Book Riot's Read Harder Challenge discussion
2018 Read Harder Challenge
>
Task #6: A book about nature
message 151:
by
Sherri
(new)
Apr 28, 2018 01:19PM

reply
|
flag

I think it sounds iffy, but it's your challenge, so if you think it works, go for it! There are other graphic novels, such as John Muir, Earth - Planet, Universe and The Rime of the Modern Mariner, that might work better.



Wild: From Lost to Found on the Pacific Crest Trail
Into the Wild"
I read Wild: From Lost to Found on the Pacific Crest Trail to meet the Oprah book selection task. It's a memoir, but she does occasionally mention the history of the Pacific Crest trail, & how plant communities & weather change as she passes through different ecosystems. And it's very much about her interactions with herself, & nature, & what that takes. I'm a plant geek, so it wasn't as nature-y as I would have wished, but it could certainly count.

Oooh, thanks for the recommendation! Just added The Nature Fix: Why Nature Makes Us Happier, Healthier, and More Creative to my list. :)

“Houseplants for Dummies�; count?"
Do you want arguments for, or against? I can provide either. :p

Wild: From Lost to Found on the Pacific Crest Trail
Into the Wild"
I read [book:Wild: From Lost to Found on the Pacific ..."
Thank you very much. I just wanted more popular books that I can find in my country :)


I hope it is, because it is my choice also

I hope it is, because it is my choice also"
I think it's predominantly a memoir, but more than 350 users have shelved it as being about the environment/nature. And how humans interact with animals that are normally wild is very much a facet of nature. Plus it's your challenge to shape as you will. If you read it & feel you read about nature, task complete! :)

“Houseplants for Dummies�; count?"
Do you want arguments for, or against? I can provide either. :p"
Either! Looking for honest feedback.... (I’m learning lots about the structure of plants, water conservation, propagation.) ;)

Either! Looking for honest feedback.... (I’m ..."
Arguing for Houseplants For Dummies (For Dummies to satisfy the task:
Houseplants are a fascinating subset of how humans interact with nature. We want to be close to nature so we bring it inside to have some wildness near us. We also want to control it, so we take huge jungle plants & grow them in pots as much smaller houseplants. Successful growing of houseplants is exercising dominion over the wild. However the constraints of growing something in a pot require all sorts of modifications to what the plant would want if it were growing where it evolved; we have to understand something of that evolution & ecosystem. Unlike how humans exert control over other humans, our dominion of houseplants requires some level of understanding what we are enslaving. Why is it the way it is?
Arguing against? Houseplants for Dummies is not really a book about nature-as-nature. I wouldn't count it for me, at least not without supplemental reading (or viewing).
But it's your challenge, & for the reasons I gave immediately above, there are a lot of reasons why it could satisfy the task. There. Both sides! :)

Either! Looking for honest feedback.... (I’m ..."
Arguing for [book:Houseplants For Dummies (For Dummies|..."
Very thoughtful reply! Thanks for sharing. :)

I'm currently listening to this audiobook for this prompt.





I had read that as well! I agree that it really was interesting. I've been recommending it to friends as a summer read.


Absolutely!! It's a fantastic book.

***Warning, do NOT read this book without first reading a summary or some reviews. It is not for the faint of heart but it is, honestly, so good. ***







I think For All the Tea in China: Espionage, Empire and the Secret Formula for the World's Favourite Drink would count for task #2, a book of true crime, & since it's about history, economics, food, & culture, it could count for task #14, a book of social science. But it doesn't seem to be so much about nature, whether at large, or in specific.
Edited to add: oh, & it could qualify for #5, a book set in or about one of the BRICs countries, as it involves both India & China.

I forgot to note that I haven't read it. It could be the book spends most of its pages talking about the history & ecology of Camellia sinensis. For me, since it's been used by humans since at least the 2nd century BC., I'm less inclined to consider that about nature, & more about human history & all the fields that go into our relationships with food.
However, this challenge is everyone's to make their own, & you may have a different perspective. :)


I read this one too and I found it to be a great read! It's not something I would have normally picked up, but it was actually kinda fun reading out of my comfort zone.

Another book that I read and enjoyed recently was The Worst Hard Time: The Untold Story of Those Who Survived the Great American Dust Bowl. Well written and informative.



Books mentioned in this topic
H Is for Hawk (other topics)Climbing Mount Improbable (other topics)
Flower Fairies of the Autumn (other topics)
Lonesome Dove (other topics)
The Triumph of Seeds: How Grains, Nuts, Kernels, Pulses, and Pips Conquered the Plant Kingdom and Shaped Human History (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Julia Whitty (other topics)Michael Finkel (other topics)
Douglas Adams (other topics)
Mark Carwardine (other topics)
Lauret Savoy (other topics)
More...