On The Same Page discussion
2023 Independent Challenges
>
Lillie's 2023 Independent Challenge

� 1. Holloway, Richard. A Little History of Religion 3 stars 7/20/23
�2. Jordan, Leslie. How Y'all Doing?: Misadventures and Mischief from a Life Well Lived 4.5 stars 1/1/23
�3. Malerman, Josh. A House at the Bottom of a Lake 2 stars 1/29/23
�4. Rowley, Steven. The Guncle 4 stars 1/28/23

�1. Ferguson, Jen. The Summer of Bitter and Sweet [Feb] 3 stars 2/6/23
�2. Lafferty, Mur. Station Eternity [Mar] 4 stars 3/14/23
�3. Gudenkauf, Heather. The Overnight Guest [Apr] 4 stars 4/4/23
�4. Allende, Isabel. Violeta [May] 4 stars 5/17/23
�5. Zevin, Gabrielle. Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow [Aug] DNF
�6. Quinn, Kate. The Diamond Eye [Sep] 3.5 stars 9/12/23
�7. Brookshire, Bethany. Pests: How Humans Create Animal Villains [Oct] 4 stars 10/10/23
�8. Reavley, Betsy. Murder at the Book Club [Nov] 3.5 stars 11/14/23
�9. Davis, Viola. Finding Me [Dec] 5 stars 12/12/23

�1. Evans, Claire L. Broad Band: The Untold Story of the Women Who Made the Internet 3 stars 1/17/23
�2. Kean, Sam. The Violinist's Thumb: And Other Lost Tales of Love, War, and Genius, as Written by Our Genetic Code 3.5 stars 2/16/23
�3. Schultz, Kathryn. Lost & Found: A Memoir 4 stars 5/4/23
�4. Valentine, Carla. The Science of Murder: The Forensics of Agatha Christie 3 stars 10/21/23

�1. John, Jessica. Bad Cree: A Novel [Jan 10] 5 stars 1/25/23
�2. Kitasei, Yume. The Deep Sky [Jul 18] 4.5 stars 9/7/23
�3. Sutanto, Jesse Q. Vera Wong's Unsolicited Advice for Murderers [Mar 14] 3.5 stars 6/14/23
�4. Wells, Martha. System Collapse [Nov 14] 4.5 stars 12/31/23
�5. Willis, Connie. The Road to Roswell [Jun 27] 2 stars 7/13/23

�1. Addison Allen, Sarah. Other Birds 3.5 stars 5/1/23
� 2. Slocumb, Brendan. The Violin Conspiracy 4 stars 6/10/23
�3. Toltz, Steve. Here Goes Nothing 2 stars 1/26/23
�4. Washington, Bryan. Memorial 3.5 stars 5/23/23

�1. Ashford, Lindsay Jayne. The Woman on the Orient Express 3.5 stars 9/15/23
�2. de Gramont, Nina. The Christie Affair 1 star 2/2/23
�3. Garmus, Bonnie. Lessons in Chemistry 4 stars 6/3/23
�4. Shafak, Elif. The Island of Missing Trees 4 stars 11/9/23

�1. Cleeves, Ann. The Rising Tide (Vera Stanhope #10) 4.5 stars 3/6/23
�2. Horowitz, Anthony. The Twist of a Knife (Hawthrone & Horowitz #4) 4 stars 1/9/23
�3. Jurczyk, Eva. The Department of Rare Books and Special Collections 1 star 7/2/23
�4. Phillips, Gary. One-Shot Harry 2/1/23 4 stars
�5. St. James, Simone. The Book of Cold Cases 3.5 stars 3/20/23

�1. Dean, Sunyi. The Book Eaters 3.5 stars 7/3/23
�2. Marske, Freya. A Restless Truth (The Last Binding #2) 3 stars 3/25/23
�3. Rivera Garza, Cristina. The Taiga Syndrome 3 stars 8/24/23
�4. Shepherd, Peng. The Cartographers 4 stars 1/18/23

