ŷ

Lisa's Reviews > Augustus

Augustus by John  Williams
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
103664948
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: national-book-award, historical-fiction, 2025, favorites

While John Williams' novel Augustus can be read as a brilliant work of historical fiction, it is also a master work of literary fiction. As Williams points out in his Author's Note: "...if there are truths in this work, they are truths of fiction rather than of history."

Williams writes this work in an epistolary format--letters, journals, proclamations, and bits of histories. I get a good sense of the characters through their writings. I also see many different views of Octavius (Augustus), all the various roles he must play to achieve and hold his place in Rome. I assemble these pieces in order to try and grasp who Octavius really is. These writings also give the work an intimate feel. I am completely drawn in and engaged.

While the bones of the history are there, from the death of Julius Caesar when Octavius was 19 through the death of Octavius at age 76, Williams puts the flesh on the bones. He puts the words in their mouths and writings, as well as creating and conveying the emotions/feelings of his characters.

Some of the themes Williams explores are power--the desire for and use of, public necessity/good vs. personal happiness, friendship and enmity, and aging.

"Perhaps we are wiser when we are young, though the philosopher would dispute with me. But I swear to you, we were friends from that moment onward; and that moment of foolish laughter was a bond stronger than anything that came between us later . . ."

Williams has a good grasp of people, and basic human nature doesn't change over time. I think those bonds we form in our youth are some of our strongest. My closest friend today is a woman I met when I was 20. We have remained close for 4 decades. We bonded over studying together for a statistics course, and our friendship grew from there. I have wonderful friends I have made since, and no one else has as long a history and knows me in this same way.

Julia to her father, Octavius, when informed of her upcoming marriage to Tiberius:

"So once again I'm to be the brood sow for the pleasure of Rome."

Political marriage is a fact of life. There is no bargaining for a life of joy or contentment.

Julia asks: " 'Father, . . . has it been worth it? Your authority, this Rome that you have saved, this Rome that you have built? Has it been worth all that you have had to do?

My father looked at me for a long time, and then he looked away. 'I must believe that it has. . . . We both must believe that it has.' "


Once you head down a path and are entrenched, it's almost impossible to change course. If Octavius had wanted to abdicate, the mess he would have left behind would have been horrendous. Even for the sake of his happiness or that of his beloved daughter, he sees no alternative. I am left to ponder this same question.

"Octavius Caesar is alone. No one from his youth remains alive, and therefore there is no one whom he feels that he can trust, no one to whom he can talk about those things that are nearest to him."

I cannot imagine. My grandfather was the last of his generation--family and friends--to pass. He often pined for a peer to converse with in those last two years of his life, so I have a tiny glimpse of what may have been felt. Add to that the feeling that Octavius has that he can't trust anyone in his present, and I am weighed down by the burden on his heart and psyche.

"I do not believe that Rome can endure the death of Octavius Caesar, and I do not believe that Octavius Caesar can endure the death of his soul."

This novel is divided into 3 Books and an Epilogue. Book 1 details Octavius' rise to power, Book 2 conveys the disintegration of his family and personal happiness, and Book 3 portrays Octavius as an old man reflecting back on his life.

I appreciate the choice to keep Augustus' inner thoughts out of the narrative until the very end. It is so impactful to read after having pieced together an idea of who he is. We, my buddy readers and I, all noted its absence. Looking for Octavius' voice created a tension/suspense that added to the pull of the book.

Williams is a masterful writer--not only the structure he chooses, but also his prose. He sees and understands people and their motivations and conveys that clearly on the page.

For a piece of literary fiction that sings, you couldn't make a better choice.

A shout out to my Buddy Readers who contributed greatly to this magnificent reading experience! See their wonderful reviews:
Mark
Dave
Debi.

Publication 1972
72 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Augustus.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 18, 2024 – Shelved
December 18, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
December 18, 2024 – Shelved as: national-book-award
December 18, 2024 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
January 2, 2025 – Started Reading
January 2, 2025 – Shelved as: 2025
January 8, 2025 –
page 179
53.27%
January 9, 2025 –
page 202
60.12%
January 9, 2025 –
page 202
60.12%
January 11, 2025 –
page 265
78.87%
January 12, 2025 –
page 336
100.0% "Finished reading; RTC."
January 14, 2025 – Shelved as: favorites
January 14, 2025 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 60 (60 new)


Charles This is a beautiful way to begin a review, and a fitting homage all around. If more historical works were written in the engaging manner this book was, I'd have a favourite genre, right there. Terrific review, Lisa, and I'm so glad Williams also hit the right notes for you with this title.


