What do you think?
Rate this book
Like a Charm #2
Like a Curse
Stuck in Loch Ness while Edinburgh falls under the control of a terrifyingly powerful Siren, Ramya Knox is frustrated. She's supposed to be learning magic from her Aunt Opal, but that isn't going as smoothly as she'd hoped. As she pushes to rescue her Hidden Folk friends in the city, long-buried secrets come to light and legends come to life.
Ramya knows she's different; she knows she's a witch. But now she must learn the true meaning of her powers... before all she loves is lost
Ramya knows she's different; she knows she's a witch. But now she must learn the true meaning of her powers... before all she loves is lost
320 pages, Paperback
First published February 2, 2023
22 people are currently reading
622 people want to read
About the author
Elle McNicoll
20books672followersHey, I'm Elle. I'm Scottish, autistic and an author/screenwriter who is really bad at logging her reading choices.
I write about autistic girls finding out who they are and what makes them happy, because I'm an autistic girl trying to find out who she is and what makes her happy.
I don't read reviews, as they are for readers, but I'm grateful to any and everyone who engages with my work, on the page or on the screen. My Young Adult Romance debut is called Some Like It Cold in it will be published on the 3rd of October. Official professional shiz below:
Elle McNicoll is a bestselling and award-winning novelist and screenwriter. Her debut, A Kind of Spark, won the Blue Peter Book Award and the Overall Waterstones Children’s Book Prize, as well as Blackwell’s Book of 2020. She is a four time Carnegie nominated author, and was shortlisted for the Books Are My Bag Awards 2020, 2021 and 2022, the Branford Boase Award 2020 and The Little Rebels Award 2020 and 2021. She was also honoured in the US with the Schneider Award, 2022.
Her second Middle Grade novel, Show Us Who You Are, was Blackwell’s Book of the Month and one of The Bookseller’s Best Books of 2021. Her first fantasy middle grade, Like a Charm, was nominated for Best Children’s Book for Older Readers in the first ever Week Junior Book Awards, and was highly praised in the New York Times.
Her debut novel, A Kind of Spark, has also been adapted for television, which debuted on UK and US screens on the 2nd of April, 2023. It is Emmy nominated and won Best Children’s Programme at the Broadcast Awards and the Royal Television Society Awards in London, 2024 and is now streaming in many territories around the globe. A second season is currently airing on CBBC.
Her debut Middle Grade was named as one of the greatest children’s books of all time, coming in at number 75, and she is twice nominated for the Astrid Lindgren Memorial Award.
Her YA debut, Some Like It Cold, will be published on October 1st (US) and October 3rd (UK). She is an advocate for better representation of neurodiversity in publishing, as an autistic and dyspraxic novelist, and currently lives in North London.
I write about autistic girls finding out who they are and what makes them happy, because I'm an autistic girl trying to find out who she is and what makes her happy.
I don't read reviews, as they are for readers, but I'm grateful to any and everyone who engages with my work, on the page or on the screen. My Young Adult Romance debut is called Some Like It Cold in it will be published on the 3rd of October. Official professional shiz below:
Elle McNicoll is a bestselling and award-winning novelist and screenwriter. Her debut, A Kind of Spark, won the Blue Peter Book Award and the Overall Waterstones Children’s Book Prize, as well as Blackwell’s Book of 2020. She is a four time Carnegie nominated author, and was shortlisted for the Books Are My Bag Awards 2020, 2021 and 2022, the Branford Boase Award 2020 and The Little Rebels Award 2020 and 2021. She was also honoured in the US with the Schneider Award, 2022.
Her second Middle Grade novel, Show Us Who You Are, was Blackwell’s Book of the Month and one of The Bookseller’s Best Books of 2021. Her first fantasy middle grade, Like a Charm, was nominated for Best Children’s Book for Older Readers in the first ever Week Junior Book Awards, and was highly praised in the New York Times.
Her debut novel, A Kind of Spark, has also been adapted for television, which debuted on UK and US screens on the 2nd of April, 2023. It is Emmy nominated and won Best Children’s Programme at the Broadcast Awards and the Royal Television Society Awards in London, 2024 and is now streaming in many territories around the globe. A second season is currently airing on CBBC.
Her debut Middle Grade was named as one of the greatest children’s books of all time, coming in at number 75, and she is twice nominated for the Astrid Lindgren Memorial Award.
Her YA debut, Some Like It Cold, will be published on October 1st (US) and October 3rd (UK). She is an advocate for better representation of neurodiversity in publishing, as an autistic and dyspraxic novelist, and currently lives in North London.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews
February 21, 2023
Speaking of curses, apparently mine is to never find a sequel that's as good as the first book. Is it my expectations? Am I wishing for too much? All I know is that after 5 starring Like A Charm, I found Ramya in this book extremely selfish, conceited and downright rude to everyone around her, which made her extremely difficult to like.
There wasn't a lot happening in this story, as the location moves from vibrant Edinburgh to dreary Loch Ness, where Ramya spends most her time shut in her family's house, when she's not sneaking out to try and save the world with all the magic she hasn't learnt yet because she can't be bothered to do her lessons and thinks she's too good for them.
I did like the new characters that were introduced, and the backstory we got for Portia and Opal. I was expecting more character development from Marley, who is constantly ordered around by Ramya and doesn't seem to think for himself. Ramya's parents also appear very little in this, I was hoping for more of Ramya's mother's backstory.
My copy was riddled with typos too, which affected my enjoyment. However, this story did deliver a good ending that felt more like the first book, it was just a shame that most of the book spent waiting around for the final battle to happen.
There wasn't a lot happening in this story, as the location moves from vibrant Edinburgh to dreary Loch Ness, where Ramya spends most her time shut in her family's house, when she's not sneaking out to try and save the world with all the magic she hasn't learnt yet because she can't be bothered to do her lessons and thinks she's too good for them.
I did like the new characters that were introduced, and the backstory we got for Portia and Opal. I was expecting more character development from Marley, who is constantly ordered around by Ramya and doesn't seem to think for himself. Ramya's parents also appear very little in this, I was hoping for more of Ramya's mother's backstory.
