

“all of this is done in service of avoiding repair; all done in service of a worldview that decides every day to enforce a system in which people do not matter if they don’t make profit for others, in which others will never matter simply because of who they are; a world in which repair is seen as theft, in which those who are deemed unworthy are punished for the crime of not mattering, in which those who are punished are blamed for their punishment, and made to pay as much of the higher burden of brokenness as possible, so that a constantly shrinking elect can enjoy the profits.”
― Very Fine People
― Very Fine People

“If you “helpâ€� individual trees by getting rid of their supposed competition, the remaining trees are bereft.”
― The Hidden Life of Trees: What They Feel, How They Communicate â€� Discoveries from a Secret World
― The Hidden Life of Trees: What They Feel, How They Communicate â€� Discoveries from a Secret World

“Think of this respectable modern idea of fighting against polarization on both sides. You know, that great narrative formulation of our modern age: Both sides. The two sides. The only two sides you have to consider. Please, name the two sides. We might use the standard way of looking at “both sides,â€� which is to frame it around whether or not somebody agrees or disagrees with a proposition. Take gay marriage. You agree with gay marriage. I disagree with it. We are both sides, though neither of us is gay. We might point out that this framing allows two people who are unaffected by a topic to discuss the topic in a way that erases the person directly affected by the harmful proposition—actually takes them completely outside of it, by postulating two sides, and not including the person affected as either of those two sides. We might point out how this advantages a person who wants to keep the harmful proposition in circulation forever. We might therefore postulate that a better way of framing “both sidesâ€� would be to view the two sides along lines of “those who are affectedâ€� and “those who aren’t affected.â€� You agree with gay marriage, I disagree, but neither of us have our humanity up for debate. We are one side. And then there are gay people, for whom marriage is a case of being a part of society or being shunned from it. The other side. I think that’s a better framing, for sure. We should use that framing, if only to understand the ways our thinking has been warped by modern “both sidesâ€� narratives, and stop treating real toxic ideas that really harm real people as if they are bloodless abstractions that merit debate.”
― Very Fine People
― Very Fine People

“Yes, and what do we mean when we say “we’ve rarely been so polarized,â€� anyway? What if instead we introduced new ideas? What if instead we said “It’s been a long time since awareness of the reality of injustice has been made so unavoidably present to otherwise comfortable people?â€� What if instead we said “It’s been a long time since so many people have become so violently resentful of the moral demands of justice?”
― Very Fine People
― Very Fine People

“Here’s a new idea: There are not two sides, but many. Here’s a new idea: We don’t need to listen to both sides, because we are the sides, multitudinous in number, and we are listening to each other already. Here’s a new idea: The people who refuse to repent of their blamelessness don’t get to be one whole side in a binary. They aren’t allowed to force us all into one side, and then wait for us to beg them for our permission to exist. Both sides? We are the sides. We are the sides. We are the sides.”
― Very Fine People
― Very Fine People

This is a book club that consists of the legendary triathlon champion Chris " Macca" MacCormack's Team Macca MX12 VIP's, and Chris himself as they exc ...more
Corie’s 2024 Year in Books
Take a look at Corie’s Year in Books, including some fun facts about their reading.
More friends�
Favorite Genres
Polls voted on by Corie
Lists liked by Corie