THE WORLD WAR TWO GROUP discussion
BOOK DISCUSSIONS
>
Favorite Passages from any WW2 Book

From diary of Count Galeazzo Ciano, son-ln-law of Mussolini, and Italian foreign minister.
December 13, 1941
The Ministe..."
In my book The Star of Africa, I mention Ciano, since Hans Joachim Marseille apparently defiled his niece I believe it was. FYI, I own a piece of Ciano's office furniture, a lovely green marble top end desk.

"I would sum up the German character best by saying that they are the best of losers and the worst of winners."
Field Marshal Edmund Ironside from:


"I would sum up the German character best by saying that they are the best of losers and the worst of winners."
Field Mar..."
A good quote from a book I own but have yet to read - and one I finally got around to buying following a mention by you not so recently.


Is this the book in question:

If so I thought it was a pretty decent account as well.


A good passage Cory. I have read a number of Mr Deighton's books but not this one; so another added to the TBR.

Geevee wrote: "Cory wrote: "By 1942, the civilized world had been brought to the brink of ruin. It had taken the Axis powers less than three years to command the high seas in the North Atlantic and the South Paci..."


Is a good book, although a little limited in scope, considering it ends before anything involving Russia and the Western Desert. It has an incident in it that I would like to have independent verification on, involving Rommel and his arrival with 7th Panzer.
I liked:

better, but it has a few weaknesses that annoy me.
No footnotes, lots of quotes with no citations, and worst of all no Bibliography. Still it is a good read and if you like Blitzkrieg you should give it a shot.
Rory wrote: "Blitzkrieg, the first in his series, was also very good. Haven't read his "Bomber" book, yet."

On back cover are recommendations from Atkinson (Liberation Trilogy) and Doughty who wrote one of my favorite books on fall of France--Breaking Point, Sedan. Grab that with book by Alistair Horne and the above mentioned blitzkrieg and you have a great quick read of battle of France.



Rory wrote: "Very funny you mention Dennis Showalter--at suggestion elsewhere on the group I picked up Corp Commanders at the Bulge and he does the forward. Not sure I have come across him before.
On back cove..."

message 20:
by
Geevee, Assisting Moderator British & Commonwealth Forces
(last edited Jan 02, 2014 12:18PM)
(new)

The audio book of Bomber is well performed with a fine cast and I highly recommend it.
Not a WWII title but I liked Alistair Horne's


This is the last line of Isaac's Army: The Jewish Resistance in Occupied Poland which I have just finished reading.
The author interviewed many of the survivors and his book details the build up to the Ghetto revolt of 1943 as well as Jewish participation in the Warsaw Uprising of 1944.
Lesser known aspects are also detailed such as the conflict between some of the right wing fascist elements within the non-Jewish Polish resistance army and the Jewish units.
I'd highly recommend this for an understanding of the Jewish underground and particularly the internal conflicts within the Jewish resistance itself.

Indeed one of the earliest missions in the 44 Uprising was to free 348 Jewish prisoners in the G?siówka Concentration camp that was located in the ruins of the Ghetto who were subsequently armed and fought with the Underground. Some of them survived the war by being provided with forged papers showing them as Gentiles.

Under Russian rule Jews in parts of what had been Poland were treated poorly with many anti-Semitic laws coming into force and there was violence at regular intervals. Jews fought alongside Poles for Polish independence in 1918, but by the 1930s restrictions on Jewish employment and for example not being allowed to work on Sundays (as it was declared a day of rest) created difficulties for Jews, as did the rise of anti-Semitism as a whole across Europe. I suspect this historic dislike/antagonism (or worse) may hold the key to Poles not wanting Jewish help; plus perhaps I wonder if a minor concern might have been for some of those Poles who did not want armed assistance from Jews would have been what would the Russians or Germans do to them if they had been caught fighting alongside Jews?
message 28:
by
Geevee, Assisting Moderator British & Commonwealth Forces
(last edited Jan 05, 2014 07:40AM)
(new)


I have this on my GR TBR too:


Indeed one of the ..."
Interesting information Mcrmilhist thanks. My post is my own views from reading about the relationship between Jews and others and so your examples are a good foil to my post.

More info here

There was in fact open anti-Semitism in Poland, not unique in Eastern Europe. Remember that Galician Poles formed one of the most effective death squad auxiliaries. In addition, the Uprising of 1943 was almost entirely a Jewish event, they received little non Jewish Polish support. The 44 Uprising was different, called the General Uprising because the Red Army was closing in, that gave 'braveheart" syndrome to the Gentiles and any Jews remaining in hiding.

Good points. Many apologists for Poland conveniently forget that, outside Nazi Germany, the most stringent anti-Semitic laws in the pre-WW II era were instituted by the authoritarian Polish regime of the late-1930s.

