Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge discussion
2018 Challenge Prompts - Regular
>
5. Nordic noir
message 151:
by
Јована
(new)
Jan 11, 2018 09:03AM

reply
|
flag

She is on a list of Nordic Noir writers here:
So, yes.

thank you!

My mom recommended that book to me for this category!

I'm reading The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, so I can participate in our ŷ/Popsugar January reading, but I just wanted to put that out there.



Possibly Echoes from the Dead, The Boy in the Suitcase or The Ice Princess?

I read Jar City by Arnaldur Indriðason (set in Iceland) this year, and might do the next bo..."
I just finished Jar City a couple days ago. I enjoyed it!


I don’t recall graphic imagery in The Boy in the Suitcase, but it’s been awhile and it’s not something I’m bothered by so I might not note it as much.


That's helpful to know, thank you!

Others in the genre that I've read (which include varying levels of violence) include:
A Darker Sky
Until Thy Wrath be Past
The Leopard (I remember this one as being quite violent)


Thank you for the recommendation Johanne! Hopefully I can find one of their books at the library :)

I will read the next book in the series The Defenceless because I already bought it not realising that is was the second book of the series. I think I probably could have read it as a stand alone but I like to read book series chronologically so that's when I went back and read the first. Apparently this series improves when she gets a better translator.

It doesn't look like that the translator changes. There are only few current Finnish-to-English translators out there anyway, I can name maybe four, and I assume three of them translate most of the books.

It doesn't look like that the translator changes. There are only few current Finnish-to-English translators out the..."
Fair enough. To be honest I don't think the translation was that bad but there were a few strange word choices that gave the book less of a noir feel. I just took that from the reviews I saw on ŷ. Maybe they mean that the translation had more of a noir feel to it in future books or this might come from the author herself.
I mean no disrespect to the translator as it must be really difficult to translate the feel of a novel to a different language.

Or more likely the author wasn't writing "noir". It is a genre label given from the outside, and Finnish authors generally don't care in which genre their novels are categorized, or at least not enough to change their writing style to follow some arbitrary genre conventions or rules.




From reading the thread so far, Echoes from the Dead or The Boy in the Suitcase seem like they might be okay. If anyone had read either of these, can you give me some insight on whether these might fit what I'm looking for?
Any other suggestions?



I'm Traveling Alone by Samuel Bjørk
Has anyone read it?

I read The Bat by Jo Nesbo. I chose this one because last winter I read The Snowman and really enjoyed it. The Bat shows his progression as on author, as I found it a bit more mild than The Snowman but I still enjoyed it and learning more about the younger Harry Hole.


I am reluctant to dip into a series as it would nag at me until I read the whole series even if I didn't enjoy it *sigh*

I am reluctant to dip into a series as it would nag at me until I read the whole series e..."
Smilla's Sense of Snow
Let the Right One In
I think those are standalone.

Let the Right In is on my mental tbr list as I enjoyed both the play & the playscript I really should read the original book at some point :)


The best thing about this prompt was researching what qualifies as Nordic Noir and learning delightful terms from TV Tropes such as "Crapsaccharine World" and "Fan Disservice."


While it is Nordic I don’t think it qualifies as noir because the book isn’t a mystery . But I’m using it for the book about sports because hockey is a big part of the story.



I haven´t read it, but I just read a review. I´d definitely say yes.


If anyone is struggling with this prompt and willing to stretch, I think Beartown could work. It's Nordic, dark, there is a crime, and the first chapter sets up sort of a mystery. So not necessarily Nordic noir, but it has the same feel and some key elements.

One Nordic noir author I’ve read several books from is Hakan Nesser. They do involve murder and can be very dark but I’ve found them to be enjoyable stories with a great detective that I can’t quite figure out who the killer is which is always a plus if you read a lot of mysteries.
Books mentioned in this topic
Last Train to Helsingør (other topics)The Bat (other topics)
Death of a Nightingale (other topics)
1222 (other topics)
As Red as Blood (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Salla Simukka (other topics)Samuel Bjørk (other topics)
Johan Theorin (other topics)
Arnaldur Indriðason (other topics)
Åsa Larsson (other topics)
More...