Book Riot's Read Harder Challenge discussion
2019 Read Harder Challenge
>
Task #8: An #ownvoices book set in Oceania
message 51:
by
Jill
(new)
Jan 02, 2019 06:43PM

reply
|
flag


Sister Heart
Carpentaria
Follow the Rabbit-Proof Fence
Swallow the Air
[book:The Bone ..."
I got Carpentaria on Audible so will be listening to that for this one!

That's a good question. She's Japanese-American (her family name is Japanese) but she's lived in Hawai'i since her childhood. According to her wikipediapage, her father's lived in Hawai'i either for a very long time or since birth. Yanagihara's mother's Korean, while her father is American with Japanese ancestors.
I mean...this sounds like you could argue for both Yes and No.


I don't think Bridge of Clay would qualify - Markus Zusak is the son of European immigrants to Australia, and having read about half of Bridge of Clay before deciding I hated it, it appears to be about a white experience.

Yes, it is.
"Geographically, Hawaii is considered to be located in Oceania. The continent of Oceania consists of four regions: Australasia, Micronesia, Polynesia, and Melanesia. Polynesia consists of a number of sovereign states and thousands of inhabited and habited islands. Initially, the term Polynesia referred to the islands of the Pacific, but in 1831, the Geographical Society of Paris restricted the word to mean South Sea Islands. The Polynesia Region is mapped by a triangle in the Pacific Ocean. Polynesia includes Samoa, New Zealand, Norfolk Island, Tonga, Tuvalu, the Cook Islands, and on the northernmost tip of the triangle, lies the islands of Hawaii."

Moving Through The Streets by Joseph Veramu
Sidewinder by Alastair Te Ariki Campbell.
I didn't like them, but someone else might!
I've just ordered the two sequels to "Frangipani".
Cross-posting this from the other #ownvoices task discussion, with some additional commentary on Oceania specifically.
"Hi everyone! Thanks for the discussion. In the broader publishing industry, an author from Central America or Mexico *is* marginalized because the industry is extremely US/UK-centric. So a book by an author from those countries would count even if they are a member of a majority of the population of that nation, but, for example, a book by an American author writing about Mexico would not. Of course there are nuances here, but we trust that y'all understand the spirit of the challenge, which is to read a variety of perspectives not dominant in the publishing industry."
That's to say that white authors from Australia would not be considered marginalized. For this task, marginalized people from Oceania writing about characters who are marginalized in the same way - in this case Aboriginal people or those from the islands of Oceania - are considered #ownvoices. Again, there are nuances, but hopefully this will clarify what the intent of the task is.
"Hi everyone! Thanks for the discussion. In the broader publishing industry, an author from Central America or Mexico *is* marginalized because the industry is extremely US/UK-centric. So a book by an author from those countries would count even if they are a member of a majority of the population of that nation, but, for example, a book by an American author writing about Mexico would not. Of course there are nuances here, but we trust that y'all understand the spirit of the challenge, which is to read a variety of perspectives not dominant in the publishing industry."
That's to say that white authors from Australia would not be considered marginalized. For this task, marginalized people from Oceania writing about characters who are marginalized in the same way - in this case Aboriginal people or those from the islands of Oceania - are considered #ownvoices. Again, there are nuances, but hopefully this will clarify what the intent of the task is.

1. The Swan Book by Alexis Wright (female, Australian Aboriginal)
2. Carpentaria by Alexis Wright (Australian Aboriginal)
3. The Whale Rider by Witi Ihimaera (Maori)
4. Where We Once Belonged by Sia Figiel (female, Samoan)
I was going to add The Bone People by Keri Hulme but was unsure if it fully fit the challenge as Hulme is of Maori descent but also English/Scottish descent. Although her character is also part Maori and part European so they do share similar heritage of both being part Maori and part something else

Her obituary was also notably atrocious...

