see that he gets his own book later which I will be reading ASAP).
EVERYONE NEEDS TO READ THIS BOOK IT'S LITERALLY FREE AND YOU WON'T BE DISSAPOINTED.
CW: homophobia, abusive parent (flashbacks), death of a parent (on page), arson
I love downloading a free book on a whim and it ends up being excellent! 🥰❤️
Edward, Duke of Caddonfell, is forced to flee London after being caught with a very powerful man's son. Once he returns to his family's home in the country, he comes across his former childhood friend Sir Gabriel Winters, passed out in a flowerbed. After Edward nurses Gabriel back to health, Gabriel returns the favor when Edward's life is in danger.
Read this book if you love: former childhood friends to lovers, handsome vicars, forced proximity, hurt/comfort, AN ADORABLE ADOPTED KITTEN NAMED BUTTONS, found family, protective siblings.
This book was amazing. The yearning and sexual tension was exquisite! Edward and Gabriel's journey was beautifully written, from wary friendship to a passionate romance. Edward doesn't feel like he's good enough for Gabriel, so he frequently hides behind his well-known rake persona to push him away and Gabriel is so patient and loving and is just...not having it 😂 Whenever Edward tries to keep him at a distance he's like "Yeah, I know what you're doing and I'm not buying it" Edward and his younger brother Maurice had a horrific childhood, so Edward doesn't feel like he's capable of love. It's incredibly powerful when he finally lets down his walls. Gabriel has an equally powerful journey as he grapples with his faith and what that means for his relationship with Edward. Their HEA is gloriously well-earned. The final chapter had me giggling and kicking my feet.
But Poor Hartley! EVERYONE NEEDS TO GROVEL AT SOME POINT IN THIS SERIES (I see that he gets his own book later which I will be reading ASAP).
EVERYONE NEEDS TO READ THIS BOOK IT'S LITERALLY FREE AND YOU WON'T BE DISSAPOINTED.
CW: homophobia, abusive parent (flashbacks), death of a parent (on page), arson
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 7, 2021
This is author Annabelle Greene's debut novel and it is a well-written Regency-style M/M romance, which is completely in my wheelhouse. And from page one, I was hopelessly drawn in:
The author has a gift for beautifully fleshing out characters and crafting their internal dialogues and we get Edward and Gabriel's POV throughout. Their love story is incredibly steamy, very poignant as Edward comes to terms with his childhood, and ultimately pretty wonderful.
The middle of the book lagged just a bit, and the final resolution seemed a bit too tidy and the timeline was wonky, but overall, I loved this book, the sizzling love story between Edward and Gabriel, the unlikely relationship developing between Maurice and Caroline, and the promise of getting the fascinating backgrounds of Captain Benjamin Frakes (featured in the next book in the series) as well as Hartley.
Annabelle Greene is one great writer and I can't wait to read more of her Society of Beasts series! 4.5 stars.
I received an ARC from the Publisher, via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review.
Gabriel hadn't planned on dying young, especially on such a fine April evening. He also hadn't planned on dying outdoors - but as he lifted his hand to his forehead, finding it slick with sweat, a violent dizziness overcame him.Lord Edward Stanhope - nicknamed "Scandal" by the ton - and Sir Gabriel Winters - chaste, hardworking vicar - were boyhood friends but haven't seen each other in over 10 years.
Death was coming, apparently on a very fast horse, to the opulent grounds of Hardcote House. Right to this particular flowerbed swimming in front of his eyes.
A life of sin had been good to Edward. The skinny, fine-boned adolescent he remembered had grown into a tall, lithely muscled man who whispered dangerous elegance from head to foot.After a huge scandal in London - a hangable offense involving being caught in flagrante delicto in a stable with the Duke of Sussex's eldest son - Edward and his brother Maurice have returned to Hardcote to figure out their next move. The Duke of Sussex cannot be bribed and is determined to run Edward aground and kill him. Gabriel's sister Caroline, Edward's man Bryce, along with Edward's friends gather to protect Edward and plan a way out of this untenable situation.
The author has a gift for beautifully fleshing out characters and crafting their internal dialogues and we get Edward and Gabriel's POV throughout. Their love story is incredibly steamy, very poignant as Edward comes to terms with his childhood, and ultimately pretty wonderful.
The middle of the book lagged just a bit, and the final resolution seemed a bit too tidy and the timeline was wonky, but overall, I loved this book, the sizzling love story between Edward and Gabriel, the unlikely relationship developing between Maurice and Caroline, and the promise of getting the fascinating backgrounds of Captain Benjamin Frakes (featured in the next book in the series) as well as Hartley.
Annabelle Greene is one great writer and I can't wait to read more of her Society of Beasts series! 4.5 stars.
I received an ARC from the Publisher, via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review.
August 30, 2021
What a lovely treat. I must confess, I'm new to Regency romance, but what I've read of the MM variety has me hunting for more. The challenge lies in crafting a convincing happily ever after for a gay couple during a period of such rigid societal restrictions, and I often hesitate out of fear the author won't be able to rise to the task. Not so with Annabelle Greene. In addition, the dialogue was wonderful witty and sharp. The sex, scorching. And the action packed climax nicely suspenseful. Throughout the prose had a great energy to it that really took me in. I'm happily on board for the rest of this series.
(I'm an author who only posts reviews of books I like. If you want to hear about what I don't like, get me alone and buy me a (good) doughnut)
(I'm an author who only posts reviews of books I like. If you want to hear about what I don't like, get me alone and buy me a (good) doughnut)
December 27, 2021
There is nothing particularly wrong with this book especially as it's the debut work of the author. I even enjoyed some parts of it. However, being the chaotic reader that I am, I have already read the 2nd book of this series a few months back. And, believe me, is one of the best historical MM romances of 2021.
So, reading this book after that gem made me feel nothing special about the author's writing. I had to struggle to finish the audiobook for more than 10 days, even though it was narrated by one of my fav narrators Cornell Collins.
So, reading this book after that gem made me feel nothing special about the author's writing. I had to struggle to finish the audiobook for more than 10 days, even though it was narrated by one of my fav narrators Cornell Collins.
February 7, 2025
So this is a debut and the writing holds promise but I couldn’t stop myself tuning out for most of the second half. I actually thought I’d downloaded book 2 which has much better reviews and couldn’t understand why I was having such a rough time engaging. It started off interesting and with some nice tension between the MC’s. I liked the initial side characters and thought there was some cute potential between Edward’s brother and Gabriel’s sister (probably a bad sign that I was more into the m/f romance than the m/m one)
Unfortunately the plot started to get convoluted, I got lost with the added side characters and things felt repetitive and messy. I constantly found it difficult to ascertain whose POV I was in. The actual interactions between the MCs were nice but as soon as the storyline opened up the whole thing lost appeal.