�1. Chambers, Becky. A Prayer for the Crown-Shy 3.5 stars 6/21/23
�2. Corey, James S.A. Babylon's Ashes (The Expanse #6) 4 stars 5/22/23
�3. Erlick, Nikki. The Measure 2.5 stars 1/8/23
�4. Taylor, Jodi. A Second Chance (The Chronicles of St. Mary's #3) 3.5 stars 11/15/23
�5. Wexler, Django. Hard Reboot 3.5 stars 8/25/23

�1. Dimaline, Cherie. The Marrow Thieves (The Marrow Thieves #1) 4 stars 3/31/23
âœ� 2. Ferrada, MarÃa José. How to Order the Universe 2 stars 8/27/23
�3. Ibrahim, Maiya. Spice Road 4 stars 7/10/23
�4. Palasi Andreades, Daphne. Brown Girls 3.5 stars 11/23/23

�1. Dennis, Patrick. Auntie Mame: An Irreverent Escapade (Auntie Mame #1) DNF
�2. du Maurier, Daphne. My Cousin Rachel 4.5 stars 12/5/23
� 3. von Armin, Elizabeth. The Enchanted April 4 stars 4/13/23
� 4. Wilde, Oscar. The Importance of Being Earnest 4 stars 3/23/23

�1. Gill, Nikita. Where Hope Comes From: Poems of Resilience, Healing and Light 4 stars 11/7/23
�2. Gorman, Amanda. Call Us What We Carry 4.5 stars 2/21/23
�3. Harjo, Joy. An American Sunrise 4 stars 11/6/23
�4. St. Vincent Millay, Edna. Renascence and Other Poems 3 stars 1/31/23

�1. Evaristo, Bernardine. Girl, Woman, Other 4 stars 3/1/23
�2. Fofana, Sidik. Stories from the Tenants Downstairs 3 stars 3/18/23
�3. Melnick, Kseniya. Snow in May: Stories 2 stars 12/13/23
�4. Orange, Tommy. There There 4 stars 3/21/23

