Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Joe's Reviews > Palace of the Drowned

Palace of the Drowned by Christine Mangan
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26876584
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2021, mystery-suspense, fiction-general

My introduction to the fiction of Christine Mangan is Palace of the Drowned. Published in 2021, this is an example of a novel I paused reading to check what other books the author had written so I could add those to my reading docket. I wish there was a bell I could ring when this happens. "Fiction-General" might be a more appropriate shelf for this than "Mystery/ Suspense," but the novel is evocative, mysterious and strong enough that I kept turning the pages even without a lot of tricks and turns. Some writers need plot to keep me engaged while others can do so by the imagery they conjure and strangeness their stories generate. Mangan belongs to the latter.

The story centers on Frances Croy, a writer whose debut novel was published to great acclaim, but whose three subsequent books have received diminishing praise. Frankie, single and childless, has grown apprehensive about her future. She is upset by a harsh critique in a weekly magazine she's unfamiliar with by a writer who identified themselves only as "J.L." Frankie was seething by the time she attended a party and socked a woman in the mouth. She checked herself into a clinic but tiring of the rigamarole there, fled London for Venice, where the family of her best friend Jack own a vacant palazzo where Frankie can work on the last novel remaining on her contract.

On her way to the market to buy vangole from one of the fishermen, Frankie is approached by an enthusiastic young Brit named Gilly Larson. Gilly claims to have met Frankie before and allows her to believe that she is the daughter of one of her editors. She persists on meeting Frankie for a cup of coffee sometime and despite her best efforts, Frankie concedes. Alone in the palazzo with the exception of the family's housekeeper, Frankie hears footsteps on the second floor and assumes it to be her neighbors, though Jack has no knowledge of any tenants. Gilly sounds a few warning bells but for lack of anyone to spend time in Venice with, Frankie befriends her.

During the recital, Gilly appeared indifferent--or oblivious, rather--to the looks her presence was garnering from the men who crowded the bar on the other side. She was tall and thin and young, and that always counted for something in the world, Frankie knew. It was enough, at any rate, to ensure a casual glance, a roving eye. But this was something different, as was, it seemed, Gilly. There was the way that she spoke--loudly, not so much that it annoyed but enough so that it aroused interest--and there were the gestures that went along with her speech, wide and sweeping, without concern for the space of others around her. And behind it all, a confidence, a certainty, in the way she spoke, in the way she moved, that belied her youth. That was it, Frankie realized. She had never before met anyone so self-assured at her age--other than herself--and so she knew firsthand how it made one unique among peers, however unintentional.

Frankie stifled a smirk. It was strange to think of how differently these same attributes were viewed with age. Now, instead of confident, she was labeled stubborn. Instead of independent, she was a spinster. The most frustrating part was that she didn't feel any differently than she had at Gilly's age, only a bit less manic, a bit more calm, and yet the world insisted that she was entirely changed from her younger self.


Palace of the Drowned doesn't embrace its potential as a thriller until the 65% mark but its strength is that without crime or violence or sex, Mangan fully invested me. Venice isn't described as much as it is imbibed. The way she sets not just places or people but a rhythm of life and almost a different way of dreaming in the City of Bridges put its hooks into me. I wasn't sure what direction the novel was going to take. Though set in October 1966, with only minor changes the story could take place in virtually any decade. In a credit to its protagonist, the writing is muscular and propulsive. If it were a Golden Girl, it would be Dorothy.

Gilly. That was what she had called herself. Frankie thought it had a ring of falsity to it. As did her story about their supposed introduction. Gilly, with a hard G. It was too juvenile, too hard to believe that someone had willingly bestowed it as an actual given name. As Frankie took another sip of wine, she allowed that it wasn't the girl herself so much as the girl's recognition that had unsettled her. A reminder that while she might play at disappearing into Venice, her vanishing act could never truly be complete. There would always be someone who knew her--and who knew about what had happened at the Savoy. The two were synonymous now, intrinsically linked. No matter how much she detested the thought.

Frankie gave a small shake of her head, cursing under her breath.

If only she had never read that damned review.


