The Catholic Book Club discussion
General
>
What are you reading now?
message 1:
by
Doreen
(new)
Jul 12, 2017 01:55PM


reply
|
flag

I just finished The Philosophy of Tolkien: The Worldview Behind the Lord of the Rings, by Peter Kreeft, in advance of a re-reading of LOTR. Absolutely wonderful. Kreeft elucidates the Catholic worldview that is the foundation of Tolkien's wonderful story. Kreeft was so good I've changed my mind and decided to start by reading the Hobbit.

No. I want to read it. Why, Why in my country Peter Kreeft is not translated :-(?.


John wrote: "I think my interlibrary loan is coming by way of snail. I will still post questions tomorrow."
As the old Irish saying goes, if you want to make God laugh, tell him your plans. I will try to get discussion questions posted later today.
As the old Irish saying goes, if you want to make God laugh, tell him your plans. I will try to get discussion questions posted later today.

Courtney wrote: "i am reading One Thousand Gifts by Ann Voskamp. I dont know if its Catholic but certainly Christian. It was given to me by a friend who said Sister Ann Sheilds quotes from it. While I have always b..."
Yes, but I view that as a good thing. I tend to think and ponder more.
Yes, but I view that as a good thing. I tend to think and ponder more.

and The Handbook for Catholic Moms: Nurturing Your Heart, Mind, Body, and Soul by Lisa M. Hendey.
My life has been pretty dicy the last several years. Last year was lots of medical issues being corrected, this year a little more.
I am hoping that one (or all) may give me direction for 2018.


It ia very interesting reading Tania, but very dificult i send my total support it is based in the theory of Refrigerium of the ancient Christian, with this book Lewis replied to Blake that the Heaven and Inferno were not together.

It ia very interesting reading Tania, but very dificult i send my total support it is based in the theory of Refrigerium of the ancient Christian, with this book Lewis replied to Blake that the Heaven and Inferno were not together.
Benjamin wrote: "Joan of Arc: Her Story"
I read Mark Twain's book on her which has made me hungry for a more factual treatment. How do you like this one?
I read Mark Twain's book on her which has made me hungry for a more factual treatment. How do you like this one?
I am reading Reasonable Pleasures: The Strange Coherences of Catholicism, which we passed on reading as a group, and am enjoying it very much. If anyone else was thinking about it, I would definitely recommend it as a worthy read.


It ia very interesting reading Tania, but very dificult i send my tot..."
Fonch, about this book, I'm glad I managed to finally concentrate, and find it was very interesting.
:)

It ia very interesting reading Tania, but very dificult..."
Fernando wrote: "I'm reading the book on abortion by Fr. Frank Pavone, and 111 Questions on Islam by Fr. Samir Khalil Samir."
Very interesting Mr. Uña. I wish you participated more in Catholic Book Club. You are welcome.
Well it is not my favorite C.S. Lewis`s book, but it is very interesting, and it has his interest. It is interesting that you could compare with the J.R.R Tolkien`s book "The Niggle`s leaf" that it is his equal in the literature.

/review/show...

/review/show...
I alsotake the chance to hang the list of the best books of 2017 chosen by the most relevants catholic of United States, and United Kingdom.

Jim wrote: "I am reading "The Mind That is Catholic" by Fr. James V. Schall."
Unfortunatley I gave up on this book and have started others


From Islam to Christ by Derya Little
Deep Conversion Deep Prayer by Father Thomas Dubay
He Leadeth Me by Walter J. Ciszek
A Song for Nagasaki by Paul Glynn

From Islam to Christ by Derya Little
Deep Conversion Deep Prayer by Father Thomas Duba..."
The last two books are really good. I am very interested in the Derya Little`s book.


Rodney Stark is not catholic, and i like him.


Well my felings are the same.
Bice wrote: "I just saw this today. There are several Catholic books I have read this year so far that I highly recommend.
From Islam to Christ by Derya Little
Deep Conversion Deep Prayer by Father Thomas Duba..."
Bice, do you want to consider nominating any of these for the group to consider?
From Islam to Christ by Derya Little
Deep Conversion Deep Prayer by Father Thomas Duba..."
Bice, do you want to consider nominating any of these for the group to consider?

From Islam to Christ by Derya Little
Deep Conversion Deep Prayer by Fathe..."
John i read two out of the four books and they are really godos. Bice although she did not need it. She has my approval with their books, besides i also want to read the Derya Little`s book, although i do not think that i could not read it, because it is not in spanish :-(.

I love to follow the group but I am not an active member for which I apologize. Love to check in and see what you are reading and to follow the discussion. Keep up the good work.
Bice and Fonch,
My only point was to direct this to the Nominations thread, if that is the goal. I don't want to continue having me parse out whether a given discussion of a book, or recommendation of a book is meant generically or as a nomination. That converts the moderator into a gatekeeper, and as long as there is a Catholic link to a proposed book (or Christian with a sufficiently broad applicability), that is not the role I've sought. It is also a little harder to track whether it is someone else's nomination or mine.
If either of you wants to nominate these books, you should feel free to do so in the Nominations thread. Of course, if you want them considered for reading this year, then Bice should nominate them, as Fonch and I have a substantial backlog.
:)
My only point was to direct this to the Nominations thread, if that is the goal. I don't want to continue having me parse out whether a given discussion of a book, or recommendation of a book is meant generically or as a nomination. That converts the moderator into a gatekeeper, and as long as there is a Catholic link to a proposed book (or Christian with a sufficiently broad applicability), that is not the role I've sought. It is also a little harder to track whether it is someone else's nomination or mine.
If either of you wants to nominate these books, you should feel free to do so in the Nominations thread. Of course, if you want them considered for reading this year, then Bice should nominate them, as Fonch and I have a substantial backlog.
:)
Bice wrote: "Hi John. Yes of course especially Song of Nagasaki. The Derya Little book starts out well falters a little towards end but still worth reading.
I love to follow the group but I am not an active mem..."
No need to apologize, Bice, I am glad you find it worthwhile to follow us.
I love to follow the group but I am not an active mem..."
No need to apologize, Bice, I am glad you find it worthwhile to follow us.