Laysee "I assemble these pieces in order to try and grasp who Octavius really is."

I did the same when I was reading this book. I wanted to decide for myself who Augustus really was. What an excellent review, Lisa. I enjoyed reading the insights you gained with reference to your own personal experiences. And I love knowing that group reading added much pleasure to your appreciation of this masterpiece.


message 3: by Diane (new)

Diane Barnes Fantastic review Lisa. You really got into the heart of this book.


Dave Marsland That's a stunning review, Lisa. You included some brilliant quotes, I especially enjoyed the last one. You are absolutely right, Williams is a masterful writer. If there is a better work of historical fiction out there, I'd love to know what it is.


Albert Excellent review of a wonderful novel.


message 6: by K (new)

K Stellar review, Lisa! ...Williams puts the flesh on the bones. That phrase sold me before I even finished your review. Plus, your 5-star rating. (I take note of your 5-star ratings.) I loved Stoner so much that I immediately bought Augustus and Butcher's Crossing, so your review has made it easy for me to make Augustus a priority in 2025.


message 7: by Antoinette (new) - added it

Antoinette Perfect review, Lisa! I haven’t read this book but your review really brought Augustus alive in my mind.


Lisa Charles wrote: "This is a beautiful way to begin a review, and a fitting homage all around. If more historical works were written in the engaging manner this book was, I'd have a favourite genre, right there. Terr..."

Thank you, Charles. This book is a much appreciated gift for my reading senses. Will I be too disappointed if I back up and read Butcher's Crossing after a great lapse of time?


Lisa Laysee wrote: ""I assemble these pieces in order to try and grasp who Octavius really is."

I did the same when I was reading this book. I wanted to decide for myself who Augustus really was. What an excellent re..."


Thank you, Laysee. Wasn't it genius, the way Williams guided us along? Augustus is quite a compelling read, and so ripe for discussion with my august buddy readers (pun intended).


message 10: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Diane wrote: "Fantastic review Lisa. You really got into the heart of this book."

Thank you, Diane. I struggled to write down the essence without writing a several page essay. I am still a bit giddy with love for this one.


message 11: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Dave wrote: "That's a stunning review, Lisa. You included some brilliant quotes, I especially enjoyed the last one. You are absolutely right, Williams is a masterful writer. If there is a better work of histori..."

Thank you, Dave. That last quote really goes to the heart of the book, doesn't it?

I have it on good authority that Memoirs of Hadrian is equally as good. I am proposing we look at that one for the future.


message 12: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Albert wrote: "Excellent review of a wonderful novel."

Thank you, Albert. I agree it is a stunning novel.


message 13: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa K wrote: "Stellar review, Lisa! ...Williams puts the flesh on the bones. That phrase sold me before I even finished your review. Plus, your 5-star rating. (I take note of your 5-star ratings.) I loved [book:..."

Thank you, K. I am confident that this one will be a winner for you. I hope you get to this one soon, and find it as swoonworthy as I do.


message 14: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Antoinette wrote: "Perfect review, Lisa! I haven’t read this book but your review really brought Augustus alive in my mind."

Thank you, Antoinette. I have spent the last several days living in Ancient Rome, and haven't yet quite returned to the present. You know how picky/discerning I am, so that's quite a testament to Williams and this novel.


message 15: by Ron (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ron It did feel like reading a great piece on history, as close as he could get and still capture a story that's not so textbook. I'm struck by the sheer variety between the books he wrote, but that "grasp of people" you mention seems key, Lisa. Enjoyed reading your review!


message 16: by Debi (last edited Jan 14, 2025 02:03PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Debi Cates Oh Lisa, what a review! I'm so glad to have read this with you and then now to have read your excellent review here. You have such a gift for the perfect quote to include within your commentary, giving us a feel of the writer but also illustrating your insights so well.

The stars were aligned with this read--the book, the subject, the buddies. It had me on Reader Cloud 9 ❤️

P.S. I am going now to edit my review to include the links to y'all too! Great idea and thank you.


Cecily Lovely review, with plenty of context to help people know what to expect, and why it should appeal to those who might not expect to enjoy it.


Tsung Nice review Lisa! 2025 should be declared a Buddy Read Year.


