Nicholas Nickleby in Catching up on Classics (and lots more!)

From the Bookshelf of Catching up on Classics (and lots more!)…

Nicholas Nickleby

Charles Dickens

Start date: April 1, 2025

Finish date: June 30, 2025

Discussion: Current Group Reads

Why we're reading this: 2025 2nd Quarter (April - June) Long Read
[close] 2025 2nd Quarter (April - June) Long Read

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of -2 topics — 227 comments total

Current Group Reads

* The Shadow of the Wind Spoiler Thread
By Lynn , New School Classics · 12 posts · 38 views

last updated Jun 10, 2025 05:27PM

* Zero Hour - June 2025
By Bob , Short Story Classics · 7 posts · 50 views

last updated Jun 08, 2025 03:40PM

showing 10 of 26 topics view all »

What Members Thought

Dec 14, 2018 Laura rated it really liked it

Shelves: read-2020, film-only, british-literature, fiction-19th-century

4* The Trial for Murder
3* The Haunted House
3* The Baron of Grogzwig
2* The Chimes
4* A Christmas Carol
4* Our Mutual Friend
4* A Tale of Two Cities
4* Great Expectations
4* David Copperfield
3* Oliver Twist
4* Nicholas Nickleby
TR A Child's History of England
TR The Seven Poor Travellers
TR The Christmas Books, Vol 2: The Cricket on the Heart/The Battle of Life/The Haunted Man
TR The Cricket on the Hearth
TR To Be Read at Dusk
TR No Thoroughfare
TR Martin Chuzzlewit
TR A Child's Dream of a Star

About Charles Dic ...more

3 likes · Like · see review

Nov 27, 2008 Everyman rated it liked it · review of another edition

Yes, it's Dickens. But it's immature Dickens, a man still feeling his way from the genre of comedy and legal reporting (of Parliamentary debates) into the still developing world of fiction.

I won't talk about plot details, because I hate reviews that reveal too much to the first time reader. Suffice it to say that the full title of the book is "The Life and Adventures of Nicholas Nickleby." And while at various times we stray from Nicholas's life, in the end he remains the central character.

Cent Yes, it's Dickens. But it's immature Dickens, a man still feeling his way from the genre of comedy and legal reporting (of Parliamentary debates) into the still developing world of fiction.

I won't talk about plot details, because I hate reviews that reveal too much to the first time reader. Suffice it to say that the full title of the book is "The Life and Adventures of Nicholas Nickleby." And while at various times we stray from Nicholas's life, in the end he remains the central character.

Central among a large cast of characters all of which have a degree, and in most cases a very high degree, of unreality. Dickens in his mature writing was a master of character, creating complex and interesting characters. But that's not the case yet. Most of his characters are either very, very good or very, very bad. And with one minor possible exception, there is no mistaking which is which. The good are good throughout; the bad are bad throughout. There is no moral complexity in the book.

What there is is a plethora of coincidences. The first few one can overlook. But as the book proceeds and coincidence piles on coincidence (in several instances, a person wandering the streets of London or going at random into an establishment just happens to run into another character who also has no reasonable reason for being there) one can only shake one's head at the absurdity of it all.

There are also a few polemical intrusions which add little to the narrative. It's not a spoiler, I think, to say that Dickens savages the Yorkshire schools which were a blot on the education of English youth at the time. He also brings in a digression on the evils of publishers who steal an author's work without payment for it.

With all that said, why did I give the book even three stars? Because of the writing. Even at this point in his career, Dickens has the ability to create highly believable places and rich moods. Wandering the lanes of England or the streets of London with him is a genuine pleasure, irrespective of what his characters may be doing at the time. And while his characters are generally less than believable, he does have the ability to portray them in a few sentences which make them spring to life before the eye.

Unless one wants to tackle Dickens in the chronological order he wrote his books, I can't recommend starting a foray into Dickens with Nicholas Nickleby. There are much stronger novels (indeed, it is questionable whether it is fair to consider NN a true novel) with richer characters and the moral ambiguity which is present in all real people and all good fictional characters. When you have exhausted the great Dickens novels, you can consider whether you want to take a look at the path he took to get to that greatness.

...more

1 like · Like · see review

May 24, 2010 Surreysmum rated it really liked it

Shelves: 1983, classics-british, library, 2021

[These notes were made in 1983:]. Read for exams. Good old Dickens -- always a pleasure to read, even under compulsion. Mrs. Nickleby -- eternally fretful, gullible, and good-hearted -- is a masterpiece.

Re-read 2021: I enjoyed this more than I expected from my memories, which I find had overemphasized the villains (particularly schoolmaster Squeers and Ralph Nickleby) and had completely lost any impression from their balancing angels, the Cheeryble Brothers and Newman Noggs. It was pleasant to e [These notes were made in 1983:]. Read for exams. Good old Dickens -- always a pleasure to read, even under compulsion. Mrs. Nickleby -- eternally fretful, gullible, and good-hearted -- is a masterpiece.

Re-read 2021: I enjoyed this more than I expected from my memories, which I find had overemphasized the villains (particularly schoolmaster Squeers and Ralph Nickleby) and had completely lost any impression from their balancing angels, the Cheeryble Brothers and Newman Noggs. It was pleasant to encounter the latter group again (along with the comic theatre troupe, Vincent Crummles and his family, including the Infant Phenomenon). Nicholas was a more spirited and impulsive young fellow than I remembered, with two common assaults on his record (Squeers and Sir Mulberry Hawk), but as soon as he encounters the Cheerybles, one is never again in doubt for his future, nor for that of his sister Kate, who unfortunately doesn't have much to do in this novel except blush and duck unwanted suitors. The Cheerybles, you see, have such an unbeatable combination of virtue and wealth that they constitute a pretty much impenetrable wall between misfortune and anyone they adopt into their circle, so they do suck the suspense out of the story a bit. Still, I was happy to find that the novel wasn't quite such a depiction of unrelieved horrors as I half-remembered it.

I wonder if Mrs. Nickleby is related to Mrs. Bennet? I can just imagine their voluble conversations, neither of them paying the slightest attention to the other!

This is young Dickens, but just a few novels into his career, he has has taken control of the form, introducing layer after layer of characters, motivations and personal secrets (coincidental encounters galore, of course), and swinging the whole thing back, via Yorkshire and its revisited trauma, to Nicholas' idealized childhood home, where his damaged brother figure (and - spoiler alert - actual blood relative) can rest after making a truly sentiment-filled exit of the type I will only forgive from an author who has also made me laugh so heartily. No-one's fate is forgotten in the pages of denouement, but it is not a tedious matter, because it is the relatively minor characters, eccentrics all, who have added the spice to every page, and I, for one, did want to know what happened to them. In Dickens' world, just deserts not only exist, but they exist as the reason for the tale.

So glad I decided to re-read Nickleby instead of skipping it because there was already an entry here. ...more

Like · see review

Mar 24, 2021 Kai Coates rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Maybe the best cast of characters Dickens ever created, which is saying a lot for the author who created some of the most well-known characters in literature. Nicholas himself is kind of boring (his one fault being a proclivity towards violence, but only towards those who deserve it so is that even a fault?), but the motley collection of people who come in and out of his life are pure gems.

This was published in installments, and sometime it felt like Dickens was trying to mash in other works to ...more

Like · see review