Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Carmen's Reviews > Hunting Badger

Hunting Badger by Tony Hillerman
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
25353295
's review

liked it
bookshelves: mystery, traditionally-published, fiction, he-says, american-author, published1999

Chee relaxed, closed his eyes, recognized that he was feeling much, much better. Why did talking to Joe Leaphorn do that for him? And now this business with Bernie. Worrying about his ankle. Bossing him around. Why did that make him feel so much better? He opened his eyes and looked up at her. A very pretty young lady even when she was frowning at him.

I don't have much to say about this one.

A casino is robbed, two people are murdered and the FBI is swarming all over the area.

Joe Leaphorn is approached by an old acquaintance with a list of names of the men involved, asking Leaphorn to get the list to the FBI without implicating him.

And of course Jim Chee is also assigned to this case. Can he and Leaphorn figure out whodunit and why?
...

NOTES:

- Jim Chee has a cat again. Mentioned in one paragraph in the second chapter. Who is this cat? How did Chee acquire it? We have no flipping idea. Hillerman tells us nothing. We all remember what happened to the LAST cat Jim Chee had... I'm frustrated. I demand a backstory.

- Jim Chee is slowly, slowly starting to realize he might actually like the pretty cop who has a crush on him: one Bernie Manuelito.

Bernie's confidence in him was flattering, if misguided. Why did the thought that Bernie was having an affair with this rent-a-cop disappoint him? It should be a relief. Instead it gave him an empty, abandoned feeling.

It's taken him long enough. Even though absolutely nothing happens between them romantically in this book, they work together and Bernie brings him some food and coffee when he has hurt his ankle.

- Who knows WTF is going on between Joe Leaphorn and Louisa Bourebonette? They appear to be living together in this book. Living together but sleeping in separate bedrooms. They hug once. It seems as if Hillerman, at the end of the novel, is implying that they will be developing a romantic relationship. But don't ask me. They've been fluttering around each other with no clear purpose or intent for years now. I'm not holding my breath.


Tl;dr - An exciting plot about robbers who are anti-government hiding out in the canyons of the Utah/Arizona border. Both Chee and Leaphorn are moving at a glacial pace towards the women in their lives - IF they are even moving at all. It's hard to tell. No one will sit down and have a conversation with each other about love or relationships, so it's all very vague.

Equally slow-moving is the men's relationship with each other. They are kinda-sorta liking each other now? I'd hesitate to say they are close, but they sort-of like each other now. Perhaps by the next book they may actually be friends? I don't want to get too crazy here. We're only FOURTEEN flippin' books in the series and these legendary cops are STILL not friends. Sad. Annoying.
51 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Hunting Badger.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 29, 2015 – Shelved
November 1, 2015 – Started Reading
November 1, 2015 –
page 9
2.83% "What cat? What? A cat? *is confused*"
November 1, 2015 –
page 16
5.03% "Bernie's confidence in him was flattering, if misguided. Why did the thought that Bernie was having an affair with this rent-a-cop disappoint him? It should be a relief. Instead it gave him an empty, abandoned feeling.

Uh-huh."
November 1, 2015 –
page 44
13.84% "Professor Louisa Bourebonette was sleeping in the quieter bedroom, and Leaphorn didn't want to awaken her.

What? What?"
November 1, 2015 –
page 234
73.58% "They're living together?"
November 1, 2015 –
page 241
75.79% "Chee relaxed, closed his eyes, recognized that he was feeling much, much better. Why did talking to Joe Leaphorn do that for him? And now this business with Bernie. Worrying about his ankle. Bossing him around. Why did that make him feel so much better? He opened his eyes and looked up at her. A very pretty young lady even when she was frowning at him."
November 1, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Donna (new)

Donna That's so weird how these books sometimes skip forward without explanation of certain events such as with Leaphorn and Louisa living together. I've never read any books like that and it would annoy me if I did. Hopefully Chee will get a clue about why he feels better around certain people. He seems so detached from his feelings like he's stepped out of himself to view them as something strange to him. I hope the next book will progress in some way or offer explanations with whatever changes do happen. How frustrating this series must be for you to read even though you're enjoying many things about it.


Carmen Hillerman is not the best explainer. I can deal with it, but sometimes it frustrates me. Even though I'm reading the books in order, I often am plagued by the feeling that I missed a book.

On to the next one! Onward and upward! LOL


carol. Ha--you want backstory on the cat?


Carmen YES. Hillerman has this habit of just... plopping things in to the middle of a storyline with no origin or explanation of how these things got there.

I honestly half think he forgot that Chee shipped the cat to Mary Landon and just thought Chee still had a cat for a book before remembering suddenly that he'd gotten rid of it, because this spontaneously generated cat never shows up again ever and is never mentioned again, either. I think it was an editing mistake, honestly.


carol. lol!! nice continuity catch!


message 6: by Carmen (last edited Dec 31, 2015 11:03AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Carmen LOL That's what happens when you read all 18 (or whatever) books in order back-to-back, LOL


message 7: by Greg (new)

Greg Hodgkins Carmen, I'm sure you are right about the cat..TH forgot that Chee had shipped the cat. There is also a big skip in this book when Chee and Cowboy find Timm's airplane. They are heading off where they think Timm hid the plane and two chapters later it is casually mentioned at they found it. Could have used a little more exposition, fear goodness sakes the book is short enough!


Carmen Carmen, I'm sure you are right about the cat..TH forgot that Chee had shipped the cat. There is also a big skip in this book when Chee and Cowboy find Timm's airplane. They are heading off where they think Timm hid the plane and two chapters later it is casually mentioned at they found it. Could have used a little more exposition, fear goodness sakes the book is short enough!

Thanks, Greg!


Lisa Shafer This is my least favorite of his so far. Bleah.


Carmen Lisa wrote: "This is my least favorite of his so far. Bleah."

I'm sorry it was a dud for you, Lisa.


Ms.pegasus All excellent questions/observations!


Carmen Ms.pegasus wrote: "All excellent questions/observations!"

Thank you, Pegasus!


back to top