Fantasy Book Club Series discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Nominations and Poll Invitations
>
Nominations for 2015 reads





I was just looking at this but the final part isn't due out until 2016.

I'm afraid The Raven's Shadow series won't be finished until summer 2015 so that's also not eligible for nomination if I'm not mistaken.

I decided to nominate The Powder Mage series by Brian McClellan. The first book is Promise of Blood (which I read and is really amazing) and the third and final book will be out in February so it should be ok.

Several things recommend it. It's a great introductory look at a classic author, it has NONE of the triggers that his other series do, and it has a lovely depth, both to story, character, and style, that offers a lot of ground for discussion. The books are large, the concepts are deep, and it packs everything into a two volume package.

He's a great writer, a hardworking dude and deserves all the exposure he can get.

Nominate: Shadowmarch, This has been on the shelf for some time and should be read.
Janny wrote: "I'd like to nominate the Mordant's Need duology by Stephen R. Donaldson. It's two very long books, The Mirror of Her Dreams and A Man Rides Through.
Sever..."
Second.....Mordant's Need duology.
Sever..."
Second.....Mordant's Need duology.
message 23:
by
Kathi, There’s no such thing as too many books!
(last edited Nov 08, 2014 09:09PM)
(new)
I will second the Shadowmarch series by Tad Williams. I've already read Mordant's Need and really liked it, so I'm going for something I have on my shelf but haven't read.

Both series are on my to-be-reread list.
Tara wrote: "I am just wondering, if the group read a series back in 2011 (like the Farseer Trilogy) wouldn't it be ok to read it again? I am sure there are a lot of new members in the group that were not membe..."
I'm not a moderator so I don't know the answer to this, but I will say that those discussions are still available and open for comments to be added. I read the Farseer Trilogy earlier this year and read each part of the discussion here as I finished each book. It helped deepen my understanding and appreciation. In the past, I have commented on "old" discussions as well and sometimes that revives the conversation. I plan, as I read other series that this group has already read, to use the old discussions in the same way.
I'm not a moderator so I don't know the answer to this, but I will say that those discussions are still available and open for comments to be added. I read the Farseer Trilogy earlier this year and read each part of the discussion here as I finished each book. It helped deepen my understanding and appreciation. In the past, I have commented on "old" discussions as well and sometimes that revives the conversation. I plan, as I read other series that this group has already read, to use the old discussions in the same way.

I re-read them with the group but would pop into an updated thread.
Ran wrote: "Tad Williams 's The Dragonbone Chair trilogy also known as "Memory,Sorrow and Thorn""
Hi Ran, we can only have one nomination.
We've read Black company. We've also read Broken Kingdom.

Seconded:
Mordant's Need
Memory Sorrow Thorn(acceptable nom?, did two)
Shadowmarch
Powder Mage
Coldfire
Nominated:
Prospero's Daughter
Tower and Knife
Lightbringer-withdrawn
Winds of Forelands
Imriel's Trilogy
2 noms: Shannara OR Memory Thorn Shadow(which has 2nd)
Awaiting a mod:
Broken Empire (has 2nd)-read
Farseer-read
Game of Thrones-unfinished
Black Company-read
Raven's Shadow- not eligible

Just checked UK kindle, book one £5.99, book two extra £3. Book three due 10th Feb £6.99. If his book two will drop in price then.

I want to second this, even though the series isn't complete it's definitely worth the attention.

Seconded:
Mordant's Need
Memory Sorrow Thorn(acceptable nom?, did two)
Shadowmarch
Powder Mage
Coldfire
Nominated:
Prospero's Daugh..."
Tower and Knife Trilogy by Mazarkis Williams

As an alternative, I would propose David Gemmel and his Drenai saga.
We recently read Black Magician and Broken Empire was just this year! So no...
We read Black Company just a year or two ago...
you are more than welcome to re-visit old threads and keep the commentary going. Most of us who are regular readers here love to talk about them!
We read Black Company just a year or two ago...
you are more than welcome to re-visit old threads and keep the commentary going. Most of us who are regular readers here love to talk about them!
We don't want two series by the same author competing! This has been problematic before.....
so Shadow's March or Memory, Sorrow thorn but not both.
Edit: Memory sorrow throne was a second nom so it is eliminated
so Shadow's March or Memory, Sorrow thorn but not both.
Edit: Memory sorrow throne was a second nom so it is eliminated
Ran wrote: "Tad Williams 's The Dragonbone Chair trilogy also known as "Memory,Sorrow and Thorn""
Ran-you already have a nomination so I will eliminate this one
Ran-you already have a nomination so I will eliminate this one
Marco wrote: "Hello everyone! Sorting through our bookshelf I noticed that about half of Ian Cameron Esslemont's Malazan Empire is marked as read. How about reading the whole thing? The final book came out this ..."
I love Malazan more than anyone! I would happily do the ones we missed as a side read...
I love Malazan more than anyone! I would happily do the ones we missed as a side read...
David wrote: "Rigante series by David Gemmell."
Since we have a Gemmel nom I am not counting this nomination
Since we have a Gemmel nom I am not counting this nomination
I have been wanting to read City of Saints and Madmen forever! This is the Ambergris series
I will second Prospero Lost
I will second Prospero Lost
Lovish wrote: "How about The black magician trilogy by Trudy Caravan"
This is the series we just finished, but there was actually very little discussion. Anyone who wants to read it and add to the discussion, please do. I would join the conversation since I just read it with the group.
This is the series we just finished, but there was actually very little discussion. Anyone who wants to read it and add to the discussion, please do. I would join the conversation since I just read it with the group.

http://www.goodreads.com/series/40522...
If I'm not mistaken the Rigante numbers 4 books (for some reason it's called a trilogy though...).
/series/4284...

This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Sword of Shannara Trilogy (other topics)The Sword of Shannara Trilogy (other topics)
Legend (other topics)
Legend (other topics)
The Sword of Shannara Trilogy (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
David Eddings (other topics)Stephen R. Donaldson (other topics)
Tad Williams (other topics)
Tad Williams (other topics)
Stephen R. Donaldson (other topics)
More...
Our dark Tower read will finish this month, and Long Price in February, so we need some new material!
Please nominate any fantasy series that is or will be FINISHED in time for our read.
All nominations need a second
Each member may have one nomination and one second.
No repeating an author from another nomination-this just divides votes!
Please check to make sure your nomination has not been read by the group previously (the bookshelf)
Be creative!
Nominated and seconded:
Mordant's Need
The Emperor's Knife
Black Sun Rising
Promise of Blood
Shadowmarch
The Sword of Shannara
Prospero Lost
Nominated needing seconds:
Rules of Ascension
Kushiel's Scion
Legend
Dance Of The Goblins
City of Saints and Madmen