Fantasy Aficionados discussion
Books & Discussions
>
What are you reading? (Reboot 2.0)
message 251:
by
Michelle
(new)
Dec 11, 2013 10:14AM

reply
|
flag

Mixed feelings. I enjoyed it as a whole (gave it a 4 stars). I loved how the author built her world (some would say "slowly". I won't). I loved her writing style. I loved this Weather magic. I loved the deep characterization. I loved the shift in POV. I loved, oh, I LOVED Prince Gar.
I didn't like the ever present prophecy thing (but that's just me. I believe people can change their destiny but here, oh God, they did EVERYTHING to have the prophecy fulfilled, no matter what).
I didn't very much like the changes in Asher. I understand what he's been through but still. I was a bit disappointed with him.
I also thought it would have been great to have more space dedicated to Asher mastering his powers. I mean, we knew he was practicing spells and all but I wish we could have watched him doing it (instead, we stayed in the kitchen). The transition from Innocent to Deadly would have been more credible.
As for the Doranen "colonization" (because that's what it is) and the Doranen/Olken living together but not actually living together (Doranen "superior" race), I didn't think much about it. I read Fantasy because I want something different from real life so I try not to connect the events of a book to real life events (let's avoid headaches when it's possible).
I didn't like Dathne for many reasons (manipulative being one of them). And what she did to Darran in the epilogue only emphasized that feeling. I hated her for that. I thought she was cruel. But Asher, the kind and compassionate Asher, the Asher with a heart as big as that, found it funny *shrug* Disappointed...I know it sounds stupid but this precise fact decided me to not read the sequel duology (also there's another major fact I can't talk of because I'd only be spoiling). No more of Dathne, thanks.
Another thing. It took 2 books to build the climax up but less than a chapter to the actual good/evil confrontation. I'm not for 100-pages-battles with gore and blood but, I don't know, it was just like Asher-comes-and-destroys-the-bad-guy faster than the speed of light, thank you, goodbye.
As for the villain. Not that smart really or perhaps overconfident ? (like every villain). Well.
Anyway. To sum up, I have loved this read. I highly recommend it (unless one is looking for epic battles, Elves, Dragons, Fairies...there's "nowt" of this in this duology).



Yes, I'm reading this one too and it's another new author I will be adding to my list of favorites. He has a very well-reasoned world and a great magic system. (And it's military fantasy...I'm addicted to military fantasy, lol.)


Looks interesting but I don't think I'm in the mood for what looks to be a military fantasy with lots of political intrigue. but I know some people who would love it...

That has been on my To read shelf for a while now. Please let us know how you like it Carol!
Michelle, yes, Book of Lost Things is great! I am now reading something completely different. I was curious to find out how the Sookie Stackhouse series ended so am reading Dead Ever After

I finished Alif, which I liked a great deal, and now am deciding whether or not to re-read or to venture on. I have a few reviews waiting to be written!


Jalilah, I loved The Book of Lost Things! :)"
The first five books of the Wheel of Time series are awesome! Books 6 to 8 get a bit bogged down, but I've read book 9, Winter's Heart, really enjoyed it, and am looking forward to reading book 10 soon.

Trotting through The Hobbit in the meantime.



Now I'm reading Hard Magic. It is really good so far.

Just started The Outstretched Shadow




I'm reading it right now.
I'm only 16 chapters in but...I don't get YA per se...but I do feel a complete separation between me and the characters. I find it easy to put down...in fact, haven't picked it up in a week. I don't care about any of the characters and I no longer care what's happening. It's all too distant.

I'm reading it right now. I'm only 16 chapters in but... I find it easy to put down...in fact, haven't picked it up in a week. I don't care about any of the characters and I no longer care what's happening. It's all too distant. ..."
I read this over the summer in its omnibus The Legend of Eli Monpress. I had no idea it was three novels in that one volume - it was such a "light read". In one of the author's interviews she even stated that the series was begun to be:
"... a long running, episodic spectacle with each volume containing its own adventure and a large cast of characters that grew and deepened with each installment. Think any popular TV show ever and that's what I was shooting for."
Like so many of the "installment" fantasy series, I sort of relegate these reads to airplane layovers and long car trips.



Now reading The Lives of Tao.


Course that's really the basics.
I like to think of the three books as all one.


Course that's really the basics.
I like to think of the three books as all one."
Yeah, thanks. It seemed like McKillip changed her mind halfway through about what to do. The whole first half was just thrown away. I'll still read Harpist in the Wind because I enjoy her writing style so much.

Anyway the first volume is still my favorite. I wasn't thrilled at the way the story went, but it's written so well.


Will now start Scriber. I've heard plenty of good things about this book.


Now I'm reading Christine.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Hymn to Dionysus (other topics)Sorcery and Small Magics (other topics)
Monster Hunter Siege (other topics)
Man in the Empty Suit (other topics)
The Hunting Party (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Natasha Pulley (other topics)Maiga Doocy (other topics)
Raymond E. Feist (other topics)
Kim Stanley Robinson (other topics)
Anne Bishop (other topics)
More...