Lawyer's Reviews > A Christmas Memory
A Christmas Memory
by
by

Lawyer's review
bookshelves: memoir, non-fiction, southern-literature, southern-class-and-culture, autobiography, childhood, christmas
Jan 01, 2010
bookshelves: memoir, non-fiction, southern-literature, southern-class-and-culture, autobiography, childhood, christmas
Capote's Holiday Memoirs: The Whispers of Memory
Truman Capote's The Thanksgiving Visitor was chosen as a Moderator's Choice by Laura Webber, "The Tall Woman," as a read for the group On the Southern Literary Trail for November, 2014
These reflections have been written over the course of nearly three years. After my wife read these thoughts, she pointed out the importance of marking the time of thoughts in connection with the events of our lives.
December 24, 2011
Perhaps I should say this is not so much the review of a book, but the response A Christmas Memory still draws from me each year when I read it. Perhaps it is just a simple statement of the preciousness of memory and the gift it brings us to keep things alive within us, though those things have been gone from us for many years.
Things. Toys, books, friends, parents, lovers, spouses, children. What would we do without the gift of memory? How would we survive? Without it, we would be nothing but empty shells mindlessly living in the moment.
On an old revolving bookcase in my library are some of my favorite books. Faulkner and Fitzgerald, Hemingway and Steinbeck fill the little shelves that turn easily at the push of a finger. Eudora Welty is there, as is Flannery O'Conner, Carson McCullers and Thomas Wolfe. My beloved "To Kill a Mockingbird" rests underneath a miniature of the old Monroeville courthouse on a shelf up on the wall overlooking the little bookcase that holds the treasures of my imagination.
I glance up at it and back down to the little case that spins so easily. There is Erskine Caldwell. And there is Truman Capote. There is a copy of the complete short stories of the little man who spent his summers with Harper Lee in Monroeville when they were children.
Normally two slender volumes stand next to the Capote short stories . They are slipcased editions of "The Thanksgiving Visitor" and a "Christmas Memory." I have taken them to the bedside table because it is time to read them once more. The Holidays have begun. Thanksgiving has come and gone. I could re-shelve "The Thanksgiving Visitor, but I never do until I have read "A Christmas Memory" once more.
Remembrance of Things Past
They are a matched set in more ways than one. "The Thanksgiving Visitor" is in a blue slipcase, "A Christmas Memory" is in red. Each has a photograph of a very young Truman Capote and his best childhood friend, Aunt Sook, tipped onto the case. The books slide easily from their cases for I have read them so many times. Each is a testament to the art of making books one does not often find anymore. The gold titles still gleam along the spines. Each page is on paper so thick I can feel the rag content between my fingers. There is still the faint smell of the typesetter's ink. Or is it only my imagination? Does it matter? The dark green endpapers turn stiffly at the insistence of my finger, reminding me something special is inside. And in each of them is the spidery Spenserian handwriting of my grandmother, "Xmas 1980, Ammomie and Papa."
Evidence of love surrounds us
It is that inscription that urges me to take these little books out each year. For in addition to the joy and simple kindness of Capote's holiday memories are the memories of my own Thanksgivings and Christmases, some joyous and some not, especially those holidays without my grandparents, both of whom have been gone now over twenty years. Yet I still long for their presence, I find them with me more often now because of the gift of memories, especially the sweetest ones.
But reading these little stories, seeing my grandmother's little inscription, bring my grandparents back to me in ways I could not have without the weight of these books in my hand. They are the physical ties that bind us together no matter how many years we may be apart, no matter how many years it may be before we hopefully are together again, or not. Who is to say? Who knows? I certainly don't.
So it is Christmas Eve once more. Tonight I will read "A Christmas Memory." I have lost count of the times I have read it.
Today my mother's kitchen will be redolent with the aromas of Roast Turkey, buttermilk pie, sweet potato souffle and sweet bourbon corn pudding. The cornbread dressing will be steaming and the giblet gravy will be hot and succulent. I will share the table today with my wife and mother. I will be thankful for home and family and the memory of those I love who will not be sharing our table today, whether separated by simple miles or death itself. I will raise a toast to each of those dear to me and I will feel their presence around the table because of two little books given to me one Christmas morning more than thirty years ago.
Though there will be no fruitcake at our table, I will delight in Sook's excited call to Buddy. "It's Fruitcake Weather!"
I have walked the streets of Monroeville, Alabama, many times. There is little sign of Truman Capote or Nelle Harper Lee in that town, other than the old Courthouse, now a museum. Truman Capote's childhood summer and Christmas home is a vacant lot. Ms. Lee's home, if my geography is right, is occupied by something akin to a Dairy Queen, though some owner long past decided the name recognition was not worth the franchise price to have it.
Whether you celebrate Christmas, Kwanzaa, Hanukkah, or nothing at all, I wish each of you the best of memories for the coming day.
To Life--
Mike
Addendum
December 24, 2013
