ŷ

Robin's Reviews > All the Pretty Horses

All the Pretty Horses by Cormac McCarthy
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
36555254
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: national-book-award, 2018, american, literary-fiction, 1001-before-you-die

On the surface, this book is a cowboy adventure. A gritty story in which childhood doesn't exist and two teenage boys, John Grady and Lacey Rawlins, are alone riding in a land foreign to them. They speak when they only truly have something worth saying. They sleep under the stars. Their only possessions are often the clothes on their back, a razor and a toothbrush. Oh, and their horses.

This life is sometimes idyllic, but more often, dangerous. It becomes complicated when they run into Blevins, a kid whose fate entwines with theirs, with disastrous consequences.

As in other books by this author, themes of fate and inevitability echo. Several lines have a prescient quality to happenings later on in the book. And, similar to No Country for Old Men, the wheels of the story are pushed down the hill by one single decision. It's pretty brutal (cauterizing a bullet wound using a heated gun barrel is just one of the cringe-inducing scenes), though truth be told, this is decidedly gentler than other McCarthy books.

So yes, wild west saga. But between the lines, the book couldn't be more romantic. Not Nora Roberts romantic, no, although there is a love story here too. But within this book pulses a heart that beats passionately for the past. This heart is broken for the loss of a time that no longer exists. The ticking clock has left John Grady in a country he doesn't recognise, and to which he no longer belongs.

Set in 1949, he is witnessing is the death of an era. People will watch movies about cowboys, instead of living like them. Elvis and television, office jobs and jello-molded salads - an artificially sanitised culture is around the bend. We don't glimpse the new world in the pages of this book, but we readers know what is ahead, and we know this guy on his horse will be the square peg, a ghostrider, a bewildered and bewildering sight.

This yearning nostalgia is reflected in unbelievably lyrical prose. McCarthy outdoes himself here in lush descriptions that convey a deep romance, while at the same point writing with zero sentimentality. It's a magical mixture of the bleak and the heartfelt.

This novel isn't perfect. The ending, just as in No Country, slows significantly from a galloping story to a series of rambling speeches. But, I just couldn't give it less than five stars. I guess I like romance more than I thought.

At the end of the day, there are few things John Grady can count on. One is his profound solitude. The other: those horses, those pretty horses - time cannot touch them.

166 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read All the Pretty Horses.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 11, 2016 – Shelved
September 15, 2018 – Started Reading
September 23, 2018 –
10.0%
September 30, 2018 –
20.0%
September 30, 2018 –
30.0% "A good-lookin horse is like a good-lookin woman, he said. They're always more trouble than what they're worth."
September 30, 2018 –
50.0% "Nesting cranes that stood singlefooted among the cane on the south shore had pulled their slender beaks from their wingpits to watch. Me quires? she said. Yes, he said. He said her name. God yes, he said."
September 30, 2018 –
50.0% "Nesting cranes that stood singlefooted among the cane on the south shore had pulled their slender beaks from their wingpits to watch. Me quieres? she said. Yes, he said. He said her name. God yes, he said."
October 2, 2018 –
70.0%
October 5, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 63 (63 new)


message 1: by Padraig (new)

Padraig I read this so long ago all I can remember is the opening sentence about the candle and the shadow of the candle fluttering simultaneously!


Robin Padraig wrote: "I read this so long ago all I can remember is the opening sentence about the candle and the shadow of the candle fluttering simultaneously!"

That's impressive Padraig, that you remember the opening line. He has so many beautiful and memorable lines here, though. I did a bunch of underlining as I was reading.


Katie Great review, Robin. I've only read The Road and it's time I read another of his.


Robin Katie wrote: "Great review, Robin. I've only read The Road and it's time I read another of his."

Thanks, Katie. I really loved and can recommend No Country for Old Men - it was super brutal and violent but the story charged forward powerfully and the bad guy Anton Chigur is SO very bad, maybe the baddest.