My copy was riddled with typos too, which affected my enjoyment. However, this story did deliver a good ending that felt more like the first book, it was just a shame that most of the book spent waiting around for the final battle to happen.
February 6, 2023
Ohhhh did I love this book (and the fantasy duology it completes)! By the end of the first book in the series (Like A Charm), prickly, abrasive and proudly neurodivergent Ramya had discovered her true magical powers and the force of her (justified) rage in a world that had tried so hard to shame her for her differences and smother everything about her that was unique. Now, under the tutelage of her aunt Opal (also neurodivergent, and also a witch), she's being challenged to learn how to cope in a new and different way - how to learn the power of emotions other than rage, including the most scarily vulnerable feelings, and how to LET herself learn from an authority figure whose expectations of her are, for once, frighteningly high instead of low.
And just to make it all even more exciting, Ramya's following (really cool) magical leads and fighting magical dangers at a breathtaking pace all the way through!
I absolutely loved this line from midway through the book (with brackets inserted to hide a spoiler-y detail):
"Maybe neurotypical children were made for behaviour charts and school reports and following commands but I'm not. I feel out of place in a classroom. I feel wrongly made whenever I'm stood up next to my peers at Sports Day or Open Day.
"But I feel very at home on this [amazing mythical creature]."
<3 <3 <3
The magical adventure plotline is tense and scary as it zooms back and forth between the beautiful, remote countryside around Loch Ness and the city of Edinburgh (and I loved all the specifics of the different, hidden magical subcultures in each setting), but what made me cry at the end was the power of Ramya's own emotional catharsis. It was so moving, it really blew me away.
I will be re-reading both of these books many times in the future! And I can already tell this will be one of my favorite books in any genre this year.
And just to make it all even more exciting, Ramya's following (really cool) magical leads and fighting magical dangers at a breathtaking pace all the way through!
I absolutely loved this line from midway through the book (with brackets inserted to hide a spoiler-y detail):
"Maybe neurotypical children were made for behaviour charts and school reports and following commands but I'm not. I feel out of place in a classroom. I feel wrongly made whenever I'm stood up next to my peers at Sports Day or Open Day.
"But I feel very at home on this [amazing mythical creature]."
<3 <3 <3
The magical adventure plotline is tense and scary as it zooms back and forth between the beautiful, remote countryside around Loch Ness and the city of Edinburgh (and I loved all the specifics of the different, hidden magical subcultures in each setting), but what made me cry at the end was the power of Ramya's own emotional catharsis. It was so moving, it really blew me away.
I will be re-reading both of these books many times in the future! And I can already tell this will be one of my favorite books in any genre this year.
May 18, 2023
This is a �50% of the plot could have been avoided if anyone had told the main character anything� kind of story, and it just felt like it went round in circles. I still love Ramya, but she spends the entire book doing stupid and impulsive things that were totally unnecessary, and I found myself getting frustrated by the futility of it all.
That said, I still loved how well Elle McNicoll conveys the depth of all Ramya’s emotions, and all the ways she grows and learns over the story! Plus her and Marley’s friendship and the way they balance each other is just everything.
That said, I still loved how well Elle McNicoll conveys the depth of all Ramya’s emotions, and all the ways she grows and learns over the story! Plus her and Marley’s friendship and the way they balance each other is just everything.
April 30, 2023
Witches am I right.
January 7, 2025
This plot could have been avoided if the characters simply talked to each other.
February 12, 2023
Well, that was frigging LOVELY. Like a Charm was my first read from Elle McNicoll, and it was just the cosy read about a Scottish neurodivergent witch that I didn't know my life had been missing. This sequel was so well done, it had all the heart of the first book, and wrapped everything up so well. The last few pages filled my heart to the brim.
March 15, 2024
Finally finished this one! Only took about a year...
Not because the book is bad mind you, it was great! I just forgot I was in the middle of reading it... And once I remembered I finished it within a week!
So yeah, it was good! I almost never see dyspraxia representation in books, so I'm so glad this one had it! As someone who has dyspraxia, I found myself relating to the child MC in this book more than adult MC's in other books. Mostly because of the dyspraxia.
Hopefully some day I can make a whole youtube video about books with dyspraxia representation, but for now this series is the only one on that list.
Thank you so much for the author for writing this wonderful series!
(Sorry if this review sounds a bit weird, I'm in a lot of pain today so I can't really think clearly. I just hope it wasn't too much of a mess to read...)
Not because the book is bad mind you, it was great! I just forgot I was in the middle of reading it... And once I remembered I finished it within a week!
So yeah, it was good! I almost never see dyspraxia representation in books, so I'm so glad this one had it! As someone who has dyspraxia, I found myself relating to the child MC in this book more than adult MC's in other books. Mostly because of the dyspraxia.
Hopefully some day I can make a whole youtube video about books with dyspraxia representation, but for now this series is the only one on that list.
Thank you so much for the author for writing this wonderful series!
(Sorry if this review sounds a bit weird, I'm in a lot of pain today so I can't really think clearly. I just hope it wasn't too much of a mess to read...)
May 1, 2023
4.5 stars
January 20, 2025
The second book in the series does not disappoint! It increases the drama without forgetting that the main characters are children. The story was gripping with some good twists and turns. The character development of everyone was very pleasing!
February 2, 2023
I have been extremely lucky this week to read Like a Curse, the sequel to Like a Charm, and guys, it’s just so good. It is the perfect ending to Ramya’s story with raised stakes, satisfying endings and beautifully written, as ever. Fantasy lovers, make sure it's on your radar.
Talking about the second book in a duology is always tricky because I don’t want to spoil anything from Charm, but Ramya’s journey in this book is so brilliant � balancing power with responsibility, navigating your own ego and determination to help when you're eager.
If you haven’t read the first book Like a Charm, the story follows Ramya a young dyspraxic girl as she tries to complete her grandfather’s wish to document all the Hidden Folk, except in doing so she uncovers the dangers of the Sirens and a lot of family secrets too.
A couple of moments made me cry out, and cry too, as is traditional for a McNicoll novel. There’s brilliant dialogue, furious fights, heartwrenching moments and it all comes together so seamlessly.