On the whole I’d recommend just going straight into book 2 and skipping this one unless you’re a stickler for doing things in order or more tolerant than I.
The narration itself was beautiful by Cornell Collin’s, easy 4-5stars for the narration.
This was free with my Audible subscription in the Plus catalogue.
Unfortunately the plot started to get convoluted, I got lost with the added side characters and things felt repetitive and messy. I constantly found it difficult to ascertain whose POV I was in. The actual interactions between the MCs were nice but as soon as the storyline opened up the whole thing lost appeal.
On the whole I’d recommend just going straight into book 2 and skipping this one unless you’re a stickler for doing things in order or more tolerant than I.
The narration itself was beautiful by Cornell Collin’s, easy 4-5stars for the narration.
This was free with my Audible subscription in the Plus catalogue.
July 22, 2021
3 ⭐️⭐️⭐️
I read this book because I want to read the second book in the series and I felt like I’d do better if I started at the beginning. I’m glad I did because I have a better feel for the characters and the society they belong to.
I felt this book had many lovely parts. I love past friends or lovers who reunite and we get that here. I liked the cast of characters and that there was a camaraderie amongst them.
I did feel as though the book was too long causing it to drag in places. There was a lot of repeating inner thoughts that I found annoying. I also had some difficulty with who was speaking at times. There were also two issues I had which usually ruin a book for me:
1) When Gabriel & Edward were becoming intimate on several occasions they were interrupted. This can become so annoying to me as a reader! I don’t mind it happening maybe once or twice (I prefer once or never) but it happened a few times here.
2) Gabriel’s sister Caroline butted in too much. I know many seemed to like her and I did too until she was trying to put in her two cents. I felt like she was more of a distraction and I wasn’t a fan overall.
The last part of the book did get a bit dramatic but it also was quick wrapping up. I didn’t feel like the resolution was too easy but maybe a bit too coincidental.
One other other thing I found weird was (Spoiler) that Edward returns to his home town and the Duke of Sussex having ties to that town didn’t think to look for Edward there sooner? It seemed like a no brainer.
I do hope the second book is better overall. I think this series has potential to be really good.
I read this book because I want to read the second book in the series and I felt like I’d do better if I started at the beginning. I’m glad I did because I have a better feel for the characters and the society they belong to.
I felt this book had many lovely parts. I love past friends or lovers who reunite and we get that here. I liked the cast of characters and that there was a camaraderie amongst them.
I did feel as though the book was too long causing it to drag in places. There was a lot of repeating inner thoughts that I found annoying. I also had some difficulty with who was speaking at times. There were also two issues I had which usually ruin a book for me:
1) When Gabriel & Edward were becoming intimate on several occasions they were interrupted. This can become so annoying to me as a reader! I don’t mind it happening maybe once or twice (I prefer once or never) but it happened a few times here.
2) Gabriel’s sister Caroline butted in too much. I know many seemed to like her and I did too until she was trying to put in her two cents. I felt like she was more of a distraction and I wasn’t a fan overall.
The last part of the book did get a bit dramatic but it also was quick wrapping up. I didn’t feel like the resolution was too easy but maybe a bit too coincidental.
One other other thing I found weird was (Spoiler) that Edward returns to his home town and the Duke of Sussex having ties to that town didn’t think to look for Edward there sooner? It seemed like a no brainer.
I do hope the second book is better overall. I think this series has potential to be really good.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 28, 2020
A lovely story, in the style of Regency romances but with a dark twist of mystery and a few unforgettable characters, this reminded me of many of the romances I devoured in my twenties and thirties, though with men falling in love with men this time.
I enjoyed the variety of characters, especially Gabriel, the vicar with a gentleman status who yearns for his lost love, Edward Stanhope, the Duke of Caddonfell. Edward is the rogue of rogues among the ton and Gabriel’s wishes come true when Edward returns home, until he learns Edward is in hiding due to his latest seduction—the soon-to-be-married son of the infamous Duke of Sussex—witnessed in a stable during a society ball.
The author brought Edward’s character to life over time and the prickly rascal soon became someone to root for. Gabriel, with his good deeds and untiring work, was an easy character to like right from the beginning. His sister, Caroline, was a strong female character, not a harpy but still a bit too sharp for my taste, though overall, a good catalyst character. Edward’s brother, Marcus, was highly intelligent, intense, and interesting, and one would hope by the end of the story that he and Caroline can find their way to one another. They certainly were cut from the same cloth, so to speak.
The Society of Beasts, a club of men who like men, was structured in a similar fashion to male/female historical romances I’ve read in the past, and a few male/male I’ve read in the present. One of the members has betrayed the others and that affects all, especially Edward who feels personally betrayed.
Overall, this story had an interesting plot among well-drawn characters and a sweet, slow-burn romance, but to be honest, I became bored around one-third of the way in when events—including the attraction between Edward and Gabriel—didn’t advance at more than a tortoise pace. Toward the end, when all of the people, the settings, the background, and mystery pieces were finally set up, the pace picked up and the story held my attention for longer periods. Edward’s and Gabriel’s dance of attraction/dissention/attraction/self-destruction, dragged on too long. I enjoyed the last chapters, when all the threads (and there were many!) wove together to not only make sense but to see the “bad guy� overpowered and the “good guys� get a lovely HEA.
I enjoyed the variety of characters, especially Gabriel, the vicar with a gentleman status who yearns for his lost love, Edward Stanhope, the Duke of Caddonfell. Edward is the rogue of rogues among the ton and Gabriel’s wishes come true when Edward returns home, until he learns Edward is in hiding due to his latest seduction—the soon-to-be-married son of the infamous Duke of Sussex—witnessed in a stable during a society ball.
The author brought Edward’s character to life over time and the prickly rascal soon became someone to root for. Gabriel, with his good deeds and untiring work, was an easy character to like right from the beginning. His sister, Caroline, was a strong female character, not a harpy but still a bit too sharp for my taste, though overall, a good catalyst character. Edward’s brother, Marcus, was highly intelligent, intense, and interesting, and one would hope by the end of the story that he and Caroline can find their way to one another. They certainly were cut from the same cloth, so to speak.
The Society of Beasts, a club of men who like men, was structured in a similar fashion to male/female historical romances I’ve read in the past, and a few male/male I’ve read in the present. One of the members has betrayed the others and that affects all, especially Edward who feels personally betrayed.
Overall, this story had an interesting plot among well-drawn characters and a sweet, slow-burn romance, but to be honest, I became bored around one-third of the way in when events—including the attraction between Edward and Gabriel—didn’t advance at more than a tortoise pace. Toward the end, when all of the people, the settings, the background, and mystery pieces were finally set up, the pace picked up and the story held my attention for longer periods. Edward’s and Gabriel’s dance of attraction/dissention/attraction/self-destruction, dragged on too long. I enjoyed the last chapters, when all the threads (and there were many!) wove together to not only make sense but to see the “bad guy� overpowered and the “good guys� get a lovely HEA.