Katie Thanks Robin. I've seen the excellent film. No reason not to read the book though!


message 6: by Fede (new)

Fede Well, darling... after the frog and the bear, I guess the horses were inevitable. Especially if they are pretty. :)
Wonderful analysis, Robin.


Wayne Barrett Great review. After finishing the book I watched the movie with my wife. She was frustrated at the end because he didn't get the girl, and I said, "Honey, you missed the point. The story wasn't about the girl. It was about the horses."


message 8: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe I'm thrilled that you read this novel, enjoyed it and offered your perspective, Robin. It made me appreciate the book in a different, thrilling way. "The end of the cowboy" is a sub-genre very popular in film going back as far as the outstanding Kirk Douglas-Gena Rowlands-Walter Matthau contemporary western Lonely Are the Brave in 1962. Another great one from that era was The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance with the law and order Jimmy Stewart represents relegating the archetypal self-made pioneer John Wayne represents to the history books. On my reading of McCarthy, I really didn't feel he was pushing that theme hard and the book had a wonderful sense of discovery to it.




message 9: by Cheri (new) - added it

Cheri Such a lovely, poignant review, Robin. This is on my list, has been for a while, but I love the way you've made this sound.


Robin Katie wrote: "Thanks Robin. I've seen the excellent film. No reason not to read the book though!"

Agreed! I had seen the film first also, but found the book equally riveting.


Robin Fede wrote: "Well, darling... after the frog and the bear, I guess the horses were inevitable. Especially if they are pretty. :)
Wonderful analysis, Robin."


I've turned into a weird zookeeper of sorts, Fede. Wtf?


Robin Wayne wrote: "Great review. After finishing the book I watched the movie with my wife. She was frustrated at the end because he didn't get the girl, and I said, "Honey, you missed the point. The story wasn't about the girl. It was about the horses.""

You nailed it, Wayne! Exactly. The storyline with the girl was lovely but secondary. It was always about the horses.


message 13: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi I'm ahead of myself this week, Robin. I'm reading this with my Friday evening wine rather than my Saturday morning pumpkin coffee! Another lovely review. I own the paperback and perhaps needed this little push to get to it :)


message 14: by Laysee (new)

Laysee Wonderful review, Robin. It offers a rich feel of what this book has to offer. Lyrical prose and nostalgic romance do appeal to me. I'm just not so sure about reading a book that is slightly gentler than other McCarthy books. I know, I'm a coward in this department. But give me the romance any time though not the Nora Roberts variant. :-)


message 15: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro Oh, you romantic fool, Robin. : )
A fab review, as ever!


message 16: by Laura (new)

Laura Eloquent review - makes me interested, although I keep avoiding this one for its old-fashioned attachment to what is gone.


Robin Joe wrote: ""The end of the cowboy" is a sub-genre very popular in film going back as far as the outstanding Kirk Douglas-Gena Rowlands-Walter Matthau contemporary western Lonely Are the Brave in 1962. Another great one from that era was The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance with the law and order Jimmy Stewart represents relegating the archetypal self-made pioneer John Wayne represents to the history books."

Joe, I can count on you to enrich the discussion with pertinent film gems. I haven't seen either of those movies but now I'm intrigued. The westerns that I have watched have been by far and large ones starring Clint Eastwood. Hubba hubba.




Robin Cheri wrote: "Such a lovely, poignant review, Robin. This is on my list, has been for a while, but I love the way you've made this sound."

Thank you, Cheri! This was on my list for several years too. I think in general, I was intimidated by Cormack McCarthy, but after reading The Road and No Country for Old Men this year, I can safely say I've gotten over that fear. He's immensely readable and can sure tell a story! Pretty damn bleak outlook, though this book is less so.


Robin Candi wrote: "I'm ahead of myself this week, Robin. I'm reading this with my Friday evening wine rather than my Saturday morning pumpkin coffee! Another lovely review. I own the paperback and perhaps needed this little push to get to it :)"

Ah Candi! I wondered if we would be meeting for our Saturday morning coffee date today :D But you beat me to it. Wine is good too.
Thanks so much, and I look forward to reading your review of this one day. It's got a great story with a sweeping cinematic romanticism that's hard not to love.