Lori  Keeton Wow! Lisa this is one of your best reviews! You have written so lovingly and it shows! I’m also very engaged with this one and think reading it with others is the best route!


message 20: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi I was pretty confident I'd love this one since Stoner and Butcher's Crossing rank among my favorite books. Now your superb review convinces me even further, Lisa!

"Williams has a good grasp of people, and basic human nature doesn't change over time."

Yes! This is one of the reasons I love his writing so much :)


message 21: by Ebba Simone (new)

Ebba Simone Lisa, Great review! I want to read this too now. I am excited that Williams sees and and understands people and their motivations. It is the most important thing to me. My favourite work of historical fiction is Kepler by Banville.


message 22: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Ron wrote: "It did feel like reading a great piece on history, as close as he could get and still capture a story that's not so textbook. I'm struck by the sheer variety between the books he wrote, but that "g..."

Thank you, Ron. This book was a sheer delight for me. I'm thrilled that we share a love of Williams the author. I haven't read Butcher's Crossing. In Stoner and Augustus Williams has his characters examine their lives--what they did and what they could have done to understand who they are. A look at their very humanity which relates to all of us and calls to me.


message 23: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Debi wrote: "Oh Lisa, what a review! I'm so glad to have read this with you and then now to have read your excellent review here. You have such a gift for the perfect quote to include within your commentary, gi..."

Thank you Debi. Who could ask for more than a 5 Star read with 5 Star reading buddies?


message 24: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Cecily wrote: "Lovely review, with plenty of context to help people know what to expect, and why it should appeal to those who might not expect to enjoy it."

Thank you, Cecily. I confess to being one of those who thought I might not enjoy this one, so I put it off regardless of how much I love Stoner. I am thrilled to love this one so much! I am curious as to why Stoner appealed to you more than Augustus.


message 25: by Lisa (last edited Jan 15, 2025 03:18AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Tsung wrote: "Nice review Lisa! 2025 should be declared a Buddy Read Year."

Thank you Tsung. I have declared it so! I hope you enjoy many books and many BRs in 2025.


message 26: by Lesle (new)

Lesle Outstanding review Lisa!! Very informative as well. Adding to my wish list!! Thank you


message 27: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Lori wrote: "Wow! Lisa this is one of your best reviews! You have written so lovingly and it shows! I’m also very engaged with this one and think reading it with others is the best route!"

What kind words, Lori. I love this novel and hope you get as much joy in your read of Augustus as I did! You certainly have an exceptional reading companion.


message 28: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Candi wrote: "I was pretty confident I'd love this one since Stoner and Butcher's Crossing rank among my favorite books. Now your superb review convinces me even further, Lisa!

"Williams has a good grasp of pe..."


I will give you a money back guarantee if you don't love this one! 😜
I am enamored with his writing and am still recovering from a book hangover. I have decided to wait a few days before picking up another piece of fiction. I just can't do it right now.


message 29: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Ebba Simone wrote: "Lisa, Great review! I want to read this too now. I am excited that Williams sees and and understands people and their motivations. It is the most important thing to me. My favourite work of histori..."

Thank you, Ebba. I'm off to look up Kepler. I have yet to read Banville, though he is on that incredibly long list.


message 30: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Lesle wrote: "Outstanding review Lisa!! Very informative as well. Adding to my wish list!! Thank you"

Lesle, this was an outstanding read which I hope you love as much as I do. I'm still gushing!


message 31: by Lesle (new)

Lesle Lisa your thoughts on this might have me shopping for it before the morning is over!


message 32: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Lesle wrote: "Lisa your thoughts on this might have me shopping for it before the morning is over!"

I aim to be a book enabler! 😜


message 33: by Debi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Debi Cates Lisa wrote: "I aim to be a book enabler! 😜"


😂😂😂


message 34: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Your review sings too, Lisa! But then you always put so much heart into your book thoughts!


message 35: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Fionnuala wrote: "Your review sings too, Lisa! But then you always put so much heart into your book thoughts!"

Thank you, Fionnuala. What else can I do when a books speaks to me so whole heartedly?


message 36: by Linda (new) - added it

Linda Terrific review, Lisa. I am currently taking an outstanding Great Course on Ancient Rome and William' Augustus is a book I want to dig into soon.


message 37: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Linda wrote: "Terrific review, Lisa. I am currently taking an outstanding Great Course on Ancient Rome and William' Augustus is a book I want to dig into soon."