June 25, 2021
ARC provided by the publisher via Net Galley.
1.25 stars
I was very hopeful when I started this, even though it was a bit slow.
However, it never fully got in gear for me.
The characters that ended up calling out to me the most were Maurice and Caroline, and believe me, no one is more surprised than me that I liked the het pairing more than the MCs in an MM romance. Specially considering the ship is only in my head (at least so far).
I failed to connect to Edward and Gabriel in any meaningful way, their relationship felt very tentative, to the very end and the steamy bits were not very steamy at all - in fact, I was borderline concerned at one point. I know this isn't set in modern times, but still.
The overall plot was very predictable and failed to instill me with any curiosity of that desire to keep reading to see if all works out. I had to keep forcing myself to pick this up again to finish it, even though it's on the shorter side.
(watch me never be approved by this publisher ever again TT - which would be terrible because I looove Rachel Reid, Annabeth Albert & Cole McCade, so here's hoping)
1.25 stars
I was very hopeful when I started this, even though it was a bit slow.
However, it never fully got in gear for me.
The characters that ended up calling out to me the most were Maurice and Caroline, and believe me, no one is more surprised than me that I liked the het pairing more than the MCs in an MM romance. Specially considering the ship is only in my head (at least so far).
I failed to connect to Edward and Gabriel in any meaningful way, their relationship felt very tentative, to the very end and the steamy bits were not very steamy at all - in fact, I was borderline concerned at one point. I know this isn't set in modern times, but still.
The overall plot was very predictable and failed to instill me with any curiosity of that desire to keep reading to see if all works out. I had to keep forcing myself to pick this up again to finish it, even though it's on the shorter side.
(watch me never be approved by this publisher ever again TT - which would be terrible because I looove Rachel Reid, Annabeth Albert & Cole McCade, so here's hoping)
March 26, 2024
I've given this an A- for narration and a D for content at AudioGals; the narration grade should push this up into the 3.5/4 star bracket, but the book is SO TERRIBLE, I can't bring myself to put any more than 3 stars. Seriously, it's dire.
I’m always on the lookout for new m/m historicals, and Carina Press, who published the print edition of début author Annabelle Greene’sThe Vicar and the Rake, has a pretty good track record when it comes to LGBTQ+ romance. When I saw that Cornell Collins would be narrating this title, I decided to listen rather than read which, in one way was a good decision, because his polished, accomplished narration was absolutely the best thing about it. In another way? Not so much, as even his expertise couldn’t disguise what is essentially a weak story with poorly defined characters, no romantic tension or chemistry, plot points that made no sense and a completely ridiculous ending.
Okay, so a quick resumé of the plot, such as it is. Reverend Sir Gabriel Winters decided to give up a life of luxury for that of a country vicar when he was younger, and along with his holy orders,turned his back on his secret desiresand tooka self-imposed vow of celibacy� which basically amounts to “God, I know I’m gay but I vow never to act upon it.� Gabriel pretty much grew up with his best friend, Edward Stanhope, now the Duke of Caddonfell,a man so visibly, arrogantly, dangerously libertine that his nickname, whispered from one end of England to the other, was simply Scandal.And:The terror of every mother in the ton, not for their daughters, but for their sons. The most infamous sodomite in London.
Now that, right there, on page one, is where the wheels start to fall off the wagon. I’m well aware there were men among the nobility who preferred the company of their own sex. But given that homosexuality was illegal in England until 1967, they had to be discreet about it � and while it may be true that a duke could do pretty much anything he liked and get away with it, I’m not certain that being openly queer was one of them. Murder, blackmail, embezzlement, fraud, violence � probably. Being gay? Doubtful. So the idea of Edward as an infamous sodomitejust doesn’t ring true.
Anyway.
The book opens with Gabriel, in a raging fever, crawling his way to Hardcote House (the family home of the Stanhopes) � which is empty � and passing out in a flower bed. Fortunately for him, the place is to be unoccupied no longer; Edward has fled London to the one place he’s sworn never to come back to (Daddy issues, natch) following a rather serious faux pas. He was caught in flagrante with the son of the powerful Duke of Sussex, and the furious, outraged Duke has vowed revenge of the worst sort. Edward’s younger brother Maurice � who seems to have spent most of his life clearing up his brother’s messes � has told Edward he needs to get out of town and hide away while he � Maurice � can work out what to do next, because Sussex is out for blood and is not above hiring an assassin to dispose of Edward.
Upon finding his boyhood friend (and first love) feverish in the flower beds, Edward decides he can’t just leave him there � despite Maurice’s injunction to let NO ONE know where he is. Edward and his valet get Gabriel into the house and care for him overnight � and hey presto! By morning (and after some delirious snogging), he’s all better.
When Maurice arrives, he decides the best thing to do is to get some dirt on Sussex in order to get him to leave Edward alone, but that’s not going to be easy because Sussex is � or appears to be � one of the few aristocrats in the land who is squeaky clean.
Then � oh. Er. That’s about it in terms of the plot. For over half the book, we get Gabriel and Edward mooning over each other (and Gabriel reminding himself of his vow and then promptly breaking it), Maurice being grumpy and Gabriel’s sister being quietly rather awesome. Then, despite the fact that Edward is IN HIDING, a group of his friends � his fellow “Beasts� (the series title isThe Society of Beasts) � turn up in support, having figured out that it’s the only place Edward could have gone� which begs the question, if they can find him, why can’t the Duke of Sussex? But with their arrival comes treachery and betrayal. And more plot-holes.
The two leads are barely two-dimensional, and although the story is told in alternating PoVs, neither has a distinct voice. And that impression isn’t helped by the fact that each chapter seems to be about five minutes long, so we’re switching back-and-forth, back-and-forth so often that it’s almost like being at Centre Court at Wimbledon. It was bad enough in audio � I can only imagine how irritating it would have been in print, with chapters lasting no longer than a few paragraphs! The real issue though is that they’re so short as to allow no time for the listener to get a handle on who these men are, and how they relate to each other.
The romance is non-existent. What we have here are two men we’re told were in love as boys, picking up pretty much where they left off, so there’s no romantic development or character progression whatsoever. Instead we get a lot of “sex by numbers�; 1. Snogging and groping � check. 2. Hand-jobs (one each) � check. 3. Blow-jobs (one each)� check. 4. Anal sex and then switching it up � check. Gabriel’s vow goes out the window early on � he instigates quite a few of the sexy-times, so I have no idea why he even bothered to make it in the first place, seeing as how it prevents him from indulging in sexual acts NOT AT ALL.
