Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge discussion
2019 Challenge Prompt - Advanced
>
50 - A book set in an abbey, cloister, monastery, vicarage, or convent
message 201:
by
Josie
(new)
Mar 10, 2019 06:48AM

reply
|
flag

I'm currently listening to La Belle Sauvage for this prompt, so I agree that it fits, and I recommend the audiobook if you enjoy listening to books!
I just realized that Holy Fools by Joanne Harris (author of the Chocolat trilogy) is set in a convent. I might read it for this prompt since I just finished Chocolat and plan to read the next two in the trilogy.


Angela wrote: "I'm a little surprised no one seems to have mentioned The Priory of the Orange Tree. It's a chunk of a book, but has great reviews. I just picked up a copy from my library and I'm s..."
Wow. That is one huge book, but it does look to be a good read!
Wow. That is one huge book, but it does look to be a good read!



Did you get to the end? How was it? I want to read it and am hoping its as good as it sounds.
Karen wrote: "Angela wrote: "I'm a little surprised no one seems to have mentioned The Priory of the Orange Tree. It's a chunk of a book, but has great reviews. I just picked up a copy from my li..."
I've been wondering about that book too, because the blurb and the reviews make it seem like it won't actually work for this category. I know the title says "priory" but it doesn't sound like it actually takes place in a priory, or cloister or monastery or vicarage or convent.
I've been wondering about that book too, because the blurb and the reviews make it seem like it won't actually work for this category. I know the title says "priory" but it doesn't sound like it actually takes place in a priory, or cloister or monastery or vicarage or convent.

I just finished The Pillars of the Earth, and I really enjoyed it. I listened to the audiobook. It took a long time. The nice thing about a book like this is you really get to know the characters and not just for a short time. I'd highly recommend it.

I am happy to see King of Scars mentioned (another one I've bought but not got to yet). I would be struggling with this one without fantasy!

I did finish it last week, I couldn't put it down! One of my new all time favorites. It is pure fantasy done right, and so refreshing that it's a stand-alone novel! Strong characters, both female and male, and a unique take on dragons and magic. I absolutely loved it, and will be looking for more from this author, should she decide to write something else that is not YA.
After having read it, the main bulk of the story does not take place in the priory (I had assumed too much based on the title), but a small part does. So it can fit, but I used it instead for "A book that includes a wedding".


Elizabeth wrote: "Is this supposed to be set in - as in all/almost all the action takes place in, or is partially in it fine? I read Wicked Saints this year, and am trying to figure out if I can shov..."

Yes, Bitter Greens fits this challenge well.
Oh was she?! Maybe that's why I have that book penciled in as a possibility for this prompt!!! I'm finding this category is trickier than I expected, the book I thought would work doesnt actually fit, so I need to find another.

I am so glad to hear this! I had originally wanted to read Bitter Greens for "A book with bitter (etc.) in the title," but I ended up reading something else. I was struggling for this prompt, so yay!






Have you tried looking for books set in Buddhist monasteries by Asian writers? Saying that, I think a house called a convent is close enough if reading POC is your priority.


I hope it might work here because the blurb says it is about a Conclave getting ready to start at the Vatican.
Steve Berry is a favorite of mine and I would enjoy reading this a lot.







It's not my favorite of the Star Wars books, but Into the Void by Tim Lebbon would work. Of course there are plenty of others.

I have to be honest, it was the title that made me pick this book. I have always been really aware of the way other people's homes smell, in a way similar to the characters of this book who are aware of their outsider status. I hadn't realised that this was a YA book, and actually it doesn't read as young as some others in that category do. The issues of loss, painful family dynamics and teenage pregnancy were dealt with in a way I would expect them to be in a "grown ups" novel, but with just a little less depth, possibly. It was that depth that I did find lacking though, as there are so many complex issues that the characters face that I wanted to really feel the emotions with them, but I appreciate that would have made this book too heavy for the readers Hitchcock had in mind. I think my desire for a deeper dive says a lot about how well the characters came across, and the strength of their stories. For such an easy read there is a lot going on in this book, and I really enjoyed all the different relationships and journeys that the characters have. It all tied up a bit too cleanly for me, but I think that is again a reflection of the fact that at 35 I'm not exactly the target audience for this book, rather than a criticism of the book. Because really, I have no criticisms - this is a compelling read that trusts a YA audience with complex issues, explored with some beautiful writing through the stories of believable characters.


If I remember correctly, Mansfield Park has a brief visit to a vicarage, but no other applicable settings. I don't know anything about The Girl in the Tower, so I'm no help there.


One of the main characters is the abbess (in the the first ten or so of the series, anyway) and at least part of each book takes place at the abbey

Nicole wrote: "reading Bitter Greens for another prompt right now, and it would work for this one, as well. Really enjoying it so far- it's a mix between historical fiction and a fairy tale retelling"
Ooohhh...Bitter Greens looks amazing! :)
Ooohhh...Bitter Greens looks amazing! :)


Books mentioned in this topic
The Sinner (other topics)The Sinner (other topics)
The Handmaid’s Tale (other topics)
The Testaments (other topics)
The Handmaid’s Tale (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Margaret Atwood (other topics)Margaret Atwood (other topics)
G.M. Malliet (other topics)
Ferenc Máté (other topics)
Bonnie-Sue Hitchcock (other topics)
More...