1. Adam’s, Lyssa Kay. A Very Merry Bromance 4* 1/2
2. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Takes Stock 3.5* 1/6
3. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries on the Ball 3.5* 1/12
4. Gray, Claudia. The Murder of Mr. Wickham 4* 1/14
5. Weaver, Ashley. A Peculiar Combination 4* 1/14
6. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries on the Trail 3.5* 1/22
7. Fawcett, Heather. Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries 3.5* 1/23
8. Raybourn, Deanna. Killers of a Certain Age 4.5* 1/27
9. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Plays the Cook 3.5* 1/27
10. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries and the Missing Alibi 3.5* 1/29
11. Thorogood, Robert. The Marlow Murder Club 4* 2/1
12. Page, Sally. The Keeper of Stories 3.5* 2/4
13. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Stands Corrected 3* 2/8
14. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Takes the Stage 3.5* 2/13
15. Harper, Jane. Exiles 3.5* 2/18
16. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Questions the Answer 3.5* 2/19
17. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Reveals Her Art 3.5* 2/21
18. Chow, Jennifer J. Death by Bubble Tea 3* 2/22
19. Neely, Barbara. Blanche on the Lam (Blanche White #1) 4* 2/23
20. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Takes the Cake 3.5* 3/2
21. Lin, Ed. Ghost Month 2.5* 3/2
22. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Rocks the Boat 3.5* 3/3
23. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Weeds the Plot 3.5* 3/4
24. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Pinches the Post 4* 3/4
25. Cambridge, Colleen. Murder at Mallowan Hall 4* 3/5
26. Schellman, Katharine. The Body in the Garden 3.5* 3/8
27. Brown, Diane Marie. Black Candle Women 2.5* 3/16
28. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Pleads Her Case 3* 3/17
29. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Sweeps the Chimney 3.5* 3/19
30. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Stalks the Hunter 3* 3/19
31. Chiang, Ted. Exhalation 2.5* 3/28
32. Robb, J.D. Encore in Death 4* 4/1
33. Mandanna, Sangu. The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches 4* 4/3
34. McGeorge, Chris. A Murder at Balmoral 2* 4/6
35. Gagnon, Jilly. All Dressed Up: A Novel 2* 4/9
36. Cleverly, Barbara. Fall of Angels 3* 4/11
37. Alexander, Poppy. The Littlest Library 3.5* 4/12
38. Claire, Ann. Dead and Gondola 3* 4/16
39. McFetridge, John. Every City Is Every Other City 2* 4/18
40. Rothschild, Peggy. Playing Dead 3.5* 4/20
41. Hasting, Anastasia. Of Manners and Murder 4* 4/23
42. Krentz, Jayne Ann. When All the Girls Have Gone3* 4/25
43. Krentz, Jayne Ann. Promise Not to Tell 3* 4/27
44. Krentz, Jayne Ann. Untouchable 3* 4/29
45. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries and the Silent Knight 3.5* 5/2
46. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Appeals the Verdict 3.5* 5/3
47. Bennett, S.J. The Windsor Knot 3.5* 5/4
48. Adams, Ellery. The Secret, Book & Scone Society 3* 5/5
49. Adams, Ellery. The Whispered Word 3* 5/5
50. Adler-Olsen, Jussi. The Shadow Murders 3.5* 5/7
51. Glass, Eva. Alias Emma 4* 5/8
52. Smith, Alexander McCall. Tears of the Giraffe 4* 5/18
53. Smith, Alexander McCall. Morality for Beautiful Girls 4* 5/19
54. Taylor, John. Benedict Cumberbatch Reads Sherlock Holmes' Rediscovered Railway Stories: Four Original Short Stories 2.5* 5/12
55. Adams, Ellery. The Book of Candlelight 3* 5/21
56. Corey, James S.A. Strange Dogs 2.5* 5/22
57. Smith, Alexander McCall. The Kalahari Typing School for Men 4* 5/24
58. Adams, Ellery. Ink and Shadows 3* 5/25
59. Smith, Alexander McCall. The Department of Sensitive Crimes 3* 5/26
60. Li, Grace D. Portrait of a Thief 2* 5/28
61. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries and the Best Laid Plans 3.5* 5/27
62. Adams, Ellery. The Vanishing Type 3.5* 5/27
63. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries and the Feast of St. Stephen 3.5* 6/3
64. Adams, Ellery. Paper Cuts 2.5* 6/4
65. Henry, Emily. Happy Place 2.5* 6/5
66. Smith, Alexander McCall. In the Company of Cheerful Ladies 4* 6/5
67. Thomas, Sherry. A Tempest at Sea 4* 6/7
68. Thorogood, Robert. Death Comes to Marlow 4* 6/11
69. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Holds the Trump 3.5* 6/13
70. Smith, Alexander McCall. Blue Shoes and Happiness 4* 6/15
71. Smith, Alexander McCall. The Good Husband of Zebra Drive 4* 6/16
72. Smith, Alexander McCall. The Miracle at Speedy Motors 4* 6/17
73. Child, Lincoln. Deep Storm 4* 6/19
