ŷ

Paul Bryant's Reviews > The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Stieg Larsson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
416390
's review

liked it
bookshelves: novels, scandilit


Editorial meeting of Bryant Reviews Ltd
Topic : book 1, Millennium series

- Is everyone here?
- We should start anyway.
- Okay, well, we have to figure out how to review this damned Dragon Tattoo book. The problem is, everyone and his dog has already reviewed it, and seen the movie. Movies. What’s left to say?
- Well, you could say the same thing about Dickens.
- All due respect, Larsson is not no Dickens.
- True dat.
- True dat? Who are you, gangsta-reviewer?
- What about the sandwiches and coffee?
- ?
- You know, you could do a kind of parody, might be funny�
- It’s been done! Haven’t you read Joel’s review?
- Done!
- Done done done!
- Also, really, there weren’t that many sandwiches. I counted, there were 7. It’s a bit of a myth.
- That’s 7 more than most sane novelists describe in their novels. I bet you could scour the works of Henry James and not find a single sniff of a sandwich.
- That’s cause they only eat ptarmigan’s brains on a bed of rocket leaves in Henry James.
- What about the blatant product placement? I mean, I assume that’s what this is.
- Product placement in a novel? Can you do that?
- Well, listen to this bit :

She set her sights on the new Apple PowerBook G4/1.0 GHz in an aluminium case with a PowerPC. 7451 processor with an AltiVec Velocity Engine, 960 megs of R.A.M and a sixty-gig hard drive. It had Blue-Tooth and built-in CD and DVD burners. Page 202.

- Yep, that has to be product placement. It’s like right out of a sales brochure. Outrageous really.
- So did anyone like this thing?
- Oh sure. It was kind of okay.
- Okay?
- It’s a thriller, you know, it’s not A la recherché du Temps Tattoo. Also, it’s a serial killer thriller, where the victims are females chopped up in various horrible ways. So it’s a completely ordinary thriller. They say shit like “But for you I would be dead!� and “This can’t be brushed under the carpet!� and “Get out of my house this minute!�

(General laughter)

- What about Salamander?
- It’s Salander.
- Oh yeah, I did that too. Every time it said Salander I thought it said salamander, it was so crazy.
- She was a bit off the peg, didn’t you think?
- Yeah, it was like a central casting “hip edgy young female character�.
- I liked her.
- Everyone likes her. Okay, except you. You too? Okay, vote � who liked her? Okay, that’s three who did, so the rest of you didn’t. All right then, we’ll take a contrarian position on Salander. We’ll say, oh, I don’t know, utterly implausible, Manga cartoon, middle-aged guy’s fantasy girlfriend, the goth version of the manic dream pixie girl, you know, that kind of stuff.
- Agreed.
- What about the plot?
- It was just a big fat thriller so it had a big fat villain who was completely silly and an exciting denouement which I’ve been more excited going through a tunnel in a train to be brutally honest.
- Anybody else?
- Er� I felt slightly tense. Once.
- Oh, and did you notice it took like 80 pages to splutter into life and then another 50 pages after the story ended to wind down and go to sleep?
- Well look, there’s a deadline here, this review has to be done by Tuesday evening. Any volunteers?
- �.
- �.
- I’ll do it then
- Hey, thanks. And as your reward� you don’t have to read The Emo who Played with Fire or The Emo who Fucked Up the Beehive.
- Okay, I appreciate that.
- The rest of you watch it� I see any review slackness and Emo with the Beehive is coming right at you.

(General catcalling and ribaldry)

