ŷ

Readers' Most Anticipated Fall Mysteries & Thrillers

Posted by Cybil on August 19, 2024


As a category, Mysteries & Thrillers covers a wide range of storytelling styles: police procedurals, private investigations, espionage, noir, cozies, historical, legal, paranormal…the list goes on.

Because this genre is so reliably popular with readers, you’ll find all of these and more on bookshelves this fall. We’ve compiled below the most anticipated titles of the upcoming season, as determined by early reviews, ratings, and ŷ regulars� Want to Read shelves. The books are sorted by month this time around, to help facilitate your reading calendar.

Some spotlight items, in no particular order: The inimitable Rachel Kushner is back this September with Creation Lake, a fascinating noir about a mysterious American woman infiltrating a French anarchist collective. On the cozier side of things, Richard Osman (The Thursday Murder Club series) profiles a father-in-law/daughter-in-law investigator team with We Solve Murders.

Comic book fans may want to check out Alex Segura’s Alter Ego, a kinda-sorta sequel to 2022’s Secret Identity, both of which feature deadly intrigue in the comics industry. The new novel from genre veteran Liane Moriarty, meanwhile, asks an uncomfortable question: What would you do if you knew exactly when and how you will die?

Finally, fans of Laura Dave’s The Last Thing He Told Me—winner of the 2021 ŷ Choice Award mystery prize—may want to save some shelf space for The Night We Lost Him, featuring estranged siblings, family secrets, and a reportedly bananas final twist.

Click on the book cover images for more information about each title, and add anything that looks promising to your Want to Read shelf.

Publishing in September

Publishing in October

Publishing in November

Publishing in December



Which mysteries are you looking forward to this fall? Tell us all about it in the comments below!


Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Mwanamali (new)

Mwanamali New Keigo Higashino 🥳🥳🥳


message 2: by TOTINEE (new)

TOTINEE December and the new Keigo Higashino book, now that sounds like a great Christmas plan!
I can't wait for the new book.


message 3: by klaudia (new)

klaudia katarzyna Currently reading The Treasure Hunters Club and I already recommend it!


message 4: by Bloss � (new)

Bloss ♡ Louise Penny! ❤️
I was privileged to receive an advanced copy of The Grey Wolf and Gamache fans will not be disappointed!


message 5: by Grace =^_^= (new)

Grace  =^_^= I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you.


𲹻ٳا☾༺♰༻☽ا cant wait for freida mcfaddens book and deadly animals and so many more!! fall is going to have some good reads this year!!


message 7: by Amy (new)

Amy Gray We Solve Murders is fantastic but the sleuths are a woman and her father-in-law, not her father.


message 8: by Sharon, ŷ employee (new)

Sharon Amy wrote: "We Solve Murders is fantastic but the sleuths are a woman and her father-in-law, not her father."

Thanks! We've fixed this!


message 9: by Bloss � (new)

Bloss ♡ Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."
Ah, Grace! You’re in for a treat. I would recommend starting at the beginning (Still Life), while each book can stands on its own merits, there are some beautiful character and story arcs if you read them in order. The books get better as Louise polishes her craft too!


message 10: by Johnny (new)

Johnny Macpherson Laidlaw Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

Bloss � wrote: "Louise Penny! ❤️
I was privileged to receive an advanced copy of The Grey Wolf and Gamache fans will not be disappointed!"


start with a nice easy one, the lion above the door , for grace


message 11: by Johnny (new)

Johnny Macpherson Laidlaw Johnny wrote: "Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

Bloss � wrote: "Louise Penny! ❤️
I was privileged to receive an advanced copy of T..."


grace i know its not louise penny but its lighter read


message 12: by Ivonne (new)

Ivonne Rovira I bought the Audible edition of We Solve Murders months ago, LOL! I can't wait for it to drop!


message 13: by Reenah (new)

Reenah Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."


Hi Grace,
in my opinion you have to start with the first Gamache book and read them in sequence. I also think that the first 4 books are more or less really good crime fiction, but I didn't get addicted until Book 5. However, without the first 4, I couldn't have enjoyed Book 5 and all later ones. There is a long and important story arc from Book 1 to Book 10. Also, the Gamache books are really about this magical village Three Pines and its inhabitants, and also about the fascinating character of Gamache. If you can, start with Book 1 and enjoy the journey - it gets ever better :)


message 14: by Debbie (new)

Debbie Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

Bloss � wrote: "Louise Penny! ❤️
I was privileged to receive an advanced copy of The Grey Wolf and Gamache fans will not be disappointed!"


