English Mysteries Club discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Book of the Month pre-2020
>
November 2012
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Poornima
(new)
Sep 25, 2012 12:09AM

reply
|
flag

Since this is book #4 in a series, will it matter if you haven't read the previous three? I've been meaning to read the Dalgliesh books for ages but haven't got to them yet. Sigh.

@Jemidar I've never read the Dalgliesh books in order and I don't find it bothers me much. Each mystery is so nicely self-contained. I love the way James focuses on a small community or gathering with its own rules.

Otherwise, I'm happy to go along with whatever's chosen; I just read all the Teys so I could discuss without having to reread, and it's been a long time since I've read Richard Jury - the only reason I wouldn't want to is I know I would end up reading the whole series over, and I don't think I want to right now. I never did get into Dalgliesh for some reason, and I've never read George, so I'm game.

Thanks Jane. Sometimes it matters and sometimes it doesn't, although I tend to be a bit anal about reading things in order so fingers crossed I can cope. LOL.

I almost nominated that one instead of A Great Deliverance as it's also sitting here on my Mt TBR glaring at me. I think I've had the Elizabeth George one longer though. The Tey would also be good :-).



I'm not enthusiastic about "St Zita." Rendell's Wexford novels are marvelous, but her non-Wexford books are mostly just creepy (IMO). Does someone know whether "St Zita" is an exception? I haven't read it.
I agree that "Before the Poison" by Robinson is highly worth reading, but I like his Banks novels better.
Mostly, I am thrilled that we are considering some "new school" English mysteries (in the terminology of the group's home page).

It's one of the few series you don't have to read in order.



The problem with brand new books is that they are expensive to get with no paperbacks available and
have long waiting lists at the libraries. Just my opinion. I love Ruth Rendell.

I agree Joan. I really enjoyed the Wexfords, but Rendell's more "psychological" tales are not to my taste. Any of the other suggestions sound good to me.



Thanks Jean-Luke! :)

I agree!


Have you read it yet? I am curious about it.

Hav..."
Tom,extremely sorry for the late late reply. Its festival season here in my country and I got caught up in it. By this time you may have already read it.The story starts a tad slowly,but in classic Rendell style all the characters, the situation are etched in carefully.I liked it very much.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Daughter of Time (other topics)The St. Zita Society (other topics)
Before the Poison (other topics)
Cut to the Quick (other topics)
The Old Contemptibles (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Ruth Rendell (other topics)Kate Ross (other topics)