74. Armstrong, Kelley. A Rip Through Time 3.5* 6/20
75. Montimore, Margarita. Acts of Violet 4* 6/23
76. Liu, Simu. We Were Dreamers: An Immigrant Superhero Origin Story 3.5* 6/24
77. Kim, Fay. Love & Saffron 4* 6/25
78. DeWitt, Helen. The English Understand Wool 4* 6/28
79. Johnson, Maureen. Your Guide to Not Getting Murdered in a Quaint English Village 4* 6/30
80. Willis, Connie. The Road to Roswell 2 stars 7/12
81. Rosenblum, Emma. Bad Summer People 4* 7/13
82. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries in the Nick of Time 3.5* 7/14
83. Child, Lincoln. Terminal Freeze 3* 7/15
84. Armstrong, Kelley. The Poisoner's Ring 3.5* 7/16
85. Smith, Alexander McCall. Tea Time for the Traditionally Built 4* 7/17
86. Godfrey, Sierra. A Very Typical Family 3.5* 7/19
87. O'Connor, Carlene. Murder in an Irish Village 3* 7/20
88. O'Connor, Carlene. No Strangers Here: A Riveting Irish Mystery 3* 7/22
89. O'Connor, Carlene. Murder at an Irish Wedding 3* 7/24
90. O'Connor, Carlene. Murder in an Irish Churchyard 3* 7/26
91. Chern, Lina. Play the Fool 4* 7/28
92. Smith, Alexander McCall. The Double Comfort Safari Club 4* 7/31
93. Harrow, Alix E. A Mirror Mended 2.5* 8/1
94. Joyce, Rachel. Maureen 2.5* 8/2
95. Jimenez, Abby. Part of Your World 3.5* 8/4
96. Huber, Anna Lee. This Side of Murder 3* 8/6
97. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries and the Yuletide Weddings 3* 8/8
98. Ferguson, Hannah. The Infinite Miles 2* 8/9
99. Huber, Anna Lee. Treacherous Is the Night 3.5* 8/11
100. Moore, Ian. Death and Croissants 3* 8/12
101. O'Connor, Carlene. Murder in an Irish Pub 3* 8/14
102. Smith, Alexander McCall. The Saturday Big Tent Wedding Party 4* 8/16
103. Huber, Anna Lee. Penny for Your Secrets 3.5 stars 8/18
104. Engberg, Katrine. The Tenant 3.5* 8/19
105. Baldree, Travis. Legends & Lattes 4.5* 8/20
106. Nesbø, Jo. Killing Moon 5* 8/21
107. Jimenez, Abby. Yours Truly 3.5* 8/22
108. O'Connor, Carlene. Murder in an Irish Cottage 3* 8/23
109. Van Pelt, Shelby. Remarkably Bright Creatures 4.5* 8/26
110. Talty, Morgan. Night of the Living Rez 4* 8/27
111. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Speaks Her Mind 3.5* 8/28
112. Cruz, Angie. How Not to Drown in a Glass of Water 4* 8/29
113. Engberg, Katrine. The Butterfly House 3* 8/30
114. Smith, Alexander McCall. The Limpopo Academy of Private Detection 4* 9/1
115. Engberg, Katrine. The Harbor 3* 9/2
116. O'Connor, Carlene. Murder at an Irish Christmas 3* 9/4
117. Hollis, Lee. Poppy Harmon Investigates 3.5* 9/5
118. Hollis, Lee. Poppy Harmon and the Hung Jury 3.5* 9/6
119. Hollis, Lee. Poppy Harmon and the Pillow Talk Killer 3* 9/9
120. Smith, Alexander McCall. The Minor Adjustment Beauty Salon 4* 9/11
121. Christie, Agatha. Murder in Mesopotamia 4* 9/19
122. Hollis, Lee. Poppy Harmon and the Backstabbing Bachelor 3* 9/23
123. Moses, Ose Utomi. The Lies of the Ajungo 3.5* 10/1
124. Smith, Alexander McCall. The Handsome Man's Deluxe Café 4* 10/3
125. Osman, Richard. The Last Devil to Die 4* 10/5
126. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries Forges Ahead 3.5* 10/7
127. Christies, Agatha. Double Sin and Other Stories 3* 10/8
128. Manansala, Mia. Murder and Mamon 3.5* 10/14
129. Huber, Anna Lee. A Pretty Deceit 3.5* 10/19
130. Plait, Philip. Under Alien Skies: A Sightseer's Guide to the Universe 3* 10/22
131. Fluke, Joanna. Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder 3* 10/25
132. Fluke, Joanna. Strawberry Shortcake Murder 3* 10/28
133. Fluke, Joanna. Blueberry Muffin Murder3* 11/1
134. Fluke, Joanna. Lemon Meringue Pie Murder 3* 11/3
135. O'Connor, Carlene. Some of Us Are Looking 3.5* 11/4
136. Cates, Bailey. Brownies and Broomsticks 3* 11/6
137. Cates, Bailey. Bewitched, Bothered, and Biscotti 3* 11/7
138. Fluke, Joanna. Fudge Cupcake Murder 3* 11/10
139. Smith, Alexander McCall. The Woman Who Walked in Sunshine 4* 11/11
140. Brightwell, Emily. Mrs. Jeffries and the Mistletoe Mix-Up 3.5* 11/14
141. Fluke, Joanna. Sugar Cookie Murder 3* 11/16
142. Huber, Anna Lee. Murder Most Fair 3.5* 11/17
143. Fluke, Joanna. Peach Cobbler Murder 3* 11/18
144. Huber, Anna Lee. A Certain Darkness 3.5* 11/19
145. Saunders, Kate. The Secrets of Wishtide 3* 11/21
146. Chakraborty, Shannon. The Adventures of Amina al-Sirafi 4.5* 11/30
147. Robb, J.D. Payback in Death 4.5* 12/5
148. du Maurier, Daphne. My Cousin Rachel 4.5* 12/6
cont list with msg #261
These look great, Lillie! I like that you limited yourself to 4 books in each genre, to start with.
Good luck, Lillie!
Good luck, Lillie!



