Morales 2341 Spring 2015 Class MW discussion

This topic is about
The Overcoat
Race, Class, and Culture
>
Appearance and Social Class- The Overcoat
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Lillian
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Apr 17, 2015 06:59AM

reply
|
flag





“That day was truly a triumphant and festive one for Akaky Akakievich.� - “The Overcoat� by Nikolai Gogol

“You must know that Akaky Akakievtch’s cloak served as an object of ridicule to the officials: they even refused it the noble name of cloak, and they called it a cape.”—Nikolai Gogol





"Akaky akakievich walked around in a happy holiday mood. He was full of the knowledge that he had a new overcoat on his shoulder, and several times he laughed with secret pleasure." -Nikolai Gogol

I agree, society says that you need to have the best of everything in order to be liked. Akakievich didn't have much and was never noticed. When he got a new coat, everybody noticed. Society never noticed him for other things that he would do which is cruel, he had to live his life trying to be accepted.





I do agree with you Shanda, I believe society does play a big role on how we see people. Obviously nobody wants to hang around with someone like Akaky. He had no drive what so ever and his way of dressing said a lot about him. Even though his new coat lead to his death, it goes to show that some people try to impress others all the way till their death. Even though Akaky was happy with his job, in todays society, lets be real, we all get judge by how we dress and how we speak.

Kirsten, society is cruel, but I think that sometimes we need that. I don't mean to be pushed around or be make fun off, but that can help some to overcome themselves. Even though society has this image on how we are supposed to see people and how they dress, maybe that can help some of them to realize that there is always more to life, not just the job of making copies at work. Akaky could have become someone better and well liked, but he didn't really care, to me he just wanted something to do in his spare time.


I agree with you Luis on how akaky was simply replaced at work . And only if he would of stay the way he was at first maybe he would of still been alive. Maybe he should have stay with his old coat.

Awkward is an appropriate word to describe Akaky. The appearance of an individual does gives a stranger an initial impression. Akaky got a new coat out of necessity, but ended up with a coat made him appear to belong to a higher social class. Akaky did not seem to match the type of people he met at the party, just like the coat did not seem to match Akaky's personality.

I agree with your post, but I think that Akaky never really cared about his appearance before he realized that he needed a new coat. He made sure that the coat would be special. With the coat, he gain some self confidence and others noticed this as well as how he was dressed.

Luis, I agree with you that Akaky was a simple clerk who was considered a nobody. He was merely a man who was happy doing his job and nothing more. He did not fit in with the rest of society and was only noticed when he got his new coat. But little did they know the sacrifice behind the coat that made him so proud.

I agree with Kimberly because people do judge by the looks of other people. The short story is related to real life. This is the type of society we live now in this days. Poor Akaky, he was a hard working man, but because of his appearance he was invisible to the others.

I agree Leslie. People often ignore others if they don't meet their standards in society. People made fun of him and once he got a new coat everybody was giving him attention. I felt so bad when he got robbed because he worked so hard for his new coat.

I agree Amber, unfortunately society has always treated people based on their appearance and that is not right. Akaky went from nothing to everything just because of a new overcoat, a simple piece of fabric. In the end getting a new coat bascially backfired and caused him his life.

Hilda, I agree with you that Akaky was a simple low ranking clerk who was considered a nobody. He was merely a man who was happy doing his job. He did not fit in with the rest of society and because of that he was belittled and tormented by his coworkers. It's sad to face reality and admit how one's appearance has such a powerful impact on someone based by the way they dress or look.

I agree that Akaky saw that people noticed him but that unfortunately did not last. The people that mugged him certainly saw his fancy overcoat and judged him, assuming he was rich. Without an overcoat in the cold winters of Russia he shortly died.

Akaky's co-workers took notice of him right when they saw him wearing his new coat. They saw him in a different way for what he was wearing. I agree that Gogol was trying to tell the reader that society treats people different for their appearance , assuming they are of higher class.


It was unfair of Akaky's coworkers to not pay attention to him until he had a new coat. A coat doesn't give a person their personality.

Its funny and sad how something as simple as getting a new coat changed the way Akaky was treated by those around him. Society now hasn't really changed since the same mindset still exist.


I agree with Rosie that Akakys end was horrible. He never was the one to care what others thought of him until they finally accepted him and then he dies.

I agree with Monique when she says, “Gogol is trying to emphasize the point that the way you look and what you have effects the way you’re treated and respected.� It’s a sad truth but that’s the cruel reality that some people face.

Hilda i agree society and the author of this story is trying to tell us that society does base everything, including hoe they think your attitude is according on how you dress.

I agree with you, society is superficial and judgmental. I felt sorry for Akaky because he was bullied by his coworkers. I wished he would of stand up to them but he was too peaceful.

It is true, society treats us by our appearance not by our personality. Poor Akaky, being disrespected at work and then being mugged by thieves stealing his coat that he had worked for so hard.

To me appearance should be everything, there is a saying in Mexico “How you look is the way they are going to treat you�. I firmly believe in the saying but it does not mean you have to buy the fanciest clothing out there or the most expensive. IN Akaky’s situation is more about his attitude than his overcoat, after Akaky bought his new coat and his perspective in live change and with that the people around him.

It is a sad reality, we judge people everything. Wouldn't you agree that sometimes judgement is owed? I think dressing nicely should be common knowledge, and by this I don't mean the fanciest clothing. I think it is our social responsibility to dress half way decent, people now days dress in pajamas everywhere even to school. My family always told me "It is your responsibility to dress appropriately you will find that how you look is the way they are going to treat you".