The Christmas dinner described above was the last my wife and I shared with my Mother. We were fortunate to have her with us through Thanksgiving and Christmas. Our homes were two doors apart. My wife and I moved into her home to be her caregivers. Mother died February 1, 2012. I am fortunate to have a number of books given to me by her through the years. I am mindful of the poet W.S. Merwin who told us, “What you remember saves you.� Yes, it does.
Another Thanksgiving, Evening, November 22, 2014
Tomorrow, my wife Martha Jo and I begin our Thanksgiving trip to Wilmington, North Carolina. Waiting for us there will be MJ's brother, Bill, whom MJ once hit over the head with a cast iron skillet because he insisted on watching Bonanza when she wanted to watch Lucy. His wife, Anne, will be producer and director of all activities. She was not the former Postmistress of Killingsworth, Connecticut, for nothing. Bill commonly tells people he is also from Connecticut. However the most important person in Wilmington we will see is Zola Mae Boston, MJ and Bill's mother. Zola Mae is ninety-five years young. She is from Dallas, Texas, as is MJ, and, of course, Bill. Although Bill is quite adroit in addressing anyone in a clipped Connecticut accent, when he tells anyone in Zola Mae's presence he is from Connecticut, she corrects him. "Why, Bill Boston, you're not from Connecticut. You're from Dallas, Texas. I ought to know. I was there when you were born." I rather enjoy seeing a Texan denying his heritage chastened. *chuckle*
So it is not that I am without family. I am embraced by them, particularly Zola Mae who loves how I say Alabama. That our accents are not that different has not occurred to her.
The Thanksgiving Visitor and A Christmas Memory have both been carried to Wilmington. Holiday dinners there are not small affairs. Friends and neighbors fill the house. Extra tables and chairs are brought in. Each couple, group, single, brings a dish.
Following dinner, I have read each of Capote's memoirs aloud in character. And these stories have become part of the memories of many others over two previous holiday seasons. I can do it straight. And, yes, I can channel Capote, which rather unnerves even me.
This year these little books grow even more special to me as I read the comments of "The Trail" members while they experience Capote's stories. One mother is reading "The Thanksgiving Visitor" to her ten year old daughter. She's a smart child. She likes Buddy's friend and says the narrator is good. Now there's another child who will have some special memories of her own.
In all our lives we have memories both bitter and sweet. Nobody said it better than Robert Frost. "In three words I can sum up everything I’ve learned about life: it goes on."
Happy Thanksgiving. Should you not have occasion to celebrate that holiday, simply find a reason to remember it. Each day is a gift.
Truman Capote's The Thanksgiving Visitor was chosen as a Moderator's Choice by Laura Webber, "The Tall Woman," as a read for the group On the Southern Literary Trail for November, 2014
These reflections have been written over the course of nearly three years. After my wife read these thoughts, she pointed out the importance of marking the time of thoughts in connection with the events of our lives.
December 24, 2011
Perhaps I should say this is not so much the review of a book, but the response A Christmas Memory still draws from me each year when I read it. Perhaps it is just a simple statement of the preciousness of memory and the gift it brings us to keep things alive within us, though those things have been gone from us for many years.
Things. Toys, books, friends, parents, lovers, spouses, children. What would we do without the gift of memory? How would we survive? Without it, we would be nothing but empty shells mindlessly living in the moment.
On an old revolving bookcase in my library are some of my favorite books. Faulkner and Fitzgerald, Hemingway and Steinbeck fill the little shelves that turn easily at the push of a finger. Eudora Welty is there, as is Flannery O'Conner, Carson McCullers and Thomas Wolfe. My beloved "To Kill a Mockingbird" rests underneath a miniature of the old Monroeville courthouse on a shelf up on the wall overlooking the little bookcase that holds the treasures of my imagination.
I glance up at it and back down to the little case that spins so easily. There is Erskine Caldwell. And there is Truman Capote. There is a copy of the complete short stories of the little man who spent his summers with Harper Lee in Monroeville when they were children.
Normally two slender volumes stand next to the Capote short stories . They are slipcased editions of "The Thanksgiving Visitor" and a "Christmas Memory." I have taken them to the bedside table because it is time to read them once more. The Holidays have begun. Thanksgiving has come and gone. I could re-shelve "The Thanksgiving Visitor, but I never do until I have read "A Christmas Memory" once more.
Remembrance of Things Past
They are a matched set in more ways than one. "The Thanksgiving Visitor" is in a blue slipcase, "A Christmas Memory" is in red. Each has a photograph of a very young Truman Capote and his best childhood friend, Aunt Sook, tipped onto the case. The books slide easily from their cases for I have read them so many times. Each is a testament to the art of making books one does not often find anymore. The gold titles still gleam along the spines. Each page is on paper so thick I can feel the rag content between my fingers. There is still the faint smell of the typesetter's ink. Or is it only my imagination? Does it matter? The dark green endpapers turn stiffly at the insistence of my finger, reminding me something special is inside. And in each of them is the spidery Spenserian handwriting of my grandmother, "Xmas 1980, Ammomie and Papa."
Evidence of love surrounds us
