Lisa's Reviews > Northanger Abbey
Northanger Abbey (Vintage Classics)
by
by

"It is only a novel... or, in short, only some work in which the greatest powers of the mind are displayed, in which the most thorough knowledge of human nature, the happiest delineation of its varieties, the liveliest effusions of wit and humour, are conveyed to the world in the best-chosen language."
Well, I guess Jane Austen wrote my review of her novel - in her novel. That's a bit annoying, as I can't compete with her wit of course. But even more annoying is the fact that I wrote my own imaginary review in my head before I started the book - and as opposed to Austen's summary, mine doesn't work out at all anymore, now that I know the story. It is dangerous to check the facts before writing your opinion - for facts have the frustrating habit of changing your opinions - if you dare to leave the realm of your fiction.
Like the young heroine in Northanger Abbey, I seemed to have lost grip of fiction and reality recently - due to an overly greedy consumption of novels!
Like the young heroine, I thought I knew what to expect of characters, setting and plot before I had even ventured out to explore them, and like her, I created a massive amount of tension for myself, only to find myself in the somewhat silly situation of waking up to a reality that did not at all justify my preconceived ideas.
Let's say I prided myself in "knowing" what to expect of Jane Austen. Let's say I started full of prejudices. Let's say that I had to force myself to come to my senses after a roller coaster that tested my sensibility more than I am willing to admit. Let's say I thought I had a perfect review in the making, following the idea of explaining the exaggerated characters and dramatic actions with regard to Austen's time, place and gender. I was going to put Northanger Abbey in its place - liking it for its classic status, but dismissing it (secretly) as irrelevant in the modern context. I was going to compare it to earlier works of Gothic fiction, and maybe even to my timeless favourite Dickens and his comically evil villains and puritan heroes.
But no. It won't do.
She's a bloody genius, - Jane Austen (if one can still say that nowadays without involuntarily insulting her intelligence and judgment)!
Exaggerated characters? The Thorpes too vain, greedy, shallow and stupid? Eh - show me the person in high society today that is NOT equally vulgar, volatile and obvious!
Ridiculous naivety of the heroine? Eh - we have people organising Flat Earth Conferences (and it isn't even fiction or satire, but plain truth).
Old-fashioned family structures? Eh - if the eternal generation conflict was solved in the meantime, I must have missed it! Can you send me the action plan, please?
So, if there is anything "dated" in Jane Austen, it must be the lovable character of her protagonist, her passionate argument for reading (novels), and her linguistically convincing prose. Well, for those minor defects I am willing to forgive her, in the name of classic literature.
She's proof that literature can always transcend the narrow boundaries of its time and place. It can speak to readers all over the world, in the most various life circumstances - as long as the message is honest and rings true.
Loved it. Despite all my pride and prejudice, with all my sense and sensibility.
Well, I guess Jane Austen wrote my review of her novel - in her novel. That's a bit annoying, as I can't compete with her wit of course. But even more annoying is the fact that I wrote my own imaginary review in my head before I started the book - and as opposed to Austen's summary, mine doesn't work out at all anymore, now that I know the story. It is dangerous to check the facts before writing your opinion - for facts have the frustrating habit of changing your opinions - if you dare to leave the realm of your fiction.
Like the young heroine in Northanger Abbey, I seemed to have lost grip of fiction and reality recently - due to an overly greedy consumption of novels!
Like the young heroine, I thought I knew what to expect of characters, setting and plot before I had even ventured out to explore them, and like her, I created a massive amount of tension for myself, only to find myself in the somewhat silly situation of waking up to a reality that did not at all justify my preconceived ideas.
Let's say I prided myself in "knowing" what to expect of Jane Austen. Let's say I started full of prejudices. Let's say that I had to force myself to come to my senses after a roller coaster that tested my sensibility more than I am willing to admit. Let's say I thought I had a perfect review in the making, following the idea of explaining the exaggerated characters and dramatic actions with regard to Austen's time, place and gender. I was going to put Northanger Abbey in its place - liking it for its classic status, but dismissing it (secretly) as irrelevant in the modern context. I was going to compare it to earlier works of Gothic fiction, and maybe even to my timeless favourite Dickens and his comically evil villains and puritan heroes.
But no. It won't do.
She's a bloody genius, - Jane Austen (if one can still say that nowadays without involuntarily insulting her intelligence and judgment)!
Exaggerated characters? The Thorpes too vain, greedy, shallow and stupid? Eh - show me the person in high society today that is NOT equally vulgar, volatile and obvious!
Ridiculous naivety of the heroine? Eh - we have people organising Flat Earth Conferences (and it isn't even fiction or satire, but plain truth).
Old-fashioned family structures? Eh - if the eternal generation conflict was solved in the meantime, I must have missed it! Can you send me the action plan, please?
So, if there is anything "dated" in Jane Austen, it must be the lovable character of her protagonist, her passionate argument for reading (novels), and her linguistically convincing prose. Well, for those minor defects I am willing to forgive her, in the name of classic literature.
She's proof that literature can always transcend the narrow boundaries of its time and place. It can speak to readers all over the world, in the most various life circumstances - as long as the message is honest and rings true.
Loved it. Despite all my pride and prejudice, with all my sense and sensibility.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Northanger Abbey.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 5, 2018
–
Started Reading
January 5, 2018
– Shelved
January 5, 2018
– Shelved as:
1001-books-to-read-before-you-die
January 5, 2018
– Shelved as:
jane-austen
January 5, 2018
–
7.05%
""In every power, of which taste is the foundation, excellence is pretty fairly divided between the sexes.""
page
17
January 10, 2018
– Shelved as:
favorites
January 10, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-45 of 45 (45 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Steffi
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Jan 10, 2018 08:15AM

