ŷ

Sean Barrs 's Reviews > The Fellowship of the Ring

The Fellowship of the Ring by J.R.R. Tolkien
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
27788046
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: tolkien, 5-star-reads
Read 3 times. Last read June 26, 2016.

I’m not going to write a normal review; it’s almost impossible for a fantasy fan to do so in this case. Instead I’m going to give you a series of ten points to explain exactly why I love this particular book. Take from it what you will. There will be spoilers. Here goes:

1. The wizards!

"“Do not meddle in the affairs of wizards, for they are subtle and quick to anger.�

Now I do love wizards. Who doesn’t? The wisdom of Gandalf is unmatched. He is, in effect, the leader of the forces of light. He is the commander in chief, the battle general and the tactician. He organises everything. From Aragorn’s coming, to the hobbits bearing the ring, Gandalf is behind it all. He has walked middle earth for thousands of years. He has seen it all. And he understands the perilous nature of the quest better than most. He is the grand optimist, the man who sees the best in people. He should have been the leader of the Isatri. He was the most pure. He is nothing like the changeable leader of his order.

description

Contrastingly, Saruman is the realist. He is neither light nor dark, but a being who can adapt to the circumstance. He saw only defeat for man, so he turned his cloak and helped to usher in the doom of middle earth. His mind was poisoned by the palantir, Sauron fed of his ambition and bent him to his will. Something Saruman didn’t fully conceive. He considered himself the equal of Sauron. In reality, if Sauron had regained the ring, he would have crushed Saruman like a bug. And if Saruman had gained the ring first, things would have become much different. It would have been a war between the two, one that would have unforeseen circumstances.

2. A desperate quest

The quest itself, the sending of just nine people to destroy the conduit of darkness, speaks of desperation. The elves are not what they once were in the first age. Their power has diminished: their people are leaving these lands. They do not have the power to stand against the tide. The Dwarves are shattered and broken. Their leadership in Erabor has their own problems to deal with. They, too, face invasion. And men, men, are weak. Well at least according to Elrond. So sending of a small party of mighty heroes, and a few untested hobbits, is a back door attempt of destroying the evil that infests middle earth. And I love it. Have you ever read about a quest so unlikely and so improbable?

“I will take the Ring", he said, "though I do not know the way.�

description

3. A Hidden King

Other than the obvious wizard, the agile elvish prince, the stalwart dwarf lord, the fellowship has a secret weapon. Aragorn, the heir to Isildur, has finally come forth.

“All that is gold does not glitter,
Not all those who wander are lost;
The old that is strong does not wither,
Deep roots are not reached by the frost.

From the ashes a fire shall be woken,
A light from the shadows shall spring;
Renewed shall be blade that was broken,
The crownless again shall be king.�


He alone has the power to unite the failing world of men. Only he can save the white tree of Gondor and insure that men do not fall into darkness. And the darkness, it genuinely fears him. He is the last hope of men: he is their salvation. His ancient ancestor Isildur struck the ring from the hand of evil; thus, Sauron fears his coming. However, he is more powerful than Isildur. He has lived amongst the elves, and he has learnt how his ancestor failed to crush the darkness in his vain weakness. Aragorn will not make the same mistake. He will do better.

description

4.Loyalty

The party itself, the Fellowship of the Ring, are bound together with a mutual goal. But it’s more than that; they are dependent on each other. Each has skills the others could never possess. And each brings with him the hope of a people. Simply put, these heroes cannot fail. Middle earth depends on them. They are the best of their races, the most representative of their cultures, and their participation speaks of a will to conquer the shadow that approaches. It speaks of commitment.

description

5.Finding your courage

Not all the party have been fully tested. With them travel four young hobbits, the most unlikely of companions for such a journey. They are the overlooked, the forgotten about, the race that is casually discarded and considered insignificant in the wider world. And perhaps this has been the downfall of society in middle earth previously. The forces of darkness exploit everything they can get their hands on, from giant spiders to rampaging trolls, from dragons to orcs, from men of the east to the undead, Sauron tries to wield it all. This is something the forces of good have not fully considered until recently. Within the bosom of the hobbit beats a strong heart of fortitude and resilience.

“My dear Frodo!� exclaimed Gandalf. ‘Hobbits really are amazing creatures, as I have said before. You can learn all that there is to know about their ways in a month, and yet after a hundred years they can still surprise you at a pinch.�

They carry with them the key to destroying the dark. Bilbo showed them how he could resist the ring. The hobbits are an almost incorruptible race, and because of this they are Sauron’s doom. It is something he has overlooked.

“It would be the death of you to come with me, Sam," said Frodo, "and I could not have borne that."