And then there’s the ending. Oh, dear, that ending.
As I said at the beginning, the only bright spot in this mess is Cornell Collins, without whom I would probably have consigned this audiobook to the scrap heap. It’s thanks to his vocal characterisations that I was able to tell the difference between Edward and Gabriel at all; as I said before, there is nothing individual about the way they are written and, something that was pointed out to me by an online friend who read the print version, there are very few dialogue tags in the story, so having a narrator actually differentiating the characters was a positive thing as it meant I could always tell who was speaking. The characters of Maurice and Lady Caroline (Gabriel’s sister) are far more interesting than the two leads, and I particularly liked Mr. Collins� portrayal of the always exasperated Maurice. The rest of the secondary cast � Edward’s “Beastly� friends and the dastardly Sussex � are clearly delineated, the pacing is fine and Mr. Collins is reliably good in the more intimate moments and at injecting some sort of life and vibrancy into the characters and the story as a whole.
Ultimately however, if you want to listen to historical m/m with happy endings that are well thought-out and plausible � and simply superior in every way � listen to KJ Charles, Joanna Chambers or Cat Sebastian. The only good thing about the audiobook ofThe Vicar and the Rakeis Cornell Collins� expert performance � but even a narrator as talented as he is can’t weave a silk purse from this particular sow’s ear.
This review originally appeared at .
I’m always on the lookout for new m/m historicals, and Carina Press, who published the print edition of début author Annabelle Greene’sThe Vicar and the Rake, has a pretty good track record when it comes to LGBTQ+ romance. When I saw that Cornell Collins would be narrating this title, I decided to listen rather than read which, in one way was a good decision, because his polished, accomplished narration was absolutely the best thing about it. In another way? Not so much, as even his expertise couldn’t disguise what is essentially a weak story with poorly defined characters, no romantic tension or chemistry, plot points that made no sense and a completely ridiculous ending.
Okay, so a quick resumé of the plot, such as it is. Reverend Sir Gabriel Winters decided to give up a life of luxury for that of a country vicar when he was younger, and along with his holy orders,turned his back on his secret desiresand tooka self-imposed vow of celibacy� which basically amounts to “God, I know I’m gay but I vow never to act upon it.� Gabriel pretty much grew up with his best friend, Edward Stanhope, now the Duke of Caddonfell,a man so visibly, arrogantly, dangerously libertine that his nickname, whispered from one end of England to the other, was simply Scandal.And:The terror of every mother in the ton, not for their daughters, but for their sons. The most infamous sodomite in London.
Now that, right there, on page one, is where the wheels start to fall off the wagon. I’m well aware there were men among the nobility who preferred the company of their own sex. But given that homosexuality was illegal in England until 1967, they had to be discreet about it � and while it may be true that a duke could do pretty much anything he liked and get away with it, I’m not certain that being openly queer was one of them. Murder, blackmail, embezzlement, fraud, violence � probably. Being gay? Doubtful. So the idea of Edward as an infamous sodomitejust doesn’t ring true.
Anyway.
The book opens with Gabriel, in a raging fever, crawling his way to Hardcote House (the family home of the Stanhopes) � which is empty � and passing out in a flower bed. Fortunately for him, the place is to be unoccupied no longer; Edward has fled London to the one place he’s sworn never to come back to (Daddy issues, natch) following a rather serious faux pas. He was caught in flagrante with the son of the powerful Duke of Sussex, and the furious, outraged Duke has vowed revenge of the worst sort. Edward’s younger brother Maurice � who seems to have spent most of his life clearing up his brother’s messes � has told Edward he needs to get out of town and hide away while he � Maurice � can work out what to do next, because Sussex is out for blood and is not above hiring an assassin to dispose of Edward.
Upon finding his boyhood friend (and first love) feverish in the flower beds, Edward decides he can’t just leave him there � despite Maurice’s injunction to let NO ONE know where he is. Edward and his valet get Gabriel into the house and care for him overnight � and hey presto! By morning (and after some delirious snogging), he’s all better.
When Maurice arrives, he decides the best thing to do is to get some dirt on Sussex in order to get him to leave Edward alone, but that’s not going to be easy because Sussex is � or appears to be � one of the few aristocrats in the land who is squeaky clean.
Then � oh. Er. That’s about it in terms of the plot. For over half the book, we get Gabriel and Edward mooning over each other (and Gabriel reminding himself of his vow and then promptly breaking it), Maurice being grumpy and Gabriel’s sister being quietly rather awesome. Then, despite the fact that Edward is IN HIDING, a group of his friends � his fellow “Beasts� (the series title isThe Society of Beasts) � turn up in support, having figured out that it’s the only place Edward could have gone� which begs the question, if they can find him, why can’t the Duke of Sussex? But with their arrival comes treachery and betrayal. And more plot-holes.
The two leads are barely two-dimensional, and although the story is told in alternating PoVs, neither has a distinct voice. And that impression isn’t helped by the fact that each chapter seems to be about five minutes long, so we’re switching back-and-forth, back-and-forth so often that it’s almost like being at Centre Court at Wimbledon. It was bad enough in audio � I can only imagine how irritating it would have been in print, with chapters lasting no longer than a few paragraphs! The real issue though is that they’re so short as to allow no time for the listener to get a handle on who these men are, and how they relate to each other.
The romance is non-existent. What we have here are two men we’re told were in love as boys, picking up pretty much where they left off, so there’s no romantic development or character progression whatsoever. Instead we get a lot of “sex by numbers�; 1. Snogging and groping � check. 2. Hand-jobs (one each) � check. 3. Blow-jobs (one each)� check. 4. Anal sex and then switching it up � check. Gabriel’s vow goes out the window early on � he instigates quite a few of the sexy-times, so I have no idea why he even bothered to make it in the first place, seeing as how it prevents him from indulging in sexual acts NOT AT ALL.
And then there’s the ending. Oh, dear, that ending.
As I said at the beginning, the only bright spot in this mess is Cornell Collins, without whom I would probably have consigned this audiobook to the scrap heap. It’s thanks to his vocal characterisations that I was able to tell the difference between Edward and Gabriel at all; as I said before, there is nothing individual about the way they are written and, something that was pointed out to me by an online friend who read the print version, there are very few dialogue tags in the story, so having a narrator actually differentiating the characters was a positive thing as it meant I could always tell who was speaking. The characters of Maurice and Lady Caroline (Gabriel’s sister) are far more interesting than the two leads, and I particularly liked Mr. Collins� portrayal of the always exasperated Maurice. The rest of the secondary cast � Edward’s “Beastly� friends and the dastardly Sussex � are clearly delineated, the pacing is fine and Mr. Collins is reliably good in the more intimate moments and at injecting some sort of life and vibrancy into the characters and the story as a whole.
