Poll
SERIES DISCUSSION: This run-off poll determines which series will be the subject of our second official Beyond Reality Series Discussion!
The Wars of Light and Shadow by Janny Wurts
The Chronicles of Amber by Roger Zelazny
Poll added by: Stefan
This Poll is About
Comments Showing 1-6 of 6 (6 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Charles
(new)
Jun 07, 2010 04:15PM

reply
|
flag

My apologies for the tackiness of mentioning one group in another, but I thought people might like to know...

Silly me, I thought of Stormwarden for whatever reason, it didn't register that it's Wars of Light and Shadow...I do own those...So wichever one wins works. Just gotta go over my parents to dig out my copies of the Wars books.
I'm a member of that group too, actually, but didn't want to mention the other group's discussion here to avoid influencing the vote. Ah well.
I'm wondering if it makes more sense to refer our members to the other group if Wars of Light and Shadow wins. Otherwise we have a duplicate discussion running, which is just a waste of time (also for Janny, who is a member in both groups).
I'm wondering if it makes more sense to refer our members to the other group if Wars of Light and Shadow wins. Otherwise we have a duplicate discussion running, which is just a waste of time (also for Janny, who is a member in both groups).

Let the group have what it wants - I admire Zelazny very much so I will be with the group whatever the outcome.
Tomorrow's the last day to vote, and we have a close race, so make sure to cast your vote!
Quick clarification: despite the messages above, we're going to stick with whichever series wins here. If The Wars of Light and Shadow wins, we may go with a slightly different discussion format - instead of covering one book per month, we may do 2 chapters per week or something like that (we'll work out the details). This will allow more people to participate, and also hopefully lead to a more in-depth discussion. And of course, Janny will be here to host the discussion! If Amber wins, the books are short enough to cover one book per month, so in that case we can stick with the usual format.
Voting will end on Monday evening!
Quick clarification: despite the messages above, we're going to stick with whichever series wins here. If The Wars of Light and Shadow wins, we may go with a slightly different discussion format - instead of covering one book per month, we may do 2 chapters per week or something like that (we'll work out the details). This will allow more people to participate, and also hopefully lead to a more in-depth discussion. And of course, Janny will be here to host the discussion! If Amber wins, the books are short enough to cover one book per month, so in that case we can stick with the usual format.
Voting will end on Monday evening!