ŷ

Once Upon a Broken Heart (Once Upon a Broken Heart, #1) Once Upon a Broken Heart discussion


131 views
How can jacks have 2 one true loves?

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Mina Kashif Like tella and evangline. THis makes no sense to me


Amanda yeahhhh that felt like a bit of a plot hole to me—I’ve read the trilogy 5 times and it still doesn’t really make sense. I think the way it was kinda explained is that the girl who would make Jacks� heart beat again (Tella) would never love him, but the girl who is Jacks� true love is immune to his kiss (Eva). Idk that’s the most sense I can make of it 🤷‍♀�


June Furey So like it was explained that the fact that only a girl who could never love Jack is immune to his kiss, but I guess true love always wins in the end and it was kind of like a fairytale. I don’t know. All I know is that I was happy when they ended up together.


Matilda I honestly dont know the answer to this but i heard someone say that because tella has legend blood in her she is immune to Jacks kiss. bu again isnt she Jacks true love if she made his heart beat again. gave this series a 5 star tho so fricken good


Satvika Panyam I know ive read this book but i can't remember anything about it lol.


TheyLuvStarry Idk. The book is kinda convoluted, and it has lots of plot holes. I do like it, but some parts just don’t make sense. (I’m pretty sure Stella wasn’t actually Jacks� true love though)


message 7: by M (new) - rated it 5 stars

M You guys REALLY should read the rest of the trilogy


message 8: by M (new) - rated it 5 stars

M ITS REALLY GOOD


message 9: by S (new) - rated it 5 stars

S V But it’s explained in the third book why Tella isn’t his true love. The actual curse it the one girl who survives his kiss will never be able to return his love. Not his one true love.


Priya Patel My understanding is that he was cursed so that the only person immune to his kiss is someone who could never love him. There was a chance with the people he kissed, they just always died. Jacks was Eva's true love because the apples (dragon fire) that tasted like your true love and hers tasted like Jacks(in a way). I think it may have had to do with Aurora or his heart being in the jar, but either way, he could kiss Eva.


back to top