Linda, you will find this a gripping read, especially if you already have the historical background. Maybe you won't have to make sidetrips down the historical rabbit holes. 😂


Violeta A superb, insightful and wonderfully worded review, Lisa. It's obvious how inspired you were by William's writing. Now I'm wondering why I didn't give it 5 stars - I've been more generous with less worthy reads.


message 39: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Violeta wrote: "A superb, insightful and wonderfully worded review, Lisa. It's obvious how inspired you were by William's writing. Now I'm wondering why I didn't give it 5 stars - I've been more generous with less..."

Thank you Violeta. This novel is magic for me, and I'm glad that came through in my review. I hope to inspire some more people to pick it up.

I think those stars live at the whim of the moment. That's why the words that go with them are so important.


message 40: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer Welsh Sounds almost polar opposite of the interior Stoner, Lisa � so interesting. I’m so curious how the latter part would affect me emotionally after that more distant acquaintance. Maybe it feels like the building of most relationships?


message 41: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Jennifer wrote: "Sounds almost polar opposite of the interior Stoner, Lisa � so interesting. I’m so curious how the latter part would affect me emotionally after that more distant acquaintance. Maybe it feels like ..."

Jennifer, it's not the polar opposite of Stoner. In fact, the novels have a lot of commonality--the themes of significant change in the protagonist, governance, machinations for power, obligations vs. personal happiness, aging and looking back on a life lived.

I think you would love how Williams portrays Julia. The second part of the book puts her front and center. We learn more about Octavius and life at the time through her.

For me Augustus was a puzzle to solve. Each piece laid out carefully. And not until the end could I come close to fully assembling them. This one touched me cerebrally and emotionally, my sweet spot.


message 42: by Ilse (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ilse Exquisite review of this marvellous historical novel, Lisa! I am so glad you decided to read Marguerite Yourcenar's Memoirs of Hadrian too, I am sure you will find fascinating parallels with Williams' book on Augustus. I loved how Williams managed to create a distinctive voice for each letter writer and to get back to that particular delight, I have high hopes on another epistolary, historical novel, Perspective(s): A Novel by Laurent Binet (taking us to 16th century Florence).


message 43: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer Welsh Lisa wrote: "Jennifer wrote: "Sounds almost polar opposite of the interior Stoner, Lisa � so interesting. I’m so curious how the latter part would affect me emotionally after that more distant acquaintance. May..."

You know I love a good puzzle! Now I'm looking forward to getting to this one day. Really appreciate your response :)


message 44: by Robin (new)

Robin This is a beautiful and comprehensive review, Lisa. It's lovely to see a different John Williams book being read/reviewed (so many of us have only read Stoner, myself included).


message 45: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Jennifer wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Jennifer wrote: "Sounds almost polar opposite of the interior Stoner, Lisa � so interesting. I’m so curious how the latter part would affect me emotionally after that more distant acqu..."

Ha! You should know me well enough to be looking for a response. When I love a book I want to proselytize. Are you ready to be converted? 😜


message 46: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Ilse wrote: "Exquisite review of this marvellous historical novel, Lisa! I am so glad you decided to read Marguerite Yourcenar's Memoirs of Hadrian too, I am sure you will find fascinating parallels with Willia..."

Ilse, thank you for your kind words. I am excited to have Yourcenar's book to look forward to this summer. The novel Perspective(s) is unknown to me so I will be looking for your thoughts once you have read it.


message 47: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Robin wrote: "This is a beautiful and comprehensive review, Lisa. It's lovely to see a different John Williams book being read/reviewed (so many of us have only read Stoner, myself included)."

Robin, I hope you will consider reading Augustus. The prose is just as wonderful as Stoner and a lot of the themes are the same. Yet it is a totally different structure and way of developing characters.

And thank you for your kind words.


message 48: by Debbie (new)

Debbie W. I love historical fiction works like these that are extremely well-written - true works of literary art.
Fantastic review, Lisa!


message 49: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Debbie wrote: "I love historical fiction works like these that are extremely well-written - true works of literary art.
Fantastic review, Lisa!"


Debbie, those words are so true!


Mark  Porton How did I miss your review Lisa? Wow - a terrific write up! I am so happy you were 'all-in' on this one, and that you loved it so much. Wasn't it one of the best? Augustus was a colossal character right?

You've touched on all of the main themes beautifully. Also, you mention he was in a bind - if he abdicated, the Empire could have easily fallen back into the chaos of the civil wars. The fact he held on for 40 years, created a generation of normalcy in a way. Great review Lisa :))

ps. This was also a metaphor-free read right? Or did I miss them again 😉


« previous 1
back to top