"Not as certain as being left behind," said Sam.

"But I am going to Mordor."

"I know that well enough, Mr. Frodo. Of course you are. And I'm coming with you.�


description

6.The Rich History

Middle earth didn’t pop up overnight. This word has been around for thousands of years. Such can be seen from the ruined statues and monuments that dot the landscape, to mentions of historic battles and finally to kings long since departed. This is a world that has seen a lot. This moment in the third age, which is arguable the most important series of events this world will ever see, is merely the surface. Go read The Silmarillion. Go see how old and beautiful this world is. I could lose myself in Middle-earth. And this book carries with it all the baggage of what came before. It’s extraordinary.

description

7.The Diverse Languages and Races

And with this history comes the language of the people. The elves, the men, the dwarves and Sauron’s creatures of darkness all come with their own developed languages. This isn’t some random phrases stuck in the book, which you may see with other fantasy novels, but actually fully developed languages. They have their own grammatical forms, syntax styles and sound qualities that reflect the speaker. The languages are real. Naturally, the elvish language is a personal favourite of mine:

description

8.The Power of Redemption

It is easy to judge Boromir of Gondor. He tried to take the ring from Frodo, though for all his misguidedness, he was trying to do right by his people. He naively believed, due to his farther Denethor, that the ring could be wielded against the evil. So when a young hobbit is trying to destroy his people’s supposed salvation, he strikes.Until that moment he doesn’t fully understand the evil it holds, until his desire for it twists his heart and turns him violent. But, afterwards, after he sees what he has become, his willpower does prevail: he understands. He later dies defending the Fellowship of the Ring, a bloody end, but one that saves his honour.

description

9. The Forces of Darkness

One evil binds them all. Sauron tried to make himself the ultimate tyrant, and claim dominion over all lands: he wanted to be the de facto ruler of middle earth. He failed. Those that followed his initial claim are forever left in the dark. Their souls are black, their hearts corrupt: their bodies no more. The Nazgul have become the living dead; they are complex figure, driven by hate and a will no longer their own. These men have become something else. Do they wish to rest? I do not know. Do they wish to carry out their master’s work or are they driven by his domination? I do not know. Orcs are mere tools for the darkness, the Nazgul are something much darker. They are the perfect harbingers of their lord.

description

10. The Elves

The elves are my favourite part of middle earth. I should have been born an elf. I would love to spend a few years in Rivendell, especially in Elrond’s library relaxing by the waterfalls reading the histories of middle earth. Doesn’t that just sound like so much fun? The best thing about reading fantasy like this is the pure escapism it provides, the worse thing is realising how shit the “real world� is in comparison.

description

To quote another fine author of fantasy, and to conclude this review, I will simply repeat these words:

"They can keep their heaven. When I die, I’d sooner go to middle Earth."

___________________________________

You can connect with me on social media via .
__________________________________
707 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Fellowship of the Ring.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
Finished Reading
January 17, 2014 – Shelved
June 10, 2014 – Shelved as: tolkien
Started Reading
June 26, 2016 – Shelved as: 5-star-reads
June 26, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-47 of 47 (47 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Layla ✷ Praise the sun ✷ Fantastic non-review-review. The elves are my favorite part of middle earth as well :)


Puneet Gautam Wow !! This piece by you just brilliant.


message 3: by Carmen (new)

Carmen Awesome Sean. My reasons for loving it are the same:) but I couldn't put it so well. I read it as a child and it shook my world forever.


Anne Amazing review, Sean! It reminds me of exactly why I love this book :))


message 5: by Michelle (new)

Michelle Curie Beautifully put!


Sheila Beaumont I've lost count of how many times I've read this!


Colin Aragorn is based on Oswald of Northumbria according to The King in the North: The Life and Times of Oswald of Northumbria which I've just been reading. There are definitely a lot of parallels: Oswald was an Anglo Saxon son of a Northumbrian king but went into exile as a child to the Gaelic kingdom of Dal Riata (in Western Scotland and including the island of Iona) where he was brought up and effectively fostered by the Dal Riatan king. He returned to claim the kingship as an adult, reuniting the two Northumbrian kingdoms of Bernicia and Deira and bringing Christianity to the English.


Sean Barrs Colin wrote: "Aragorn is based on Oswald of Northumbria according to The King in the North: The Life and Times of Oswald of Northumbria which I've just been reading. There are definitely a lot of..."

Very interesting, I didn't know that


Sean Barrs Sheila wrote: "I've lost count of how many times I've read this!"

Ive read it three times


Sean Barrs Michelle wrote: "Beautifully put!"