Bice wrote: "By the way Bice is pronounced Bee-chay. I was born in Italy and came to USA when I was 3."
Bice is the short name Dante gives to Beatrice in "Vita nuova":
io vidi monna Vanna e monna Bice
venir invêr lo loco là ov'io era,
l'una appresso de l'altra maraviglia;
Bice is the short name Dante gives to Beatrice in "Vita nuova":
io vidi monna Vanna e monna Bice
venir invêr lo loco là ov'io era,
l'una appresso de l'altra maraviglia;

My only point was to direct this to the Nominations thread, if that is the goal. I don't want to continue having me parse out whether a given discussion of a book, or recommendatio..."
In this have reason John. We wrong in the section, where the books should be recomended, although the books are really good. The Songs of Nagsaki. It is a biography of one of my heros (i am a lover of Japan) Takashi Nagai converted to the catholic religion, and posibly a future blessed or saint. Hewas well known as the christian Gandhi. He was an example of corouge with the atomic bomb, where he lost to his wife. He died few years later victim of the radiation.
Good point Mr. Alfonseca. I did not know that Bice was a way of Beatrix i have a lot of things to learn it :-).
Bice wrote: "How lovely Manuel! Thank you! Can you tell me which part in Divine Comedy?"
It is not in the Divine Comedy, but in Vita Nuova, a book of commented poems that Dante wrote while Beatrice was alive, and was interrupted by her death. The three verses I quoted make the first tercet in this sonnet:
Io mi senti' svegliar dentro a lo core
un spirito amoroso che dormia:
e poi vidi venir da lungi Amore
allegro sì, che appena il conoscia,
dicendo: «Or pensa pur di farmi onore»;
e ciascuna parola sua ridia.
E poco stando meco il mio segnore,
guardando in quella parte onde venia,
io vidi monna Vanna e monna Bice
venir invêr lo loco là ov'io era,
l'una appresso de l'altra maraviglia;
e sì come la mente mi ridice,
Amor mi disse: «Quell'è Primavera,
e quell'ha nome Amor, sì mi somiglia».
In this address you can find the photograph of a painting that probably depicts the scene in this sonnet:
It is not in the Divine Comedy, but in Vita Nuova, a book of commented poems that Dante wrote while Beatrice was alive, and was interrupted by her death. The three verses I quoted make the first tercet in this sonnet:
Io mi senti' svegliar dentro a lo core
un spirito amoroso che dormia:
e poi vidi venir da lungi Amore
allegro sì, che appena il conoscia,
dicendo: «Or pensa pur di farmi onore»;
e ciascuna parola sua ridia.
E poco stando meco il mio segnore,
guardando in quella parte onde venia,
io vidi monna Vanna e monna Bice
venir invêr lo loco là ov'io era,
l'una appresso de l'altra maraviglia;
e sì come la mente mi ridice,
Amor mi disse: «Quell'è Primavera,
e quell'ha nome Amor, sì mi somiglia».
In this address you can find the photograph of a painting that probably depicts the scene in this sonnet:
Manuel wrote: "Bice wrote: "How lovely Manuel! Thank you! Can you tell me which part in Divine Comedy?"
It is not in the Divine Comedy, but in Vita Nuova, a book of commented poems that Dante wrote while Beatric..."
I found a translation online
I felt a loving spirit suddenly,
past a long slumber, in my heart arise;
from far away then Love I seemed to see,
so glad, I could his face ill recognize.
He told me, “Do your best to honor me,�
and laughter in each word I did surmise.
With my lord there, I was still eagerly
watching his steps, when I, to my surprise,
saw Mona Vanna and Mona Beatrice
coming towards me, where I still was standing�
one bliss pursuing still another bliss.
And—here is what I am reminded of�
Love said, “The first is Springtime, but the second
resembles me so much, her name is Love.�
It is not in the Divine Comedy, but in Vita Nuova, a book of commented poems that Dante wrote while Beatric..."
I found a translation online
I felt a loving spirit suddenly,
past a long slumber, in my heart arise;
from far away then Love I seemed to see,
so glad, I could his face ill recognize.
He told me, “Do your best to honor me,�
and laughter in each word I did surmise.
With my lord there, I was still eagerly
watching his steps, when I, to my surprise,
saw Mona Vanna and Mona Beatrice
coming towards me, where I still was standing�
one bliss pursuing still another bliss.
And—here is what I am reminded of�
Love said, “The first is Springtime, but the second
resembles me so much, her name is Love.�
Books mentioned in this topic
Hope in Time of Abandonment (other topics)Heresies and How to Avoid Them: Why It Matters What Christians Believe (other topics)
The Christmas Story (other topics)
Warranted Christian Belief (other topics)
The Shining Company (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jacques Ellul (other topics)Ben Quash (other topics)
Chad A. Ripperger (other topics)
James V. Schall (other topics)
C.S. Lewis (other topics)
More...