The Wide Web of Friends in YA Books discussion

This topic is about
The One
Archives
>
The One
message 1:
by
Rachel , The Attentive One
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Sep 28, 2013 06:41AM

reply
|
flag

This is PART of a rant review I wrote on THE ELITE:
Does there really have to be a love triangle here? We all know that America is going to come to her senses and choose Maxon. If America isn't with Maxon and if they don't make changes to Illéa, it would totally ruin everything that this series is building towards and I will not view this series the same way. Despite all of my irritations with this book, I can't bare to knock a star off the rating because I am in love with this series, or the idea and premise of this series. America get your head together and get your priorities straight!
Does there really have to be a love triangle here? We all know that America is going to come to her senses and choose Maxon. If America isn't with Maxon and if they don't make changes to Illéa, it would totally ruin everything that this series is building towards and I will not view this series the same way. Despite all of my irritations with this book, I can't bare to knock a star off the rating because I am in love with this series, or the idea and premise of this series. America get your head together and get your priorities straight!




I'm hoping America ends up with Maxon, obviously. I also think Aspen might get with Lucy, it seemed like The Elite was hinting that she had a crush on Aspen. So I think that could happen.

I completely agree, and I also think Aspen and Lucy could happen.
I agree too Hannah. I'm hoping this book resolves everything. This book can make or break the series.

I want to see (assuming Maxon & America are endgame) how they rule and change Illea. I want to know more about the rebels. I think the world she created is pretty awesome and I wish we got to see more of the political/war aspects instead of just love triangle this, mean girls that.
I at least wish the series would be longer...


I think so, too. I mean, this IS about a prince selecting one of 35 girls. While America dumping him in the end and chosing Aspen would be an interesting twist, I just don't see it coming, especially after she's finally made her mind up to fight for Maxon at the end of Elite.
Can't wait for May 2014!

I guess it would be unexpected, but I also think it would kind of make the whole series pointless if she just went back to her old life with Aspen. yea, they'd be higher in the caste system (assuming they didn't get caught) but I think America's journey is largely about her realizing that she can be a Princess, that she has the potential inside of her to really make changes in the country, and that she shouldn't run away from real love just because she's scared of that responsibility.
that's why I think so much is resting on the ending, it could make or break the series and America's whole arc as a character.

I wholeheartedly agree with everything you just said.


Although this is another reason why I think this series should be longer, that kind of conflict shouldn't be resolved in a book that will most likely be less than 400 pages.

I wished it was longer too, I can't imagine how she will resolve the rebels in one book, and in the same time their relationship between them, the choice, Aspen's opinion in the matter- because I don't think he will go without a fight, neither will Celeste, Also we have Maxon's horrible father and the truth about the casts and how they got created. Those are a lot of things to deal properly in only one book!

I think The One is going to feel really rushed judging by the sheer amount of things that need to be addressed and resolved. I'm really just hoping for a good ending, even if it's somewhat open ended.

I feel like this whole series is just a scam to take our money. It's a cute concept that was poorly written and has many flaws. AND it's really expensive and short (page length). The more I think about it, the more annoyed and irritated I get.

I'm still going to be glad I read it, I enjoy the series, I love Maxon as a character, I like America most of the time, I just wish this whole story had been executed better. I don't like feeling like I'm being taken advantage of as a ploy to make more money. We all know The Selection and The Elite could have been one book, I'm honestly surprised they're not extending the series to 6 books just to keep dragging it out.



I think that all YA authors are starting to produce novellas just so they can make more money. Write 50 ebook pages and charge $1.99. Cassie Clare made TEN which she released once a month and cost $2.99. So not worth it... I like CoLS better than CoA but CoFA was my least favorite. As much as I love Simon, there was just too much of him.




That's true, but she just looks just like how I pictured America :P I meant more physical appearance, not personality.



I'd rather have nothing than have them butcher the best character in the series and the whole storyline. I feel like on TV it always has to be about the girl getting the bad boy, so they turned Maxon into a jerk.


they did the same thing with Delirium, they turned Julian into some scumbag pervert who spied on girls through windows. I know I'm probably the only one but Julian was my favorite character in the series and I would have hated to see them slaughter that on a TV show.


they changed Delirium a lot just plot wise too. but I was a fan of Gregg Sulkin as Julian so I'm sad I'll never see him play the real Julian, not creepy stalker Julian who gets with Hana for some reason.

oh novellas are such a scam, especially because they'll release them in between books and then release all the novellas in physical form, so you're kind of tricked into buying them on your kindle/ipad and then when the series is over you want to buy the physical copy too.


THEY PUT JULIAN WITH HANA???!!! NO WAY!!! Wow, but I guess it was a possibility, considering how open Requiem ended, especially on Hana's end. I just hate when best friends share boyfriends.

yea they made it so that Julian had known Lena and Hana like their whole lives and he was Hana's neighbor and would like watch her change and stuff through her bedroom window. Everything else was the same with his dad and all that, it was just that he lived in Portland from the beginning rather than Lena meeting him in New York.