Sometimes WWII seems like part II of..."
Geevee is right on the money (as usual). I too endorse:


More info here ..."
Thank you Mcrmilhist. The article was interesting and and I shall look to see if I can access the further reading too.



Letter, GSP, Jr., to Frederick Ayers, January 14, 1944
...
I am not the first General to catch hell; Wellington had plenty of it, as did Grant, Sherman, and countless others.
I am quite worried over the reaction after the war. I have already met several quite intelligent men who say "Now we will have no more wars"...The avowed purpose of the treaty at Vienna in 1814 was to see that was the last war. Around 1700 BC the Hitities, Cretans, and Egyptians had a tri-party treaty to avert wars, and we learned about it in 1914. Some explorers discovered the Hitite capital and in the library discovered the bricks with the treaty on them---yet before the mud had dried, the Egyptians and Cretans had ganged up and destroyed the Hitites.
If we again think that wars are over, we will surely have another one and damned quick. "Man is WAR" and we had better remember that. Also, we had better look out for ourselves and make the rest of the world lout out for themselves. If we try to feed the world, we will starve and perhaps destroy America...

Well, maybe.
There is little doubt that Polish anti-semitism was pretty virulent and there is plenty of data that indicates that the Poles contributed signficantly to the Final Solution.
Maybe the best evidence is that, by 1960, the Jewish populations of every country in Europe, including Germany, had returned or exceeded their pre-war levels. Except one. Poland.
That's a pretty good indicator of the situation on the ground.


Referring to the Battle of Kohima when Japan suffered a huge defeat, it appeared that the two commanders Renya Mutaguchi and Masakazu Kawabe knew they stood no chance to winning and their forces were about to be annihilated. Yet both of them would not order a retreat. Post war, this was what they wrote in their respective diaries:
Renya Mutaguchi: Although I wanted to say that it's already time to quit the fight in Imphal, when these words reached my mouth, I just couldn't get them out. I could only hope that someone would be able to tell from my expression.
Masakazu Kawabe: I got the impression from Mutaguchi's expression that there was something he wanted to say but just could not bring himself to. I didn't probe, and the meeting ended that way.


Referring to ..."
Good post, Chin Joo. It strikes me as typically Japanese.


Referring to ..."
Fascinating insight into the minds and thoughts of the Japanese in this period Chin Joo.

No Manray9, it's typically Asian. We and our concept of Face.

No Manray9, it's typically Asian. We and our concept of Face."
I lived in Japan for three years (1980-1983) and so much confusion and misunderstanding took place because we had so many communications difficulties. The Japanese wouldn't say "no," so we often thought we had an agreement about some matter, but they expected us to read their body language and understand the unstated. Confusion resulted and, sometimes, hard feelings. Needless to say, it was an education.

"Herr Hitler's language and behavior showed clear signs of mental abnormality."
message 46:
by
Geevee, Assisting Moderator British & Commonwealth Forces
(last edited Mar 20, 2014 03:02AM)
(new)

"Herr Hitler's language and behavior showe..."
Good quote Jill - I had to look up Sir Percy and seems he had an interesting life but not favoured by his staff nor Churchill:
This book is about him: Professional Diplomat; Sir Percy Loraine: Of Kirkharle, Bt., 1880 1961 [No cover] by Gordon Waterfield

Max lifted his head, with great sorrow and great astonishment. "There were stars," he said. "They burned my eyes."

Max lifted his head, with great sorrow and great astonishment. "There were stars," he said. "They burned my eyes.""
The Book Thief was very good, but a bit on the depressing side.
My favorite passage from a World War II book, is from James Cross Giblin's The Life and Death of Adolf Hitler. In the end of the book, Giblin wrote a section titled something like, "Hitler Lives." What he said was something to the effect of that it is our duty as human beings to make sure that Hitler's desires are never met. I completely agree with that.
Books mentioned in this topic
Fatal Decision: Anzio and the Battle for Rome (other topics)Command Decision (other topics)
Helmet For My Pillow (other topics)
As Good As Dead: The Daring Escape of American POWs From a Japanese Death Camp (other topics)
Eastern Approaches (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Robert Leckie (other topics)William T. Vollmann (other topics)
Gordon Waterfield (other topics)
John Doyle Klier (other topics)
Norman Davies (other topics)
More...
From diary of Count Galeazzo Ciano, son-ln-law of Mussolini, and Italian foreign minister.
December 13, 1941
The Minister from Cuba came to declare war. He was very emotional, and was disappointed that I did not share his emotion. But after having had the good fortune, or is it misfortune, to declare war on France, on Great Britain, on Russia, and on the United States, could the good man really think that I would turn pale on learning that Sergeant Batista was mobilizing against us the forces of Cuba on land and sea, and in the air? Ecuador, too, has declared war, but I had my secretary receive the Minister.