I’m so glad to read neurodivergent kids in fantasy stories and Ramya is one of the best; she’s never dulled down or simplified. She just is herself, in all her complicated spiky and brilliant ways.
And all in all it is a McNicoll novel through and through � characters who are complicated and real, high emotional stakes, the absolute best villains and a solid story through and through. I can't wait to yell about it with everyone else.
There is so much I want to talk about but I will be good and quiet and wait for you all to get there too in February *zips mouth closed*
Talking about the second book in a duology is always tricky because I don’t want to spoil anything from Charm, but Ramya’s journey in this book is so brilliant � balancing power with responsibility, navigating your own ego and determination to help when you're eager.
If you haven’t read the first book Like a Charm, the story follows Ramya a young dyspraxic girl as she tries to complete her grandfather’s wish to document all the Hidden Folk, except in doing so she uncovers the dangers of the Sirens and a lot of family secrets too.
A couple of moments made me cry out, and cry too, as is traditional for a McNicoll novel. There’s brilliant dialogue, furious fights, heartwrenching moments and it all comes together so seamlessly.
I’m so glad to read neurodivergent kids in fantasy stories and Ramya is one of the best; she’s never dulled down or simplified. She just is herself, in all her complicated spiky and brilliant ways.
And all in all it is a McNicoll novel through and through � characters who are complicated and real, high emotional stakes, the absolute best villains and a solid story through and through. I can't wait to yell about it with everyone else.
There is so much I want to talk about but I will be good and quiet and wait for you all to get there too in February *zips mouth closed*
February 1, 2023
Can I give this more than five stars?
When I grow up, can I be Aunt Opal? *gulps at the fact I’m probably Aunt Opal’s age*
When I grow up, can I be Aunt Opal? *gulps at the fact I’m probably Aunt Opal’s age*
March 11, 2025
What a great ending to this series. I loved the sequel so much, even though it was a bit weaker than the first one in certain parts of the story.
The book starts with "great evil coming to Edinburgh" and this sets the tone to the whole book. The story is fast paced with exciting adventures, interesting mythological creatures, new friends, old enemies and unbelievable revelations.
What I really enjoyed about the series and this book in particular is that it does not feel like middle grade at all. The fight scenes are epic and there are so many twists and turns that really caught my interest. In the middle of the book, however, I disliked some of Ramya's actions and decisions. While her being dyspraxic serves as a superpower in the debut novel, it kind of frustrated me how she turned out in the sequel thinking that the world owes her something and that she is destined for greatness. While she definitely is more than meets the eye, she became a bit too self-absorbed in my opinion, causing a lot of trouble and harm to other people. However, the ending definitely made up for that.
I highly recommend this series if you like mythology, witches and just great literature for kids, teenagers and those young at heart!
The book starts with "great evil coming to Edinburgh" and this sets the tone to the whole book. The story is fast paced with exciting adventures, interesting mythological creatures, new friends, old enemies and unbelievable revelations.
What I really enjoyed about the series and this book in particular is that it does not feel like middle grade at all. The fight scenes are epic and there are so many twists and turns that really caught my interest. In the middle of the book, however, I disliked some of Ramya's actions and decisions. While her being dyspraxic serves as a superpower in the debut novel, it kind of frustrated me how she turned out in the sequel thinking that the world owes her something and that she is destined for greatness. While she definitely is more than meets the eye, she became a bit too self-absorbed in my opinion, causing a lot of trouble and harm to other people. However, the ending definitely made up for that.
I highly recommend this series if you like mythology, witches and just great literature for kids, teenagers and those young at heart!
March 7, 2023
Paperback edition
by T Lander
“Amazing sequel, read them both, they're beautiful�
I read Like A Charm - the first in this duo - last summer. And I was spellbound throughout so this was ordered to arrive as soon as possible on publishing!
And Ramya is back.
This story follows on immediately after Like A Charm.
Ramya, her mum and Opal are staying with her Gran in Loch Ness, while Ramya is learning how to control her new found powers, something that isn't made easy by her dyspraxia. But they aren't alone for long, because although Marley is due to be in a concert in Edinburgh, his performance is interrupted by the arrival of Portia. Edinburgh falls under her siren spell, and the hidden folk go into hiding.
Ramya wants to help her friends, but is frustrated by her family telling her she can't interfere. It transpires that one of her magical friends hasn't been telling her everything either.
Ramya and Marley, who is happy to go with her, find more hidden creatures in her efforts to help, one is particularly spectacular. She visits Edinburgh to try to help with differing results. She finds out just how important, and special, her friends and family are. And that they are there to help not hinder her attempts.
But does Opal have secrets? And what about Portia, what is driving her desire for power?
This is a fabulous sequel from Elle McNicoll, I only wish this wasn't the end of Ramya's story. Elle ties up some loose ends, we meet more magical creatures (Ramya gets to write them into Grandpa's book) and, of course, there are the characters we already know. Absolutely love it.
Please don't read this without reading Like A Charm first, as that explains the first part of Ramya's story.
I really need to read A Kind of Spark, which we have at school but I haven't got to yet! (dreadful i know)
by T Lander
“Amazing sequel, read them both, they're beautiful�
I read Like A Charm - the first in this duo - last summer. And I was spellbound throughout so this was ordered to arrive as soon as possible on publishing!
And Ramya is back.
This story follows on immediately after Like A Charm.
Ramya, her mum and Opal are staying with her Gran in Loch Ness, while Ramya is learning how to control her new found powers, something that isn't made easy by her dyspraxia. But they aren't alone for long, because although Marley is due to be in a concert in Edinburgh, his performance is interrupted by the arrival of Portia. Edinburgh falls under her siren spell, and the hidden folk go into hiding.
Ramya wants to help her friends, but is frustrated by her family telling her she can't interfere. It transpires that one of her magical friends hasn't been telling her everything either.
Ramya and Marley, who is happy to go with her, find more hidden creatures in her efforts to help, one is particularly spectacular. She visits Edinburgh to try to help with differing results. She finds out just how important, and special, her friends and family are. And that they are there to help not hinder her attempts.
But does Opal have secrets? And what about Portia, what is driving her desire for power?