Ultimately however, if you want to listen to historical m/m with happy endings that are well thought-out and plausible � and simply superior in every way � listen to KJ Charles, Joanna Chambers or Cat Sebastian. The only good thing about the audiobook ofThe Vicar and the Rakeis Cornell Collins� expert performance � but even a narrator as talented as he is can’t weave a silk purse from this particular sow’s ear.
This review originally appeared at .
February 13, 2022
Overall: 3.5 rounded to ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Plot/Storyline: 📖📖📖
Feels: 🦋🦋🦋
Emotional Depth: 💔💔💔
Sexual Tension: ⚡⚡�
Romance: 💞💞
Sensuality: 💋💋💋💋
Sex Scene Length: 🍑🍑🍑🍑
Steam Scale (Number of Sex Scenes): 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Humor: Just a touch
(These are all personal preference on a scale of 1-5 (yours ratings may vary depending what gives you feels and how you prefer you sex scenes written, etc) except the Steam Scale which follows our chart from )
Basic plot
Gabriel has never forgotten his young love Edward. Heartbroken, his letters left unanswered, he has become a vicar and lives a simple life of helping others. Edward removed himself to London to live the life of a rake and forget the abuse he’s suffered by his father. Unfortunately, one of his escapades gets him noticed by the Duke of Sussex, who will stop at nothing to harm Edward for his actions.
Give this a try if you want:
- M/M romance � our heroes are Edward and Gabriel
- Regency time period � this one takes place in 1818
- Hero nurses hero back to health
- Childhood friends to lovers
- A bit of action/mystery mixed in � Gabriel and Edward work together to save Edward
- Mix of country and London setting
- Medium to higher steam � 4 scenes, I found most of them plenty explicit and well developed
My thoughts:
This is Annabelle Greene’s debut novel and I really loved a lot of it! I did listen to the audiobook with Cornell Collins, who I am now obsessed with. His voice was perfect to me and really loved listening to him tell me the story.
Edward and Gabriel grew up together. There were feelings there, but nothing was acted on. When Edward inherited the dukedom, he went to London without a goodbye and didn’t answer any of Gabriel’s letters that arrived. Gabriel stayed in the country with his self-imposed celibacy and became a vicar to try to do some good in the world.
Edward causes all sorts of uproar in London with his behavior, but when he’s caught in a compromising position in the stables with the Duke of Sussex’s son, the duke will stop at nothing to end Edward’s life. He retires to the country in hiding. Immediately upon his return he finds a sick Gabriel that he nurses back to health.
I really loved a lot about this story. I thought the characters were lovable. I liked the supporting cast of family members and animals. I loved the sex. Some parts were really tender to me, and I loved how Edward opened up with Gabriel and was vulnerable in ways he hadn’t been with others in the bedroom.
Some of it went off the rails for me in regards to the whole duke vs Edward plot, especially towards the end. I also could have used a bit more character depth. You got a bit with Edward with the abuse he suffered, but I wanted his recovery explored a bit more. And I definitely wanted to know Gabriel more.
I would 100% try this author again.
Content Warnings:
Locations of kisses/intimate scenes: (These might be a little off from the book as I listened to audio)
Plot/Storyline: 📖📖📖
Feels: 🦋🦋🦋
Emotional Depth: 💔💔💔
Sexual Tension: ⚡⚡�
Romance: 💞💞
Sensuality: 💋💋💋💋
Sex Scene Length: 🍑🍑🍑🍑
Steam Scale (Number of Sex Scenes): 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Humor: Just a touch
(These are all personal preference on a scale of 1-5 (yours ratings may vary depending what gives you feels and how you prefer you sex scenes written, etc) except the Steam Scale which follows our chart from )
Basic plot
Gabriel has never forgotten his young love Edward. Heartbroken, his letters left unanswered, he has become a vicar and lives a simple life of helping others. Edward removed himself to London to live the life of a rake and forget the abuse he’s suffered by his father. Unfortunately, one of his escapades gets him noticed by the Duke of Sussex, who will stop at nothing to harm Edward for his actions.
Give this a try if you want:
- M/M romance � our heroes are Edward and Gabriel
- Regency time period � this one takes place in 1818
- Hero nurses hero back to health
- Childhood friends to lovers
- A bit of action/mystery mixed in � Gabriel and Edward work together to save Edward
- Mix of country and London setting
- Medium to higher steam � 4 scenes, I found most of them plenty explicit and well developed
My thoughts:
This is Annabelle Greene’s debut novel and I really loved a lot of it! I did listen to the audiobook with Cornell Collins, who I am now obsessed with. His voice was perfect to me and really loved listening to him tell me the story.
Edward and Gabriel grew up together. There were feelings there, but nothing was acted on. When Edward inherited the dukedom, he went to London without a goodbye and didn’t answer any of Gabriel’s letters that arrived. Gabriel stayed in the country with his self-imposed celibacy and became a vicar to try to do some good in the world.
Edward causes all sorts of uproar in London with his behavior, but when he’s caught in a compromising position in the stables with the Duke of Sussex’s son, the duke will stop at nothing to end Edward’s life. He retires to the country in hiding. Immediately upon his return he finds a sick Gabriel that he nurses back to health.
I really loved a lot about this story. I thought the characters were lovable. I liked the supporting cast of family members and animals. I loved the sex. Some parts were really tender to me, and I loved how Edward opened up with Gabriel and was vulnerable in ways he hadn’t been with others in the bedroom.
Some of it went off the rails for me in regards to the whole duke vs Edward plot, especially towards the end. I also could have used a bit more character depth. You got a bit with Edward with the abuse he suffered, but I wanted his recovery explored a bit more. And I definitely wanted to know Gabriel more.
I would 100% try this author again.
Content Warnings:
Locations of kisses/intimate scenes: (These might be a little off from the book as I listened to audio)
May 13, 2022
It took me a while to get through the audiobook, but I enjoyed it on the whole. This book is mostly about the characters and their history with each other. The two MCs (Edward and Gabriel) are both amazingly dramatic and I didn’t even mind what could be considered too much internal monologuing bc they were so entertaining. - that’s a ten star scene all on it’s own. But the plot is kind of weak, so I can’t really give it five stars. I have high hopes for books 2 and 3!
October 8, 2020
Gabriel Winters is a gentleman who gave up his station to become a vicar. Edward Stanhope, Duke of Caddonfell, was his boyhood friend but is now literally nicknamed Scandal for all the shenanigans he gets up to in London. Edward flees to his childhood home to escape a sticky situation and finds Gabriel passed out and delirious with fever in his driveway.
This book didn't work for me. It's fine, but it failed to thoroughly keep my interest (though, admittedly, the news environment when I read this was extremely distracting).