Conquered, by Paula Ann Lujan Quinene, is an #ownvoices romance set in Guam during World War II, so it also would work for Task #16, an historical romance by an author of color. I can't find it on GoodReads but it's included with Kindle Unlimited:
Scarlet Lies: Book One in the Scarlet Series by Lani Wendt Young. The author is Samoan, and I believe this is a self-published title (Task #23) as well but I'm not sure. Telesa: The Covenant Keeper is another one of her books.
Scar of the Bamboo Leaf by Sieni A.M., another Samoan author.
Breadfruit by Celestine Vaite, a Tahitian author.

Conquered, by Paula Ann Lujan Quinene, is an #ownvoices romance set in Guam during World War II, so it also would wo..."
I could do Breadfruit. This category is killing me for some reason.

Also look at Anita Heiss, a Wiradjuri woman, who has written a romance series, Barbed Wire and Cherry Blossoms, and Tiddas, as well as nonfiction book "Am I Black Enough For You?"
For YA you could look at Erin Gough's book The Flywheel and Amelia Westlake. And Ugly by Robert Hoge has both a younger readers version and an adult version (it's a memoir, not fiction, but I think it counts?).
I know there are so many more... oh, I can't leave out Queens of Geek and The Brightsiders by Jen Wilde.
And Mullumbimby by Melissa Lucashenko, one of my favourite Aussie books of all time, and Becoming Kirrali Lewis.
And anthology Meet Me At The Intersection.


Also look at Anita Heiss, a Wiradjuri woman, who has written a romance series, Barbed Wire and Cherry Blossoms, and Tiddas, as well as nonfiction book "Am I Black Enough For You?"
Thanks! Great recs.






For those asking Keri Hulme would definitely count for this challenge. Almost all Maori have some European blood, but in a Maori worldview there is no such thing as “part� Maori. You either identify with the culture or you don’t. Hulme certainly does.


I have only read one of Lucashenko’s novels, Mullumbimby, and based on that one I would recommend trying whatever you can get your hands on.

This looks wonderful. Thanks for the recommendation



Moloka'i is neither set in Oceania (Hawaii isn't considered Oceania) nor an ownvoices novel (author is an American). Sorry.


However, I think "Frangipani" by the same author was better.
I have the third one in the series to read later!
For what it's worth on the Hawaii debate - I just watched a TV programme on the history of art of Oceania and that included Hawai'ian artists who very much thought of themselves as of Oceania! So I guess it depends who you ask!

Wikipedia says about Hawaii:
"Hawaii is the only U.S. state located in Oceania, the only U.S. state located outside North America, and the only one composed entirely of islands."

/list/show/1...

It's past a stretch. #ownvoices is about listening to people who are marginalized & under-represented. While it's true a female author has more challenges than a man, a white female in Australia is still very privileged, & in no way a minority. (Depending on where one is, indigenous authors may not be minorities in their own country, but they are very much minorities within the world of publishing.)

Hawaiians are Americans, but indigenous Hawaiians may also consider themselves to be Pacific Islanders, Asian Pacific Islanders, &/or Oceanic.

Also look at Anita Heiss, a Wiradjuri woman, who has writ..."
Fantastic suggestions. I'm just going to add the anthology Anita Heiss edited, Growing Up Aboriginal in Australia to the list if someone is looking for a non-fiction option.


I doubt I’m going to find a book in the library that fits. I’m in the UK.


Not necessarily."
In my opinion, your statement makes as much sense as saying New Yorkers are not necessarily Americans or Idahoans are not necessarily Americans. They are all American states, therefore one of their many identities is American.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Dharma Punks (other topics)Terra Nullius (other topics)
The Things She's Seen (other topics)
The Things She's Seen (other topics)
The Things She's Seen (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Brandy Nālani McDougall (other topics)Craig Santos Pérez (other topics)
Randa Abdel-Fattah (other topics)
Hannah Gadsby (other topics)
Kaui Hart Hemmings (other topics)
More...