ŷ

Beta Reader Group discussion

Mark Wm Smith
This topic is about Mark Wm Smith
449 views
PAID services requested > Request for paid beta reader

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Mark (new)

Mark Wm Smith (markwrite-markcom) | 4 comments I believe I posted this on the Services offered board by mistake, so I’m reposting here.

Potential Beta Readers, I’m looking for direct and to the point feedback for this book.

If you're a fan of Chandler, Ross Macdonald, and Lawrence Block... you'll probably enjoy this. It's Matthew Scudder meets DCI John Barnaby. One reader said "Exciting, sexy and suspenseful. A full throttle thrill ride that will keep you on the edge of your seat right up until the end!" about the first book in the series. This isn't your typical murder mystery with a smart detective book, it's... nuanced, complex, witty and psychological insightful.

I wrote this book because the gap between the smart, untainted-by-humanity sleuth and the miserable, doomed detective with no hope has grown so wide. I wanted a detective who had real problems that threatened their happiness and contentment, but also drove them to overcome, both in the detection of crime, and in the fulfillment of personal obligations.

If you HATE the same old cheesy amateur sleuth without a care or doomed P.I./Detective without hope, but love complicated detectives with real problems they actually try to solve, then this book is for you.

Back cover copy
Sales Are Down. Murder Is Up.
Connor Pierce struggles to salvage the foreign car dealership his father left him, despite his mother's constant hindrance to every sale. Its the year 2000 in nationalist Eastern Montana, and he's kept the business alive through Y2K. His part-time P.I. business barely helps to make ends meet, and his routine absence displeases his wife. And he rarely sees his children.

When a major deal falls through, Connor does the only thing he knows to do� find lost things and solve mysteries. He takes on a P.I. job 600 miles away, in the wild mountains near Canada, to help his rebellious sister find a missing child and make enough money to survive the holiday.

Then, things take a dark turn � his reckless investigation style triggers a murder that lands his sister in jail. He must solve the murder to set her free. Local law wants him out of town and an underground network of human traffickers backed by East Coast gangsters run interference.

As the stakes grow, he must confront his family's long-standing grudges and trauma to clear his sister's name. The clock is ticking, and every step he takes brings him closer to the edge of a treacherous cliff with no safety net below.


message 2: by Blessing (new)

Blessing | 134 comments Hi Mark!
I love detective books so much and the thrill that comes with them. I would love to read your WIP if you’ll have me.
Here's my website; - you can flip through it to know more about me and my services.

Thank you 🤍


message 3: by Cielo (new)

Cielo (cielobellerose) | 139 comments Hi! I have over three years of verifiable experience as a beta reader, and I'd love to be considered.
My service includes:
-Thorough feedback report addressing elements such as: plot and character development, narration and writing style, plot holes and inconsistencies, pacing, worldbuilding, dialogue, dull moments, etc.
-Inline comments addressing specific elements and including my reaction to key moments in the novel.
-The option to answer up to 20 specific questions you may have in your novel, which you can submit either before or after receiving my feedback.
My rate is $1 per 1000 words.
Here is my page in which you can see a full list of testimonials + more info on my service:
If you're interested in working with me, please contact me via email at: [email protected].
Thank you!


message 4: by Lana (new)

Lana | 67 comments Hello!
I am an experienced and affordable beta reader having beta read plenty of manuscripts, finished 3 of my own and working on 2 more. I am happy to offer my services.

My prices are affordable and highly negotiable.

I will provide you with the following if you choose to hire me for my services:
- Detailed in-line comments on your text
- A full document detailing feedback and thoughts about plot, characters, setting etc.
- I will give you a "review" and a "rating" after finishing the manuscript
- I will fix grammar and spelling mistakes
- I will answer any questions you have about my feedback or any questions you specifically have about your manuscript or writing
- I can promise a quick turnaround rate (depending on the length of your work)
- If there's anything additional you would like me to do/give feedback on, I'll be more than happy to do that as well

If you're interested please email me at [email protected] I am more than happy to give the help needed!

reply | edit | delete | flag


message 5: by Sarah � (new)

Sarah ☾ (thenarrativeatelier) | 78 comments Hi!

As an avid reader of murder and thriller, I believe I would be a great beta reader for your manuscript! My passion began with reading books from Agatha Christie (you would know her, she is the queen of murder mystery with her famous detective Mr Poirot)

Aside from the extensive knowledge in books related to your genre
I provide :-
� in-line commenting
� detailed chapter report
� detailed overall report
� character report (newly added!)

� and timely turnaround

You can see my testimonial at

/topic/show/...

And check out my website at



If interested sent me a mail at [email protected] after which I’ll send my sample report and free 1000 word reading to see if we’re compatible

Thank you


message 6: by Racheal (last edited Jul 31, 2024 10:46PM) (new)

Racheal Joy | 41 comments Hello Mark,

You had me at psychologically insightful murder mystery. I believe my experience with mysteries and thrillers can help me provide detailed feedback that can make a difference.

I provide feedback with the help of
� In-line comments, reactions and suggestions

� A detailed reader report covering a chapter by chapter review, suggestions and observations for improvement, general analysis of plot, character, setting, etc and overall thoughts

� Grammar corrections, spell checks, tense and POV

� Detailed, helpful answers to any questions you may have for me after beta reading.

To view my testimonials, you can click on the link below
/topic/show/...

For further discussion, you can contact me via [email protected]. Let me help you elevate your manuscript.


message 7: by Ayesha (new)

Ayesha Abdul | 262 comments Hi Mark,
This sounds like something I would enjoy. I am interested in beta reading for you.
My website, has more information about my services, examples of my commenting style, and testimonials. There are also more testimonials on my ŷ thread:
/topic/show/...