Thanks Lea! I'm going to try to read Klara and the Sun in January. We'll see what kind of mood I'm in, lol. I've been eyeing The Enchanted April for a while now. And, since reading Rebecca this summer, I'm very interested in reading more of Daphne du Maurier and decided on Jamaica Inn as the one to start with.
Have decided to listen to the poets, well, the ones still alive that have audiobooks...

Happy Reading!


Have decided to listen to the poets, well, the ones still alive that have audiobooks..."
I'm also interested in reading more du Maurier, but not sure where to go. I loved Rebecca (one of my top 10 books), but did not find Jamaica Inn to be of the same caliber, so I'm not sure what to read next. I hope you love Jamaica Inn and wonder what the heck I'm talking about. :-)

Thanks! I enjoy reading across genres and have been doing my challenges in a similar fashion for the past several years. But I had more books listed in each category. Felt slightly constrained this year and needed to mix it up a bit. Added a couple new categories and less books listed. So I still challenge myself but have the time and space for mood reading and not feel guilty. Long explanation for needed a slight change, lol

Thanks Martha! Leslie Jordan has 2 books out? I’m so excited! And sad at the same time. I’ll be missing his humor on social media. He really did make quarantine more bearable.

Oh no! You’re making me second guess Jamaica Inn. It was a toss up between My Cousin Rachel and Jamaica Inn.

I three starred it, which means that I liked it, but not nearly as much as Rebecca. If I recall correctly, I hated the ending. It's possible that I read it wrong, though, as most of my GR friends list really liked the ending. So, you'll probably be fine.

My only Daphne du Maurier was Rebecca, which is one of my big favorites and one of the handful books I've ever re-read. So you can imagine, I absolutely loved it. I have these other 2 on my TBR, but haven't read any of them yet. I hope you'll enjoy whichever one you pick!


Have updated Classics. Added what we chose for RL Book Club. And I threw everything out for 2023 Releases and picked 4 new books. Three new-to-me authors and one author that I've read and enjoyed but in sci-fi not fantasy.


I won't be reading for a while, maybe in the summer? Maybe you'll be able to pick up at that time?


I won't be reading for a while, maybe in the summer? Maybe you'll be able to pick up at that time?"
Yes! That would work perfectly! Let's do it!

Done! Will keep it for summer. Let me know when you’re ready.


Really love his voice, both as a narrator and storyteller. I’m sorry that I came in late to the game. Just as I was beginning to appreciate him, he tragically died a couple of months ago. He didn’t shy away from the good or bad in his life as some actors do in a memoir. He let us into his life. It was funny and sad and sweet. 4.5/5 stars
Book #2

No 5 in the Bromance series about a men’s book club who read romances. It’s very sweet and, being a romance, has some steamy scenes. I enjoy these books. They’re a great respite from the realities of our world. Liked the romance between Colton and Gretchen.
Lillie wrote: "Currently reading:
audiobook [spoilers removed]
"
This looks GOOD!! Can't wait to see what you think of it. I may have to add this based on its nomination alone!

"
This looks GOOD!! Can't wait to see what you think of it. I may have to add this based on its nomination alone!