This is a fabulous sequel from Elle McNicoll, I only wish this wasn't the end of Ramya's story. Elle ties up some loose ends, we meet more magical creatures (Ramya gets to write them into Grandpa's book) and, of course, there are the characters we already know. Absolutely love it.
Please don't read this without reading Like A Charm first, as that explains the first part of Ramya's story.
I really need to read A Kind of Spark, which we have at school but I haven't got to yet! (dreadful i know)
March 5, 2023
Nice to spend time with Ramya and co again. Old familiar characters and a variety of new ones.
Family secrets are revealed.
Ramya spends a lot of time not practising her skills or doing what the adults want her to do. Of course she then had to face the repercussions.
Enjoyable but not as much as the first. Too much faffing about in the middle.
Family secrets are revealed.
Ramya spends a lot of time not practising her skills or doing what the adults want her to do. Of course she then had to face the repercussions.
Enjoyable but not as much as the first. Too much faffing about in the middle.
January 18, 2024
I have enjoyed all the books by Elle McNicoll I have read. I prefer her earlier releases over the Like a Charm duology. The duology is a great middle grade read for lovers of witches and mythology.
I also loved how unapologetic Ramiya was.
I also loved how unapologetic Ramiya was.
December 4, 2024
Is this the end of the series? Because if so, oof. Just an unsatisfying all around. Especially disappointing is the relationship with her parents isn't really addressed.
(Now, if this is just the second in a series, than it's a 3 star review.)
(Now, if this is just the second in a series, than it's a 3 star review.)
February 7, 2023
Ramya knows she is a witch and is still learning how to do magic at Grans house with Aunt Opal at Loch Ness. But, arch enemy Portia arrives and takes the city by storm. Marley, Aunt Leanna and Mum Cassandra are sent to the Loch Ness, but Mum and Gran leave in the first night if their arrival.
But, when Marley and Ramya meet Alona the Dryad on their first, sneaking-out-of-the-house-at-night missions, they find out that there are more Hidden Folk at the Loch Ness then Ramya thought, everything changes�
A beautifully written book about a Dyspraxic and her adventure through the Magical world of Hidden Folk.
But, when Marley and Ramya meet Alona the Dryad on their first, sneaking-out-of-the-house-at-night missions, they find out that there are more Hidden Folk at the Loch Ness then Ramya thought, everything changes�
A beautifully written book about a Dyspraxic and her adventure through the Magical world of Hidden Folk.
January 30, 2023
A great story for ages 10+ featuring a neurodiverse protagonist with magical powers who must save her friends and family from a spreading evil.
January 1, 2024
Ramya and her magical family are holed up together in Loch Ness. Having fled from their Edinburgh home in fear for their lives, they are determined to defeat the siren who is torturing their friends and terrorising the local residents. Ramya might be new to magic and magical creatures but she is determined to play her part in the upcoming battle. The thing is there are so many secrets beneath this war - So many hidden stories and twists and turns. Will Ramya’s impatience and impulsivity help or hinder?
This is an amazing YA book with the theme of difference and forgiveness. It has some amazing words for kids dealing with grief and loss, for those feeling like they aren’t enough and some seriously healing passages for those of us who grew up othered and misunderstood.
Love this author! Love this message! Love the inclusion of ND characters as leads! Love the inclusion of imperfect adults and adults who say sorry! @ellemcnicollofficial - healing my inner child, one book at a time. ♥️
April 26, 2023
this wasn’t my favourite book but it was still really good! i loved the creativity of the different characters and finding out more about what was happening. my favourite character is Ramya bcs i like the way she is proud of her differences!
November 14, 2024
What worked:
Ramya is a witch-in-training who is trying to unlock her magical abilities. One thing she can do that others cannot is to see through Glamours that camouflage Hidden Folk. She can spot every troll, vampire, or fae she encounters and she’s immune to the hypnotic songs of the sirens. She also has a special connection to water which comes in handy around Loch Ness. Ramya is neurodivergent so her approaches to interacting with others and reacting in sticky situations lack the tactfulness and nuances that may be “normal�. She tends to be impulsive and blunt. The author is also neurodivergent so she can provide insight into Ramya’s ways of speaking and behaving.
I haven’t read the previous book in the series but apparently, Ramya previously defeated a siren named Portia. Portia is back again as the protagonist and she controls the minds of humans in Edinburgh and rounding up Hidden Folk. The conflict centers on Portia’s search for a creature hiding in the depths of Loch Ness that isn’t Nessie. No one knows what the beast might be and many doubt it exists. Coincidentally, or not, Ramya is hiding behind a powerful Glamour near Loch Ness with her aunts and cousin. She’s frustrated and angry that her parents are in Edinburgh and no one will let her help confront Portia.
The cast of minor characters offers an unusual variety of personalities to assist Ramya. Her cousin Marley is human and doesn’t have any special abilities other than his loyalty and faith in her. He believes Ramya whenever she sees things he cannot and he willingly goes along with her rash decisions. They meet a dryad named Alona and are shocked that she can’t transform into a huge oak tree or a single, small leaf. Ramya has a good friend named Freddy who happens to be a siren. Marley questions their relationship since sirens are the bad guys in this book. Ramya learns a stunning truth about Freddy later in the book that should make her suspicious.
What didn’t work as well:
Ramya isn’t close to mastering her powers yet but she’s determined to stop Portia on her own. Her Aunt Opal is the most formidable witch Ramya knows and even Opal knows it’s fool-hardy to face the powerful siren. Ramya’s inner instincts usually come to the rescue when her life is in danger so it often feels like she gets lucky.
The final verdict:
I’m sure the first book has an exciting adventure of its own but this book can be read independently. Ramya may be rash and reckless but she has strong, unwavering feelings for family and friends. Loch Ness holds unexpected surprises and twists for the plot and the climax leaves readers wondering about Portia’s future. Overall, I recommend you give this book a shot.
Ramya is a witch-in-training who is trying to unlock her magical abilities. One thing she can do that others cannot is to see through Glamours that camouflage Hidden Folk. She can spot every troll, vampire, or fae she encounters and she’s immune to the hypnotic songs of the sirens. She also has a special connection to water which comes in handy around Loch Ness. Ramya is neurodivergent so her approaches to interacting with others and reacting in sticky situations lack the tactfulness and nuances that may be “normal�. She tends to be impulsive and blunt. The author is also neurodivergent so she can provide insight into Ramya’s ways of speaking and behaving.