It is that inscription that urges me to take these little books out each year. For in addition to the joy and simple kindness of Capote's holiday memories are the memories of my own Thanksgivings and Christmases, some joyous and some not, especially those holidays without my grandparents, both of whom have been gone now over twenty years. Yet I still long for their presence, I find them with me more often now because of the gift of memories, especially the sweetest ones.
But reading these little stories, seeing my grandmother's little inscription, bring my grandparents back to me in ways I could not have without the weight of these books in my hand. They are the physical ties that bind us together no matter how many years we may be apart, no matter how many years it may be before we hopefully are together again, or not. Who is to say? Who knows? I certainly don't.
So it is Christmas Eve once more. Tonight I will read "A Christmas Memory." I have lost count of the times I have read it.
Today my mother's kitchen will be redolent with the aromas of Roast Turkey, buttermilk pie, sweet potato souffle and sweet bourbon corn pudding. The cornbread dressing will be steaming and the giblet gravy will be hot and succulent. I will share the table today with my wife and mother. I will be thankful for home and family and the memory of those I love who will not be sharing our table today, whether separated by simple miles or death itself. I will raise a toast to each of those dear to me and I will feel their presence around the table because of two little books given to me one Christmas morning more than thirty years ago.
Though there will be no fruitcake at our table, I will delight in Sook's excited call to Buddy. "It's Fruitcake Weather!"
I have walked the streets of Monroeville, Alabama, many times. There is little sign of Truman Capote or Nelle Harper Lee in that town, other than the old Courthouse, now a museum. Truman Capote's childhood summer and Christmas home is a vacant lot. Ms. Lee's home, if my geography is right, is occupied by something akin to a Dairy Queen, though some owner long past decided the name recognition was not worth the franchise price to have it.
Whether you celebrate Christmas, Kwanzaa, Hanukkah, or nothing at all, I wish each of you the best of memories for the coming day.
To Life--
Mike
Addendum
December 24, 2013
The Christmas dinner described above was the last my wife and I shared with my Mother. We were fortunate to have her with us through Thanksgiving and Christmas. Our homes were two doors apart. My wife and I moved into her home to be her caregivers. Mother died February 1, 2012. I am fortunate to have a number of books given to me by her through the years. I am mindful of the poet W.S. Merwin who told us, “What you remember saves you.� Yes, it does.
Another Thanksgiving, Evening, November 22, 2014
Tomorrow, my wife Martha Jo and I begin our Thanksgiving trip to Wilmington, North Carolina. Waiting for us there will be MJ's brother, Bill, whom MJ once hit over the head with a cast iron skillet because he insisted on watching Bonanza when she wanted to watch Lucy. His wife, Anne, will be producer and director of all activities. She was not the former Postmistress of Killingsworth, Connecticut, for nothing. Bill commonly tells people he is also from Connecticut. However the most important person in Wilmington we will see is Zola Mae Boston, MJ and Bill's mother. Zola Mae is ninety-five years young. She is from Dallas, Texas, as is MJ, and, of course, Bill. Although Bill is quite adroit in addressing anyone in a clipped Connecticut accent, when he tells anyone in Zola Mae's presence he is from Connecticut, she corrects him. "Why, Bill Boston, you're not from Connecticut. You're from Dallas, Texas. I ought to know. I was there when you were born." I rather enjoy seeing a Texan denying his heritage chastened. *chuckle*
So it is not that I am without family. I am embraced by them, particularly Zola Mae who loves how I say Alabama. That our accents are not that different has not occurred to her.
The Thanksgiving Visitor and A Christmas Memory have both been carried to Wilmington. Holiday dinners there are not small affairs. Friends and neighbors fill the house. Extra tables and chairs are brought in. Each couple, group, single, brings a dish.
Following dinner, I have read each of Capote's memoirs aloud in character. And these stories have become part of the memories of many others over two previous holiday seasons. I can do it straight. And, yes, I can channel Capote, which rather unnerves even me.
This year these little books grow even more special to me as I read the comments of "The Trail" members while they experience Capote's stories. One mother is reading "The Thanksgiving Visitor" to her ten year old daughter. She's a smart child. She likes Buddy's friend and says the narrator is good. Now there's another child who will have some special memories of her own.
In all our lives we have memories both bitter and sweet. Nobody said it better than Robert Frost. "In three words I can sum up everything I’ve learned about life: it goes on."
Happy Thanksgiving. Should you not have occasion to celebrate that holiday, simply find a reason to remember it. Each day is a gift.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
A Christmas Memory.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 1, 2010
– Shelved
December 24, 2011
–
Started Reading
December 24, 2011
– Shelved as:
memoir
December 24, 2011
– Shelved as:
non-fiction
December 24, 2011
– Shelved as:
southern-literature
December 24, 2011
– Shelved as:
southern-class-and-culture
December 24, 2011
– Shelved as:
autobiography
December 24, 2011
– Shelved as:
christmas
December 24, 2011
– Shelved as:
childhood
December 24, 2011
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-49 of 49 (49 new)
date
newest »



