2022 ONTD Reading Challenge discussion
2020 ♦️ARCHIVES♦️January
>
January Wrap-Up
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Lea
(last edited Dec 30, 2019 07:13AM)
(new)
Dec 30, 2019 07:02AM

reply
|
flag

I honestly thought the narrator was going to make it out of the conference room, but then I remembered I was reading Roald Dahl 😂 The ending was cute with the boy and his Grandmamma bonding even more. Not sure I liked the “You should die with your grandma� undertones but I can forget that.
I think I’ll also read Death on the Nile since I liked Murder on the Orient Express!


i'll be interested to see how it translates to the screen, because it could get really dull, OR it could be that creepy, unsettling vibe.


I honestly thought the..."
I just finished it and the 'dying with your grandma' bit does seem depressing. I too thought he'd make it out of the conference room! Haha.

I enjoyed the first half more than the second half. Dahl is just so good at building these worlds that totally make sense within its realm. But after the witch showdown, I guess I expected it to follow more with the protagonist in the future telling the reader more clues to avoid witches, but it wasn't quite the same.

Choosing to read the audiobook version, however, deffo helped me keep my attention in the goings on.
In any case, I can see how the book eventually became a classic. The writing was pretty solid throughout (though I deffo side-eyed Maxim's random mean behavior in the beginning. Like, when he tells the nameless narrator that he wishes she could never age to 36 and beyond.)

i'll be interested t..."
I can recommend the 1940s version directed by Hitchcock for moodiness. Also, Joan Fontaine does a good job on being naive without going overboard. Depending on your own feelings abt Lawrence Olivier, his version of Maxim might be kinda meh or smouldering IDK, lol. I've also watched the 1979 version and 1997 one too. They were okay-ish but less creepy than expected. Out of the two, the 1997 is far more solid than the 1979 one.
The fact that armie hammer is Maxim (when so many other good actors are right here to do that role) really makes me salty.

There were times when it felt a little padded, though. It provably could have lost a couple dozen pages. Now I’m ready for the film.



i'll ..."
i'll be sure to check out the Hitchcock version for sure. I could see where as a film it could be done with an unsettling vibe and have that be really effective, i just didn't feel that coming through the pages. Which, i still really enjoyed the book it just wasn't the creep-fest i was expecting.




This was a very entertaining horror with elements of comedy and wonderful pop culture references. I enjoyed the story and liked the ending too. The physical version of the book is so amazingly designed like an IKEA catalog.

This was a very entertaining horror with elements of comedy and wonderful pop culture references. I enjoyed..."
Omg that it's designed like an Ikea catalog sounds amazing! I'm adding that to my tbr list


Oh god; that was my original pick and I ended up putting it down in favour for Normal People because it was taking me so long to get through. I had to like, decipher & analyze the writing to know what was going on half the time. Idk if I'm gonna go back.

The top review for the book on ŷ is hilarious and I completely agree with it.



I, like many others, read Little Fires Everywhere. I thought it was really well done, especially the characterizations. It was an engaging book and I'm interested to catch the miniseries.

I enjoyed it for the most part, but the phonetic spelling of "simple working folk"'s speech did my head in, especially downright mocking the swearing one. Not a sport I'd expect from an Irishman...
Dainey, so I watched the Dracula adaptation as I was very curious and it is SO. EMBARRASSING. I don’t know what it is about the source material that makes people come up with such bizarre adaptations. The main actor did his best though, poor guy.
I finished A Suitable Boy!!!!!!!! I fucking did it!!!!!!!! It was great, I can't wait for the TV series. I think it will be fantastic because I have faith in Mira Nair and the excellent cast she picked (Tabu!!!!! queen!!!)

message 30:
by
Rabbit {Paint me like one of your 19th century gothic heroines!}
(new)

With Dracula, it took a little while to get used to the sheer amount of words. But given its being told in first person - makes sense to have so much being written. Also, I havent read much 19th century literature but I think its fairly standard?
The Secret Garden was I thought a re-read but turns out, I think I had internalised the 1990s film. I very much enjoyed the novel. I can appreciate the novel, the film and possibly the new film as individual items.
I didnt realise it was written in 1911 and so working out that Colin and Dickon were very likely involved in WW1 and definitely WW2 was sad to think about given the magical nature of the novel.

Back to the book, I enjoyed it! Mostly because Indira Varma narrated it, and she's AMAZING. It was so lovely to escape to a beautiful garden and see two children grow into themselves along with it. I didn't love the racism ingrained in the text; it threw me.
Is anyone watching the Little Fires Everywhere mini-series on Hulu? It premiered last week. This was the book I read for January, but I didn't feel like there was as much black-vs-white racial tension in it between the families? (I know there was because of Brian, but I'm talking the Mia-Pearl-Elena dynamic.) Did I completely misread or was that written in because of the casting?
I know I’m incredibly late but � When this challenged started, I originally wanted to re-read Stargirl for this but then switched to Normal People. Didn’t expect much but I loved the writing.
Books mentioned in this topic
Normal People (other topics)Stargirl (other topics)
Rebecca (other topics)
Dracula (other topics)
Normal People (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Grady Hendrix (other topics)Grady Hendrix (other topics)