I haven’t read the previous book in the series but apparently, Ramya previously defeated a siren named Portia. Portia is back again as the protagonist and she controls the minds of humans in Edinburgh and rounding up Hidden Folk. The conflict centers on Portia’s search for a creature hiding in the depths of Loch Ness that isn’t Nessie. No one knows what the beast might be and many doubt it exists. Coincidentally, or not, Ramya is hiding behind a powerful Glamour near Loch Ness with her aunts and cousin. She’s frustrated and angry that her parents are in Edinburgh and no one will let her help confront Portia.
The cast of minor characters offers an unusual variety of personalities to assist Ramya. Her cousin Marley is human and doesn’t have any special abilities other than his loyalty and faith in her. He believes Ramya whenever she sees things he cannot and he willingly goes along with her rash decisions. They meet a dryad named Alona and are shocked that she can’t transform into a huge oak tree or a single, small leaf. Ramya has a good friend named Freddy who happens to be a siren. Marley questions their relationship since sirens are the bad guys in this book. Ramya learns a stunning truth about Freddy later in the book that should make her suspicious.
What didn’t work as well:
Ramya isn’t close to mastering her powers yet but she’s determined to stop Portia on her own. Her Aunt Opal is the most formidable witch Ramya knows and even Opal knows it’s fool-hardy to face the powerful siren. Ramya’s inner instincts usually come to the rescue when her life is in danger so it often feels like she gets lucky.
The final verdict:
I’m sure the first book has an exciting adventure of its own but this book can be read independently. Ramya may be rash and reckless but she has strong, unwavering feelings for family and friends. Loch Ness holds unexpected surprises and twists for the plot and the climax leaves readers wondering about Portia’s future. Overall, I recommend you give this book a shot.
January 2, 2025
I found the ending highly satisfying. The fact they finally put an end to Portia's reign and we know what The Stranger's magic is, and most questions were answered. I don't think it needs 3rd book, because the main tensions were resolved, and hopefully now because Portias stopped, the hidden creatures will be able to live their lives now, if other sirens stop.
I really like the main character Ramya. In this story and the 1st book, we are in the point of view of Ramya a (now) 13 year old that's just learned she has the power to see hidden folk, and other powers because she's a witch, that can control water. I can see why some people may find her irritating and not like the book, even a lot of the people she interacts with find her irritating. But I love reading books where the character is complex and 3- dimensional. One's who don't want to sit back and let the 'grown ups' deal with everything because its not a place of a child's. Which is what Ramya does. She constantly disobeys her family's orders, and sneaks out of the house to ride a dragon to Edinburgh, because she wants to help people. She may come off as rude, selfish and annoying, but I think her character would be pretty accurate if a 13 year old actually found out she was a witch. She's flaunting that she's a witch, when she doesn't want to practise it, but who wouldnt? What 13 year old would want to study books about magic when they have to power to make it rain inside??? I don't think she's annoying, I think she's a child with super cool powers and wants to use them to help people. Help the hidden folk who are being constantly scrutinised by sirens, specifically Potia. Her family are constantly hiding things from her, and she wants the answers, and the only way to find them is by sneaking out and finding them by herself.
She's angry. When she's up against a powerful hidden folk, like the Druid, who is attacking her, she's angry. She acts in a non rational way and makes mistakes and puts everyone in danger. But it's only because she wants to save everyone, she wanted to save Murrey, and Alona and all the hidden folk trapped in Portia's dungeon.
I loved her character, and I loved the storyline. Ramya is complex but thats what makes it good, if she wasn't it would just be boring. Like serously, imagine if she didn't sneak out, there would be no plot! I also adored blue :3. Cutie patoodie.
I've rated it the same as the 1st book, because I equally like them both.
I really like the main character Ramya. In this story and the 1st book, we are in the point of view of Ramya a (now) 13 year old that's just learned she has the power to see hidden folk, and other powers because she's a witch, that can control water. I can see why some people may find her irritating and not like the book, even a lot of the people she interacts with find her irritating. But I love reading books where the character is complex and 3- dimensional. One's who don't want to sit back and let the 'grown ups' deal with everything because its not a place of a child's. Which is what Ramya does. She constantly disobeys her family's orders, and sneaks out of the house to ride a dragon to Edinburgh, because she wants to help people. She may come off as rude, selfish and annoying, but I think her character would be pretty accurate if a 13 year old actually found out she was a witch. She's flaunting that she's a witch, when she doesn't want to practise it, but who wouldnt? What 13 year old would want to study books about magic when they have to power to make it rain inside??? I don't think she's annoying, I think she's a child with super cool powers and wants to use them to help people. Help the hidden folk who are being constantly scrutinised by sirens, specifically Potia. Her family are constantly hiding things from her, and she wants the answers, and the only way to find them is by sneaking out and finding them by herself.
She's angry. When she's up against a powerful hidden folk, like the Druid, who is attacking her, she's angry. She acts in a non rational way and makes mistakes and puts everyone in danger. But it's only because she wants to save everyone, she wanted to save Murrey, and Alona and all the hidden folk trapped in Portia's dungeon.
I loved her character, and I loved the storyline. Ramya is complex but thats what makes it good, if she wasn't it would just be boring. Like serously, imagine if she didn't sneak out, there would be no plot! I also adored blue :3. Cutie patoodie.
I've rated it the same as the 1st book, because I equally like them both.
May 28, 2024
I had heard from friends that this book is more frustrating than book 1 because a lot of it is Ramya making terrible choices because no one will explain anything to her - and I definitely agree!!
I didn't enjoy this as much as the first one, and that was a big part of the reason. Equally annoying was that even though the adults get plenty of the blame here too, Ramya also really frustrated me! In my opinion she went way beyond the limits of 'this is understandable that she's making so many terrible decisions because she doesn't have enough information'. She is constantly doing things that put the lives of others at risk, and then is horrified when it has serious consequences - but then she immediately keeps doing it??