really good review. It is a really good story.


GoldGato, thank you for your comment. I've read all of the works of Truman Capote with the exception of a volume of his letters. Don't stop with the holiday books. There is much to explore in his novels and stories. I recommend all of them.

Melanie, thank you so much. I always appreciate your encouraging words.

Sir, you're most welcome. And I certainly see you've gotten the Christmas Spirit. Love the new profile shot!

Erika, you're so kind to comment. It's always a nice occasion to hear from a member of "The Trail."

Thank you Cathy. This one was a pleasure to write, though it was bittersweet to present this reflection with its addendum. However, the power of memory remains as strong a gift as it ever has been.

Your words are especially valued, for we have both experienced the sweet and the bitter. My friend, you've been a great support to me, and I hope that I have been so for you.

Spenk, this reply is long overdue. I am somewhat abashed over my neglect. I am often guilty of not looking back on a review or essay after it has been posted. I hope you will accept my apology, for I certainly never intended to ignore a comment from you. You have been a continuing source of encouragement to me for a long time. Please know how much I value your opinion.


And thanks for the Merwin quote I hadn't heard before: 'What you remember saves you' and for reminding me of the Frost one: 'In three words I can sum up everything I've learned about life: it goes on'.

I'm Connecticut born and raised so love your references to family that have roots here. Though I never met Anne, I can attest to the spirit of our Postmistresses. We are fortunate that in our small Eastern CT towns that we get to know and love them. One of my favorite librarians is Director of Killingworth Public Library. Small world.
I have always loved the Southern writer Ferrol Sam's Christmas Gift. I have never read Truman Capote's Thanksgiving Memory or A Christmas Memory. I will remedy this based on your poignant comments. My copies will not have inscriptions but I will know that you, Mike, suggested these. That will make them special. Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours.

