2022 ONTD Reading Challenge discussion
2019 ♦️ARCHIVES♦️ January
>
JAN '19: Read a Book that is Being Adapted into a Movie or TV Show in 2019



Marlene wrote: "Hmm, would Captain Marvel, Volume 1: In Pursuit of Flight or any of the other Captain Marvel comics count even if the movie might not necessarily cover a specific arc from it?"
hmm, I would say that this particular instance with Captain Marvel couldn't count for January. Comics/graphic novels are generally fine for our challenge but this month is tricky since it's an adaptation. I would say that unless it was an adaptation of a specific volume or collection then it can't count. For example reading Watchmen would count if the film was coming out this year, or reading the first volume of the Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, Vol. 1: The Crucible could count if season 1 of the Netflix show was being released this year. On the other hand, reading past issues of Archie wouldn't count since the tv show Riverdale doesn't really follow those. I think Captain Marvel adaptation here is more similar to Riverdale. From what I can tell it's not actually adapting In Pursuit of Flight?
Sorry!
hmm, I would say that this particular instance with Captain Marvel couldn't count for January. Comics/graphic novels are generally fine for our challenge but this month is tricky since it's an adaptation. I would say that unless it was an adaptation of a specific volume or collection then it can't count. For example reading Watchmen would count if the film was coming out this year, or reading the first volume of the Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, Vol. 1: The Crucible could count if season 1 of the Netflix show was being released this year. On the other hand, reading past issues of Archie wouldn't count since the tv show Riverdale doesn't really follow those. I think Captain Marvel adaptation here is more similar to Riverdale. From what I can tell it's not actually adapting In Pursuit of Flight?
Sorry!

I was considering that (I read the Secret History in 2018 and really liked it), but the length is intimidating me because I don't seem to have much dedicated reading time these days lol.
I think I've settled on the Sun is Also a Star. I might use my Audible credit to get it. But seeing the Nightingale on the list makes me want to read that too. Or possibly a re-read of the Golden Compass. I just saw that A Gentleman in Moscow was announced as a TV mini-series but I don't think there's a release date yet:/

I'm considering Lovecraft Country, NOS4A2, or The Knife of Never Letting Go for no other reason than the plots sound weird + interesting. I downloaded samples of each so I'm going to give those a peek and make my decision tonight!
i still don't know what i want to read!
I saw that In The Tall Grass, which is based on a Stephen King/Joe Hill novella, should be released this year but there's no official date for it. Maybe IT, for the chapter 2 release?! IDK... The Visible Filth sounds good too (the adaptation is "Wounds" with Dakota Johnson)
I saw that In The Tall Grass, which is based on a Stephen King/Joe Hill novella, should be released this year but there's no official date for it. Maybe IT, for the chapter 2 release?! IDK... The Visible Filth sounds good too (the adaptation is "Wounds" with Dakota Johnson)

Sue wrote: "I'm going to read
. Just bought it from Waterstones."
enjoy! i listened to it on audiobook over the summer and really liked it.

enjoy! i listened to it on audiobook over the summer and really liked it.

I briefly thought about Artemis Fowl, but decided after seeing the casting call for Artemis that a refresher might not be the best for me if I intend to watch it.

I think I'm going to also read The Sun is Also a Star.

Damn, I was actually considering switching to this cause it's short + I'm feeling kind of lazy.

Damn, I was actually considering switching to this cause it's short + I'm feeling kind of lazy."
That it was short was the only thing it had going for it. I read it before bed last night. Messy and not creepy or scary just a pile of trash.


Anything fun and upbeat I can add to the list for this month would be appreciated, I'm trying to put more energy into the challenge this year. I kept getting distracted by other books last year. :(



ETA: Apparently The Power isn't coming out in 2019. So it might be The Woman in the Window now lol.
message 75:
by
Rabbit {Paint me like one of your 19th century gothic heroines!}
(new)




I was considering picking a second book to fit challenge if I finished early but I found this month's theme so hard that I'm just gonna read something light from my tbr instead lol.



message 83:
by
Rabbit {Paint me like one of your 19th century gothic heroines!}
(new)

message 85:
by
Rabbit {Paint me like one of your 19th century gothic heroines!}
(new)

My username on LJ is brit_addict"
What part are you at?

My username on LJ is brit_addict"
What part are you at?"
I just finished chapter 32 where she's about to leave her apartment to go see what's happened across the road.




The book itself was okay. There were lots of character names to remember and some scenes got bogged down with too many details, but it was an interesting story. I wouldn't recommend it if you have a fear of flying, though!

I think I’m gonna try The Sun Is Also A Star next.

I think I’m gonna try The Sun Is Also A Star next."
I'm going to read this because I didn't like "can you keep a secret".


Finally decided on a book for the challenge - The Devil All the Time. I started it and it seems extremely up my alley. I have some work reading/prep I need to get out of the way these next couple days but after that I look forward to getting stuck in.
I put In The Tall Grass on hold... I was planning on tackling It, but realistically I don't think that's going to happen soon lol.


I decided to read The Sun is Also a Star for the challenge. Let me tell you, this did not seem like a book I would enjoy (contemporary? no fantasy elements?? pfft.) I was so pleasantly surprised. Despite not having an immigrant experience and not experiencing racism personally, I still identified my teen self with Natasha a lot. So much of her emotional journey with her father is familiar to me (expect it was my mom). I liked the style, the random asides, and even the ending. (view spoiler)

I'm a bit late to the game but I'm also interested in reading The Knife of Never Letting Go as I have it in my audible library and it was recommended by a friend. I also think Lovecraft Country sounds interesting, so might look into buying that. And I haven't read Little Women since I was 9 so can't remember much, but I saw a film adaptation recently and loved it so might have a look at that too if I can get a copy at the library.
I listened to The Secret History a few years ago narrated by Donna Tartt. It was literally the worst audible experience I have ever had. Sooooo long, sooooo boring and nothing relatable about any of the characters. Also it sounded like Marvin the Paranoid Android reading, it wasn't even touchingly sad, it was self-indulgently morose and repetitive. I was going to give Tartt another shot since The Goldfinch has so many good reviews, but after seeing the LJ post for this I have decided against it.
Finished Can You Keep a Secret? today after having the paperback on my shelf for literally YEARS and it was super cute and now I'm looking forward to the movie.
Books mentioned in this topic
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark (other topics)Little Women (other topics)
Little Women (other topics)
Twenties Girl (other topics)
Can You Keep a Secret? (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Donna Tartt (other topics)Henry James (other topics)
Madeline Miller (other topics)
thanks i think i will read this too