I probably sound overly harsh since she is after all a kid, and she is under a lot of pressure. It just bothers me so much when main characters of any age have Big Realizations that everyone else has literally been telling them the whole time...but misses being able to do something desperately important with that obvious realization by a few seconds
And part of my frustration could also be due to some of the writing choices. I loved McNicoll's writing in all 3 of her other books I've read, but this one felt more disjointed to me. Plot points would come up in the strangest ways, characters would make choices seemingly out of nowhere, significant things would happen and either would be brushed off or have wild assumptions made about them...
I sound like I really didn't like this book, lol. But I genuinely did still enjoy lots of things about it! I just love Elle McNicoll so much that this one felt like a let-down.
But on the more positive side: I like that Ramya is more self-aware by the end of the book and is recognizing that, even though she truly does get awful treatment from some people, she's been using that as an excuse to treat others badly / think only about herself.
I really love some of the side characters (Marley!! my sweet boy 🥹. I love his and Ramya's friendship so much), and I continue to like the mixing of fantasy with contemporary.
So I'm definitely still a huge fan of McNicoll's work - this one was just a bit more of a miss for me.
CW: Grief, ableism, kidnapping, anxiety
I didn't enjoy this as much as the first one, and that was a big part of the reason. Equally annoying was that even though the adults get plenty of the blame here too, Ramya also really frustrated me! In my opinion she went way beyond the limits of 'this is understandable that she's making so many terrible decisions because she doesn't have enough information'. She is constantly doing things that put the lives of others at risk, and then is horrified when it has serious consequences - but then she immediately keeps doing it??
I probably sound overly harsh since she is after all a kid, and she is under a lot of pressure. It just bothers me so much when main characters of any age have Big Realizations that everyone else has literally been telling them the whole time...but misses being able to do something desperately important with that obvious realization by a few seconds
And part of my frustration could also be due to some of the writing choices. I loved McNicoll's writing in all 3 of her other books I've read, but this one felt more disjointed to me. Plot points would come up in the strangest ways, characters would make choices seemingly out of nowhere, significant things would happen and either would be brushed off or have wild assumptions made about them...
I sound like I really didn't like this book, lol. But I genuinely did still enjoy lots of things about it! I just love Elle McNicoll so much that this one felt like a let-down.
But on the more positive side: I like that Ramya is more self-aware by the end of the book and is recognizing that, even though she truly does get awful treatment from some people, she's been using that as an excuse to treat others badly / think only about herself.
I really love some of the side characters (Marley!! my sweet boy 🥹. I love his and Ramya's friendship so much), and I continue to like the mixing of fantasy with contemporary.
So I'm definitely still a huge fan of McNicoll's work - this one was just a bit more of a miss for me.
CW: Grief, ableism, kidnapping, anxiety
April 11, 2025
Humans, Witches, Fae, Sirens, oh my!
Like a Curse by Elle McNicoll is the second book in the Like a Charm Series and a nice blend of teens knowing what’s best and totally getting themselves into trouble.
Even though it’s the second book in the series, it provides a decent amount of exposition from the first to figure out what’s going on. It definitely seems like it would be much better starting with the first book so everything makes sense, so start with the first if you haven’t read it yet!
I really like that there’s different types of gifts amongst the magical creatures and witches. But the sirens take things to another level. It’s fun to see sirens not only affecting humans but other magical creatures too.
It’s also really cool to see how the well known lore gets intertwined with the story. Between the Loch Ness monster and Scotland as a whole, it pulls you in.
I really love that there’s a gifted war. Not only is it a situation between magic and humans but also magic and other magical creatures. That in itself takes things to another level. The fact that Ramya has a special gift that allows her to not be bothered by the curses that others succumb to, yet she has to be hidden away. It’s also cool that she can also see things others cannot.
If you’re into a world of magic, magical creatures, a fight between humans and magical creatures and other magical creatures, and teens/tweens saving the day, this is for you! Highly recommended for kids 9-12 or older. Yup, that’s you adults who love middle grade!
Other books by Elle: A Kind of Spark, Show Is Who You Are, Like a Charm
*This was an honest review for a complimentary copy of Like a Curse from Elle McNicoll via NetGalley
Like a Curse by Elle McNicoll is the second book in the Like a Charm Series and a nice blend of teens knowing what’s best and totally getting themselves into trouble.
Even though it’s the second book in the series, it provides a decent amount of exposition from the first to figure out what’s going on. It definitely seems like it would be much better starting with the first book so everything makes sense, so start with the first if you haven’t read it yet!
I really like that there’s different types of gifts amongst the magical creatures and witches. But the sirens take things to another level. It’s fun to see sirens not only affecting humans but other magical creatures too.
It’s also really cool to see how the well known lore gets intertwined with the story. Between the Loch Ness monster and Scotland as a whole, it pulls you in.
I really love that there’s a gifted war. Not only is it a situation between magic and humans but also magic and other magical creatures. That in itself takes things to another level. The fact that Ramya has a special gift that allows her to not be bothered by the curses that others succumb to, yet she has to be hidden away. It’s also cool that she can also see things others cannot.
If you’re into a world of magic, magical creatures, a fight between humans and magical creatures and other magical creatures, and teens/tweens saving the day, this is for you! Highly recommended for kids 9-12 or older. Yup, that’s you adults who love middle grade!
Other books by Elle: A Kind of Spark, Show Is Who You Are, Like a Charm
*This was an honest review for a complimentary copy of Like a Curse from Elle McNicoll via NetGalley
April 7, 2023
What can I say apart from that Elle McNicoll is a magical writer and Like a Curse is no different. This is a sequel to Like a Charm and it’s such an amazing sequel and is the perfect ending to Rama’s storyline and this one is even more high tense, high stakes but has such a magical ending that this book deserves to on your TBR.
Talking about the second book in a duology is always tricky because I don’t want to spoil anything from Charm and this book continues the events from book one. Ramya’s journey in this book is so brilliant, she is balancing power with responsibility, navigating your own eagerness to prove who you are, and it’s been amazing to see Ramys grow up and learn her skills.
If you are reading this and want to start this Series, like a Charm follows Ramya a young dyspraxic girl as she tries to complete her grandfather’s wish to document all the Hidden Folk, except in doing so she uncovers the dangers of the Sirens and a lot of family secrets too.