- The blurb mentions Gabriel's fever. I thought this was going to start out with a prolonged sickbed and recovery section. Gabriel recovers from apparent near death overnight. I love a sickbed scene, so this was disappointing to me.
- I don't get who Gabriel is. His character feels inconsistent to me and his backstory seems patchy. Edward I get - dissolute rake with a tragic childhood. Fine.
- I got lost. I frequently had to re-read to check who was talking or thinking. Though please see my note about very distracting news environment here and take with whatever grain of salt you need.
- Edward and Gabriel's shared backstory was a little murky to me. I didn't have enough of it to really buy into their reunion. A flashback chapter or two showing some adolescent bonding would have gone a long way.
- Sudden unexpected plot twists. The action really picks up at 75-80%, but it's all a surprise. I want a few more breadcrumbs to follow before random stuff starts happening.
- Secondary characters steal the show. Edward's brother and Gabriel's sister were way more interesting to me than the MCs. Maybe because Gabriel's sister talks/engages in banter? She's got a whole story/backstory going on that I wanted to know more about.
Despite all that, I think this will work for a lot of readers. It's fine. It just didn't work for me now, but all my issues are things that be fixed in future books. I would absolutely check in with this author a few books down the road and see what she's writing.
I received an ARC of the book from the publisher via NetGalley.
This book didn't work for me. It's fine, but it failed to thoroughly keep my interest (though, admittedly, the news environment when I read this was extremely distracting).
- The blurb mentions Gabriel's fever. I thought this was going to start out with a prolonged sickbed and recovery section. Gabriel recovers from apparent near death overnight. I love a sickbed scene, so this was disappointing to me.
- I don't get who Gabriel is. His character feels inconsistent to me and his backstory seems patchy. Edward I get - dissolute rake with a tragic childhood. Fine.
- I got lost. I frequently had to re-read to check who was talking or thinking. Though please see my note about very distracting news environment here and take with whatever grain of salt you need.
- Edward and Gabriel's shared backstory was a little murky to me. I didn't have enough of it to really buy into their reunion. A flashback chapter or two showing some adolescent bonding would have gone a long way.
- Sudden unexpected plot twists. The action really picks up at 75-80%, but it's all a surprise. I want a few more breadcrumbs to follow before random stuff starts happening.
- Secondary characters steal the show. Edward's brother and Gabriel's sister were way more interesting to me than the MCs. Maybe because Gabriel's sister talks/engages in banter? She's got a whole story/backstory going on that I wanted to know more about.
Despite all that, I think this will work for a lot of readers. It's fine. It just didn't work for me now, but all my issues are things that be fixed in future books. I would absolutely check in with this author a few books down the road and see what she's writing.
I received an ARC of the book from the publisher via NetGalley.
September 10, 2020
3 stars for this debut novel
For the last month and half , I have been reading all the historical romance , I can get my hands on. And that's how I found Annabelle Greene debut novel The Vicar and the Rake.
I had a good time reading this soapy, emotional , melodramatic , very steamy sexy story.
Even though , I should not compare some of the similarity , of this story to KJ Charles outstanding Society of Gentlemen series it is near impossible not to do. And of course, the results are this tale falls short in comparison.
Also, there are few glaring plot-holes and timeline inconsistencies that render the mystery big secret chronologically impossible.
That said, I think this author has a lot of potential and have written an entertaining story. Looking forward reading the upcoming books .
I just reviewed The Vicar and the Rake by Annabelle Greene. #TheVicarandtheRake #NetGalley
For the last month and half , I have been reading all the historical romance , I can get my hands on. And that's how I found Annabelle Greene debut novel The Vicar and the Rake.
I had a good time reading this soapy, emotional , melodramatic , very steamy sexy story.
Even though , I should not compare some of the similarity , of this story to KJ Charles outstanding Society of Gentlemen series it is near impossible not to do. And of course, the results are this tale falls short in comparison.
Also, there are few glaring plot-holes and timeline inconsistencies that render the mystery big secret chronologically impossible.
That said, I think this author has a lot of potential and have written an entertaining story. Looking forward reading the upcoming books .
I just reviewed The Vicar and the Rake by Annabelle Greene. #TheVicarandtheRake #NetGalley
October 11, 2020
One could not refuse the work of love -- the work of loving.
Writing-wise? This is straight up like, 9.5/10. It was really really good. I've gotten into the habit of putting little quotes at the start of my reviews, but there are SO many good ones in this book that I'm having the hardest time choosing what I want to highlight! Not just in terms of the style of the writing (which was really good, striking, immersed me in the time period, sometimes really witty) but also some of the things it said about life and love and being yourself. A couple times I had to like, stop and just... appreciate certain passages. The author managed profundity without it being like, preachy or fake? I really liked it.
“But... love, as I have seen it practised, does not require one to be an expert practitioner when one begins. One learns as one goes. It... it’s one of the only states where the broken can function as well as the whole.�
The romance was good! Soooooooort of a second chance romance, but not really. I do wish we'd seen or been told more about the characters when they knew each other 10 years ago. It would have gone a long way towards making their feelings in the present day feel realer? But it was a really cute romance; I like how different they were, and how their personalities complemented each other's. The little mystery around the plot was good (not great, but serviceable), and I really liked all of the secondary characters. (Especially Maurice and Ginger; their little exchange, and the class commentary that came out of it, was super short, but really meaningful.) This is one of the few romance novels where I don't MIND that the author introduces POVs other than the main couple, because it's done for a reason, and not in a distracting way.
Also this book has a really freaking cute kitten.
Where the book sorta lost me, as so many books unfortunately lose me, was in the pacing and structure. The way things come together isn't very believable, especially as it happens so quickly. As the book moved along, I feel like a great deal of time was spent just waiting for things to happen. Structure-wise, the chapters were too short, and often ended in weird places; sometimes mid-scene.
And the romance! It was good, but it could have been great! How to explain... The characters have history together, but as I said, we don't really SEE much of that history on page. When they meet again at the start of the book, it feels like their relationship is already at 90. So instead of a slow build up, it felt like we quickly jumped to Very Intense Feelings, and things remained at that plateau for most of the book. The love confessions in this book are honestly beautiful, but I don't think we got enough development leading up to them. I also wanted to delve a bit deeper into their characters. We got a good amount of backstory for Edward; not enough for Gabriel imo! At times I sorta forgot he was a vicar, tbh.
All told, I think this is a really good debut, and I look forward to reading more from Greene in the future. Would definitely rec this to people who are looking for queer historical romance. I just wish the plotting and pacing had been a bit tighter.
3.5 stars.
� Review copy provided via NetGalley.