In other novels, I'd be fidgeting if an author digressed into Venice or cafe society for half a book and might abandon it out of boredom, but not Palace of the Drowned. Mangan could've set the novel in a phone booth and I'd have hung in there with her. The writing is so confident that I felt myself in good hands, certain this was leading somewhere. My only criticism is that Frankie is so caustic and has so little control of her emotions that she's freaking out in public, begging why her friend Jack (a heiress, a woman) is so devoted to her. It's a minor ding in a book that is fantastic from cover to cover. I'm looking forward to reading Mangan's debut novel as well as her next.
48 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Palace of the Drowned.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 23, 2022 – Shelved
December 23, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read
August 3, 2023 – Started Reading
August 3, 2023 –
page 3
0.94% "She was on her way to Rialto market, hoping to buy some vongole from one of the local fishmongers, despite the fact that it was October and therefore not really the season for them, when she felt someone grab her by the wrist."
August 3, 2023 –
page 11
3.44% "She knew herself already--too well, she often thought--and so she knew that the dark, rainy streets of London were for her, that the high street in Crouch End and the trip down to Euston on the 91 bus, followed by a brisk walk over to Bloomsbury to show her reader's ticket at the British Museum's Round Reading Room, were the only kind of excitement she wanted."
August 3, 2023 –
page 39
12.19% "She didn't remember hitting the woman, only the feel of the impact. She didn't remember the blood but had been reminded the next day by the stain on her white gloves. Afterward, she had disposed of them in the bin, had wondered, briefly, if it would count as tampering with evidence."
August 3, 2023 –
page 68
21.25% "It was strange to think of how differently these same attributes were viewed with age. Now, instead of confident, she was labeled stubborn. Instead of independent, she was a spinster. The most frustrating part was that she didn't feel any differently than she had at Gilly's age, only a bit less manic, a bit more calm, and yet the world insisted that she was entirely changed from her younger self."
August 3, 2023 –
page 71
22.19% "Frankie had been surprised to discover just how much being a novelist suited her. She had always been serious, even as a child, and there was something about the solitude, about the discipline that the work entailed--to make oneself sit, alone, for hours on end, even on those days when your mind seemed to scream in protest--that she found reassuring."
August 4, 2023 – Shelved as: 2021
August 4, 2023 – Shelved as: mystery-suspense
August 4, 2023 – Shelved as: fiction-general
August 4, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Lorna Oh Joe, a magnificent review of this wonderful book. And with the iconic background of Venice, I loved this book and couldn’t put it down. And yes you hung in there, Joe.


Left Coast Justin I'm always on the lookout for books like this -- books with both a plot and great writing. Thanks for the tip!


message 3: by Bonnie G. (new)

Bonnie G. Sold! I was already sold, but when I got to a sentence starting with " If it were a Golden Girl," I was doubly sold. (BTW, there is no wrong answer, to that, Rose, Blanche, Sophia, all would have sent me running for this book!) Thanks for turning me on to a book I had not heard of but am now dying to read.


message 4: by Diane (new)

Diane Wonderful review. I haven’t heard of this author. Will have to check this out.


message 5: by Joe (last edited Aug 05, 2023 10:30AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Lorna wrote: "Oh Joe, a magnificent review of this wonderful book. And with the iconic background of Venice, I loved this book and couldn’t put it down. And yes you hung in there, Joe."

Thank you, Lorna. An author should give us a reason to keep turning the pages. I think that's essential. None of the books I give one and sometimes two stars to do that for me.


message 6: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Left Coast Justin wrote: "I'm always on the lookout for books like this -- books with both a plot and great writing. Thanks for the tip!"

That's a good way to put it, Justin, and great criteria for a read.


message 7: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Bonnie G. wrote: "Thanks for turning me on to a book I had not heard of but am now dying to read."

Thanks, Bonnie. I hope my good credit stands after you read it!


message 8: by Joe (last edited Aug 05, 2023 10:36AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Diane wrote: "Wonderful review. I haven’t heard of this author. Will have to check this out."

Palace of the Drowned might have been a novel I first heard about on CrimeReads. Only two people I follow on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ have reviewed it. Once in a blue moon, the crime fiction website comes through for me. Thanks, Diane!


message 9: by Debbie (new) - added it

Debbie What a fabulous review! You had me hitting the Want to Read button faster than a hummingbird flits around a bird feeder! I love it when a book is so good you have to stop and look up their other books. Good stuff! Can’t wait to read it!


message 10: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Debbie wrote: "What a fabulous review! You had me hitting the Want to Read button faster than a hummingbird flits around a bird feeder! I love it when a book is so good you have to stop and look up their other books. Good stuff! Can’t wait to read it!"

Thank you, Debbie. I hope my credit score is still pretty high after you read this. Frances Croy has the Complaint Board on speed dial, when I think about it.


message 11: by Kimber (new)

Kimber Silver "If it were a Golden Girl, it would be Dorothy."-what a great line! Excellent review, Joe!


message 12: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Kimber wrote: ""If it were a Golden Girl, it would be Dorothy."-what a great line! Excellent review, Joe!"

Dorothy is not one to tolerate any ostentatious displays, for sure. Thank you for your comment, Kimber.


back to top