Thanks,
Ayesha
[email protected]


message 8: by Mamta (new)

Mamta Menon (mamtamenon) | 121 comments Hi,

I’d love to work with you. My email id is [email protected]


Here is my link with testimonials:


/topic/show/...


Looking forward to hearing from you.

Regards,
Mamta


message 9: by Liz (new)

Liz (joycecarolnopes) | 134 comments "If you HATE the same old cheesy amateur sleuth without a care or doomed P.I./Detective"

Me: *Raises hand*

In all seriousness, I'd love to discuss a potential beta read for you! If you're interested, please reach out to me at my email: [email protected]

Thanks and have a good one,

Lisa


message 10: by Melinda (new)

Melinda  Taylor (mtaylor67) | 92 comments I have beta reading, proofreading, and editing experience and have written many book reviews for books on different platforms. I can beta read a book of any length and can work with any book genre. I am hardworking, reliable, responsible, organized, detail oriented and meet deadlines. I am an effective cross functional communicator, rapid and adaptive learner, committed high receiver, skilled collaborator, dynamic solution-oriented professional. I love beta reading, proofreading, editing and writing reviews and look forward to writing yours.
I am interested in your book. It sounds like an amazing story. I am trying to get back into beta reading, proofreading, and editing after a hiatus and this would be a wonderful start. I have experience with a variety of genres and would love to find out if we are a good fit. I have worked with authors on ŷ, Amazon, and Upwork. I am excited to get started since I love to read and review books. I look forward to hearing from you and wish you all the best in your book's success whether you choose me to work with or not.
Here are my Upwork reviews:
"Melinda delivered excellent work on this project and we enjoyed working with her. Her communication was top-notch, she met all deadlines, and her skills were strong. She adapted and learned whatever had to be learned. At one point we asked for an additional milestone, and she was very forthcoming and happy to meet our new, changing requirements. She was hands-on through the entire process. Her greatest strength has to do with seeing the tiny details, some of which we did not see ourselves. On a personal note, I enjoyed working with her and undoubtedly have additional jobs for her in the future. Don’t hesitate. Hire her!"

"I would work with Melinda again. Her prompt communication, adherence to deadlines, and cooperation was much appreciated, and mark her as a true professional. She's very skilled at what she does, and I couldn't have asked for more. Thank you!"

"Great work! Will definitely rehire for future projects requiring reviews."

"Amazing job! Would definitely recommend her!"

"Excellent job"


message 11: by Helen (new)

Helen Odey | 121 comments Hi Mark,

I love detective novels and am curious how Connor will save his sister, her child, and himself. If you're interested in my honest feedback, contact me at [email protected] or here

Thanks,
Helen


message 12: by Stories (new)

Stories Matter (storiesmattereditingservice) | 25 comments This sounds awesome! I would love to take a look at it. I have over 10 years experience in both traditional and indie publishing as an editor/beta reader and formatter. You can reach me at
[email protected]


message 13: by Marvin (new)

Marvin | 185 comments Mark wrote: "I believe I posted this on the Services offered board by mistake, so I’m reposting here.

Potential Beta Readers, I’m looking for direct and to the point feedback for this book.

If you're a fan of..."


I'd argue that I just wrote one of these myself (7 drafts finished) for the same reasons. I'd read your first two chapters for free and give feedback.


message 14: by elle ☕️ (new)

elle ☕️ | 83 comments I would love to work with you! Feel free to reach out to me on Fiverr.




message 15: by Luculle (new)

Luculle Stols (realliferebel) | 43 comments Hi Mark,

The book blurb sounds fab. I am interested in working on your crime fiction novel.

I provide constructive feedback on your manuscript. Let’s collaborate to reach your goals by leveraging my experience, expertise, and skills.

When you work with me:

1. I read your submission cover to cover and give feedback on the structural strengths, weaknesses, inconsistencies, and noted errors.
2. I follow a methodology that provides clear, actionable recommendations, inclusive of inline comments, and a comprehensive reader report covering the following structural elements:

• Opening Scene
� Characterisation and Motivation
� Plot and Conflict
� Pacing
� Setting and Worldbuilding
� Dialogue
� Craft
� Overall Impression
� And more

Why trust me with your project?

I am a copywriter, editor, and natural storyteller. I am also an Indie Author, published on Amazon in the Juvenile Fiction genre. I have been collaborating with authors and writers on their book projects since 2014 and am familiar with the essential elements of the publishing process.

� About My Service -
� Enquiry/Order Here -
� FIVE Star Client Reviews -

Any questions, special requirements, or limited budget? Write me a note - [email protected].

Looking forward to working on your project.

Kind regards
Luculle Stols


message 16: by Emmanuel (new)

Emmanuel Odey | 100 comments Hi Mark,
The story line is gripping. I'd like to beta read it on Fiverr, if you still need a beta reader. Here's my Fiverr link:
I hope to hear from you.
Regards,
Emmanuel


message 17: by Anna (new)

Anna (andzela) | 73 comments Hi Mark, I would love to beta read for you.

Here are my rates and what I offer.

I will read your story and send you very detailed feedback, often times specifying what are my reflections as I am reading. (a reader report)
I will focus on:
- the characters (are they likable, enjoyable, did you manage your goal of making them awful ...)

- the story (pacing, great moments, twists, dead ends, dragging parts...)

- is your world believable? Is it detailed enough, or too detailed. 

-repetitions, beautifully written parts, quotes I loved.

$20 for 10000 words (2 days delivery)
$60 for 50000 words (7 days delivery)
$100 for a 100000 words (12 days delivery)

My email is [email protected]
References and sample work are available upon request.
Martin Brisebois [email protected]
Tammy Euliano [email protected]
Jaclyn Warren [email protected]
Maggie Shaw [email protected]
Guy Boutin [email protected]

𲵲,
Anna


back to top