Writing-wise? This is straight up like, 9.5/10. It was really really good. I've gotten into the habit of putting little quotes at the start of my reviews, but there are SO many good ones in this book that I'm having the hardest time choosing what I want to highlight! Not just in terms of the style of the writing (which was really good, striking, immersed me in the time period, sometimes really witty) but also some of the things it said about life and love and being yourself. A couple times I had to like, stop and just... appreciate certain passages. The author managed profundity without it being like, preachy or fake? I really liked it.
“But... love, as I have seen it practised, does not require one to be an expert practitioner when one begins. One learns as one goes. It... it’s one of the only states where the broken can function as well as the whole.�
The romance was good! Soooooooort of a second chance romance, but not really. I do wish we'd seen or been told more about the characters when they knew each other 10 years ago. It would have gone a long way towards making their feelings in the present day feel realer? But it was a really cute romance; I like how different they were, and how their personalities complemented each other's. The little mystery around the plot was good (not great, but serviceable), and I really liked all of the secondary characters. (Especially Maurice and Ginger; their little exchange, and the class commentary that came out of it, was super short, but really meaningful.) This is one of the few romance novels where I don't MIND that the author introduces POVs other than the main couple, because it's done for a reason, and not in a distracting way.
Also this book has a really freaking cute kitten.
Where the book sorta lost me, as so many books unfortunately lose me, was in the pacing and structure. The way things come together isn't very believable, especially as it happens so quickly. As the book moved along, I feel like a great deal of time was spent just waiting for things to happen. Structure-wise, the chapters were too short, and often ended in weird places; sometimes mid-scene.
And the romance! It was good, but it could have been great! How to explain... The characters have history together, but as I said, we don't really SEE much of that history on page. When they meet again at the start of the book, it feels like their relationship is already at 90. So instead of a slow build up, it felt like we quickly jumped to Very Intense Feelings, and things remained at that plateau for most of the book. The love confessions in this book are honestly beautiful, but I don't think we got enough development leading up to them. I also wanted to delve a bit deeper into their characters. We got a good amount of backstory for Edward; not enough for Gabriel imo! At times I sorta forgot he was a vicar, tbh.
All told, I think this is a really good debut, and I look forward to reading more from Greene in the future. Would definitely rec this to people who are looking for queer historical romance. I just wish the plotting and pacing had been a bit tighter.
3.5 stars.
� Review copy provided via NetGalley.
July 1, 2024
*sigh* guess i’m reading this series now
September 19, 2020
This was a strong debut. I liked the romance between Edward and Gabriel; they had good chemistry, and I like how they took time to get past their previous disagreements and estrangement. The mystery of the missing diamonds was also interesting, and I loved Buttons the kitten.
However, while I did like both Gabriel and Edward as individual characters, I struggled to really connect with either of them. I think that it sometimes felt like the author was trying to focus on too many things at the same time, and as a result, there wasn’t enough of a focus on the actual protagonists as there should have been.
However, while I did like both Gabriel and Edward as individual characters, I struggled to really connect with either of them. I think that it sometimes felt like the author was trying to focus on too many things at the same time, and as a result, there wasn’t enough of a focus on the actual protagonists as there should have been.
January 11, 2021
Surrey, 1818
Gabriel’s sister wrote him a letter, Edward is back! After ten years!
Edward Stanhope, Duke of Caddonfell. The terror of every mother in the ton, not for their daughters, but for their sons.
After reading the letter, vicar Gabriel Winters� words weren’t for the ears to hear, he couldn’t speak them out loud, but the word started with d and ended with amn. His childhood friend Edward ran away ten years ago, Edward abandoned him just like that.
“I am excellent at things I’m indifferent to. Imagine how spectacular I am at the things I like.�
Edward's memories are bad and hurtful. He didn’t run off just like that. But he’ll never speak about them. Acting haughty to keep everyone at distance.
Edward is back, hiding, he’s in danger. Edward's brother Maurice is also there to eliminate the threat.
“My God, you’re worthless. You need to be corrected, damn you.�
Edward has demons he can't get rid of. He has nightmares and wounds who won't disappear not even love could. He has to keep Gabriel at arm's-length.
Gabriel is the opposite of Edward, he's open and honest to Edward about his feelings.
He's strong but speaks softly.
"the thought that he had been waiting for Edward’s command was more erotic than a thousand forgettable back-alley encounters"
From the first page, I was head over heels. What a marvelous story. There was humor, the best, a sort of dramatic theatrical humor.
The historical side of this narrative felt authentic. The used language, the build of the sentences. I could hear them clearly. The clothing, the traveling, the politeness, it was quite convincing. I love the amount of drama.
The sexual attraction and tension between Edward and Gabriel were beautiful, heartbreaking, and delightful at the same time.
The suspense was killing. I read on and on, biting my nails until I could breathe again.
My goodness what a story
The end OMG the end... goosebumps thick goosebumps!
Brilliant narrative absolutely brilliant!
Gabriel’s sister wrote him a letter, Edward is back! After ten years!
Edward Stanhope, Duke of Caddonfell. The terror of every mother in the ton, not for their daughters, but for their sons.
After reading the letter, vicar Gabriel Winters� words weren’t for the ears to hear, he couldn’t speak them out loud, but the word started with d and ended with amn. His childhood friend Edward ran away ten years ago, Edward abandoned him just like that.
“I am excellent at things I’m indifferent to. Imagine how spectacular I am at the things I like.�
Edward's memories are bad and hurtful. He didn’t run off just like that. But he’ll never speak about them. Acting haughty to keep everyone at distance.
Edward is back, hiding, he’s in danger. Edward's brother Maurice is also there to eliminate the threat.
“My God, you’re worthless. You need to be corrected, damn you.�
Edward has demons he can't get rid of. He has nightmares and wounds who won't disappear not even love could. He has to keep Gabriel at arm's-length.
Gabriel is the opposite of Edward, he's open and honest to Edward about his feelings.
He's strong but speaks softly.
"the thought that he had been waiting for Edward’s command was more erotic than a thousand forgettable back-alley encounters"
From the first page, I was head over heels. What a marvelous story. There was humor, the best, a sort of dramatic theatrical humor.
The historical side of this narrative felt authentic. The used language, the build of the sentences. I could hear them clearly. The clothing, the traveling, the politeness, it was quite convincing. I love the amount of drama.
The sexual attraction and tension between Edward and Gabriel were beautiful, heartbreaking, and delightful at the same time.
The suspense was killing. I read on and on, biting my nails until I could breathe again.
My goodness what a story
The end OMG the end... goosebumps thick goosebumps!
Brilliant narrative absolutely brilliant!
March 9, 2021
A new author - great book - lots of twists and turns. Will definitely read the next one! Great narration!
Hoopla audible
Hoopla audible
May 27, 2022
That was actually a really rewarding read. Didn't have a great many expectations going in, I was just in the mood for a regency romp and I got what I wanted.
