The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion
OLD TASK HELP THREADS
>
Julie KS's task - 20.1

Would the Left behind series work for this task?



I was wondering about Narnia too...


Also, what about Beyond the Reflection's Edge?
I have been waiting to read The Vanishing Sculptor as I really enjoyed her DragonKeeper series. If not that is fine, I haven't read some of the Hideaway series by Hannah Alexander either which I am pretty sure fit this task.

Anyway, I absolutely love C.S. Lewis and have read quite a few of the things he's written (he wrote a lot more than the Chronicles of Narnia!!!) but I have never gotten around to reading his space trilogy, even though I’ve had them sitting on my bookshelf for 10 or 15 years. From my understanding, it’s very similar to a lot of the things Lewis wrote after his conversion to Christianity—so very allegorical.
I plan on reading the first book in this trilogy for the science fiction task, so my question is whether the second in the series, Perelandra by C.S. Lewis would count for this task?
I only ask for clarification because Lewis’s writing style isn’t anything like the gentle fiction that people characteristically think of as “Christian fiction", which is what the task seems to imply to me as its written. His books are quite a bit more philosophical and gritty...
A lot will depend on what Julie has in mind for this task, but The Screwtape Letters by C.S. Lewis is absolutely fascinating as a heads up to others. I've recommended it to Christians and non-Christians alike and have had some absolutely amazing conversations afterwards. It's written in epistolary format with letters back and forth between two devils who are discussing the best way to tempt a Christian (a senior devil advising a junior devil). It's really short and I've read it at a few different points in my life, which provided some very unique perspectives...


Beverly Lewis is definitely Christian fiction. I enjoyed her Heritage of Lancaster County series (The Shunning, The Confession, The Reckoning) much more than some of her others.
If you don't like preachy, I would suggest avoiding What a Girl Wants or anything else from that series by Kristin Billerbeck. I forced myself to finish this one, but it was painful.

Julie, would you count Traveling Mercies Some Thoughts on Faith ? I've not read it, and it's about writing as well as faith, so I'm not sure where it falls.
Also, if Julie approves them, I wholeheartedly agree with the C.S. Lewis recommendations for anyone who's looking.

Of course it's up to Julie to give the okay on them.


The Left Behind books are DEFINITELY going to work.
Someone needs to PM Julie and get her over here... ;) Does anyone know which Julie is the Kansas Julie?


I have this one on my shelf. I read his book, Sarah A Novel, several years ago, which I enjoyed.

"christianfiction" shelf: http://www.goodreads.com/shelf/show?s...
I've been meaning to watch the Love Comes Softly series of movies... so maybe I'll read Love Comes Softly by Janette Oke... Or this one looks like it might be interesting: The Measure of a Lady by Deeanne Gist. Ooh, actually a few of Deeanne Gist's look good... If you like romance novels... haha!
I'm just glad I live deep in the heart of Texas... Christian fiction novels are plentiful...

If you want something shorter, Mark Rempel wrote a few teenage novels about a fictional school shooting and how it affected several Christian students - I'm guessing it was inspired by Columbine. I don't know how easy these books are to locate as I read them about six years ago!
Melody Carlson has written LOTS of Christian novels for both adults and teenagers and I think they're quite easy to locate as the ones listed here have lots of reviews. Again, they aren't preachy and just talk about how Christian men and women deal with issues in their lives.
Meg Harper wrote several childrens' novels about a girl who is the daughter of a female minister. The references to Christianity are quite basic, but they are there.
Kacy Barnett-Gramckow wrote three novels based on events in the book of Genesis in the Bible. I've only read the first but it was very well written.
Beverly Lewis has written many Amish novels, the most famous being The Shunning. There are a lot of other authors of Amish Christian fiction, but she's the only one I've read.
Hope this helps!

"christianfiction" shelf: http://www.goodreads.com/shelf/show?s......"
I've only seen the first two of the Love Comes Softly movies, but I love them :)

"christianfiction" shelf: http://www.goodreads.com/shelf/show?s......"
I've never seen the movies, but I do like this series of books.

"christianfiction" shelf: http://www.goodreads.com/shelf/show..."
Maybe I'll read one of those books then since I'm flipped from you :) LOL

Is At Home in Mitford by Jan Karon ok for the task? Otherwise, it's going to be The Shack if Julie gives the thumbs up.

Heather in KS

Is At Home in Mitford by Jan Karon ok for the task? Otherwise, it's going to be The Shack if Juli..."
My mom loves the Mitford books and I'm pretty sure she's told me that they're Christian Fiction.

Is At Home in Mitford by Jan Karon ok for the task? Otherwise, it's going to be The Shack if Juli..."
I can't imagine why The Shack wouldn't work. It's fiction, the main character is Christian, Christian ideals play a major role, Jesus is actually in the book (personified), and it absolutely demonstrates the importance of living a faith centered life. Personally, I thought the writing was terrible, but if that won't bother you then go for it!


Been so long since I had a lot of my Christian Fiction novels. And I /just/ finished a couple.

Thank you! I already own that book, so that's what I'll use.


I'm almost positive that's who she meant, Lyn. Janette Oke is a wildly popular Christian author who's been around for a long time. It’s been at least 15 years since I was “into� the Christian fiction scene but she was definitely one of the heavy-hitters in the genre at the time and still seems to be very popular.

Aha! I have that one! Thanks, I'll be using that as well as Cait!


Yay, I have The Preservationist too!





I was wondering about this too, Sam. I'd really like to use The Battersea Park Road to Enlightenment which is about faith and living a faith-centered life, but it's not about Christianity.

I agree.


Any other suggestions? I've already read those.

I saw "Faith-Centered Life" before "Christian Fiction" and thought, "Ooh...Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance.

The fact that they aren’t mutually exclusive is exactly why I’m questioning whether I can read C.S. Lewis or not.
But if Lewis is approved by Julie, I would absolutely recommend The Screwtape Letters to anyone who feels a bit iffy about reading Christian fiction. C.S. Lewis was a self-proclaimed atheist for years before his conversion to Christianity, which I think gives even his Christian writings a unique twist.

The Sparrow
Traveling Mercies Some Thoughts on Faith
Plan B Further Thoughts on Faith
--or--
The Dance of the Dissident Daughter

Here's my question: If these books aren't about Jesus or the Bible, how to we know they're Christian fiction? Why not call them spiritual fiction? Doesn't the word Christian imply a theological specificity beyond an allegory about faith or good living? Is it just because the author identifies as a Christian?
Books mentioned in this topic
The Screwtape Letters (other topics)Arena (other topics)
Gilead (other topics)
Cry, the Beloved Country (other topics)
Cry, the Beloved Country (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Alan Paton (other topics)Alan Paton (other topics)
Mindy Starns Clark (other topics)
Mindy Starns Clark (other topics)
Francine Rivers (other topics)
More...
Also, I noticed that The Lord of the Rings seems to be on some of the Christian Fiction lists here on goodreads. Would that qualify for this task?
This one is a bit outside my comfort zone. Any help would be appreciated.