Robin Laysee wrote: "Wonderful review, Robin. It offers a rich feel of what this book has to offer. Lyrical prose and nostalgic romance do appeal to me. I'm just not so sure about reading a book that is slightly gentler than other McCarthy books. I know, I'm a coward in this department. But give me the romance any time though not the Nora Roberts variant. :-)"

I steer clear of Nora Roberts romance too, Laysee. This book is a different breed altogether. A thoroughbred, now that I come to think of it ;)

You're not a coward at all, my dear. Not every book is for every reader. I'm wired this way - I belong in these dark pages - but I don't recommend you to force yourself through something you know isn't your thing. You read so widely as it is! Thanks again for stopping by my review, especially one of a book that you likely won't read. I appreciate it.


message 21: by Markus (new)

Markus Beautiful review, Robin. Thank you. Romantic. I have "Lonesome Dove" on my shelf.


message 22: by Susan “Sam� (new)

Susan “Sam” Rockin' review, Robin!


Robin Kevin wrote: "Oh, you romantic fool, Robin. : )
A fab review, as ever!"


You know me, Kevin, I'm such a sap! :D
Thanks for stopping by - I feel like I need to go see what you've been reading lately. I haven't read a Kevin-review in a little while!


Robin Laura wrote: "Eloquent review - makes me interested, although I keep avoiding this one for its old-fashioned attachment to what is gone."

Thank you kindly, Laura! There's no getting away from the romantic and nostalgic depictions of cowboy life in this book. (And violent/brutal ones, too.) But along with that is a pretty compelling story. Maybe that tempts you a little?


Robin Markus wrote: "Beautiful review, Robin. Thank you. Romantic. I have "Lonesome Dove" on my shelf."

So do I! It happens to be one of my reading goals for this year - fingers crossed I get to it. Thanks so much for your lovely comment, Markus.


Robin Susan wrote: "Rockin' review, Robin!"

Why, thank you, Susan! :D


message 27: by Susan “Sam� (new)

Susan “Sam” Oops! Sorry Robin and thank you for your kind method used to correct me.


Robin Susan wrote: "Oops! Sorry Robin and thank you for your kind method used to correct me."

Hi Susan - I'm confused, no need for you to apologise and I definitely wasn't correcting you. Just thanking you happily for stopping by my review and taking the time to make a kind comment. :-)


message 29: by Julie (new) - added it

Julie G Robin,
My middle child walked behind me as I was finishing up your review and she gasped at the photo of the horses. That's how things go around here.
Five stars, eh?


Robin Julie wrote: "Robin,
My middle child walked behind me as I was finishing up your review and she gasped at the photo of the horses. That's how things go around here.
Five stars, eh?"


I can't say I blame her. They are magnificent!

Yes, five stars. It was a tough call for me, because the ending wasn't as strong as the first three quarters of the book. I think Joe felt the same. I wavered between 4 and 5 many times. This would have been a solid 4.5 if ŷ allowed half stars. But at the end of the day, the horses won me over.


message 31: by Julie (new) - added it

Julie G Horses have that effect on us!

But, you know. . . you still haven't read the BEST book about cowboys yet. . .


Robin Julie wrote: "Horses have that effect on us!

But, you know. . . you still haven't read the BEST book about cowboys yet. . ."


You're talkin' Lonesome Dove, right?

I KNOW! < hangs head in shame >
It's one of my 2018 reading goals. I hope to get there!!


message 33: by Julie (new) - added it

Julie G Yes, I'm glad you knew the answer. Yes. Yes. Yes.


Robin Oh, I’m very aware! I’m thinking... November...


message 35: by Julie (new) - added it

Julie G Yes. . . and for the first 80 pages you'll be reading about a pig under a porch, and you'll be thinking. . . What's the big deal, Julie??. Next thing you'll know, you'll be calling me from Canada.