A disgraced nobleman ends up back at his childhood home and gets reacquainted with an old friend - who happens to be the parish vicar. There's lots of drama in the background and the crux of the novel is a bit too neatly and improbably wrapped up but the romance was great. The first half is a study in UST, and then the second half felt a bit abbreviated for me but I found it really sweet and romantic.
Definitely going to keep an eye on Ms Greene.
A disgraced nobleman ends up back at his childhood home and gets reacquainted with an old friend - who happens to be the parish vicar. There's lots of drama in the background and the crux of the novel is a bit too neatly and improbably wrapped up but the romance was great. The first half is a study in UST, and then the second half felt a bit abbreviated for me but I found it really sweet and romantic.
Definitely going to keep an eye on Ms Greene.
Read
September 30, 2020I think I'm about ready to call it. DNF at 64%. I did not come to the decision to quit this book lightly because it has such potential, but in the end it was too much of a slog. It was riddled with little holes that were really distracting, to the point that I was unable to just suspend my disbelief and just go along for the ride (and I usually go along with some really questionable reads lol). It was especially annoying because these were things that would've been easily fixed with the help of a good editor or beta reader. I was excited about getting to know these characters but sadly there wasn't enough for me to connect to. The premise for the series is a good one and I wish this debut had shown more promise.
October 14, 2020
3.75 stars - Reviewed for
Childhood best friends falling in love is one of my favorite tropes so I was excited to dive into The Vicar and the Rake . Annabelle Greene’s debut shows lots of promise and it was easy for me to fall into Gabriel and Edward’s story.
Edward is a rake whose exploits have gone too far this time and landed him in trouble. The kind of trouble that has even his powerful brother scrambling to protect him. Having no other choice, Edward has to return to his childhood home, a place of nightmares thanks to his abusive father. And who should he find in his flower beds, delirious with fever? His childhood best friend, Sir Gabriel Winters. Gabriel is now a reverend, one working himself nearly to death trying to do as much good as possible in an effort to balance the scales against his hidden desires. Though it’s been years since they last saw each other, the attraction is instantaneous. There’s quite a bit of push-pull in this romance, though fortunately it’s not because either feels shame or denial when it comes to their sexuality. I liked the clash, the passion, and unfettered longing.
A powerful duke determined to kill Edward is only one obstacle in the romance as Edward’s sins come home to roost. Edward plays the careless rake and it’s not entirely a façade, but I loved getting deeper into his character. He’s more intelligent than he lets on and he has much more in him to give than he believes. He’s also deeply scarred and seeking to fill a void, which sometimes leads to destructive behavior. I enjoyed watching him become a better man, one who is the perfect match for Gabriel. Gabriel is kind and understanding, which makes him easy to like. He doesn’t let Edward walk all over him, which I respected. The two of them simply fit, but they’ll definitely need assistance in order to live long enough to get their happily ever after. Their siblings are on-hand to rescue them and I adored them. Gabriel’s sister, Caroline, is a take-charge widow determined to protect her brother’s heart from the man who could easily break it. And Edward’s younger brother, Maurice, is fascinating. The man is a puppet master, holding the strings of many in power by collecting secrets. He and Caroline make a formidable team and I would love to see them get their own book. And it would be remiss of me to write about this book and not mention Buttons, the adorable rescue cat who melts hearts and threatens to steal the show at every turn. Rounding out the story are Edward’s fellow “Beasts,� men who co-founded the Society of Beasts, a London club where gay men can simply be themselves without fear. I leave it to readers to discover the delights Edward’s friends offer, but suffice it to say that I cannot wait to see what Ms. Greene has planned for future books.
As I previously mentioned, Edward’s life is in danger and one plot begets another as a mystery arises. I loved the intrigue but did struggle with The Vicar and the Rake as the puzzle pieces came into play as they didn’t seem to quite fit. There was a plot hole and a few convenient twists of fate that nagged at me after I finished the story. Still, I enjoyed The Vicar and the Rake overall and I’m looking forward to the next Society of Beasts book.
FTC Disclosure: I received this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Childhood best friends falling in love is one of my favorite tropes so I was excited to dive into The Vicar and the Rake . Annabelle Greene’s debut shows lots of promise and it was easy for me to fall into Gabriel and Edward’s story.
Edward is a rake whose exploits have gone too far this time and landed him in trouble. The kind of trouble that has even his powerful brother scrambling to protect him. Having no other choice, Edward has to return to his childhood home, a place of nightmares thanks to his abusive father. And who should he find in his flower beds, delirious with fever? His childhood best friend, Sir Gabriel Winters. Gabriel is now a reverend, one working himself nearly to death trying to do as much good as possible in an effort to balance the scales against his hidden desires. Though it’s been years since they last saw each other, the attraction is instantaneous. There’s quite a bit of push-pull in this romance, though fortunately it’s not because either feels shame or denial when it comes to their sexuality. I liked the clash, the passion, and unfettered longing.
A powerful duke determined to kill Edward is only one obstacle in the romance as Edward’s sins come home to roost. Edward plays the careless rake and it’s not entirely a façade, but I loved getting deeper into his character. He’s more intelligent than he lets on and he has much more in him to give than he believes. He’s also deeply scarred and seeking to fill a void, which sometimes leads to destructive behavior. I enjoyed watching him become a better man, one who is the perfect match for Gabriel. Gabriel is kind and understanding, which makes him easy to like. He doesn’t let Edward walk all over him, which I respected. The two of them simply fit, but they’ll definitely need assistance in order to live long enough to get their happily ever after. Their siblings are on-hand to rescue them and I adored them. Gabriel’s sister, Caroline, is a take-charge widow determined to protect her brother’s heart from the man who could easily break it. And Edward’s younger brother, Maurice, is fascinating. The man is a puppet master, holding the strings of many in power by collecting secrets. He and Caroline make a formidable team and I would love to see them get their own book. And it would be remiss of me to write about this book and not mention Buttons, the adorable rescue cat who melts hearts and threatens to steal the show at every turn. Rounding out the story are Edward’s fellow “Beasts,� men who co-founded the Society of Beasts, a London club where gay men can simply be themselves without fear. I leave it to readers to discover the delights Edward’s friends offer, but suffice it to say that I cannot wait to see what Ms. Greene has planned for future books.
As I previously mentioned, Edward’s life is in danger and one plot begets another as a mystery arises. I loved the intrigue but did struggle with The Vicar and the Rake as the puzzle pieces came into play as they didn’t seem to quite fit. There was a plot hole and a few convenient twists of fate that nagged at me after I finished the story. Still, I enjoyed The Vicar and the Rake overall and I’m looking forward to the next Society of Beasts book.
FTC Disclosure: I received this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 206 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.