"
This looks GOOD!! Can't wait to see what you think of it. I may have to add this based on its nomination"
😬 I hope you end up liking it more than I did


4th book in the Mrs. Jeffries series. I really like Mrs. Jeffries, the housekeeper of Inspector Witherspoon of Scotland Yard. She and the rest of his staff help him in solving murders behind his back. Love how the characters interact with each other.
Book #4

I really really wanted to like this book. Such an interesting premise, boxes have started appearing to all adults 22 years old and older. The boxes hold strings of different lengths. Which tell how long people live. It's very much about the world we live in, the prejudices detailed. It should've been so much more than it was. It's so funny, because I believe in the politics of the book. But the author failed to keep my interest. Too many characters were crammed in it. In the end, I didn't care what happened to any of them. Bottom line, I hated the author's writing. Gave it the stars I did because I did like the premise and the potential.
Book #5

#4 in the Hawthorne and Horowitz murder series. I really enjoy how the author of these books have written himself into these books. This time out, Horowitz is accused of the murder of the theater critic who panned his play. Loved the interaction between the private detective and the author. Fun outing.
Currently reading one poem every couple of days by Edna St. Vincent Millay from her Renascence and Other Poems collection.


A phd candidate is struggling to finish her dissertation when she comes across something that could blow everything up. We follow Ingrid, the daughter of Taiwanese immigrants, as she deals with out right racism towards Asian Americans as well as internalized racism on a university campus in NY. At first I thought this was going to be a light comedic read but it turned out to be so much more nuanced. Kept me engaged throughout.


I'm really enjoying this series. Another fun one. Realized that this series is over 35 books long. A fact that makes me happy cause these books are a great palate cleanser.
Book #8

The author has taken Jane Austin's world and put all the characters from her books in one place (Emma and George Knightley, Elizabeth and Darcy, the Wentworths, the Bertrams, Colonel and Marianne Brandon). Mr. Wickham from Pride and Prejudice is the murder victim and the son of Darcy and Elizabeth investigates the death that has taken place at a month long house party. Fun. A second one should come out this year. Looking forward to it.


Number 2 in series of 3. It’s listed as a mystery but I’m not sure I’d classify it as such. There is a mystery at the center of it (finding Aunt Vivian) but it’s really more about Nan meandering through her trip to Paris. It’s a little bit romance, a little bit about jazz, about street musicians, a little bit love story of Paris, and a little bit murder mystery. Not Aunt Vic’s murder but someone connected with her. If you’re looking for a straight mystery, this isn’t it. But if you’re looking for a good book to read on a rainy day, try this.
Books mentioned in this topic
How Y'all Doing?: Misadventures and Mischief from a Life Well Lived (other topics)System Collapse (other topics)
Killing Moon (other topics)
Bad Cree (other topics)
Finding Me (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Alexander McCall Smith (other topics)Emily Brightwell (other topics)
Ellery Adams (other topics)
Kwei Quartey (other topics)
Kwei Quartey (other topics)
Reading Group Challenge: (completed)
�1. Alberto Urrea, Luis. The House of Broken Angels 3.5 stars 1/20/23
�2. Atkinson, Kate. Shrines of Gaiety 4.5 stars 2/20/23
�3. Carter, Charlotte. Coq Au Vin (Nanette Hayes #2) 4 stars 1/15/23
�4. Chou, Elaine Hsieh. Disorientation 4 stars 1/10/23
�5. Hood, Ann. Fly Girl: A Memoir 3.5 stars 1/21/23
�6. Ishiguru, Kazuo. Klara and the Sun 2.5 stars 11/23/23
� 7. Jansson, Tove. The Summer Book 2 stars 6/9/23
� 8. Kidd, Jess. The Night Ship 2 stars 3/5/23
�9. McKenzie, Alecia. A Million Aunties 4 stars 5/16/23
�10. Quartey, Kwei. Death at the Voyager Hotel 4 stars 2/10/23
�11. Robinson, Eden. Monkey Beach 3.5 stars 5/3/23
�12. Ruiz Zafón, Carlos. The City of Mist: Stories (The Cemetery of Forgotten Books) 2.5 stars 3/19/23