reply
|
flag


Die Miss Thorpe in mir bläst sich jetzt mächtig auf (obwohl die nix mit meinem Lesen zu tun hat!), während die zaghafte Miss Morland in mir kaum hochschaut, errötet und sich heimlich doch ehrlich freut!

Da die Miss Morland in mir schon bei Steffis Kommentar errötet ist, weiss sie jetzt nicht, was sie mit sich anfangen soll, und loggt sich aus Verlegenheit mal kurz von GR aus. Die innere Isabella, hingegen, drueckt erstmal den Like-Button ihrer eigenen Review...


I second that, although I sometimes get the impression that Lisa is secretly working in the book trade and her reviews are just pitches to make us add even more books to our insanely long reading lists :)

"
Oh, dear! As you created a vacuum in my brain (The question: Do I have an opinion about that specific namesake of mine? leads to an instant power outage in the thinking parts...), I'll have to respond visually:

And of course, there is nothing like a small dose of Lisa classroom rage:


"
Oh, dear! As you created a vacuum in my brain (The question: Do I have an opinion about that specific n..."
Ich will das liken können!

I second that, although I sometimes get the impression that Lisa is secretly working in the book trade and her reviews are just pitches ..."
Well, the problem is that my bookshop has bought all the stock of books that nobody reads anymore, which is why I jealously trash The Da Vinci Code, The Alchemist and The Boy in the Striped Pajamas and other highlysuccessful moneymakers, while promoting those books I am trying to get out of my storage room by the millions. Anyone who wants to buy Aniara: An Epic Science Fiction Poem in Swedish, for example? If you buy ten, you'll get an extra copy of Strändernas svall byEyvind Johnson for free.


Thanks to your persuasive allusion, I'll make sure to read Persuasion next. I have the beautiful Vintage collection of Jane Austen, and they are next to my Henry Greens. A good chat I imagine those books to have when I am at work!


I only knew Pride and Prejudice and Sense and Sensibility before, soI am now halfway through my Jane Austen adventure.

Thank you, Marita!

It was an enjoyable treat, and as Fionnuala already beat me to the punch line, (only because you/she are 6 hours ahead of us, in the Time Space continuum) in declaring your persuasive powers, I can only add, nicely done!
A treat to revisit it through your eyes.

Check out Lisa's (the Simpson Lisa) . You may have more in common with her than you think :)
(view spoiler)

Can't tell you how pleased I am to hear that, Jaline!!


Fionnuala and you yourself are my favourite punch line masters, Julie! I can't think of anything that puts a smile on my face as fast as a good, witty comment! And I am all with you on some authors' "last" ones being the temporary favourite!

Still giggling ... after hours! You and Fionnuala really caught my pop cultural Achilles heel - Lisa Simpson and Star Wars. Just love them! Next to Captain Jack Sparrow they range in my cultural fastfood hall of fame. The CultNob?
My dearest Lisa, who’s told you you can’t compete with Austen’s wit? Boy, aren’t they unforgivably and childishly wrong!

Still giggling ... after hours! You and Fionnuala really caught my pop cultural Achilles heel - Lisa Simpson and Star Wars. Just love them! Next to Captain Jack Sparrow they range ..."

Here's to the best of both worlds, Lisa.
Definitely worthy of a coffee mug image. I may just turn up with this coffee mug for you when Fionnuala and you and I meet some winter soon .... : )


This, I promise, is the last funny of the day. And forevermore. I just couldn't resist. Now, I will do a month's penance in silence.

It is such a happiness when good people get together - and they always do.
(view spoiler)

Thank you so much, Dolors!

It's got to be pink in my case, though:


Still giggling ... after hours! You and Fionnuala really caught my pop cultural Achilles heel - Lisa Simpson and Star Wars. Just love them! Next to Captain Jack Sparro..."
Well, coffee mugs are always good - and this one would draw attention to my addiction for sure!!

It is such a happiness when good people get together - and they always do.
[spoilers removed]"
Cheers to that!

This, I promise, is the last funny of the day. And forevermore. I just couldn't resist. Now, I will do a month's penance in silence."
If you stay silent for a month for making me laugh, I'll come after you with a laser sword!

"Loved it. Despite all my pride and prejudice, with all my sense and sensibility."
Excellent!

"Loved it. Despite all my pride and prejudice, with all my sense and sensibility."
Excellent!"
Thank you, Kevin!


Agree! I read four of hers last year, and am planning on rereading the two I read in highschool soon as well. Really timeless classics in the best sense!