Joseph’s Reviews > Words without Alloy: A Biography of the Lectionary for Mass > Status Update

Joseph
is on page 219 of 296
I know I mentioned this earlier in this read, but for the love of all that is holy, this is about a very important part of the Sacred Liturgy and reading it makes me want to slam my head against the wall instead of meditating on the Sacred Scriptures.
— Jan 10, 2023 06:28PM
Like flag
Joseph’s Previous Updates

Joseph
is on page 282 of 296
Trying to spin this in the conclusions section is not helping your case, sorry Father.
— Jan 16, 2023 07:03PM

Joseph
is on page 250 of 296
As much as I enjoy reading good scholarship, there is a lot of shoddy scholarship out there to wade through. This doesn't even reach that level, I feel like I pulled a drawer out of a card catalogue and am reading each individual card. And yes, I am that old.
— Jan 14, 2023 07:28PM

Joseph
is on page 242 of 296
"The previous missal assigned complete seasonal daily readings only to Lent. Early on, Study Group 11 wanted Lent to retain its proper daily readings 'by improving the current lectionary'... By the final draft, twenty-one readings remained in place, seventeen moved to other days."
Wait, what?
— Jan 13, 2023 07:34PM
Wait, what?

Joseph
is on page 157 of 296
Ok, I have found a part of this book which is potentially useful, if still tedious.
— Dec 29, 2022 06:48PM

Joseph
is on page 125 of 296
I can't quite figure out if the headache is coming from the fact that this book is poorly organized or the fact that the events that he's describing are so random as to have no coherent line of reasoning behind them.
— Dec 24, 2022 06:03PM

Joseph
is on page 80 of 296
So the blurb says "In Words without Alloy, Paul Turner traces the history of the lectionary as if it were a person coming to full maturity." So far, the way he presents the development of the lectionary of 1970 looks more like a bunch of college students writing a screenplay under the influence. Influence of what, I'm not entirely sure.
— Dec 21, 2022 07:11PM

Joseph
is on page 43 of 296
I'm not sure how, but chapter one manages to have too much and not enough detail at the same time.
— Dec 20, 2022 05:59AM