Fantasy Book Club Series discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Nominations and Poll Invitations
>
Nominations open for our next series!
date
newest »


OK-Good news, and of course, bad news! the Mistborn: The Final Empire series will be replacing Malazan Book of the Fallen! Yay!
But 2nd place was a tie...lol. From the feedback we were getting, what we will do is start Wheel of Time after Ryria Revelations (since its a much longer series) Jon will moderate this one. This is good since the final book is coming out in January, so the timing will be about right.
We will do First Law as our next series, probably right after Mistborn.
But 2nd place was a tie...lol. From the feedback we were getting, what we will do is start Wheel of Time after Ryria Revelations (since its a much longer series) Jon will moderate this one. This is good since the final book is coming out in January, so the timing will be about right.
We will do First Law as our next series, probably right after Mistborn.


Couple of questions for readers:
Do we include The Alloy of Law as part of Mistborn? If so, then I need to squeeze it in before we start the First Law Trilogy.
And, with respect to the Wheel of Time, do we include New Spring, the prequel?
Thanks, Jon

I can't wait to start in on Mistborn and see if it's as great as I remember.
I'll be reading Wheel of Time too. Busy months coming up.

If you do decide to include it, I would recommend you include it in order of publishing (i.e. between books 10 and 11), rather than start off the readthrough with it.

If you do decide to include it, I would recommend you include it in order of publishing (i.e. between b..."
Whoops! I better go change my intro post then. :)
Jim wrote: "Jon wrote: "And, with respect to the Wheel of Time, do we include New Spring, the prequel? "
If you do decide to include it, I would recommend you include it in order of publishing (i.e. between b..."
I agree with this!
If you do decide to include it, I would recommend you include it in order of publishing (i.e. between b..."
I agree with this!
lol Nicki-in my head it's a definitely on the First Law and just a maybe on the Alloy of Law....but I havent got that far yet, so I dont know....


Thank you, Amelia. I feel exactly the same way.

I don't understand the question.
If you mean, would we start the Mistborn series read with Alloy of Law, I don't know. I have it but have not read it yet. I thought it was set in a later time period and it was published after the trilogy, so logically, it would come after the first three, correct?
Correct me if I'm confused.

Then when we are done with the Mistborn Trilogy that is four books we are onto First Law?
I will be taking the right fork in the group road with above series and not participating in WoT.
Shell- I say why in message 59, but when they tied for 2nd there were various opinons posted in the poll thread. Instead of having a runoff between them, we decided to do First Law right after Mistborn

Then when we are done with the Mistborn Trilogy that is four books we are onto First Law?..."
I will insert Alloy of Law before we start the First Law series.
Have we decided if we're adding Best Served Cold and Heroes to the other three books of First Law as well?

Sorry Mags, I didn't see that post!! Okay so I get a lil break then before we start J. Abercrombie....YAY!!! :)

Yep I got a few of those for sure! :) Been immersed in SE for a long, long time now!! :) When I finished TCG yesterday I was sad it was over!! :( BUT I still get to look forward to OST!! :)

HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAAHHAHAHAAAAAA....at least we still have a NEW Malazan tome to read yet!! :) It's great knowing there will be more books from SE/ICE in the future!!! :)


You have to finish TCG Lee, you have too!!! Besides, if you're anything like me, you'll end up rereading the last 200 pages again right away because you wont believe what you read!!!!!

So have picked it up again. 85% finished.
@ Traci, I have a love/hate relationship with Simmons, I thought Hyperion a wonderful read. I also hate every thing else he has done that I have read. Carrion comfort and Olympus spring to mind.
However, Terror is a really good read. Kind of Historical Fiction with a monster. It has plenty of theme, paced well (except the start is a little slow) and has some well developed characters. I am really beginning to hate one of them and was disappointed when another died, so that tells me I have engaged with the story.
Looking forward to Mistborn, but bearing in mind it is supposedly going to replace my Malazan read, that makes me nervous. Since June this year Malazan has been a constant every day occurrence. I have gone through the 10 (almost) Erikson and 4 ICE in that time. Every day.
Every day.
So, thinking of instead of going cold turkey, I reloaded GotM back on the kindle, so I could use it like a comforter.

Yes Lee, yes!!! :) You're gonna need it! Oh and a correction to you're statement above Lee, you've been reading Malazan since June of LAST year!!! LOLLLLL.... :)


I'm about 115 pages in to Terror and I love it. He does such a good job with the setting that you can feel the cold coming from the pages.
The only other novel by Dan Simmons that I have completed is Ilium which I enjoyed but not enough to jump right in to the sequel, Olympos. Ilium did raise my interest in Marcel Proust's In Search of Lost Time. I have bought the first volume, Swann's Way (the Lydia Davis translation). I have yet to read it.



Sorry to break the news to you, but we've already selected our next three series to read.
I'm going to close this thread to avoid further confusion to newcomers.
Thanks for joining and I hope you enjoy the series we're reading and plan to read over the next few months.
Jon
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Terror (other topics)Ilium (other topics)
Olympos (other topics)
Swann’s Way (other topics)
The Terror (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Lydia Davis (other topics)Marcel Proust (other topics)
Fiona McIntosh (other topics)
E.E. Knight (other topics)
E.E. Knight (other topics)
More...
I added the three Tawny Man books to our 'to-read' shelf this morning. I created a new shelf for the entire series 'Real..."
Excellent! I'd like the other series' added and an overall folder. Brill.
Also, I'd like to nominate The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms by Jemisin if I'm not to late.