Paula, my thanks for your time in reading and commenting. Sometimes the responses a work of literature evokes from a reader is as important as its literary merit. This is very true for me in Capote's little holiday stories. One remains to be reflected upon--One Christmas. It addresses Capote's leaving his Monroeville home. One day. Soon. The things that are done in the perceived best interests of a child. It makes you wonder at times.

Connie, it is always so good to hear from you. As always, my special thanks for reading and commenting. As children we don't understand how valuable our memories will become. Isn't it appropriate that a master of children's literature should say this:
Another true memory maker.

Renato, yours is a special friendship I value that has steadily grown and developed, thanks to this grand community of readers. We indeed share much in common in thought, regarding reading, and I sense the manner in which we view life. My thanks for reading and commenting. I can think of nothing more pleasant than spending the holidays with you. For that matter, the idea of spending any day with you over coffee, a glass of wine, surrounded by a stack of books, discussing any of them would create a memory to be treasured. It is not beyond the realm of possibility my friend. I have felt the lure of Brazil for many, many years. And, Martha Jo would feel the same!


And thanks for the Merwin quote I hadn't heard before: 'What you remember saves you' and for reminding me of the Frost one: 'In three words I can sum up everyth..."
Fionnuala, you are another special lover of books from whom I always am so pleased to receive a note. Yes. I am always drawn to the thoughts of the poets. There is a beauty in their ability to capture the essence of a life's principle in the capture of the fewest, most perfect words. Though I do not review their works often, because poetry is subject to our own unique interpretation, I constantly am drawn to their words in connection with my thoughts. My thanks for your special time in sharing your thoughts with me. As a lover of all things Celtic in heritage and folklore, my thanks, Daughter of Lir.

It is a small world indeed, Carol. Although we've frequently communicated, I don't know we've ever connected the dots that established what a small world it is, in fact. I've discovered that more than once through this wonderful reading community.
I have shared your note with Anne and Bill. Anne retired from AT&T. Bill was a multi-faceted fellow, with a degree in law, which he realized was not the profession for him. Thankfully, he realized that early, did not enter the profession, and sought another career. Once in, it is difficult to leave the Law, for it tends to enter the blood. It becomes a part of one. Bill took a degree in Library Science, entered IT during its early days of development and found his true niche. To Martha Joe's alarm, upon our meeting, she realized that we were as alike as two peas in a pod, historians, lovers of literature, and debaters of politics. "What hath love wrought," she wailed. Frankly, I have been leery of cast iron skillets since I learned of MJ's skill in the use of those heavy cooking implements as weapons. I now know her as "She who must be obeyed," alternately referring to her as "The Queen."
Following Anne and Bill's retirement, they sought a warmer client. They searched from Virginia to Alabama, eventually settling on Wilmington, North Carolina. Zola Mae's sight began to dim when she turned eighty. She lost her Texas driver's license then. Both MJ and I and her brother and sister-in-law wanted Zola Mae to reside with us. Zola Mae was fast friends with my mother, having visited with her on several occasions.
However, Zola Mae, ever practical, chose to move to Wilmington as I was still with our District Attorney's Office and MJ was in retail management. Now all of us are happily retired. MJ and I spend as much time in Wilmington as much as possible. At times, I feel as though we keep one foot in Wilmington and one foot in Tuscaloosa, Alabama.
Anne's parents were Eddie and Shirley Farrier. Eddie was a larger and life Irish-American, a veteran of the Navy who saw service in World War II. He was a beautiful Irish Tenor. Following the death of his wife, Shirley, he joined Bill and Anne in Wilmington. Eddie insisted on calling me Miguel. I called him Eduardo. We frequently joined one another in duets of Irish songs. A good time we had. We lost Eduardo shortly after my mother's death.
Although of Irish descent, Eduardo preferred a fine Martini. A strong "Dirty Martini". I honor his memory with a toast of a fine Irish Whiskey, moderately poured.
All memories come in a mixture of bitter and sweet. The year following my mother's death was one of grief and deep depression. As a care giver, one feels absolutely lost. I was an only child. My father abandoned my mother and I when I was an infant. She married young. We essentially grew up together in my grandparents' home. When my mother entered her final illness, I, who had always believed I could fix anything, naively believed I was capable of "saving" my mother's life. Of course, Medical advice was upbeat and as it turned out, pie in the sky.
The year following my mother's death was one of extreme grief. In complete honesty, it was also a period of hopelessness and deep depression. I feel no stigma in saying that I feel no stigma in that admission. The road to recovery was long and difficult. Part of that was my writing, reading, and discussion of literature. Another part of it was immersion into acts of helping others.
Our loved ones whom we have lost are never truly lost to us as long as we have the gift of memory, although we may feel their absence.
Mother remained mentally alert until the night before she died. She was still reading a book the night before she passed away. She was an inspiration to more than one nurse and physician. One doctor in particular told me of his daughter who was a voracious reader. His child read constantly. His wife complained about their daughter's constant reading. He had originally been of his wife's opinion. Over the course of his treatment of my mother, he had changed his mind about his daughter's inquisitive mind. He used my mother's quick mind as his example of why their daughter should never be discouraged from the pursuit of knowledge. That remains as a special homage to my mother's memory which I will always cherish. It is also a trait I learned not only from my mother, but my grandparents as well.
Yet again, a memory that is bittersweet. However, a fitting tribute to my mother's acumen and strength to the last. I hope for that spirit of indomitability.
Thank you my friend, to whom I was closer than I ever realized.