Grace, start with her first and work your way up. But you have lots of reading to do! ;-)


message 15: by Tanya (new)

Tanya Fantastic list! Ridiculously excited for Frieda's next novel! Loving the Island vibe this fall too! No One Will Know, Ghosts of Waikiki, Trouble Island are my Top 3!!! Let's go!


message 16: by Tanya (new)

Tanya Bloss � wrote: "Louise Penny! ❤️
I was privileged to receive an advanced copy of The Grey Wolf and Gamache fans will not be disappointed!"
I was looking at that one... great to know!!!


message 17: by Brenna (new)

Brenna I’ve been waiting for ‘We Solve Murders�! Less than a month now, I’m waiting patiently!


message 18: by Paula (new)

Paula Guaraldi Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

Start from the beginning - Still Life. Awesome stories; you will get hooked!


message 19: by Mary (new)

Mary Harper Burns Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

Definitely start with the first: Stll Life


message 20: by Veronika (last edited Aug 22, 2024 12:06AM) (new)

Veronika Alexa Donne: The Bitter End should've been on this list! :)


message 21: by Florence (new)

Florence Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

I'd read them in order - but that said, they really ramp up after the first say, 3 or 4


message 22: by James (new)

James Binz If you haven't met Richard Osman and his characters yet - you are in for a wonderful read.We Solve Murders


message 23: by Sharon (new)

Sharon Salonen Michael Connelly is a fall tradition, but I'm glad to see a new Attica Locke!


message 24: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Excited to read Loreth Anne White's The Swimmer, Jason Rekulak's The Last One at the Wedding and J.T. Ellison's A Very Bad Thing!


message 25: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

her books are best read in order.

Bloss � wrote: "Louise Penny! ❤️
I was privileged to receive an advanced copy of The Grey Wolf and Gamache fans will not be disappointed!"



message 26: by Evangeline (new)

Evangeline Elly Griffiths The Man in Black and other Stories. You never list Elly and she is a true treasure of a mystery writer.


message 27: by Tyna (new)

Tyna Woodby Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

Just start at the beginning. You will love them all!


message 28: by Susan (last edited Aug 22, 2024 12:29PM) (new)

Susan Gardner Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

Start at the beginning of the series. That will introduce you to all the characters that will continue throughout her books and to Inspector Gamache! You will enjoy them!


message 29: by Anne (w/ an E) (new)

Anne (w/ an E) I won a copy of The Sequelin a ŷ Giveaway (which is still happening, for anyone interested!)
I am also interested in the new Freida McFadden, the new Loreth Anne White, the new Jason Rekulak, and several others!


message 30: by Anne (w/ an E) (new)

Anne (w/ an E) I am looking forward to reading The Boyfriend, The Swimmer, The Last One at the Wedding,A Very Bad Thing, and a few others.

I was lucky enough to win a copy of The Sequel in a ŷ Giveaway, and the giveaway is still going on, for anyone interested!


message 31: by Wyona (new)

Wyona Mitchell Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

Start with the first book, Three Pines.


message 32: by Ronald (new)

Ronald I am still waiting for the new Inspector Rutledge!


message 33: by Nancy (new)

Nancy Alexander Grace wrote: "I've not read Louise Penny before. Any book in particular you'd recommend I try first? Thank you."

Start with her first book. They build on each other . I got hooked immediately.


message 34: by lacwygoodbooks (new)

lacwygoodbooks Grey mystery books it’s interesting to pick mystery novel.


message 35: by Yasmeen (new)

Yasmeen " we solve murders" cant wait!!!


message 36: by Kaileb (new)

Kaileb Varney Give "The One Called Jade" a read. Also check out *The Returnals* on Kindle Vella. Fall is here!


message 37: by Robert (last edited Aug 26, 2024 12:37AM) (new)

Robert They look good. Here are a few more:

The Cosmic Key: Convergence -- Patrick Donohue
The Seventh Floor -- David McCloskey
The Mistress and the Key -- Ben Mezrich
Desolation Code -- Graham Brown


Erin *Proud Book Hoarder* Lot of good looking books on this list


message 39: by Erin (new)

Erin Chiming in on the Gamache books, my favorite series ever (after the Betsy-Tacy books of my youth.). Loved The Sequel, but read The Plot first. I enjoyed The Last One at the Wedding a lot more than Hidden Pictures.


message 40: by Mattie (new)

Mattie Baker New kotaro isaka release??? SAY LESS


message 41: by Law (last edited Sep 06, 2024 05:54AM) (new)

Law Life One Moment is already out in Australia. There are so many holds on it at the library. I probably won't get it for now.


message 42: by Becky (new)

Becky Another great list! So many good books for my TBR.


message 43: by Sallie (new)

Sallie Read Here One Moment. Doesn’t disappoint. Draws you in. Hang on.


back to top