English Mysteries Club discussion
Archive pre-2020
>
Currently Reading?

Next up is Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter for a book club! Then Gone Girl, which I am really looking forward to...
Oh, and Ive borrowed both Let's Pretend This Never Happened: A Mostly True Memoir and Sarah's Key, so I need to read those and get them back to their respective owners.
And yes, I need to get a mystery in there soon. ;)
SO MANY BOOKS, SO LITTLE TIME!!!
Sarah's Key is almost a mystery. Pretty good too, and a quick read, so you should be ok.



It's so dark, even darker than the first one Cover Her Face and talks about all sorts of things that I wouldn'..."
Oh those are both excellent books by James! She can be very dark and complex. Excellent choices!
The more modern mysteries don't have the same feel, do they?
They are either totally "cozy", complete with amateur sleuth armed with cat, tea and knitting needles (which are fun sometimes, I must admit).
Or they are the urban variety, with too much "grit" for my taste (whatever that adjective means... usually too much sex, blood and depravity).
The classic mysteries were very much about what was going on socially, especially in the post-war eras (after both of the World Wars). There was so much going on to the social structure of the world, the mysteries had to reflect that. Now I get the idea that it's all Big Brother (the TV show) voyeurism and no interest in the psychological make up of the characters, unless it is to talk about a gruesome serial killer who was abused as a child.
They are either totally "cozy", complete with amateur sleuth armed with cat, tea and knitting needles (which are fun sometimes, I must admit).
Or they are the urban variety, with too much "grit" for my taste (whatever that adjective means... usually too much sex, blood and depravity).
The classic mysteries were very much about what was going on socially, especially in the post-war eras (after both of the World Wars). There was so much going on to the social structure of the world, the mysteries had to reflect that. Now I get the idea that it's all Big Brother (the TV show) voyeurism and no interest in the psychological make up of the characters, unless it is to talk about a gruesome serial killer who was abused as a child.


They are either totally "cozy", complete with amateur sleuth armed with cat, tea and knitting needles (which are fun sometimes, I must ..."
I think you've nailed it, Hayes. I definitely don't like the "amateur sleuth armed with cat, tea and knitting needles" (although I do read the Liss MacCrimmon series, but only because they're about things sort of Scottish). They are too formulaic, and characterization is almost unheard of.
Nor do I like the modern gritty mysteries -- I can watch the nightly news or read the local paper to get all of that I can manage to handle.
So I'm also a big fan of the older mysteries, especially the Brit ones. In my book, true English cozies are the Miss Marples or Poirots or Miss Silvers, etc. One of the newer series (well, there's only 2 of them, darn it!) are the Patricia Harwin books. True cozies, even if recently written.

OMG! I went to pull this off my bookshelf ... and I don't have it! WAH! I think I have everything else he wrote, and certainly I've read it, but ... now I've got to scurry around & find it! YIKES!

I did the same thing. I had seven of his books, but not this one. Until now, of course!

I really liked Sarah's Key and it was a pretty fast read.
"And yes, I need to get a mystery in there soon. ;)
SO MANY BOOKS, SO LITTLE TIME!!!"
Hahaha!!! My thoughts exactly!
I just finished Edgar Wallace's The Case of the Twisted Candle (very enjoyable) and my next mystery is to be the Crispin, if I can find it. After that, The League of Frightened Men by Rex Stout (not English, but I enjoy Nero Wolf & Archie) :)
Currently reading the following non-mystery books:
Barchester Towers by Trollope
Picadilly Jim by Wodehouse (for when Trollope gets to be too much)
and listening to the audio book of The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins

Oh dear, now you've done it Leslie(in a good way) - I haven't thought of Edgar Wallace in aeons, but I do have a set of nine of his that belonged to my Nan in my "never, ever clear out" bookcase. I think she may have had them from a book club since all are identically bound, published in the early 30s, presumably after his death? ... so now my re-read list (albeit after a VERY long delay), has suddenly multiplied!


Love Cyril hare, & have read (& own) all his books. Very good taste, Tom!

Has anyone here read any Anna Katherine Greene, and if so, how was it?

I have a bunch of freebies on my Kindle, but haven't gotten to them yet. Cyril Hare is terrific! I've been collecting those as I came across them for ages, but I'm still missing a couple.


I have a bunch of freebies on my Kindle, but haven't gotten to them yet. Cyril Hare is terrific! I've bee..."
So I did read Anna Katherine Green's "That Affair Next Door" (which isn't English, so sorry about the off-topic discussion). I enjoyed it very much (4 stars) -- if you like Miss Marple and/or Miss Silver, you should try it. It is in the public domain, so freely available as an ebook.
Tenant for Death



I went through a phase of loving her books -- I must own 10 of them -- but I found that I didn't enjoy them as much when I reread some of them... too dark for my current mood maybe. Ruth Rendell is definitely too dark for me most of the time. I tend to like the older British mysteries (Christie, Sayers, Allingham) even when I'm reading them for the second (or third) time.

Now I am reading Gone Girl. All I have to say so far is, the heck?
Still haven't gotten to Sarah's Key... :o)

LOL, Lorraine. This is my quarrel with most mystery series that take place in small towns, but I so love Armand Gamache and his crew that I turn a blind eye on that factoid....




I have Mistress of the Art of Death high up on my pile too - let us know what you think! I've also been looking at Maisie Dobbs, so I'm glad to see a thumbs up.
Lorraine, that sounds strange and fascinating! What will he do when he begins to get close?

The Canadian "Cabot Cove"? I love Penny's books!

LOL, Lorraine. This is my quarrel wit..."
Even though locals are being murdered right-and-left, I do like the Penny connects the plots together.

I really enjoyed Mistress of the Art of Death -- sort of a female Cadfael... I liked the historical fiction as much or more than the mystery.

This evening I downloaded "Playing for the Ashes" by Elizabeth George which, when completed, will put me over the 50% mark of the Inspector Lynley tales. I have read all the Daniel Silva novels with Gabriel Allon as the main character.


Helen,
I Love CJ Sansom's Matthew Shardlake series. It's really some of the best writing around. Who could not love a hunchbacked lawyer during Henry VIII's time? I liked "Winter in Madrid" but think it pales compared to the series. Have You read it?



Laurie,
I LOVED that book. We also read it for our local book club. It's good to know others like it.



My book club members call books like "Pettigrew" Geezer Lit. I really don't care as I like the book a lot.


My book club members call books like "Pettigrew" Geezer Lit. I really don't care as..."
That's funny. My mother loved the Mrs. Pollifax's books by Dorothy Gilmour. Now that's geezer lit.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Taken (other topics)Sherlock Holmes: Murder at the Savoy & Other Stories (other topics)
Wicked Autumn (other topics)
Cover Her Face (other topics)
A Mind to Murder (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Alice Clark-Platts (other topics)Chris Ould (other topics)
Adrian McKinty (other topics)
Will Thomas (other topics)
Anna Katharine Green (other topics)
More...
It's so dark, even darker than the first one Cover Her Face and talks about all sorts of things that I wouldn't have suspected like the use of LSD in psychotherapy. It was written in 1963.