Magdalena, thanks you for your reading and commenting. I appreciate your reading my reviews and your comments. I have noticed your frequent attention. I deeply appreciate this. It is the encouragement of you and others that lead me to write. It is not to gain attention, nor is it done out of any act of pride. Rather, to keep the love of reading alive. Again, my thanks.

Hah! It began after he appeared on the Dick Cavett show. It was an exceptional interview. He became a frequent guest on various late night talk shows. Capote came to Alabama for the filming of the various holiday memoirs. They were filmed in and around Montgomery. In his entourage at the time was Princess Lee Radziwill. Capote was regularly featured on Alabama newscasts. I've long had a knack for impersonation. Capote was quite easy. Flamboyant, broad gestures, a distinctive voice, a bit high, a bit of a lisp thrown in here and there.
"Odd Henderson was the meanest human creature in my experience!"
It came out perfectly. Nor was it meant disrespectfully.
The Thanksgiving Visitor was filmed for ABC Television in 1967. Capote wrote the screenplay with Eleanor Perry. Capote also served as Narrator.
The Thanksgiving Visitor is available on Youtube in five parts, beginning with part one at: . One part will lead you to the next.
A Christmas Memory is also available on Youtube complete in sections. Simply search Youtube for "A Christmas Memory Truman Capote". And enjoy.

(And look for a special DVD in your mailbox.)

(And look for a special DVD in your mailbox.)"
Randy, that is something I'll truly look forward to doing. Conversation with you is a true pleasure. Look for a message from me via goodreads e-mail. Happy Thanksgiving, my friend.

Kim, My thanks for your kind words. You have my deepest sympathy for the loss of your Mother. The first birthday, first holidays, first Mother's day are the most difficult. That the season brings you the blessing of your first grandchild truly tempers sadness with joy. Wishing you the happiness of making memories for the future.

Holidays are a curious mixture of nostalgia and a slate for new memories. I hope the new ones you make give you as much, if not more, warmth and joy!





Thank you, Amanda. What you say is so true.

This is so beautiful I'm sharing it with a group we're both in, in a "Bookish Diary" thread where we were discussing Truman Capote.
Link here to comment 930. Hope you don't mind ... and that you are well :)


I love these books by Capote. Have you read A Christmas Cup of Tea? I buy a few Christmas books every year and keep the ones I love best and give the others to our library.

I really need to read this book, and more Capote in general. I have read a handful of his short pieces and have been very impressed, but I sadly have neglected to read more. Which is a shame because I have always meant to, so this year I'm making it a goal to live in the pages of a Capote book or two for awhile.
Sorry to write so long (I have had some 'holiday cheer' or two in a glass this evening to help fuel the flow), but this review really struck me. It is good to know someone else properly respects a good book. I hope you put your written eloquence down in a memoir or a novel someday, it would be a shame not to. Cheers.