It’s Awesome to read about neurodivergent kids in fantasy stories & the representation in all these books are amazing and I think that comes from her own experience coming through the pages. Ramya is one of the best; she’s never dulled down or simplified. She just is herself, in all her complicated spiky and brilliant ways.
And all in all, it is a McNicoll novel through and through � characters who are complicated and real, high emotional stakes, the absolute best villains, and a solid story through and through. I can't wait to yell about it with everyone else.
Overall, a Book that if you Loved Like a Charm you need to have this one on your TBR!
Talking about the second book in a duology is always tricky because I don’t want to spoil anything from Charm and this book continues the events from book one. Ramya’s journey in this book is so brilliant, she is balancing power with responsibility, navigating your own eagerness to prove who you are, and it’s been amazing to see Ramys grow up and learn her skills.
If you are reading this and want to start this Series, like a Charm follows Ramya a young dyspraxic girl as she tries to complete her grandfather’s wish to document all the Hidden Folk, except in doing so she uncovers the dangers of the Sirens and a lot of family secrets too.
It’s Awesome to read about neurodivergent kids in fantasy stories & the representation in all these books are amazing and I think that comes from her own experience coming through the pages. Ramya is one of the best; she’s never dulled down or simplified. She just is herself, in all her complicated spiky and brilliant ways.
And all in all, it is a McNicoll novel through and through � characters who are complicated and real, high emotional stakes, the absolute best villains, and a solid story through and through. I can't wait to yell about it with everyone else.
Overall, a Book that if you Loved Like a Charm you need to have this one on your TBR!
May 31, 2024
Amazing!
This will be my review for both books in the duology.
There was so much I loved about these books ** possible spoilers**:
- Ramya’s powers didn’t erase her struggles with dyspraxia. There are more and more fantasy books embracing this idea that a person can be disabled or chronically ill and still be worthwhile and heroic and I absolutely LOVE it! People don’t always need or want to be fixed.
- The problems and challenges education system present for kids with hidden disabilities. Even though Ramya asks for a computer the school insists that she attend workshops to improve her handwriting and penmanship. If you think about this, it’s just so ridiculous. No one would deny someone who needs glasses access to them, yet people with hidden disabilities are forced to do things they way abled people do them all the time, instead of getting the acknowledgement and support to do them in a way that works for us.
- The conflict in between Opal, who is autistic and Ramya, who is dyspraxic, is realistic and relatable. Just because two people are both neurodivergent doesn’t mean they magically connect and never disagree. Relationships, even between people who love each other dearly, require effort, compassion and kindness, and conflict will always exist. I was glad to see that explored in the story.
- The acknowledgement of Marley’s anxiety and his inherent courage for living with it every day in the second book was incredibly heartwarming and validating.
- How the idea of the chosen one is addressed and resolved.
- Portia’s backstory and eventual ending.
- Ramya learning first to trust herself, then to trust others and finally, that hate is never a solution, even for those who have hurt you terribly.
- Blue. Just because.
- The similarities between the glamour the Hidden Folk use and neurodivergent masking.
- The Ripple as a sort of allegory for masking and following along just to fit in.
- The different kinds of Hidden Folk.
- The writing, which is excellent.
One or two minor niggles:
- The pacing in the second book is slow, but I think it was necessary to set things up so that all the loose ends could be resolved.
- Ramya’s relationship with her parents improves a great deal, but some issues still felt sort of unresolved? But perhaps that is because in real life these things don’t resolve perfectly either.
This will be my review for both books in the duology.
There was so much I loved about these books ** possible spoilers**:
- Ramya’s powers didn’t erase her struggles with dyspraxia. There are more and more fantasy books embracing this idea that a person can be disabled or chronically ill and still be worthwhile and heroic and I absolutely LOVE it! People don’t always need or want to be fixed.
- The problems and challenges education system present for kids with hidden disabilities. Even though Ramya asks for a computer the school insists that she attend workshops to improve her handwriting and penmanship. If you think about this, it’s just so ridiculous. No one would deny someone who needs glasses access to them, yet people with hidden disabilities are forced to do things they way abled people do them all the time, instead of getting the acknowledgement and support to do them in a way that works for us.
- The conflict in between Opal, who is autistic and Ramya, who is dyspraxic, is realistic and relatable. Just because two people are both neurodivergent doesn’t mean they magically connect and never disagree. Relationships, even between people who love each other dearly, require effort, compassion and kindness, and conflict will always exist. I was glad to see that explored in the story.
- The acknowledgement of Marley’s anxiety and his inherent courage for living with it every day in the second book was incredibly heartwarming and validating.
- How the idea of the chosen one is addressed and resolved.
- Portia’s backstory and eventual ending.
- Ramya learning first to trust herself, then to trust others and finally, that hate is never a solution, even for those who have hurt you terribly.
- Blue. Just because.
- The similarities between the glamour the Hidden Folk use and neurodivergent masking.
- The Ripple as a sort of allegory for masking and following along just to fit in.
- The different kinds of Hidden Folk.
- The writing, which is excellent.
One or two minor niggles:
- The pacing in the second book is slow, but I think it was necessary to set things up so that all the loose ends could be resolved.
- Ramya’s relationship with her parents improves a great deal, but some issues still felt sort of unresolved? But perhaps that is because in real life these things don’t resolve perfectly either.
July 25, 2024
LIKE A CURSE completes this duology with action, magic, and heart.
This book continues 's modern take on magical creatures. Set in the Scottish Highlands lets the story introduce more nature-based creatures. I particularly enjoyed the book's take on the Loch Ness monster (not at all what I'd expected) and also has some creepy additions like the Ceasg and the Ripple.
Despite Ramya and Murrey being in the Highlands, the book finds a very fun way to stay in contact with what's happening in Edinburgh with Portia. Having spent so much time there last book, it was so nice to revisit old places and characters. Freddy really gets a chance to shine this time.
I really liked that, while Ramya is central to the big confrontation, the adults do have a plan are are instrumental in saving the day. They are not the useless, "must be worked around" adults so often seen in fiction, though Ramya feels this way for a lot of the book. They've actually been putting together a plan and gathering allies, rather than impulsively running into things, like Ramya does. I really like seeing responsible adult and communities coming together in fiction.