- Meeting adjourned.
145 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 19, 2014 – Started Reading
May 19, 2014 – Shelved
May 19, 2014 –
page 99
18.4% "first 80 pages, I was draggin myself through more clunky dialogue than all of Woody Allen's serious movies put together - ugh; but now we're into the locked island mystery, so hopefully the fun will start. Mabe it will be a Salander Summer - read all the books and see all the movies including remakes! 3 books, 6 movies. Oh and a tv series."
May 21, 2014 –
page 196
36.43% "well I wouldn't say this is GRIPPING yet, it's kind of bumbling along, and I'm SHOCKED that by page 196 there has been not a single mention of a SANDWICH. This is not what I was led to believe."
May 25, 2014 –
page 252
46.84% "Sandwichwatch : the first one I spotted was on p204, surprisingly late. Count so far : 3. This is the number of times sandwiches get a specific mention, not the number of sandwiches made or eaten on each occasion, which, of course, varies between a single one and up to four, if Blomkvist is making two for himself and two for the person he's with."
May 26, 2014 –
page 422
78.44% "Sandwichwatch : number 7 is on page 422. After a very hectic night which involves some dreadful gruesome stuff, which I can't discuss, Lisbeth makes "thick sandwiches on rye bread with cheese and liver sausage and dill pickle". It seems close to insanity to be telling the reader about the liver sausage and the dill pickle, considering what has just happened. But maybe it is not insane, just very Scandinavian."
May 27, 2014 – Shelved as: novels
May 27, 2014 – Finished Reading
May 6, 2021 – Shelved as: scandilit

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Manny Mr. Bryant, I'm taking this as a formal admission that you crowdsource your reviews. I'm glad you've finally decided to come clean. Don't you feel better already?


Paul Bryant I do. There's seven of us. Did you ever see Multiplicity? Like that.


Manny We all loved that movie!


Manny I mean, ah, I loved that movie. Excuse me. That would have been perfectly natural in Swedish, you understand.


message 5: by Richard (last edited May 27, 2014 11:25AM) (new)

Richard Manny wrote: "I mean, ah, I loved that movie. Excuse me. That would have been perfectly natural in Swedish, you understand."

Nice save there, Mannies (view spoiler).


message 6: by Francesca (new)

Francesca Marciano Paul, after this utterly brilliant review you MUST keep on reviewing the rest of the saga. More sandwiches await you (and your other six pals)


message 7: by Eric (new)

Eric Wojcik I took the obsession with what's her face's computers not as product placement but rather tech fetishization that ages hilariously.


message 8: by Jayne (new)

Jayne Doe I picked up this series a few years back, and didn't even try and read them until at least a year later. I found the story intriguing in an uncomfortable sort of way, if I remember. I ended losing the first book while out of the house, and just donated the other two. Which was probably for the best. The style just reminded me of any other generic thriller (think James Patterson) but ~°~☆European☆~°~ as opposed to ~°~☆high brow☆~°~. Great review nometheless, Paul :^)


Praj Splendid review, Mr.B! you never fail to amaze me.


Karen Brilliantly witty review. I'd missed the product placement but now you come to mention it�.. This was the best of the trilogy - after this one he got completely bogged down in Swedish politics. Yawn


Linda This was one of those books where everyone around me l-o-o-o-v-e-d it to the nth degree, and I went along with them, thinking there was something wrong with me for only thinking it was okay. What was my inferior intellect missing? But now, thanks to you, I will revel in the thought that I stopped reading after the first book. Thanks for a great review, Paul. Well done, sandwiches, salamander and all.


message 12: by Paul (new) - rated it 3 stars

Paul Bryant It was deeply okay, profoundly not-that-bad. But very silly.

many thanks for all your comments.... as ever...


Anxious Readerrr Mr. Paul, your review is great! You made me laugh so hard. I'd like to see more reviews like this one, it was brilliant!


message 14: by Paul (new) - rated it 3 stars

Paul Bryant Thanks C - this was a one-off, but you may like this one too:

/review/show...


message 15: by Amanda (new)

Amanda Whitehouse I never read this. I couldn't get past the first few pages. Always thought maybe if I persevered I would have been rewarded. I read all of your review though, which was fun as always 😁


••• Emilee ••• I can’t decide if I should read it or not. Thoughts? I got it for free. So now I have a copy lyin� about.


message 17: by Paul (new) - rated it 3 stars

Paul Bryant I think it's fun enough to read.... just.


Bionic Jean Just brilliant! The sandwiches and pizza annoyed me too ... thank you :)


message 19: by Paul (new) - rated it 3 stars

Paul Bryant thanks Jean... this takes me back.... seven whole years!


 Cookie M. I got lost at the beginning. Wasn't there a sandwich in "Washington Square?"


message 21: by Tantravahi (new)

Tantravahi I haven't done the book, yet, but after THAT transcript, might as well thrown in my hat now and save myself some pain!


back to top