Robin 80 pages of a pig under a porch? The rest better be damn good!!!


Robert Taylor Great review made me pick it up from the library today. Blood Meridian is my alltime favorite book so it's about time I give this one a read. If it's half as good as Blood Meridian, No Country for Old Men or The Road I'll love it.


Robin Robert wrote: "Great review made me pick it up from the library today. Blood Meridian is my alltime favorite book so it's about time I give this one a read. If it's half as good as Blood Meridian, No Country for Old Men or The Road I'll love it."

Hi Robert, I'm so glad my review prompted you to read this book!

I can't speak to how it compares to Blood Meridian - I haven't read that one yet. But I loved the other two McCarthy ones you mentioned and I believe this stands up with them. It's gentler than both of those, so if you're looking for another Anton Chigurh you might be slightly disappointed. But I think it's a great book. Hope you'll pop by and let me know how you liked it!


Numidica Robin, what a lovely review! I think this is my favorite Cormac book, though The Stonemason is a close second (a book no one has heard of, and the rare uplifting McCarty story).

"This yearning nostalgia is reflected in unbelievably lyrical prose."

Yes, how true. I can read Spanish, so those extended Spanish-only parts enhanced the book for me, but I can only imagine the frustration of Cormac's editors (...."Why Cormac, why?? Can't you just translate those paragraphs?....")

Thanks for this review - I'm sorry I missed it earlier.


Robin Numidica wrote: "Robin, what a lovely review! I think this is my favorite Cormac book, though The Stonemason is a close second (a book no one has heard of, and the rare uplifting McCarty story).

Count me among those who never heard of The Stonemason - thank you for mentioning it, John! I think my favourite McCarthy thus far (I have many more to read) is No Country for Old Men, although, surprisingly, I gave it 4 stars. The end fizzled for me, but the rest of it was stunning.

I really want to read Blood Meridian soon. #goals


Numidica No Country is a great book. My sister and I emailed back and forth about the ending. Both of us saw our father in the man "carrying fire in a horn", who would be there in"all that cold and all that dark" making a fire for us to come to. And we knew when we got there, he would be there.


Robin Numidica wrote: "No Country is a great book. My sister and I emailed back and forth about the ending. Both of us saw our father in the man "carrying fire in a horn", who would be there in"all that cold and all that dark" making a fire for us to come to. And we knew when we got there, he would be there."

That's so beautiful. Really. I love that you and your sister had that conversation.


Jacob I agree, the romantic nostalgia permeates throughout the book. I though it interesting to find the children characters throughout as well. Hiding them from the life’s harsh realities seems to be a theme that supported as as gritty Americanized Bildungsroman story.


Robin Jacob wrote: "I agree, the romantic nostalgia permeates throughout the book. I though it interesting to find the children characters throughout as well. Hiding them from the life’s harsh realities seems to be a theme that supported as as gritty Americanized Bildungsroman story."

Thanks, Jacob. Great point about the children. Hard to imagine in those times that kids could be shielded from reality for very long, though.


message 45: by Théo d'Or (new)

Théo d'Or " They speak when they only truly have something
worth saying."
How much I like this concept !


Robin Théodore wrote: "" They speak when they only truly have something
worth saying."
How much I like this concept !"


Yes - minimalist communication. Something very appealing about that idea.


Lesle Great review Robin! Love when an Author descriptions are well formed! Thank you


Robin Lesle wrote: "Great review Robin! Love when an Author descriptions are well formed! Thank you"

Well thank you, Lesle - what a kind comment!


message 49: by John (new)

John DiConsiglio Nice, Robin. This is the only McCarthy I've read. I've been meaning to go down The Road. But not in any rush these days.


Robin John wrote: "Nice, Robin. This is the only McCarthy I've read. I've been meaning to go down The Road. But not in any rush these days."

Hey, John. Thanks! Yeah, we're living our own version of apocalypse these days, I can understand your not wanting to explore that in your fiction reading.


« previous 1
back to top