The conclusion was very satisfying, letting a villain be taken down without killing them. The big showdown lets the community come together and stand up for one another against Portia's divisions.
This book continues 's modern take on magical creatures. Set in the Scottish Highlands lets the story introduce more nature-based creatures. I particularly enjoyed the book's take on the Loch Ness monster (not at all what I'd expected) and also has some creepy additions like the Ceasg and the Ripple.
Despite Ramya and Murrey being in the Highlands, the book finds a very fun way to stay in contact with what's happening in Edinburgh with Portia. Having spent so much time there last book, it was so nice to revisit old places and characters. Freddy really gets a chance to shine this time.
I really liked that, while Ramya is central to the big confrontation, the adults do have a plan are are instrumental in saving the day. They are not the useless, "must be worked around" adults so often seen in fiction, though Ramya feels this way for a lot of the book. They've actually been putting together a plan and gathering allies, rather than impulsively running into things, like Ramya does. I really like seeing responsible adult and communities coming together in fiction.
The conclusion was very satisfying, letting a villain be taken down without killing them. The big showdown lets the community come together and stand up for one another against Portia's divisions.
November 15, 2023
Ramya is in Loch Ness with her aunts to focus on her magic, but can’t resist sneaking out with her cousin Marley. She discovers more than she expected, as enemies from the first book are very much still around.
It’s really important to address that I am absolutely not the target audience for this story, though I did really enjoy the first one.
I don’t feel this story added anything to the first one that was needed. Ramya was so whiney and anti basically everyone else for the majority of the book and whilst this is addressed at the end it made for a really unlikeable story for me. I read the first one physically but listened to this one on audio which I think only heightened this. Whilst I think this book is a useful exploration of dyspraxia and how learning difficulties etc are handled in mainstream schooling, this book went too far the other way in insulting everyone else to a point I just felt uncomfortable.
I just unfortunately wasn’t interested in what happened and considered DNFing a number of times. I really hope the intended age group enjoy this more than me, and I’d still really recommend the first book!
It’s really important to address that I am absolutely not the target audience for this story, though I did really enjoy the first one.
I don’t feel this story added anything to the first one that was needed. Ramya was so whiney and anti basically everyone else for the majority of the book and whilst this is addressed at the end it made for a really unlikeable story for me. I read the first one physically but listened to this one on audio which I think only heightened this. Whilst I think this book is a useful exploration of dyspraxia and how learning difficulties etc are handled in mainstream schooling, this book went too far the other way in insulting everyone else to a point I just felt uncomfortable.
I just unfortunately wasn’t interested in what happened and considered DNFing a number of times. I really hope the intended age group enjoy this more than me, and I’d still really recommend the first book!
October 13, 2024
I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley and am voluntarily posting a review. All opinions are my own.
Like a Curse is a charming sequel to Like a Charm, and while I didn’t enjoy it quite as much as its predecessor, I still found a lot to love here.
Once again, the book has a lot of whimsy in the world building, and I love how it lightly interweaves magic into Scotland, while building on its lore, especially with it set against the backdrop of the Loch Ness this time around.
Ramya is a believable protagonist, if rather flawed. Her neurodivergence and how she sees the world differently are centered in her experiences, and while she’s always well-intentioned and fairly easy to root for, she makes a lot of mistakes.
Plot wise, I found it a bit weaker than the prior book, and parts definitely dragged at times. But this was also countered by short, concise chapters that mostly kept me engaged in the story and aided in amping up the tension of the rising conflict.
Minor quibbles aside, this was an enjoyable follow-up, and I’d recommend both Like a Charm and Like a Curse (read in order) to readers seeking a fun, light middle grade witchy fantasy.
Like a Curse is a charming sequel to Like a Charm, and while I didn’t enjoy it quite as much as its predecessor, I still found a lot to love here.
Once again, the book has a lot of whimsy in the world building, and I love how it lightly interweaves magic into Scotland, while building on its lore, especially with it set against the backdrop of the Loch Ness this time around.
Ramya is a believable protagonist, if rather flawed. Her neurodivergence and how she sees the world differently are centered in her experiences, and while she’s always well-intentioned and fairly easy to root for, she makes a lot of mistakes.
Plot wise, I found it a bit weaker than the prior book, and parts definitely dragged at times. But this was also countered by short, concise chapters that mostly kept me engaged in the story and aided in amping up the tension of the rising conflict.
Minor quibbles aside, this was an enjoyable follow-up, and I’d recommend both Like a Charm and Like a Curse (read in order) to readers seeking a fun, light middle grade witchy fantasy.
May 25, 2023
Another absolutely stunning book from Elle!! Just as with Like a Charm, I was completely and utterly immersed the magic and the wonder of the world that she created, and her descriptions are so wonderful and vibrant, that I have absolutely no problem in seeing exactly what’s happening in my mind while I’m reading - almost like I’m watching it as it unfolds.
The characters are still just as wonderful as before, although there was the classic ‘we adults should definitely have told you kids more so that you wouldn’t rush off, putting yourself in danger and basically ruining the whole cause that we’re fighting for/against� trope. But it was explained with kindness and love at the end, and so I can forgive it. (Forgiveness is after all, key).
I did feel like a few aspects and plot points were maybe a little rushed, and sometimes I got slightly lost in the writing - but that may just have been my haste to find out what happened that I accidentally skipped things! Other than that, an absolutely fabulous read and I am very excited to now read Show Us Who You Are!!
The characters are still just as wonderful as before, although there was the classic ‘we adults should definitely have told you kids more so that you wouldn’t rush off, putting yourself in danger and basically ruining the whole cause that we’re fighting for/against� trope. But it was explained with kindness and love at the end, and so I can forgive it. (Forgiveness is after all, key).
I did feel like a few aspects and plot points were maybe a little rushed, and sometimes I got slightly lost in the writing - but that may just have been my haste to find out what happened that I accidentally skipped things! Other than that, an absolutely fabulous read and I am very excited to now read Show Us Who You Are!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get help and learn more about the design.