Thanks ;)


Sean Barrs Anne wrote: "Amazing review, Sean! It reminds me of exactly why I love this book :))"

Thanks ;) it's hard not too ;)


Sean Barrs Carmen wrote: "Awesome Sean. My reasons for loving it are the same:) but I couldn't put it so well. I read it as a child and it shook my world forever."

Unfortunately, I didn't read it till my late teens. I wish I read this as a youngster


Sean Barrs Puneet wrote: "Wow !! This piece by you just brilliant."

Thanks!


Sean Barrs LaylaNoir wrote: "Fantastic non-review-review. The elves are my favorite part of middle earth as well :)"

They're just so cool! And thanks ;)


message 15: by Igor (new)

Igor Ljubuncic Nice one!
Igor


message 16: by PorshaJo (new)

PorshaJo Awesome review!


Forrest Good stuff, this. Sarumsn was always my favorite character - definitely the most complex of the characters. The movies did him wrong.


Fabian  {Councillor} I belong to the few weird people who haven't read the books and not even watched the movies. I definitely have to do that soon! (It's definitely planned for next year, at the latest.) Thank you for a great review, Sean :)


message 19: by Margaret (new)

Margaret Let me echo everyone who has written before me: this is simply a wonderful piece. Your deep knowledge of and intense love for Tolkien's book and the worlds within makes this list of your ten reasons just sublime. Bravo!!


Sean Barrs Igor wrote: "Nice one!
Igor"


Cheers :)


Sean Barrs PorshaJo wrote: "Awesome review!"

Thanks :)


Sean Barrs Forrest wrote: "Good stuff, this. Sarumsn was always my favorite character - definitely the most complex of the characters. The movies did him wrong."

Very wrong. He didn't even change into Saruman of many colors. Instead both he and Gandalf were white......


Sean Barrs Councillor wrote: "I belong to the few weird people who haven't read the books and not even watched the movies. I definitely have to do that soon! (It's definitely planned for next year, at the latest.) Thank you for..."

thanks- I hope you like it too when you come to read it :)


Sean Barrs Margaret wrote: "Let me echo everyone who has written before me: this is simply a wonderful piece. Your deep knowledge of and intense love for Tolkien's book and the worlds within makes this list of your ten reason..."

Thank you. I'm just a big Tolkien nerd :)


Maame Serwa Nice one. For the past 16 years I’ve been watching this movie and I still enjoy it.


message 26: by [deleted user] (new)

I LOVE IT


message 27: by Leal (new) - added it

Leal Luo I like the last one, I also want to be born as an elf, or I simply want to find some peaceful stuffs, that's one of the reason why I like this book.


Kirsten Alright, its fall and the time for the annual reimmersion into lotr. Your post brought up all the emotions and was the perfect place to start off. 😊


Yulia Amazing review!


message 30: by Rahma (new)

Rahma Krambo Great review! Thanks.


Charis Bohler I love this book too. My Dad read it to me.


message 32: by Sury (new)

Sury De qué soy rarita con estos libros... lo soy!!! Imagina que leí la saga completa, incluyendo El Hobbit, cuando tenía 12 o 13 años. De tal forma que me los aprendí casi completos 😁 ( ves, dije que era rarita) Y sé que es imposible hacer una reseña justa, aunque tú lo has hecho muy bien. Me encanta la forma en que lo describes. Así, que nos vemos en la Tierra Media un día 🙂


message 33: by Sai (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sai I totally agree you can't rate this as a fantasy fan it is too great


message 34: by Lilly Wale (new) - added it

Lilly Wale i was reading till midnight!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


message 35: by syl (new) - added it

syl hows do you write reviews?


Carola Velazquez This is probably the best review I’ve ever read!


Benjamin Connolly I love this book and your review just shows me how good this book is even more


Scott Marshall After reading the 1 star reviews and cringing in disbelief that people actually hate these books, I’m so glad to have read your review. I don’t think anyone could have said it better. Thank you for your most amazing review. These books are incredible and I hope Tolkien wherever he may be, has the chance to read this because he would be proud. Fantastic review.


Lil Bookish Dragon This is one of the best reviews I’ve read for this book


message 40: by Jade (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jade Great review.


message 41: by Andi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Andi This is so very GOOD!!!


Ellie Long I like how you delve deeper into the book than most people would! I like it!👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻


Casey Great review.


bernadette This is absolutely the greatest review of all time


bernadette I can’t stop reading it


bernadette You have single-handedly found incredible values of this book that I have never noticed before. GREAT JOB!


message 47: by Megan (new) - added it

Megan Pinto That’s the best review I’ve ever seen


back to top