Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Gone (Gone, #1) Gone discussion


238 views
Astrid has a superpower! Why did Michael Grant not acknowledge it in the rest of the series?

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Claire Astrid does have a superpower!
I know it's not a big one, I mean seeing someone's importance is a pretty lame ability, but why didn't Michael Grant not mention it in any of the other books?


Neha Astrid is a genius, that's why she knows other capabilities & importance of each of other characters. It has nothing to do with a superpower. She's always been a genius!


°ä´Ç°ù²Ôé Neha (Athena) (Queen Elinor) wrote: "Astrid is a genius, that's why she knows other capabilities & importance of each of other characters. It has nothing to do with a superpower. She's always been a genius!"

That is true, but she still has a superpower. she has too! I mean, diana could feel she had 2 stripes.


Claire Neha (Athena) (Queen Elinor) wrote: "Astrid is a genius, that's why she knows other capabilities & importance of each of other characters. It has nothing to do with a superpower. She's always been a genius!"

She has the ability to see how important someone is through a shooting star I think. Cuz she said Sams glow was the brightest she had ever seen, meaning he was really important!


Neha Oh well, it's been a long time since I read it. But the author created her character thinking of her more as normal human rather than having superpowers.


Luna I watch a video or something awhile when Fear came out, and he confessed that he didn't want Astrid to have powers anymore, so in his words he said her power "evaporated". So for now her power was her being a smarty-pants.


Neha Ohh


Danielle yagami He said on Youtube that he screwed it up. That's why. "Plot holes so big you can drive a truck through them"


Mnemofysh Wait... what is Astrid's superpower? I really don't get it.


Rachel Paige  Hamlin Mnemofysh wrote: "Wait... what is Astrid's superpower? I really don't get it."

She can see how important someone is. It's a lame power.
She didn't really need it, so he took it out.


Mnemofysh I thought that was Diana's power? Kind of....


message 12: by Devon (new) - added it

Devon Morgan I thought that was really smart. Astrid the Genius-Knowing how talented everyone else is


Danny Mnemofysh wrote: "I thought that was Diana's power? Kind of...."

No, Diana can read the level of peoples powers' when she takes their hand. Astrid, when she takes somebody's hand she sees what she describes as a shooting star. The brighter it is, the more significant their life will be. I wish this power had been mentioned in later books...


Mnemofysh Danny wrote:

No, Diana can read the level of peoples powers' when she takes their hand. Astrid, when she takes somebody's hand she sees what she..."


Yeah, I know, but the two are still really similar... :\


Lorux Z I've just recently finished reading the gone series
Reading this conversation that took place 10 years ago is so vivid
Guess I'm late to the party huh..


Lorux Z Not to mention grant published the sequels
I'm reading them right now


Hannariina Lorux wrote: "I've just recently finished reading the gone series
Reading this conversation that took place 10 years ago is so vivid
Guess I'm late to the party huh.."



Same...


back to top